Discovering the best pizza in Selma, AL, can feel like a flavorful treasure hunt. Having explored numerous spots, I’ve come to appreciate the distinct qualities each pizzeria offers. From classic cheesy slices to inventive toppings, Selma’s pizza scene offers surprisingly diverse options for a small city. Whether you’re craving a quick bite or a leisurely meal, the choices here won’t disappoint.
What makes this list worthwhile is the focus on places that prioritize quality, freshness, and flavor—without unnecessary exaggeration. If you’re passionate about pizza, chances are you’ll find a new favorite among these establishments. Dive in to see which spots truly stand out for their crusts, toppings, and overall dining experience.
Where to find the best pizza in Selma, AL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Selma, AL:
- Little Caesars Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Closed – Papa Johns Pizza
- Hunt Brothers Pizza
- Pizza Hut Express
- Parkway Chevron
- Buffet Pizza
1. Little Caesars Pizza
Located at 1330 E Highland Ave, Little Caesars Pizza is a go-to spot for quick, satisfying slices in Selma. I’ve often stopped by for a hot, ready-to-eat pizza after a busy day, and it never disappoints. Their consistent quality and speedy service make it a popular choice for locals and visitors alike.
What sets Little Caesars apart is their commitment to affordability without sacrificing flavor. The Hot-N-Ready Pepperoni Pizza is a must-try; it embodies their signature style — crispy crust, generous toppings, and melty cheese. For a little extra flavor, the Deep! Deep! Dish offers a hearty, comforting bite. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or feeding a crowd, Little Caesars makes ordering easy with reliable, tasty options.
2. Pizza Hut
Situated at 307 Highland Ave, Pizza Hut in Selma offers a classic dining experience packed with familiar flavors. I’ve enjoyed their warm, welcoming atmosphere, especially on family nights. The variety of options ensures there’s something for everyone, making it a reliable choice for casual dining or takeout.
What makes Pizza Hut stand out is their signature crust and consistently hearty toppings. Their Cheese Lover’s Pizza showcases their commitment to rich, cheesy goodness, while the Supreme Pizza combines a medley of meats and veggies for a balanced bite. For a satisfying meal that reflects quality and tradition, Pizza Hut’s offerings in Selma never fail to deliver.
3. Closed – Papa Johns Pizza
Although currently closed, Papa Johns Pizza in Selma has built a reputation for quality ingredients and crispy, flavorful crusts. From my previous visits, I appreciated their emphasis on freshness, especially their signature sauce and generous toppings. It’s a place that prioritizes consistency and making every slice memorable.
What makes Papa Johns stand out is their commitment to “Better Ingredients, Better Pizza.” Their Philly Cheese Steak Pizza was a favorite of mine—rich, savory, and packed with quality meats. When open, their Cheese Sticks and wings are excellent sides, perfect for rounding out a satisfying pizza night in Selma.
4. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Located at 602 Broad St, Hunt Brothers Pizza offers a convenient and tasty option for pizza lovers in Selma. I’ve found their personal-sized pizzas perfect for a quick, satisfying meal. The focus on quality ingredients and customizable options makes it a flexible choice for many preferences.
What makes Hunt Brothers stand out is their commitment to affordability and fresh, great-tasting pizza. The Classic Pepperoni Pizza reflects their dedication to simple, reliable flavors. For a heartier option, their Italian Style Pizza with robust toppings is an excellent pick, echoing their straightforward yet flavorful approach. If you’re after a quick bite that doesn’t compromise on quality, Hunt Brothers in Selma is worth a visit.
5. Pizza Hut Express
Conveniently located at 2530 US Highway 80 W, Pizza Hut Express provides quick and satisfying pizza options in Selma. I’ve enjoyed grabbing a slice here during busy days, appreciating the swift service and consistent taste. It’s an ideal spot for both takeout and quick bites on the go.
What makes Pizza Hut Express stand out is their ability to deliver the classic Pizza Hut experience in a more streamlined setting. I recommend trying the Supreme Pizza — loaded with meats and veggies, it reflects their signature style of hearty, flavorful pizza. Pair it with their Garlic Breadsticks for a well-rounded, satisfying meal.
6. Parkway Chevron
Located at 2615 Citizens Pkwy, Parkway Chevron is a convenient stop for travelers in Selma. I’ve often refueled my car and grabbed a quick meal here on busy days. Their combination of gas, convenience store essentials, and pizza makes it a versatile spot for a brief break.
What sets Parkway Chevron apart is their commitment to quality and service. I recommend ordering their Hot, Fresh Pizza — it’s perfect for a quick, satisfying snack. Their crisp crust and gooey cheese showcase their attention to simple, good ingredients. It’s an ideal option for anyone looking for a quick bite during a road trip or errands around town.
7. Buffet Pizza
Located at 2615 Citizens Pkwy, Buffet Pizza offers a variety of Italian favorites in Selma. I’ve visited during lunchtime and appreciated their diverse buffet, which features fresh pizza and hearty sides. It’s a relaxed spot perfect for families or casual groups.
What makes Buffet Pizza stand out is their wide selection and focus on quality ingredients. I recommend trying their All-You-Can-Eat Pizza Buffet, especially the classic cheese and pepperoni slices, which really showcase their simple, satisfying style. Their side dishes, like garlic bread and salads, complement the pizzas well, making it a good choice for a filling, affordable meal.
More Things to Try in Selma, AL
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: What is the best pizza place in Selma, AL?
A1: The best pizza spot depends on your preference, but places like Pizza Hut, Hunt Brothers Pizza, and Buffet Pizza are popular for their variety and quality. Each offers a different style, from classic to buffet options.
Q2: Do these pizzerias offer gluten-free or vegetarian options?
A2: Many locations, including Pizza Hut and Buffet Pizza, provide vegetarian options. Gluten-free choices may be available; it’s best to call ahead or check their websites for specific menu details.
Q3: Can I get pizza delivered in Selma, AL?
A3: Yes, most places like Pizza Hut and Papa Johns offer delivery and carryout services, making it convenient to enjoy pizza at home or work.
Q4: Are there family-friendly pizza restaurants in Selma?
A4: Absolutely. Places like Pizza Hut and Buffet Pizza cater to families, with casual atmospheres and kid-friendly menu options.
Q5: What should I order if I want a quick, satisfying pizza in Selma?
A5: Try the Hot-N-Ready Pepperoni Pizza at Little Caesars or large specialty pizzas at Pizza Hut for reliable, tasty options that won’t keep you waiting.