Finding the best pizza in Santa Barbara is more than a quest for a meal; it’s an exploration of rich flavors and diverse styles that reflect the charm of this coastal city. Imagine indulging in a slice that combines a perfectly crisp crust with fresh toppings, all while enjoying the sun-soaked atmosphere of Southern California. Over the years, I’ve tried various pizzerias here, each offering something unique, from classic Neapolitan pies to modern, artisanal spins. Each bite tells a story, inviting you into the vibrant culinary scene that makes Santa Barbara special.
Whether you’re a die-hard fan of thin crust or you’re searching for that perfect deep dish, this guide curates the most recommended spots to satisfy any pizza craving. Each listed pizzeria brings its own twist to the table, promising something for everyone. Get ready to discover local gems where the dough is crafted with care, toppings are fresh, and every establishment has its own twist, making them worthy of your next pizza night out. As you dive deeper into the list, you’ll find precisely the slice you’ve been longing for.
Where to find the best pizza in Santa Barbara, CA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Santa Barbara, CA:
- Lucky Penny
- Olio Pizzeria
- Persona Pizzeria
- Patxi’s Pizza
- Bettina Pizzeria
- California Pizza Kitchen
- Mizza
- Gino’s Sicilian Express
- Rusty’s Pizza Parlor
- Ca’Dario Pizzeria
1. Lucky Penny
Lucky Penny, nestled in Santa Barbara’s vibrant Funk Zone, is a must-visit for pizza lovers. The restaurant’s exterior is adorned with over 150,000 shimmering copper pennies, creating a unique and inviting atmosphere. Inside, the warm ambiance is complemented by pizzas crafted in a wood-burning oven, giving each pie a delightful smokiness that perfectly balances the fresh ingredients.
What truly sets Lucky Penny apart is its commitment to innovation. Their menu features artisanal pizzas like the Pesto Chicken, which combines grilled chicken, basil pesto, and fresh mozzarella for a vibrant flavor explosion. Pair it with a refreshing garden salad and one of their popular Frosé cocktails for the ultimate experience.
On my last visit, I savored the Margherita Pizza, where the simple combination of tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil stood out for its quality and taste. It’s a testament to their focus on fresh, local ingredients. Lucky Penny invites you to enjoy your meal on their lovely patio or take it to go, making it an ideal spot for any pizza outing.
2. Olio Pizzeria
Olio Pizzeria brings a slice of Italy to Santa Barbara, blending authentic flavors with a warm, welcoming atmosphere. The moment you step in, the aroma of freshly made dough and savory toppings envelops you, promising a delightful culinary experience. The pizzeria stands out for its commitment to quality, using traditional Italian recipes and locally sourced ingredients.
During my visit, I was captivated by the Truffle Pizza, which perfectly balanced earthy truffle oil with creamy mozzarella and fresh mushrooms. Each bite was a testament to Olio’s dedication to artisanal craftsmanship and flavor. If you’re in the mood for something lighter, the Margherita Pizza showcases the quintessential flavors of Italy, featuring fresh tomatoes and basil.
Pair your pizza with a selection from their artisanal beer or wine offerings for a complete experience. Olio Pizzeria is more than just a restaurant; it’s a tribute to the art of pizza-making, making it a top choice in Santa Barbara.
3. Persona Pizzeria
Persona Pizzeria is where creativity meets speed, making it a perfect spot for pizza enthusiasts. Located on State Street, this fast-casual eatery lets you design your own pizza, and with their impressive 800-degree oven, your creation is ready in under two minutes. It’s a thrilling experience to watch your pizza transform from raw ingredients to a cheesy masterpiece in no time.
What makes Persona stand out is its dedication to using imported Italian flour and fresh local ingredients, ensuring an authentic taste in every bite. I opted for a custom pie topped with spicy salami, mushrooms, and fresh arugula, and it was a revelation. The crust was perfectly crisp, while the toppings balanced flavor and freshness.
For those looking for alternatives, they offer a gluten-free crust that allows everyone to join in on the fun. Stop by Persona Pizzeria for a unique pizza experience where you can truly bring your culinary vision to life.
4. Patxi’s Pizza
Patxi’s Pizza is a beloved gem in the heart of Santa Barbara, known for its comforting dishes and inviting atmosphere. This pizzeria masterfully blends deep-dish and thin-crust styles, giving diners a flavorful experience no matter their preference. On my visit, I discovered that the menu offers something for everyone, including vegetarian and gluten-free options.
What truly sets Patxi’s apart is its signature deep-dish pizza, generously layered with fresh ingredients. I indulged in the Chicago-style deep dish topped with rich sausage, gooey mozzarella, and fresh veggies, all enveloped in a buttery, flaky crust. Each slice was a warm embrace of flavor.
The casual, family-friendly vibe makes it an appealing stop for dinner or late-night cravings. With delivery and takeout options, Patxi’s Pizza ensures you can enjoy a slice of comfort wherever you are.
5. Bettina Pizzeria
Bettina Pizzeria, nestled in Montecito Country Mart, is a culinary gem that elevates the pizza experience with its naturally leavened breads and Neapolitan-style pizzas. These artisan pies are slow-fermented for over 48 hours and cooked in a wood-fired oven, delivering a crust that is both blistered and delightfully chewy. My visit there felt special not just for the ambiance but for the attention to detail in every dish.
The standout offering is undoubtedly the creamed leek pizza topped with pork sausage and crispy shallots—a testament to Bettina’s commitment to using seasonal produce and sustainably sourced meats. Every bite bursts with flavor, particularly thanks to the house-pulled mozzarella and the tangy Bianco DiNapoli tomatoes.
Pair your pizza with vibrant small plates, like the fried calamari or burrata with eggplant caponata, which enhance the sharing experience. Don’t forget to indulge in their baked goods, especially the brown-butter chocolate chip cookies, for a sweet finish to your meal.
6. California Pizza Kitchen
California Pizza Kitchen (CPK) is a household name for many who crave innovative and delicious pizzas. Located in Paseo Nuevo, this casual eatery offers a vibrant atmosphere perfect for families and friends. On my visit, I was impressed by the extensive menu that caters to a variety of dietary preferences, ensuring everyone can find something delightful.
What makes CPK stand out is its signature approach to pizza. I decided to try the Thai Chicken Pizza, topped with grilled chicken, peanut sauce, and fresh cilantro—a unique twist that showcases their creative flair. The balance of flavors truly reflects California’s diverse culinary scene.
For a lighter option, their BBQ Chicken Pizza also deserves a mention, featuring smoky barbecue sauce, red onions, and cilantro. With both takeout and delivery options, California Pizza Kitchen makes it easy to enjoy their flavorful creations wherever you are.
7. Mizza
Mizza is a charming spot located in the heart of Santa Barbara that truly delivers on its promise of authentic Italian cuisine. What caught my attention was their commitment to being a scratch kitchen, where everything from the pizza dough to the sauces is made in-house. This dedication to quality shines through in every dish. The inviting patio allows for a relaxed dining experience, perfect for soaking up the local atmosphere.
One pizza that stood out during my visit was the Margherita Pizza. With a simple yet exquisite combination of fresh mozzarella, basil, and rich tomato sauce on a perfectly chewy crust, each bite tasted as if it came straight from Italy. The fresh, local produce truly enhances the flavors.
Mizza also offers a well-curated wine list and a range of gluten-free and vegetarian options, accommodating various dietary preferences. Whether dining in or taking out, Mizza guarantees a memorable experience with fantastic food and exceptional service.
8. Gino’s Sicilian Express
Gino’s Sicilian Express offers a casual yet vibrant dining experience in Santa Barbara, perfect for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner. This pizzeria captures the essence of traditional Sicilian cuisine, prioritizing fresh ingredients and authentic flavors. The moment I walked in, the warm smell of baked dough and bubbling cheese filled the air, instantly making me feel at home.
What sets Gino’s apart is its focus on generous portions and excellent quality. Their Sicilian-style pizza is a must-try, with a thicker crust that’s both crispy and soft on the inside. I particularly enjoyed the pepperoni and bell pepper pizza, which perfectly balanced savory and slightly sweet flavors.
With convenient delivery and takeout options, Gino’s Sicilian Express makes enjoying their delicious pizzas easy, whether you’re dining in or on the go. It’s a fantastic choice for anyone craving a slice in Santa Barbara.
9. Rusty’s Pizza Parlor
Rusty’s Pizza Parlor is a Santa Barbara staple known for its casual and family-friendly vibe. With a wide variety of pizzas and a focus on quality ingredients, Rusty’s has something for everyone. During my visit, I noticed the bustling atmosphere, where friends and families gathered to enjoy good food and great company.
What makes Rusty’s stand out is its commitment to hearty portions and diverse menu options. I went for the classic Rusty’s Special, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, and fresh veggies, which offered a delightful blend of flavors. The crust was perfectly crispy, and the generous toppings made each slice satisfying.
With convenient options for delivery and takeout, Rusty’s Pizza Parlor ensures that you can enjoy their delicious offerings wherever you are—making it a reliable choice for any pizza lover in Santa Barbara.
10. Ca’Dario Pizzeria
Ca’Dario Pizzeria is a delightful find in Santa Barbara, offering a taste of authentic Italian cuisine in a charming setting. With its cozy atmosphere and friendly service, this pizzeria makes for a great spot to enjoy a meal with family or friends. During my visit, I was struck by the warm hospitality that made me feel right at home.
One of the standout features of Ca’Dario is its commitment to quality ingredients and traditional methods. I opted for the Margherita Pizza, and it was remarkable—the perfect blend of fresh mozzarella, vibrant basil, and rich tomato sauce on a beautifully charred crust. Each bite was a testament to their attention to detail.
With options for both lunch and dinner, along with takeout available, Ca’Dario Pizzeria ensures that you can savor delicious pizza whenever the craving strikes.
More Things to Try in Santa Barbara, CA
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Santa Barbara, CA?
Some top picks include Lucky Penny, Olio Pizzeria, and Bettina Pizzeria, each offering unique styles and flavors that highlight local ingredients.
Does Santa Barbara have gluten-free pizza options?
Yes, many pizzerias in Santa Barbara, like Mizza and Patxi’s Pizza, offer gluten-free crust options, ensuring that those with dietary restrictions can still enjoy a delicious slice.
What is the typical style of pizza in Santa Barbara?
You’ll find a range of styles from Neapolitan to Chicago deep-dish, with many pizzerias focusing on fresh, local ingredients and artisanal methods.
Are there vegetarian and vegan pizza options?
Absolutely! Most pizzerias in Santa Barbara cater to vegetarian and vegan diets, with plenty of toppings and crust choices to suit different preferences.
Can I dine outdoors at pizza places in Santa Barbara?
Yes, many pizzerias, including Lucky Penny and Mizza, have outdoor seating options, allowing you to enjoy your pizza in the beautiful Santa Barbara weather.
What is the price range for pizza in Santa Barbara?
Prices can vary, typically ranging from about $10 to $25 per pizza, depending on the size and toppings. Most places also offer affordable lunch specials.
Is delivery available for pizza in Santa Barbara?
Yes, many pizza places like Rusty’s Pizza Parlor and California Pizza Kitchen offer delivery and takeout options for your convenience.
Can I find pizza by the slice in Santa Barbara?
Yes, several pizzerias offer pizza by the slice, making it a great quick option for lunch or a snack on the go. Check out places like Gino’s Sicilian Express for this option.