There’s a certain joy in the smell of a good pizza place—garlic wafting, crust browning, and that hum of locals staking their claim to the “best slice” in town. Seaford, NY stands out on Long Island’s pizza map not because it screams at you from billboards but because of its quiet, loyal following. Spotting the perfect pizza here is less about flashy decor and more about what really matters: the slice on your plate. I’ve had the fun (and challenge) of biting into pies that ranged from chewy, classic New York foldables to caramelized crust wonders that leave you quietly plotting your next order.
This guide is for the curious, the pizza loyalist, and the occasional seeker of something new on a Friday night. Each spot on this list isn’t just a business—it’s a local favorite with stories, quirks, and a crust you’ll think about later. Whether you want a quick slice between errands or a drawn-out meal with family, you’ll find what you’re after. Hungry? That’s good—let’s dive into the ovens of Seaford and see which pizzerias deserve your attention.
Where to find the best pizza in Seaford, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Seaford, NY:
- Gino’s of Seaford
- Brooklyn Square Pizza
- Mario’s Pizzeria of Seaford
- Za Late Night Pizzeria
- Rosario’s Pizzeria
- Pappalardo’s Pizza Cove
- Aja Pizza
- Little Nicky’s Pizzeria
- Ronaldo Pizza
- Pappalardo Pizza Cove
1. Gino’s of Seaford
Gino’s of Seaford sits right on Merrick Road and feels like a neighborhood pizza staple the moment you walk in. The walls echo with laughter and chatter, and the menu features an impressive lineup of pies. Between the aroma and the sight of bubbling cheese, you know you’re in trusted hands.
My last visit ended in a face-off with a classic margherita pie—simple, but every ingredient pulled its weight. The crust is crisp on the outside, soft enough to fold, and never greasy. Gino’s also shines with its thin Sicilian slice, a specialty locals rave about.
Vegetarian options are solid, and service is warm yet quick, whether you dine in or take out. If you’re uncertain, start with the signature margherita or a white pie for a real taste of Gino’s style.
2. Brooklyn Square Pizza
Brooklyn Square Pizza brings a slice of old-school Brooklyn to the heart of Seaford. The spot is crisp and welcoming, with a vibe that suggests they take both their dough and their roots seriously. The first time I walked in, I caught a glimpse of a fresh pie being sliced, and knew I had to stay.
Their square pies are legendary—chewy, airy, and brushed with a balanced, robust sauce that stands up to the generous layer of cheese. The “Upside Down” square always wins me over: sauce on top, cheese underneath, and just the right amount of char along the edges.
Order by the pie or grab a slice, especially the Upside Down or a classic cheese for the full effect of what Brooklyn does best. If you like a crust you can actually taste, you’ll remember Brooklyn Square.
3. Mario’s Pizzeria of Seaford
Mario’s Pizzeria of Seaford has that classic pizzeria look—a bright counter, the warm scent of baking dough, and the hum of regulars waiting for their favorites. What makes Mario’s stand out is its dedication to the familiar, without getting stuck in a rut. The menu stays straightforward, and there’s always a new pie coming out of the oven.
When I dropped in last, I went for their plain cheese slice. Simple, but Mario’s cheese-to-sauce ratio is on point, and the crust is always firm enough for a good fold. To mix it up, their veggie pie offers a fresh, crisp take.
Seating is comfortable for a quick sit-down or a casual meal with friends. Start with their plain slice, then try the veggie if you crave something a little brighter.
4. Za Late Night Pizzeria
Za Late Night Pizzeria is where you go when most of Seaford’s lights are out but your pizza cravings are still wide awake. The cozy interior always makes you feel like you’ve stumbled on a secret spot, perfect for late-night slices and small talk.
The pizza here hits that sweet spot between crispy and chewy. I’m partial to their grandma pie—square, light on the cheese, and topped with a bright, tangy sauce that livens up every bite. It’s comfort food, but with just enough flair to keep you coming back.
Za’s menu is focused, but each pie is satisfying. Grab a grandma or classic cheese slice and savor the simplicity that keeps late-night regulars loyal.
5. Rosario’s Pizzeria
Rosario’s Pizzeria may look modest from the outside, but the pizza tells you everything you need to know. It’s the kind of place where the regulars greet each other, and even first-timers feel right at home. The dough is fresh, the cheese is generous, and you can always count on the slices being hot out of the oven.
I went for their Sicilian slice and wasn’t disappointed. The thick, pillowy crust with a golden bottom stood out—each bite had that homemade comfort that’s hard to fake. Their classic round pies also hold their own with a balanced sauce and crisp edge.
If you like a heartier slice, order the Sicilian; for something more classic, go round cheese. Rosario’s never cuts corners on quality, and it shows.
6. Pappalardo’s Pizza Cove
Pappalardo’s Pizza Cove is tucked away on Hicksville Road, and it feels like a genuine neighborhood find. When I stopped by, the aroma of baking dough and roasted tomatoes pulled me right to the counter. The place has a relaxed, slightly old-school air, but the pizza is fresh and modern in all the right ways.
Their Neapolitan round is a standout—thin, tender, and blistered just enough around the edges. If you prefer something heartier, the Sicilian is both light and satisfyingly thick, staying soft in the middle without losing structure.
If you’re indecisive, start with a round Neapolitan pie for that balance of chew and char. Pappalardo’s is about real ingredients and classic methods, never shortcuts.
7. Aja Pizza
(516) 809-9484Call
Aja Pizza at the edge of Bayview Street is one of those local secrets you almost want to keep to yourself. The place feels low-key, but the pizza surprises. On my first visit, I went in expecting something ordinary, and left with a new favorite slice in town.
Aja’s crust is thin, snappy, and carries plenty of flavor without being weighed down by grease. It’s the kind of slice that’s easy to finish but hard to forget. Their plain cheese delivers the basics perfectly, but the veggie slice packs on the freshness without losing crispness in the crust.
If you’re after a great value and a fuss-free menu, this spot is your go-to. Try the classic cheese or the veggie pizza, and enjoy how Aja nails the balance of quality and price.
8. Little Nicky’s Pizzeria
(516) 308-3785Call
Little Nicky’s Pizzeria on Merrick Road may fly under the radar, but local pizza fans know it’s worth a stop. The prices are easy on the wallet, but the flavor doesn’t take shortcuts. On a rainy evening, I ducked in for a quick slice and ended up staying for two—the dough was that good.
Little Nicky’s cheese slice is classic New York: thin, foldable, with just enough chew and a sauce that’s neither too sweet nor too tart. Each pie is cooked with the right balance, never overwhelmed by toppings.
Go for the plain cheese slice or ask for their veggie special. Little Nicky’s delivers comfort and quality, making you wish every neighborhood had a place this reliable.
9. Ronaldo Pizza
(516) 809-7501Call
Ronaldo Pizza sits right on Merrick Road, offering a straightforward take on the neighborhood slice. My first stop there was fueled by curiosity, and what I found was a pie that let each ingredient stand out without fuss. The vibe is simple—just good pizza and friendly service.
The crust at Ronaldo is thin, lightly crisped at the edge, and holds up to generous toppings. Their classic cheese slice gets the basics right, but there’s always a little twist—like a herby note in the sauce or a perfectly balanced cheese melt.
A cheese or plain slice is the way to go if you want to see what Ronaldo does best. There’s a comfort in knowing this spot doesn’t try too hard, and the quality shows.
10. Pappalardo Pizza Cove
Pappalardo Pizza Cove is the kind of pizzeria where the staff remembers regulars and the ovens rarely cool off. Tucked on Hicksville Road, it’s easy to overlook, but once you step in, the scent of rising dough and bubbling sauce draws you closer.
Their round pies are thin, light, and crisp at the edge, with a satisfying chew in every bite. When I stopped in, I went for the margherita—fresh basil and just the right touch of olive oil gave it a bright finish. The Sicilian is another star here, staying fluffy inside with that golden bottom locals rave about.
Start with the margherita or try the classic Sicilian for a taste of Pappalardo’s best. The flavors are always balanced, making each visit feel like the right choice.
More Things to Try in Seaford, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes Seaford’s pizza different from other places?
Seaford’s pizzerias combine classic New York style with local flair. You’ll find pies that balance crisp crusts, flavorful sauce, and generous cheese—all made with a neighborly touch.
Are there vegetarian pizza options in Seaford?
Yes, nearly every spot offers a solid vegetarian selection. Classic margherita, veggie-loaded pies, and white pizzas are popular choices across Seaford’s pizzerias.
Which pizzeria is best for a quick slice?
Gino’s of Seaford, Little Nicky’s, and Ronaldo Pizza are favorites for grab-and-go slices that hit the spot without the wait.
Do any Seaford pizzerias deliver?
Most pizzerias, like Gino’s of Seaford and Brooklyn Square Pizza, offer delivery and takeout. Many let you order online for convenience.
Are there late-night pizza options in Seaford?
Za Late Night Pizzeria is a top pick for satisfying cravings well past dinner, offering classic slices into the evening.