Finding standout pizza in Sayville, NY is a little like hunting for treasure, except the “X” always marks a pizzeria, and the reward is piping-hot perfection. Whether you’re strolling down Main Street, have a midnight craving, or just want a slice after a ferry ride, this hamlet quietly competes with the best of Long Island’s pizza culture. I’ve spent more nights than I care to admit weighing the virtues of thin, crisp slices against cheesy, pillowy pies, convinced that the best one always lies just around the next corner.
Sayville’s pizza scene is more than melted cheese and crust. Each shop reflects something about this town—family recipes, longtime regulars, and secret sauce debates that run so deep, you’d think someone was about to trademark oregano. The following guide pulls together not just the top spots, but also the quirks that make each pizzeria worth a visit. Read on if you believe pizza is not just a food, but a point of local pride—and if you want to avoid pizza regret.
Where to find the best pizza in Sayville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Sayville, NY:
- Sal’s Pizza
- Cherry Grove Pizza
- Umberto’s
- Sayville Pizza
- Metro’s On Main
- Domino’s Pizza
- Ginos of Sayville
- Sayville Pizza & Metros on main Italian Restaurant
- Eli Pizzeria
- Village Pizza Deli Convenience
1. Sal’s Pizza
Sal’s Pizza sits right on Main Street and offers the warm energy of a true neighborhood spot. Step inside and you’ll catch the aroma of handmade dough and simmering tomato sauce—a scent I’ve come to associate with pizza done right.
What makes Sal’s stand out is the crust. It’s airy, never greasy, with a softness at the center and a crisp snap at the edge. Their classic cheese pie is always a solid first choice, but the standout for me is their veggie slice. Fresh peppers and a generous pour of their signature sauce make it a cut above.
Sal’s is also a go-to for a quick lunch or no-fuss dinner. If you’re in the mood for variety, grab a Sicilian slice—the thickness and bold flavor show off their skill. Sal’s proves that simple, well-crafted pizza never goes out of style.
2. Cherry Grove Pizza
Cherry Grove Pizza feels like a seaside getaway with every visit. Tucked away near the water, it’s the kind of spot you find yourself drawn to after a beach stroll. I still remember grabbing a slice here after a sun-drenched afternoon—the relaxed vibe and friendly staff made it even better.
This place stands out for its relaxed charm and perfectly blistered pies. Their Margherita pizza is a favorite, showcasing a crisp crust layered with fresh tomato, creamy mozzarella, and just the right touch of basil. It’s both simple and impossible to forget.
If you like a bit of heat, try their veggie pie with fresh peppers. From the sound of the ocean to the satisfying crackle of baked dough, Cherry Grove Pizza wraps up the flavors of Sayville in every slice.
3. Umberto’s
Umberto’s offers a slice of Old World charm right in the heart of Sayville. It’s the sort of place with generations of regulars, where the staff treats you like an old friend even on your first visit. I once ducked in on a rainy afternoon, only to linger over a piping hot slice longer than I’d planned.
Umberto’s is known for its grandma pie—a thin, square creation with a deeply flavorful sauce and just the right amount of cheese. The crisp edges and tender center say a lot about the kitchen’s attention to detail.
If classic is your thing, try their margherita or a good old plain slice. Umberto’s brings the comforting, bold flavors of Italian-American pizza to Sayville, making it a beloved staple for locals and travelers alike.
4. Sayville Pizza
Sayville Pizza is a classic Main Street fixture, the kind of place where the ovens seem to have a story for every decade. I’ve stopped here after errands and always found a busy counter and the scent of fresh-baked crust drawing in the lunch crowd.
Their signature is a no-nonsense, New York-style pizza with a chewy, foldable base and a balanced sauce. It’s a reliable favorite when nothing but a classic slice will do. The fresh mozzarella slice gets my vote—simple, rich, and satisfying.
If you want a taste of their creativity, try their white pizza. Sayville Pizza keeps it straightforward, proving that sometimes, the best pizza is the one that makes you want a second slice before you’ve finished the first.
5. Metro’s On Main
Metro’s On Main blends a trendy vibe with the comfort of a family-run kitchen. From the moment you step inside, there’s a hum of conversation, clinking glasses, and the welcoming presence of staff who make you feel at home. My last visit stretched long past dinner, enjoying the easy energy and neighborhood feel.
It’s their inventive bar pies that truly set them apart. Each personal-size pie arrives crisp and hot, loaded with fresh toppings. The “Metro Veggie” is a standout—vivid, colorful, and packed with roasted vegetables on a charred thin crust.
If you’re after something unique, order their signature white pie. Metro’s fuses classic technique with creative touches, making every bite memorable. It’s where Sayville gathers when they want more than just a meal, but an experience.
6. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Sayville delivers reliable comfort, especially on nights when you crave something familiar and fast. I’ve found their speedy service a lifesaver during late study sessions and unexpected gatherings—it’s always hot when it arrives at the door.
The menu is broad and customizable, so you can go classic with a thin-crust veggie pie or dive into their chewy Handmade Pan. The cheese-to-sauce ratio is spot-on, making each bite pretty satisfying.
If variety is your mood, try building your own pizza. Domino’s stands out for its consistency and convenience, perfect for those times when you want pizza your way, right on schedule. It’s no-frills, but always hits the spot.
7. Ginos of Sayville
(631) 563-1000Call
Ginos of Sayville brings a classic Italian touch to the local pizza scene, complete with a welcoming smile and the bustle of regulars picking up takeout. I first dropped by during a storm, and the warmth coming off a fresh pie was the perfect remedy.
What sets Ginos apart is their balance of tradition and choice. The crust is thin and perfectly browned, with just enough chew. If you ask locals, their cheese pizza is a must, but the margherita and veggie pies also deserve a look.
It’s easy to see why this spot is a go-to for both takeout and casual dinners. Ginos of Sayville proves that great pizza is about honest flavors and time-tested recipes.
8. Sayville Pizza & Metros on main Italian Restaurant
Sayville Pizza & Metros on Main Italian Restaurant bridges classic pizza tradition with a modern Italian menu, all in one buzzing Main Street location. The fusion of cozy dining and quick counter service makes this spot a local favorite—especially for families and friends catching up over lunch.
The standout is their signature thin-crust pizza, which arrives hot and never overloaded with toppings. On my last visit, the margherita pie was a highlight, with fresh basil and a sauce that tasted like summer. Their veggie pizza is another go-to when I want something both filling and light.
If you want a side of atmosphere with your slice, this spot does not disappoint. Sayville Pizza & Metros delivers honest Italian flavors with every order, making it a reliable pick for any craving.
9. Eli Pizzeria
(631) 244-3600Call
Eli Pizzeria is one of those quiet gems tucked just off the main roads, known mostly by locals who like their pizza with a side of no-fuss comfort. I first found Eli’s thanks to a tip from a lifelong Sayville resident, who insisted the dough here is in a league of its own.
The crust at Eli Pizzeria is true perfection—not too thick, never soggy, and always with just the right char. Their plain cheese pizza makes a strong first impression, but the white pie shows how a simple mix of cheeses and herbs can steal the show.
Every pie feels thought-through, never overloaded, letting the fresh ingredients do the talking. If you value classic technique and a friendly spot to linger, Eli’s is worth a detour from Sayville’s busier blocks.
10. Village Pizza Deli Convenience
(631) 567-3692Call
Village Pizza Deli Convenience is an easygoing spot where pizza meets the classic deli counter, and locals swing by for a slice that never tries too hard. I once stopped in for a quick snack and ended up chatting with regulars over fresh, hot pizza—proof that everyone feels at home here.
Their pizza is sturdy, affordable, and tasty, especially if you’re on the hunt for a reliable cheese or veggie slice. It’s not fancy, just honest, hearty food that hits the spot after a long day.
The charm is in its simplicity. Village Pizza serves Sayville’s working crowd and families with old-school flavors, making it a down-to-earth choice for lunch or a no-fuss dinner.
More Things to Try in Sayville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What type of pizza is Sayville known for?
Sayville locals love classic New York-style pizza—thin, foldable slices, a balanced sauce, and the right cheese melt. Many pizzerias also offer crispy Sicilian and creative specialty pies.
Are there vegetarian-friendly pizza options in Sayville?
Absolutely. Most places, like Sal’s Pizza and Metro’s On Main, serve a variety of fresh veggie pies and plain cheese options that hit the spot for vegetarians.
Which Sayville pizza place is best for families?
Sayville Pizza, Ginos of Sayville, and Eli Pizzeria are all favorites with families thanks to casual atmospheres and generous portions.
Can I get gluten-free pizza in Sayville?
Several pizzerias offer gluten-free crusts—just call ahead to double-check availability and cross-contamination procedures.
Is there late-night pizza in Sayville?
Domino’s Pizza is your go-to for late-night cravings, delivering hot pies when most others have closed for the evening.