Best Pizza in Sisters, OR

Pizza in Sisters, OR has a certain charm that sneaks up on you. Maybe it’s the mountain air or the small-town glow that makes each slice feel a little more memorable. The local pizza scene isn’t just about cheesy pies and bubbly crust—it’s a collection of spots where family recipes meet Oregon creativity.

After a cold hike or a lazy afternoon exploring galleries, I found myself searching for the best pizza in town. Through trial, error, and a fair share of empty plates, I discovered a handful of pizzerias that each bring something different to the table. If you’re deciding where to grab your next slice, this guide will give you the real picture—no fluff, just crust, sauce, and honest reviews. Ready to find your favorite?

1. Martolli’s Pizza

Martolli’s Pizza has the cozy feel of a local favorite, nestled right on Cascade Ave. The moment you step inside, the aroma of their hand-tossed dough hits you in the best way. The crust comes out golden, and the sauce strikes a balance between zesty and just-sweet-enough. Every bite reminds you that care goes into each pie.

What makes Martolli’s stand out is their generosity with fresh toppings and their knack for blending flavors. Take their classic veggie or the simple Margherita—each lets the fresh ingredients shine. If you’re into a perfect cheese-pull, their three-cheese pizza is a must-try and truly shows off what the kitchen does so well.

Service is quick, and the welcoming vibe stays true to Sisters’ small-town warmth.

2. Lakeside Bistro

Lakeside Bistro sits near the water and has a relaxing view that pairs well with their pizza. The setting is peaceful, which makes it easy to unwind after a busy day. The counter service adds a touch of convenience when you want to grab food by the pool or after a stroll.

Their pizza leans on a thinner crust, with a nice snap when you bite in. The bistro’s spinach and mushroom pizza stands out—fresh, earthy, and not overloaded with cheese, letting each ingredient come through. Their margherita is light and bright, with sun-ripened tomatoes and a hint of basil.

This is the spot for those who appreciate a scenic meal along with crisp, satisfying pies.

3. Takoda’s Restaurant & Lounge

Takoda’s Restaurant & Lounge is where you find a mix of family comfort and a lively local vibe. The patio is perfect when the sun’s out, and the easygoing staff make every visit feel like you’re already a regular. I was drawn in by the buzz of conversation and the scent of fresh dough rising in the kitchen.

The pizza at Takoda’s comes out hot, with an airy crust that’s full of flavor. Their Mediterranean veggie is a winner—tangy olives, roasted peppers, and a balanced layer of cheese set it apart from the usual. If you’re around on a Sunday, you’ll find the menu pared down to pizza and salads, but that’s when the kitchen really shines.

Easygoing atmosphere, reliable pies, and a salad bar that actually delivers freshness—Takoda’s checks the right boxes.

4. Papandreas Pizza

Papandreas Pizza tastes like a slice of tradition tucked right on Hood Ave. The shop keeps things simple, focusing on classic pies with a generous hand for toppings and cheese. The space is understated, but the food does the talking. I popped in for a quick lunch and left with leftovers for later.

Their pepperoni and mushroom pizza hits the balance—crisp edges, gooey cheese, and tender mushrooms that don’t get lost in the mix. Papandreas doesn’t go wild with seasoning; instead, they trust the freshness of their ingredients to deliver.

It’s a go-to choice when you crave the familiar flavors of a hometown pizzeria, done exactly right. Consistency is their standout trait.

5. Boone Dog Pizza

Boone Dog Pizza is tucked inside The Barn, a fun community hub that brings together outdoor seating and a friendly, relaxed crowd. The open air and buzz of people makes grabbing a pie here feel like a real event, not just dinner. You quickly see why locals and travelers alike whisper good things about this place.

Each pizza has a wood-fired crust with just the right amount of blistering—smoky, chewy, and a little bit crisp on the bottom. Their signature wild mushroom pizza is a favorite, balancing earthy flavors and gooey cheese without being heavy.

If you’re after pizza with big personality and a unique spot to enjoy it, Boone Dog stands out—and the smell of that oven will win you over before the first bite.

6. Shulers Pizzeria

Shulers Pizzeria is easy to find on Hood Ave and even easier to like once you taste their pies. They take a hands-on approach, rolling dough fresh each day and letting each pizza develop its own character in the oven. It’s the kind of spot you stop at once, then find yourself craving a week later.

The garden pizza draws plenty of fans, with crisp peppers and juicy tomatoes layered on a crust that’s both sturdy and chewy. Try it with an extra sprinkle of mozzarella if you’re feeling bold. Their menu keeps it classic, but each bite is full of flavor only a true pizzeria can give.

Consistent, friendly, and always satisfying—Shulers delivers the genuine pizza experience.

7. Pisano’s Woodfired Pizza

Pisano’s Woodfired Pizza is worth the short drive from Sisters, especially if you care about craft and ingredients. Every pizza comes out blistered and golden from their woodfired oven, with a dough that’s both airy and crisp. The kitchen feels like it’s run by true pizza fans, the kind who tinker until every detail is right.

Their margherita is a standout—clean tomato flavor, generous basil, and the kind of mozzarella that actually stretches. For anyone avoiding gluten, their gluten-free crust is unusually good. No sacrificing flavor here.

It’s the place you go when you want real artisan-style pizza, carefully built and easy to love by the slice.

8. Silverleaf Cafe

Silverleaf Cafe, just a short trip from Sisters, has a loyal following for its laid-back charm and seriously good pizza. The place blends a casual vibe with flavors you’d expect from a more upscale spot, thanks to their focus on fresh, local ingredients. I stopped by on a road trip and was pulled in by the bustle of regulars getting their pizza fix.

Their roasted veggie pizza packs in all the right textures—charred broccoli, sweet onions, and juicy peppers, all on a cracker-crisp crust. If you want to taste how they treat the basics, the classic cheese is melt-in-your-mouth simple.

It’s a perfect spot when you want to gather, unwind, and enjoy pies that hit above their weight.

9. Pisanos Pizza

Pisanos Pizza brings artisan quality to every pie, tucked away off Strickler Ave. The wood-fired crust has a smoky snap that’s distinct, and their toppings always taste fresh. I’ve dropped by more than once for a dinner with friends, drawn by the aroma wafting from the oven before you even reach the door.

Their margherita pizza is a local favorite—simple, bright, and centered on real basil and a rich tomato base. If you’re looking for options, Pisanos handles gluten-free and vegan crusts with surprising finesse, so everyone can enjoy a quality slice.

It’s a welcoming spot for anyone craving pizza with a crisp edge and a focus on the best local flavors.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best pizza places in Sisters, OR?
Favorites include Martolli’s Pizza, Papandreas Pizza, Boone Dog Pizza, and Shulers Pizzeria. Each has its own style and local following.

Is there gluten-free pizza available in Sisters?
Yes, spots like Pisano’s Woodfired Pizza and Pisanos Pizza offer gluten-free crusts. Call ahead to check availability.

Which pizzerias have vegetarian options?
Most pizzerias in Sisters offer meatless choices. Try Martolli’s Margherita, Silverleaf Cafe’s roasted veggie pizza, or Takoda’s Mediterranean veggie.

Can I find vegan pizza in Sisters, OR?
Pisanos Pizza offers a vegan option, and others may allow you to customize with no cheese and veggie toppings.

Are there pizza places open late in Sisters?
Opening hours vary, but Martolli’s and Boone Dog Pizza tend to stay open longer during peak seasons. It’s best to check each restaurant’s website for the latest schedule.

Do any pizzerias offer delivery in Sisters, OR?
Some spots may deliver or partner with local delivery services. Many focus on dine-in or takeout, so it’s smart to call and ask.