There’s something quietly satisfying about the smell of a pizza baking in the oven. In Spring Hill, FL, that warm invitation hides behind a lot of doors—each offering its own spin on cheese, sauce, and crust. I’ve spent more hours than I’d care to admit drifting around Spring Hill’s pizza joints, fork in hand, ready for that perfect bite. My hunt for a slice that’s not just filling, but a little thrilling, has led me through family-owned nooks with doughy secrets and franchises that survive on pure consistency.
Finding the best pizza in Spring Hill is no casual endeavor. This list isn’t built on hearsay or secondhand hype; it comes from honest taste tests, accidental discoveries, and more than one happy stomach ache. Whether you crave a classic brick oven, crave a loaded deep dish, or want that thin, satisfyingly chewy bite, the places here offer more than just a meal. Let’s take a closer look at where the real flavor lives in Spring Hill, and save you the trial-and-error.
Where to find the best pizza in Spring Hill, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Spring Hill, FL:
- Pizza Villa and Restaurant
- P J’s Brick Oven Pizza
- Village Pizza
- Bizzoco’s Italian Pizzeria
- Campitiello’s Restaurant & Pizzeria
- Marco’s Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- Hungry Howie’s Pizza
- La Florizza Pizza
- Pizza Hut
1. Pizza Villa and Restaurant
Walking into Pizza Villa and Restaurant feels like stepping into someone’s cherished family kitchen. The aroma of simmering sauce lingers in the air, hinting at the Valenti family’s Brooklyn roots. Having tried many pies in Spring Hill, I always circle back here for the classic NY-style slice—crisp, chewy, and never overdone.
Their Margherita hits a nostalgic note: simple tomato, fresh basil, perfect cheese melt. The Sicilian is thick, airy, and never shy on toppings. It’s hard not to admire the four generations keeping these recipes honest and hearty.
Looking for something substantial? The Villa Special loads every bite with well-balanced flavors and a sturdy, golden crust. If you want Spring Hill’s truest taste of old-school New York, this is the pie to try.
2. P J’s Brick Oven Pizza
P J’s Brick Oven Pizza is where the crackle of a real brick oven meets Spring Hill’s hunger for honest, flavorful pies. I remember my first visit—watching the dough bubble and brown behind glass, anticipating that signature crunch. There’s a cozy, neighborhood feel in the air, and it’s easy to see why locals keep it on speed dial.
Their Margherita is a lesson in restraint, with ripe tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and fragrant basil. Try their White Pizza if you like creamy ricotta dotted over crisp crust. The veggie pie, loaded and never soggy, is a surprise favorite.
Everything arrives piping hot and generously topped. If you’re looking for a crisp crust with real flavor and a bit of oven-charred magic, this spot always delivers.
3. Village Pizza
(352) 686-8966Call
Village Pizza is where nostalgia and a classic New York slice meet on Deltona Blvd. After a busy week, I once found myself here, ordering a slice at random; one bite in, and the tangy sauce and just-right cheese pull sold me. There’s a lived-in friendliness that regulars adore, and the crust here proves they’ve been doing this for more than two decades.
Their NY-style cheese pizza is satisfyingly thin and slightly crisp, holding its toppings without folding under pressure. The White Pizza is another standout—light, garlicky, and piled with fresh ricotta.
If you’re craving variety, go for the Margherita or build your own. This place honors the New York tradition, and it shows in every bite.
4. Bizzoco’s Italian Pizzeria
(352) 683-4355Call
Hidden on Kass Circle, Bizzoco’s Italian Pizzeria brings a low-key charm and big flavor to Spring Hill’s pizza scene. The first time I dropped in, I was greeted by a warm smile and the smell of slow-cooked sauce—a promising start that paid off with every slice.
Their classic cheese pizza is an instant comfort, with mozzarella that stretches and a sauce that holds its ground. The Veggie Pizza stands out, loaded with fresh toppings and a crust baked to a gentle crisp.
If you’re exploring their menu, try the Margherita for something fresh and simple, or go classic with a customized pie. Bizzoco’s keeps it straightforward, focusing on honest ingredients and memorable taste.
5. Campitiello’s Restaurant & Pizzeria
(352) 688-2287Call
Campitiello’s Restaurant & Pizzeria holds a quiet reputation as a neighborhood favorite, and for good reason. My first visit was driven by curiosity and the promise of real-deal Italian pizza. I wasn’t disappointed—there’s an unmistakable pride in each pie that comes out of their kitchen.
Their Neapolitan pizza packs a punch of flavor, thanks to a light, airy crust and rich, balanced sauce. The Campitiello Special is a local legend, topped with a vibrant mix of vegetables and just the right touch of cheese. It’s hearty but never heavy.
I suggest pairing a plain cheese slice with a salad for the ideal lunch. If you want an authentic, sun-kissed, Italian-style pizza in Spring Hill, this is a worthy stop.
6. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza is a go-to when you’re craving consistency and a taste that’s comfortably familiar. I’ve picked up more game-night pizzas here than I can count. The staff always greets me with quick service and a laid-back vibe. There’s a reliability you can count on whether you’re dining in or taking out.
Their signature Pepperoni Magnifico stands out—loaded with two types of pepperoni and a hint of romesan seasoning. For something classic, try their Garden Pizza, which comes stacked with vibrant vegetables on a slightly chewy crust made fresh daily.
The three cheese blend here isn’t just a slogan, it’s creamy, melty, and never greasy. Marco’s offers honest comfort food, done the traditional way.
7. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza is the answer when you need pizza that’s quick, familiar, and open late. I’ve relied on this Northcliffe Blvd spot during more than one last-minute dinner scramble. Their delivery is lightning-fast, and the tracking app spares you the guessing game.
The Handmade Pan Pizza is rich and perfectly chewy, topped edge-to-edge with a generous spread of cheese. Their Thin Crust offers crisp bites and is an easy crowd-pleaser. The Veggie Pizza packs plenty of flavor for plant-based pizza fans.
Big on variety and reliable deals, Domino’s is great when you want options. There’s a reason it’s a Spring Hill staple—consistency, speed, and solid flavor every time.
8. Hungry Howie’s Pizza
Hungry Howie’s Pizza isn’t shy about its trademark: that famous flavored crust. My favorite memory here involves a late-night order where the aroma of garlic butter filled my car. Every time, it’s the crust that steals the show, with choices like sesame, ranch, or asiago.
Try their Veggie Pizza on a cajun crust for a little heat, or go classic with the Original Cheese for pure, comfort food satisfaction. The crust options are customizable, so you can match any mood or craving.
Prices stay friendly, and delivery is quick. If you like to experiment or want a pizza that’s never boring around the edges, Hungry Howie’s deserves a spot on your list.
9. La Florizza Pizza
La Florizza Pizza is a spot where wood-fired magic turns simple ingredients into something memorable. My first slice here had that telltale, smoky aroma—evidence of the real flames that give their pies a character you don’t find everywhere. The crust arrives perfectly blistered, airy inside with a satisfying chew.
The Margherita is a crowd-pleaser, dressed with fresh mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, and basil. Their Bianca pizza offers creamy ricotta paired with a crisp, golden crust—ideal if you’re in the mood for something lighter but still rich in flavor.
Ordering from La Florizza feels like a small event; each pizza is made fresh and worth the wait. Here, modern technique meets classic taste for a truly Spring Hill experience.
10. Pizza Hut
A classic never really goes out of style, and Pizza Hut on Commercial Way delivers that easy nostalgia with every box. I can’t count the number of after-school gatherings or family movie nights that started or ended with their familiar red cups and a pan pizza. There’s a comfort in knowing exactly what you’re getting—consistent, cheesy, and fresh from the oven.
Go for the Original Stuffed Crust if you crave that signature pull and golden edge. The Veggie Lover’s is solid, stacked high but not soggy. Pizzas arrive hot, reliably bubbling, and always crowd friendly.
If you like a pizza night that’s fuss-free and built for sharing, Pizza Hut remains a steady Spring Hill pick.
More Things to Try in Spring Hill, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
What style of pizza is most popular in Spring Hill, FL?
New York-style pizza is a favorite—thin, foldable, and topped with gooey cheese. You’ll also find plenty of spots offering classic pan and wood-fired options for variety.
Are there any good pizza places that offer delivery in Spring Hill?
Many local pizzerias and national chains, like Domino’s, Pizza Hut, Hungry Howie’s, and Village Pizza, provide fast delivery. Check hours and online ordering for each.
Which pizza spot has the best crust in Spring Hill?
Hungry Howie’s Pizza stands out for flavored crusts, while La Florizza Pizza’s wood-fired crust brings a smoky, chewy bite that’s hard to beat.
Can I find vegetarian pizza options in Spring Hill?
Absolutely! Most pizza spots, including Marco’s, Pizza Villa, and Domino’s, have veggie pies loaded with fresh toppings and plenty of cheese.
Are there family-owned pizza restaurants in Spring Hill?
Yes. Pizza Villa and Restaurant, Bizzoco’s Italian Pizzeria, and Campitiello’s are cherished for their homemade flavor and family-friendly vibe.