It’s amazing how a place like Selden, NY, holds endless options for pizza. The first time I searched for a slice in town, I didn’t expect to find such unique spins on the classic pie. From thin and crispy crusts to gooey, bubbling cheese pulled fresh from the oven, Selden’s pizzerias each bring something distinctive to the table. A good pizza spot isn’t just about taste; it’s about atmosphere, attention to detail, and the satisfaction that lingers after the last bite.
Exploring the pizza scene here, I’ve come across family-owned gems and bustling takeout counters, each with its own loyal regulars. If you’re sifting through options trying to figure out where to go, you’re in the right place. This list is built from careful tasting, honest reviews, and a hefty dose of local flavor. Whether you’re craving a classic cheese, a veggie-laden pie, or something totally unexpected, Selden’s got you covered. Consider this your guide to finding the best pizza, minus the fuss and with all the flavor.
Where to find the best pizza in Selden, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Selden, NY:
- Caffe Amici
- Goomba Johnny’s Pizzeria
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Salvino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
- Slice’s Pizza
- Capellini Trattoria Pizzeria
- Sal Anthonys II
- Boccone Pizza Restuar
- Selden Pizza
- Slices Pizza Boutique
1. Caffe Amici
Walking into Caffe Amici feels like visiting a familiar friend. The aroma of fresh dough and Italian spices hits you right away. On my last visit, the staff greeted me with genuine warmth and got my order just right.
What really sets Caffe Amici apart is its focus on quality, with a menu that caters to every mood. Their margherita pizza is a standout—thin, crisp, and topped with silky mozzarella and fresh basil. If you’re craving a heartier option, their veggie pizza brims with color and flavor, never skimping on the toppings.
With plenty of vegetarian and gluten-free choices, it’s easy for anyone to find something great. Try the Sicilian pie for its thick, satisfying crust. This spot makes picking a favorite almost impossible.
2. Goomba Johnny’s Pizzeria
Goomba Johnny’s Pizzeria always feels buzzy, thanks to a steady line of regulars and families picking up dinner. On my last visit, I ordered for a group, and every pizza arrived hot and perfectly made—no shortcuts here.
This place shines with its dedication to the classics. Their cheese pizza is a local legend—simple, well-balanced, and satisfying enough to taste even better the next day. For those feeding a crew, their family-sized pies are both generous and flavorful.
If you want something a little different, their white pizza is creamy and rich, perfect for anyone looking to break from tradition. Large orders, prompt delivery, and a family-run vibe set Goomba Johnny’s apart from the pack.
3. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza in Selden is a steady go-to for those craving something familiar. I’ve leaned on their delivery more than once for a no-fuss, consistent bite, and they never miss a beat with temperature or freshness.
What distinguishes this spot is its reliable use of fresh dough and signature sauce. Their original cheese pizza is a crowd-pleaser—crispy at the edges, soft in the center, and finished with a bright, garlicky tomato sauce. It’s the kind of slice that feels classic every time.
If you want more, their veggie pizza comes loaded with crisp peppers and tangy olives. Order the garlic breadsticks as a side—they’re always warm, pillowy, and perfect for sharing. It’s comfort food done right.
4. Salvino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
At Salvino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant, there’s a sense of tradition built into every order. The space gives off that classic neighborhood hangout vibe, and the staff know the regulars by name. I stopped by for a quick slice and ended up staying longer than planned, savoring each bite.
Salvino’s has a knack for getting the basics right. Their regular cheese and veggie pizzas are staples—thin, slightly chewy crust with a zesty sauce and just the right amount of melt. They don’t overload the toppings, striking a perfect balance that lets each ingredient shine.
If you want something more substantial, try their Sicilian slice. It’s thick, comforting, and notably crisp at the base. At Salvino’s, you taste both the craft and the care with every slice.
5. Slice’s Pizza
Slice’s Pizza flies under the radar, but those who know keep coming back for more. The first time I tried their pizza, I noticed how much pride they pack into every pie. Each order is made fresh, and the vibe is casual and welcoming.
This spot is all about craft. Their classic cheese slice is well-balanced, with a crisp base and just the right hit of oregano. The crust holds its own—neither too thick nor too thin—and there’s always a nice chew.
If you’re hungry for something hearty, try their veggie slice, loaded with bell peppers and onions. Consistent quality and attention to detail make Slice’s Pizza worth a detour.
6. Capellini Trattoria Pizzeria
Capellini Trattoria Pizzeria is tucked along Middle Country Road, but don’t let its quiet exterior fool you. There’s an unmistakable authenticity inside that draws locals in. The room always smells of baking bread and slow-cooked sauce—a sign you’re in for something good.
Here, every pizza is made with care. Their margherita stands out, with a light, blistered crust and a generous layer of fresh mozzarella and basil. The ingredients are fresh, never overwhelming, and the flavors shine without fuss.
If you’re looking for comfort, try a plain cheese pie or their veggie option. Each bite reflects a commitment to craft that makes Capellini a spot to seek out.
7. Sal Anthonys II
Sal Anthonys II feels like a true neighborhood mainstay. The first time I stopped in, I was greeted by a wave of savory scents and a friendly hello from the counter. This spot gives you the sense that they’ve been perfecting their craft for years.
Unlike some places that stick to the basics, Sal Anthonys II likes to experiment while staying true to the classics. Their cheese slice is a striking mix of tender crust and a generous melt of mozzarella, cooked just right for a golden finish. If you’re after a punch of flavor, try the veggie or white pizza—each one is loaded with fresh, vibrant toppings.
Consistency and a genuine welcoming vibe put Sal Anthonys II on the local pizza map.
8. Boccone Pizza Restuar
Boccone Pizza Restuar packs a flavor punch into every pie and does so without fuss. There’s a laid-back feel here; the kind that invites you to relax and linger for a while. I dropped by on a rainy afternoon, and the warmth inside instantly lifted my mood.
The menu here is refreshingly straightforward. Try the margherita or Sicilian slices—both showcase a crust that walks the line between airy and crispy. The tomato sauce tastes slow-simmered, and their cheese melts to the perfect stretchiness.
If you’re a fan of veggie pies, you’re in luck. Boccone’s has a variety that highlights crisp, well-prepared toppings. It’s a pizza spot that hits all the right notes, every time.
9. Selden Pizza
Selden Pizza feels like the quintessential corner pizza shop. The casual energy is clear from the moment you step in, and the staff keep things moving with a friendly efficiency. I’ve swung by late in the evening, only to find regulars chatting over slices at the counter.
The pies here have a straightforward, no-nonsense appeal. Their classic cheese pizza delivers on what matters—crispy edges, a chewy center, and a robust tomato sauce that stands out. For something a little different, check out their veggie slice, which gets plenty of fresh toppings without getting overloaded.
Selden Pizza stands out for its dependable flavor and community atmosphere, making it a top choice when you need a quick, satisfying meal.
10. Slices Pizza Boutique
Slices Pizza Boutique brings a modern twist to traditional pizza in Selden. The interior is bright and lively, making it just as suitable for a casual lunch as for a quick dinner run. I remember stopping in expecting standard fare and leaving pleasantly surprised by the care in each slice.
What’s impressive here is the creativity that goes into their menu. Their margherita slice is a favorite—thin, lightly crisped, and layered with fresh mozzarella and basil. Every order arrives hot and with clear attention to detail.
If you’re searching for variety, try their veggie slice or a simple cheese pie. Slices Pizza Boutique puts a boutique spin on pizza classics, making them worth the trip.
More Things to Try in Selden, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Selden, NY?
Top picks include Caffe Amici, Goomba Johnny’s Pizzeria, Papa Johns Pizza, and Slice’s Pizza Boutique. Each brings something unique to the local pizza scene.
Are there vegetarian or gluten-free pizza options in Selden?
Yes. Several spots like Caffe Amici and Boccone Pizza Restaurant offer both vegetarian toppings and gluten-free crusts for a range of dietary needs.
Which pizzerias deliver in Selden?
Most pizzerias in Selden offer delivery. Papa Johns, Goomba Johnny’s, and Selden Pizza are known for speedy, reliable service whether you order online or by phone.
Where can I find late-night pizza in Selden?
Look to Selden Pizza and Slices Pizza Boutique for late-night cravings. They tend to keep their ovens hot later than most.
Do any places offer specialty or Sicilian-style pizza?
Absolutely. Try Salvino’s, Boccone, or Capellini Trattoria Pizzeria for a Sicilian square that hits the spot. Many shops also create unique specialty pies you won’t find elsewhere.