Searching for the best pizza in Seymour, IN is like chasing down the perfect slice on a Friday night—crisp crust, golden cheese, and that balance of sauce that somehow magically leaves you wanting another bite. I’ve navigated these streets and taste-tested the town’s favorites, always with the goal to hunt down flavors worth remembering. Each pizza place here has a story and a specialty, and yes, a pie or two you’ll crave long after.
This guide doesn’t just run through the usual suspects. Every pizzeria on this list has something that sets it apart, and you won’t find any generic recommendations. Whether it’s that perfectly blistered crust you love or the spot with classic pepperoni done right, you’re about to get the lowdown on where to find real pizza satisfaction in Seymour. It’s a journey every pizza-lover in town should take—and a few pies along the way might just surprise you.
1. Brooklyn Pizza Company
There’s a buzz that lingers around the Brooklyn Pizza Company, and it’s not just the sound of the oven. This spot on West 2nd Street manages to blend small-town warmth with a taste of New York’s legendary pizza style. One visit had me hooked—the crust was thin yet sturdy, made to be folded just like the real deal.
What sets Brooklyn Pizza Company apart is attention to detail; every pie emerges with a thoughtful balance of sauce and cheese. Their classic cheese or pepperoni pizza is a must-try and gives you the flavors without fuss. If you’re in the mood to branch out, try their signature Sicilian pizza—it’s a thick, pillowy slice that speaks to the heart of true pizza craft.
2. Brooklyn Pizza Co
Stepping into Brooklyn Pizza Co on W Tipton Street feels like pizza night done right. My visits here always end up with everyone at the table reaching for another slice—there’s just something about their dough. The vibe is laid-back, perfect for both takeout and sitting down with friends or family.
This place knows how to treat its ingredients. Fresh veggies, generous cheese, and a sauce that tastes homemade set their pizzas apart. Their veggie pizza is an easy favorite, loaded but not overwhelmed, and lets the flavors shine through. If you want a taste of Brooklyn’s confidence in every bite, try a classic Margherita. It’s both simple and full of character, much like the place itself.
3. Pizza Palace
Pizza Palace on W Tipton Street is one of those hometown favorites where friendly faces and the smell of baking dough greet you at the door. On my last visit, I noticed every booth filled with locals, and for good reason—this place knows how to deliver pizza that keeps folks coming back.
The magic here is in their crust. It’s golden, chewy, and always freshly made, offering the perfect foundation for generous toppings. The Supreme Pizza piles on fresh veggies and savory cheese, making it a worthy signature dish. If you’re after something classic and crowd-pleasing, their cheese pizza never misses—it’s that trusty slice you remember long after the first bite.
4. White’s Pizza
White’s Pizza doesn’t shy away from bold, satisfying flavors, making it a true hidden gem in Seymour. The first time I stopped by, I noticed the steady stream of regulars—a solid sign you’ve found a local favorite. The team here keeps things simple, focusing on big taste and fresh, straightforward ingredients.
Their specialty is a classic pan pizza that offers a soft center and crispy edges in each bite. The meatless veggie pizza is a top pick; the cheese bubbles just right and the vegetables still have their snap. If you want straightforward comfort with every slice, this is the place to order from—and you’ll soon see why people make it a weekly ritual.
5. The Seymour Brewing Co.
If you think of The Seymour Brewing Co. as just a spot for craft beers, you’re missing out on some surprisingly memorable pizza. The setting is relaxed, with a steady flow of locals enjoying both the tap and the outdoor seating. My personal go-to here is always the pizza, especially when live music floats through the air.
What stands out at The Seymour Brewing Co. is the way they elevate the classics. Their dough is light and flavorful, with toppings that sit just right—not too heavy, never too sparse. The Margherita is a star, with bright tomato, fresh basil, and gooey cheese, perfect alongside a house-brewed soda or root beer. If you want a local experience with lots of character, grab a slice and enjoy the scene.
6. Little Caesars
Little Caesars on E Tipton Street is the quick solution when you want pizza hot and ready in minutes. There’s no fuss here—just a counter, friendly staff, and the familiar smell of baked dough greeting you right at the door. Sometimes, a fast grab-and-go option is exactly what’s needed, and this spot delivers with consistency.
The appeal is in the efficiency and the price. The classic Cheese or Veggie pizzas are always prepared fresh and ready, ideal when you’re short on time or need to feed a group without breaking the bank. Their crust has that signature soft chew, and the sauce is just tangy enough to keep you coming back. For a quick bite that hits the spot, Little Caesars gets the job done.
7. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Seymour is where convenience meets a customizable pizza experience. Whether you want to eat in, pick up, or get delivery, there’s always a friendly voice ready to take your order. On more than one rainy evening, I’ve trusted Domino’s to deliver piping-hot pizza right to my door—fast and consistent every single time.
The menu offers a variety of crust options and flavors. If you’re in the mood for a classic, their Thin Crust Cheese is always a safe bet: crispy, cheesy, and satisfying. For something heartier, the Handmade Pan pizza has a thick, buttery base with a comforting texture. Domino’s proves you don’t have to sacrifice quality for speed or choice in Seymour.
8. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on E Tipton Street is where many pizza memories are made, thanks to its familiar booths and classic red roof atmosphere. There’s a real sense of nostalgia here—I’ve lost count of the late nights spent sharing their signature pizzas with friends and family. The service is friendly, and you can always count on a warm pie made just the way you order.
The menu is packed with crowd-pleasers. If you’re looking for a standout, the Original Stuffed Crust delivers that gooey, cheesy finish every time. Their Veggie Lover’s pizza is another favorite, loaded with fresh ingredients and layered on their distinctive, buttery crust. For a slice that feels both comforting and reliable, Pizza Hut is a Seymour staple that never disappoints.
9. Chicago’s Pizza
Step into Chicago’s Pizza and you’ll see why locals keep it in their rotation. The atmosphere is inviting, with a laid-back energy that’s perfect for anything from a quick lunch to a lingering dinner with friends. On my last visit, every slice was hot and hearty, with a perfect crust-to-toppings ratio that’s easy to appreciate.
Their claim to fame is the mouthwatering pan pizza—think thick, golden crust and plenty of gooey cheese. If you want something lighter but still flavorful, the Veggie Pizza is a solid choice, full of fresh toppings and a sauce with just enough zing. Chicago’s Pizza knows how to turn simple ingredients into a satisfying meal every time.
10. Godfather’s Pizza Express
Godfather’s Pizza Express keeps things straightforward—no frills, just good pizza made fast. I’ve swung by more than once for a slice on the go, and every time I’ve been greeted with the aroma of a freshly baked pie. The setup is made for quick service, but you never feel shortchanged on flavor.
The star here is the classic pan pizza, which comes out thick and loaded with toppings. Their cheese pizza stands out for its creamy blend and perfectly baked crust, making it a great place to start. For those who like a bit of everything, the Veggie Pizza has a generous helping of fresh vegetables. Godfather’s delivers on dependable, tasty pizza right when you need it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What pizza places in Seymour, IN offer delivery?
Most national chains like Domino’s Pizza, Pizza Hut, and Little Caesars offer delivery. Local spots such as Pizza Palace and Brooklyn Pizza Company also deliver, so you can enjoy your favorite slice at home.
Are there vegetarian pizza options in Seymour?
Absolutely. Almost every pizzeria in Seymour features at least one vegetarian option, with many including Veggie or Margherita pizzas. Pizza Palace, Brooklyn Pizza Co, and Chicago’s Pizza are especially popular for their fresh veggie toppings.
Which pizza spot is known for a thick crust?
For fans of thick crust, Chicago’s Pizza and Godfather’s Pizza Express are standout choices. Their pan pizzas have a golden, fluffy base with plenty of room for all those toppings.
Where can I find gluten-free pizza in Seymour?
The Seymour Brewing Co. offers gluten-free options, and larger chains like Domino’s and Pizza Hut also have gluten-free crusts available. It’s a good idea to call ahead and check for availability.
Can I dine in at pizza places in Seymour?
Yes, many pizza spots such as Brooklyn Pizza Company, Chicago’s Pizza, and Pizza Palace offer dine-in seating if you’re looking for a sit-down meal with friends or family.