Savannah might be better known for Spanish moss and riverfront strolls, but let’s be honest—the right slice can turn any day into a celebration. As someone who has sampled pie from Bay Street to bustling Midtown, I can say with a straight face that this city’s pizza scene holds more than a few surprises. Whether you like your crust blistered and chewy or thin and crisp, the search for the best pizza in Savannah is an adventure worth savoring.
Choosing where to go takes more than a quick glance at toppings. There’s the atmosphere, that elusive aroma from the ovens, and how each spot puts its own local spin on the classics. Some places are no-frills, made for grabbing a slice on the way to Forsyth. Others make you want to linger, debating the merits of basil versus oregano over that last bite. If you’re looking for the real standouts, keep reading—you’re in exactly the right place.
Where to find the best pizza in Savannah, GA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Savannah, GA:
- Vinnie Van Go-Go’s
- Your Pie
- Graffito Pizza
- Mellow Mushroom Savannah
- Screaming Mimi’s Pizza
- Bella Napoli Italian Bistro
- Riverboat Pizza Company
- Your Pie
- Hop Atomica
- Starland Yard
1. Vinnie Van Go-Go’s
Vinnie Van Go-Go’s sits tucked in Savannah’s City Market, drawing pizza lovers like moths to an oven’s glow. This spot serves up classic New York-style pizza, with massive foldable slices and a crust that marries chew and crunch in perfect harmony. The atmosphere is pure Savannah—casual, bustling, and brimming with character.
What makes Vinnie’s stand out isn’t just the size, but the flavor. Their dough is made fresh daily, and you can taste it in every bite. I’ve lost count of evenings spent here, where the lively crowd and aroma from the kitchen make each visit memorable.
Order the white pizza—garlic, ricotta, and mozzarella in glorious balance—or classic cheese with fresh tomato. Both say everything about why this place is a local favorite.
2. Your Pie
Your Pie brings a breath of fresh air to Savannah’s pizza scene with its fast-casual charm and endless customization. Inspired by family traditions from the Italian island of Ischia, every pizza begins with hand-tossed dough and a lineup of fresh, carefully chosen ingredients. Walking in, you’ll catch hints of roasted garlic and see pizzas bubbling in the brick oven, each one tailored to the guest’s taste.
What sets Your Pie apart is choice. Vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options aren’t an afterthought here—you can build exactly what you crave. I’ve enjoyed many laid-back lunches here, finishing with a scoop of creamy gelato after a made-to-order pie.
Try the Skinny Pie or Southern Heat—both showcase Your Pie’s confidence in bold flavors and crisp, perfect crusts.
3. Graffito Pizza
Graffito Pizza fuses high energy with even higher standards for Neapolitan-style pies, right along the River Street hustle. The moment you step in, the open kitchen and friendly vibe hint that this isn’t just another pizza joint. Every pizza arrives with that signature blistered crust and balanced sauce—hallmarks of a real Neapolitan experience.
Graffito stands out for its focus on quality and atmosphere. The imported Italian flour, simple toppings, and quick wood-fired bake pay homage to tradition. I’ve enjoyed watching the pizzaiolos work, their care in every step reflected in the final product.
The Margherita is a standout—fresh mozzarella, bright tomato, and just the right hint of basil. It’s simple, classic, and perfectly executed here.
4. Mellow Mushroom Savannah
Mellow Mushroom Savannah is a slice of pure creativity on Liberty Street. Its quirky, colorful interior and laid-back vibe set the stage for pizzas loaded with flair. Gluten-free, vegan, and vegetarian diners all find easy choices here, but it’s the bold, house-made crust and imaginative toppings that win everyone over.
Mellow Mushroom stands out for its welcoming atmosphere and reliable consistency. The menu covers classics and inventive blends, each arriving hot with that unmistakable signature crust. I’ve dropped in after a long day, finding the Magic Mushroom Soup and a pie to be the perfect comfort combo.
Order the Kosmic Karma—sun-dried tomatoes, feta, spinach, and a swirl of pesto. It’s Mellow at its most vibrant, with every bite delivering style and substance.
5. Screaming Mimi’s Pizza
Screaming Mimi’s Pizza feels like a quirky Savannah staple the moment you walk in. The place buzzes with energy, and the huge New York-style slices almost spill off the plate. Chewy and thin yet strong enough for a healthy pile of toppings, the crust always impresses.
What sets Screaming Mimi’s apart is its old-school, no-nonsense approach. The atmosphere is casual, the service is brisk, and every slice delivers on flavor. After a late movie, I’ve grabbed a hot slice here more times than I can count, each time pleased by the quality and speed.
The spinach and ricotta pizza is a strong choice—simple, creamy, rich, and never overloaded. It’s proof that Screaming Mimi’s understands the balance of a great pizza.
6. Bella Napoli Italian Bistro
Bella Napoli Italian Bistro is tucked just off Wright Square, offering a slice of Napoli right in the Savannah Historic District. The aroma of baking dough immediately greets you, promising a meal that’s both soulful and authentic. Whether dining solo or with friends, the cozy interior invites you to linger.
Bella Napoli stands out for its dedication to traditional techniques and an approachable menu featuring fresh, high-quality ingredients. Every pizza is stone-baked, and the extra time in the oven gives the crust its irresistible texture.
Order the Margherita pizza—perfectly charred edges, San Marzano tomato sauce, and fresh mozzarella. Each bite highlights what makes Bella Napoli a frequent stop for anyone chasing true Italian flavor in Savannah.
7. Riverboat Pizza Company
Riverboat Pizza Company brings a relaxed charm to Savannah’s southside with its welcoming staff and inviting dining room. The hand-tossed dough and wood-fired oven give each pizza a rustic, memorable flavor. Every visit feels almost like coming home, thanks to the congenial vibe and unpretentious style.
What makes Riverboat Pizza Company stand out is their creative topping combinations and commitment to great crust. There’s pride in every pie, and you can see it in the perfectly browned edges and fresh ingredients.
The Riverboat Veggie pizza is a favorite—piled high with mushrooms, onions, peppers, and olives, it embodies their knack for turning classic flavors into something special. This spot is great for a casual dinner or takeout on the go.
8. Your Pie
+1 912-692-1123
Your Pie on Skidaway Road keeps things lively with its interactive, build-your-own pizza experience and friendly, energetic staff. The focus is always on quality, with hand-tossed dough and an array of fresh toppings for every kind of palate. Every visit feels like a new opportunity to tailor the perfect pizza or salad to your mood.
What makes this location special is its sense of community and consistent hospitality. I’ve made this a regular stop with friends, lingering over a hot pie and a side of gelato when the craving for comfort food strikes.
Give the Southern Heat pizza a try. It has roasted chicken, red onions, plenty of fresh veggies, and a swirl of tangy buffalo sauce—bold choices in every bite that showcase Your Pie’s adventurous side.
9. Hop Atomica
Hop Atomica blends a modern vibe with serious pizza chops in the heart of Savannah’s Starland District. Step inside and you’re greeted by a welcoming crew, the aroma of baking dough, and the buzz of locals who appreciate good food done right. There’s a creative edge to everything here, from decor to the deeply flavorful, hand-tossed pies.
Hop Atomica stands out by pairing inventive pizza with a relaxed, artsy atmosphere. My visits here always turn into long, easygoing meals, drawn out by friendly conversation and clever toppings that you won’t find anywhere else.
The Roasted Veggie pizza is a highlight—charred seasonal vegetables and bright herbs meet tangy tomato sauce, showing just how much fun vegetable-forward dishes can be. This is the place to try something a little different.
10. Starland Yard
Starland Yard transforms casual dining into a lively neighborhood event, thanks to its mix of brick-and-mortar spots and visiting food trucks. Set in an open, pet-friendly park, there’s always something new to experience, making each visit just a bit different from the last. The energy here, paired with live music and games, puts you in a good mood before you even grab a slice.
The real draw for pizza lovers is Pizzeria Vittoria, nestled among the rotating options. Their wood-fired pizzas feature pillowy crusts and creative, fresh toppings that set the bar for quality in Savannah.
Try the Margherita or any daily special. Every pie highlights inventive flavors and the kind of careful technique that keeps locals and visitors coming back.
More Things to Try in Savannah, GA
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizza place in Savannah for a classic slice?
Vinnie Van Go-Go’s is a local favorite for big, New York-style slices with a perfectly crisp crust and fresh toppings.
Are there good options for vegetarian or vegan pizza in Savannah?
Absolutely. Spots like Your Pie, Graffito Pizza, and Mellow Mushroom offer excellent vegetarian and vegan pizzas made with fresh, quality ingredients.
Which pizzerias offer gluten-free options?
Mellow Mushroom, Bella Napoli, and Your Pie all serve gluten-free crusts, making it easy to enjoy pizza without the gluten.
Where should I go for a unique or creative pizza?
Try Hop Atomica or Starland Yard’s Pizzeria Vittoria. They’re known for inventive toppings and bold flavors you won’t find elsewhere.
Are there late-night pizza spots in Savannah?
Screaming Mimi’s and Vinnie Van Go-Go’s are solid choices if you’re in need of a tasty slice after dark.