The search for South Hill’s best pizza can feel like scrolling through endless menus on a hungry night. Each visit brings a new debate: thin crust or pan, classic pepperoni or a kitchen-sink mix of toppings. I remember ducking out of a rainstorm and into a small shop on College Avenue, the windows foggy and the air thick with spice and yeast. That first bite made the rest of the world irrelevant—chewy yet crisp, tangy sauce edged with herbs, the perfect blend of simplicity and surprise.
If your cravings demand more than another cardboard box, our guide goes beyond bland chains and dry cheese. South Hill hides some real gems, each with its own approach to old traditions and new trends. Whether you’re settling in for a family dinner or plotting a midnight slice, the following list spotlights the most satisfying stops in town. Get ready to meet the pies that keep locals loyal, slice after slice.
Where to find the best pizza in South Hill, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in South Hill, NY:
- Luca’s Italian Restaurant
- Roma’s Italian Restaurant
- Domino’s Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Papa John’s Pizza
- Chicago’s Pizza With A Twist – Richmond Hill, NY
- Broadway Bakery & Pizzeria
- Italiana Cremosa
- I & K Pizza Incorporated
- Genovese Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc
1. Luca’s Italian Restaurant
Finding Luca’s Italian Restaurant is simple, but leaving without planning your next visit isn’t. Inside, the cozy, wood-accented space and mellow lighting set the perfect mood for a satisfying dinner. On a recent visit, my table buzzed with anticipation as we watched the staff glide by with bubbling pizzas thick with aroma.
Luca’s makes every pie from scratch. The Margherita leads with its buttery crust and garden-fresh tomatoes that hint at summer in every bite. The Veggie Supreme—loaded with crisp peppers and olives—is a winner for those who skip the meat but not the flavor.
Here, pizza is elevated. Friendly servers explain why recipes handed down through generations never went out of style. Ask for an olive oil-brushed base; it’s a detail that lifts each slice above the ordinary.
2. Roma’s Italian Restaurant
Roma’s Italian Restaurant sits tucked beside Atlantic Street and is a haven for anyone passionate about true Italian flavor. The scene thrives with the sound of families catching up and pizza paddles gliding out of the oven. On my last visit, a rainy evening made their dining room feel extra inviting.
What separates Roma’s from the rest? Their crust holds a delicate balance—airy inside, golden outside. The Four Cheese Pizza is a creamy standout with each cheese distinct but harmonious. If you lean toward bolder flavors, try the Roma Special. It’s loaded with bell peppers and mushrooms that stay bright and lively.
Whether you opt for takeout or table service, the kitchen’s devotion to tradition makes each pie memorable. Don’t leave without a side of their house-made tomato sauce for dipping the crust—it’s the finishing touch.
3. Domino’s Pizza
If you’re after consistency and speed, Domino’s Pizza on Furr Street comes through every time. It’s the place I call when deadlines loom and a hunger emergency strikes. The staff knows how to keep things efficient but always manages a smile at pickup.
The Handmade Pan Pizza sets Domino’s apart in the chain world, with a buttery, deep crust that’s crisp at the edge and fluffy inside. For those who crave comfort, the classic Cheese Pizza stacks up gooey layers in every slice. Late nights or lunchtime, Domino’s never skimps on portion or speed.
For extra flavor, consider adding garlic crust. It transforms the whole experience and holds up even under generous toppings. Delivery is fast, so that cheesy goodness lands at your door still piping hot.
4. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on E Atlantic Street is a familiar stop for comfort-seekers and pizza traditionalists alike. The red-roofed building is easy to spot and brings a sense of nostalgia every time you pull up. I’ve relied on this spot for post-game gatherings and easy weeknight dinners.
The Original Stuffed Crust® Pizza is why many regulars keep coming back—it’s hearty, stretchy and always crowd-pleasing. If you want a bigger flavor punch, try the Veggie Lover’s Pizza. The mix of peppers, onions and mushrooms gives every slice fresh crunch, showing Pizza Hut knows how to do classic combinations right.
With options for carryout, delivery and even curbside pickup, this location keeps your craving in check. Bonus tip: their crust always holds up, even after a drive home.
5. Papa John’s Pizza
Papa John’s Pizza on Atlantic Ave makes its mark with signature fresh ingredients and a crust that’s as soft as it is golden. The shop feels quietly busy, always in motion, and their team turns out pies with an even hand. On a cold afternoon, I dropped by and was met with the warm aroma of baking dough and spices that hit the senses before I opened the door.
The star at Papa John’s is the Garden Fresh Pizza, stacked with ripe tomatoes, sweet onions, green peppers, and black olives—a real treat for veggie lovers. The crust is slimmer, with a chewy base, letting the toppings shine through.
Order a side of their signature garlic sauce to dip your crust for a finishing flourish. For reliable quality and a flavor-focused menu, Papa John’s holds its own in the South Hill pizza lineup.
6. Chicago’s Pizza With A Twist – Richmond Hill, NY
Chicago’s Pizza With A Twist brings something different to the table, blending classic pizza craft with bold Indian-inspired flavors. The moment you step inside, the aroma hints you’re not in the land of ordinary cheese and tomato sauce. On my last visit, the Mango Paneer Pizza arrived bubbling and fragrant, prompting curious glances from nearby tables.
Locally sourced ingredients and a focus on both vegan and gluten-free options make this spot stand out in a crowded field. The Achari Veggie Pizza, loaded with pickled spices and a touch of heat, is a clear winner for anyone looking for more than the usual.
This isn’t just pizza, it’s a creative adventure. For anyone who thinks they’ve tried it all, Chicago’s Pizza With A Twist is a must-have South Hill stop.
7. Broadway Bakery & Pizzeria
(646) 721-3112Call
Broadway Bakery & Pizzeria may sound modest, but its reputation stretches far beyond Liberty Ave. I once wandered in late on a rainy evening, drawn by the bright lights and the scent of bread baking. The counter showcases a wide range of pizzas cooling beside fresh-out-of-the-oven loaves, making every choice a delicious dilemma.
Their Margherita Pizza stands out for its simplicity—crisp base, tangy sauce, and cheese that pulls just right. If asked for a sleeper pick, the Vegetable Pizza delivers with colorful, generous toppings and a chewy crust that doesn’t quit.
Here, you taste the harmony between bakery and pizzeria: every pie benefits from true dough expertise. Broadway is for those who believe pizza dough is as vital as the topping lineup.
8. Italiana Cremosa
(718) 441-1137Call
Italiana Cremosa is a hidden gem on 101st Ave, where classic techniques meet creamy, rich flavor. The first time I visited, I was greeted by the friendly buzz of the open kitchen and an aroma that promised satisfaction. Every pie is hand-tossed, and you can watch the dough come alive behind the counter.
The star here is the Creamy Pesto Pizza—the blend of basil and cheese creates a smooth, herby bite you won’t find elsewhere. Their Vegetable Pizza layers crisp peppers and olives over a soft, chewy base for a bold, fresh finish.
Italiana Cremosa stands out for its commitment to inventive, satisfyingly rich pizzas with a personal touch. It’s where creativity meets comfort, one slice at a time.
9. I & K Pizza Incorporated
(718) 738-4061Call
I & K Pizza Incorporated is the kind of neighborhood spot where regulars are on a first-name basis with the staff, and the whole place hums with familiarity. The menu leans classic, and when I dropped by, it was clear that simplicity and quality are the core principles. The aroma of fresh dough alone had me sold before I ordered.
What puts I & K on the map is the cheese pizza: blistered at the edges, creamy in the center, and with a sauce that’s not too sweet or tangy. Their Veggie Pie is equally popular, packed with generous heaps of fresh peppers, onions, and olives.
This is a favorite for those who love unfussy, honest pizza—delivered fast, and always satisfying. Sometimes, sticking to tradition wins the day.
10. Genovese Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc
Genovese Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc captures the spirit of family gatherings with warm hospitality and a menu brimming with traditional Italian comfort. The inviting setting instantly puts you at ease, whether you’re in for a casual lunch or a lively dinner. My last visit involved sharing pizzas at a bustling table, laughter competing with the sizzle from the kitchen.
Here, the classic Margherita is a must, topped with fresh basil and mozzarella that melts just enough. The Sicilian pie is another standout, served thick, pillowy, and sturdy enough to handle a blanket of tomato sauce and cheese.
Genovese balances authenticity with generous portions, making every visit feel like a celebration. This spot goes the extra mile to ensure each pizza speaks of tradition and quality in every bite.
More Things to Try in South Hill, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of pizza styles can I find in South Hill, NY?
You’ll find everything from classic New York-style slices to pan, Sicilian, thin crust, and even some spots serving creative fusion pies. Whether you prefer chewy or crispy, South Hill has a pizza for every preference.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in South Hill?
Yes, several pizzerias offer vegetarian and vegan pizzas. Keep an eye out for places with plant-based cheese, veggie-loaded pies, and crusts free from animal products. Just ask your server for the best options.
Can I get gluten-free pizza in South Hill?
Absolutely. Many spots include gluten-free crusts on their menu, so you can still enjoy a good slice if you have dietary restrictions. It’s a good idea to call ahead, as availability may vary from day to day.
Which pizza spot is best for a large group or family night out?
Both locally-owned family restaurants and bigger chains offer spacious seating and family-size pies. Luca’s Italian Restaurant and Genovese Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc are favorites for group gatherings with their welcoming atmosphere and generous portions.
What’s the best place for pizza delivery in South Hill?
You can’t go wrong with delivery from Domino’s, Pizza Hut, or Papa John’s for speed and consistency. Many independent pizzerias also deliver, so check if your favorite spot offers that service for your area.