There’s something about pizza in San Angelo that hits differently. Maybe it’s the way the crust crackles just right, or how the sauce leans savory without trying too hard. I’ve spent more time than I’d admit weaving through the city’s pizza joints—sometimes for research, sometimes for comfort. One evening, after a long drive through West Texas, I found myself at a small pizzeria tucked between a laundromat and a hardware store. The slice I had there was simple, but perfectly balanced—crispy base, warm cheese, and a topping combo that didn’t try to impress, yet did. That’s when I realized: San Angelo doesn’t just serve pizza. It serves character.
This guide is built for those who want more than a quick bite. Whether you’re a local looking to branch out or a traveler chasing a good slice, you’ll find reliable, honest picks here. Each spot has been chosen for its consistency, flavor, and the kind of experience that lingers after the last bite. No fluff, no filler—just a curated list of the best pizza in San Angelo, TX. Let’s get into it.
Where to find the best pizza in San Angelo, TX
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in San Angelo, TX:
- Cork and Pig Tavern
- Trophy’s Pizza
- Joe’s Italian Restaurant
- DoubleDave’s Pizzaworks
- Cicis Pizza
- Old Central Firehouse Pizzeria & Taproom
- Domino’s Pizza
- Hot Stuff Pizza
- Lily’s Pizza
- Little Caesars
1. Cork and Pig Tavern
Nestled at 2201 Knickerbocker Rd, Cork and Pig Tavern offers a welcoming atmosphere perfect for any time of day. I recall visiting on a busy weekend, where the lively vibe and aroma of fresh ingredients immediately drew me in. The restaurant’s commitment to quality and guest satisfaction is evident from the moment you walk in.
What sets Cork and Pig apart is its diverse menu that caters to vegetarians, vegans, and anyone seeking gluten-free options. For pizza lovers, the Wood-Fired Margherita stands out for its crisp crust and flavorful tomato sauce, reflecting the restaurant’s dedication to authentic, high-quality ingredients. Pair it with their signature salads or craft beers for a truly satisfying experience.
2. Trophy’s Pizza
+32 59 47 74 99
Trophy’s Pizza at 4325 Southwest Blvd is a local favorite known for its friendly service and reliable takeout. On one visit, I appreciated how quickly my order arrived, piping hot and fresh—a rare find when you’re craving quality pizza on the go.
What makes Trophy’s Pizza stand out is its straightforward, classic approach. The Pepperoni Deluxe captures that perfect balance of crispy crust and generous toppings without overwhelming the palate. Every bite speaks to their focus on consistency and flavor.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or a casual dinner, Trophy’s offers delivery and wheelchair accessibility, making it convenient for many. Their menu covers all basics well, offering solid options for anyone seeking honest, satisfying pizza in San Angelo.
3. Joe’s Italian Restaurant
Joe’s Italian Restaurant at 1601 S Bryant Blvd is where comfort food meets tradition. I remember walking in on a quiet afternoon and being greeted with the scent of garlic and fresh dough. The cozy setting and attentive service made it feel like a family gathering, even though I was dining solo.
What makes Joe’s stand out is its dedication to handmade dishes. Their Joe’s Special Pizza is a local legend—loaded with fresh vegetables, cheese, and a sauce that’s rich without being heavy. It’s big enough to share, but you might not want to.
Vegetarian-friendly and ideal for lunch or dinner, Joe’s offers table service and takeout. If you’re after a slice that feels homemade, this is the place to start.
4. DoubleDave’s Pizzaworks
DoubleDave’s Pizzaworks at 3536 Knickerbocker Rd delivers more than a meal—it’s where game-day energy meets comfort food done right. My visit landed on a Friday afternoon, and the buzz around the pizza buffet was hard to miss. The setup is casual and friendly, perfect for families and anyone with a serious pizza craving.
What sets DoubleDave’s apart is its all-you-can-eat spread and signature rolls. The Philly Cheesesteak Stromboli deserves a spotlight—not your traditional pizza slice, but packed with flavor and that signature thin, buttery crust. For a slice, the Dave’s Favorite showcases what they do best: quality dough, fresh ingredients, and just the right bake.
Whether you want to eat in or take out, DoubleDave’s offers flexibility with delivery, dine-in seating, and easy access. It’s a great stop when you’re craving something dependable and filling in San Angelo.
5. Cicis Pizza
Cicis Pizza at 4415 Sunset Drive is a vibrant spot for those who enjoy variety and abundance. I visited on a weekday evening, and the lively buffet setup was tempting. The friendly atmosphere makes it an ideal place for families and groups to share a fun meal without breaking the bank.
What makes Cicis stand out is its all-you-can-eat concept. The Classic Pepperoni Pizza is a crowd favorite—crispy, cheesy, and loaded with toppings. The buffet also offers fresh salads, tasty pasta dishes, and sweet desserts, allowing everyone to customize their plates.
If you’re looking for a casual, budget-friendly meal that offers endless options, Cicis is perfect. It’s a reliable choice for filling up with good pizza and more in San Angelo.
6. Old Central Firehouse Pizzeria & Taproom
Old Central Firehouse Pizzeria & Taproom blends historic charm with a modern love for pizza. Housed in a restored 1929 fire station, it’s more than just a place to eat—it’s an experience. The exposed brick, vintage touches, and relaxed vibe make it a standout in downtown San Angelo.
What sets this spot apart is its commitment to quality. The dough is made fresh daily, and the ingredients are thoughtfully sourced. The Margherita Pizza is a must-try—simple, fresh, and balanced. For something heartier, The Firehouse Special delivers with bold flavors and a crisp, wood-fired crust.
Whether you’re grabbing lunch or winding down with dinner, this pizzeria offers a cozy setting and consistently good food. It’s a place where locals linger, and visitors feel like they’ve found a hidden gem.
7. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza at 2223 W. Avenue N. is a reliable go-to for pizza lovers in San Angelo. It’s the kind of place where convenience meets consistency, and the staff knows how to keep things moving without sacrificing quality.
What makes this location stand out is its range of crust options. The Handmade Pan Pizza is thick, golden, and satisfying, while the New York Style Pizza folds just right—perfect for those who like a classic slice. If you’re after something indulgent, the Parmesan Stuffed Crust delivers a cheesy punch in every bite.
On a busy weeknight, I grabbed a Pacific Veggie Pizza and was surprised by how fresh the toppings tasted. It’s a solid choice for anyone looking for flavor without going overboard.
Domino’s doesn’t try to be fancy—it focuses on getting the basics right. And in a town with plenty of pizza options, that’s what keeps people coming back.
8. Hot Stuff Pizza
Hot Stuff Pizza at 1801 College Hills Blvd offers a welcoming spot for those craving slice after slice. I visited during a casual weekend evening, and the aroma of freshly baked pizza filled the air—impossible to ignore. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere made it feel like a neighborhood favorite.
What makes Hot Stuff stand out is its consistent quality and focus on flavor. The Hot Stuff Special is a crowd-pleaser—delivered with a perfect blend of toppings, cheese, and a crisp crust. Their pizza combines classic styles with a touch of uniqueness, ensuring each bite is satisfying.
If you’re in the mood for a relaxed, hearty meal, Hot Stuff Pizza is a reliable choice. It’s well-known among locals for its delicious, straightforward approach to great pizza in San Angelo.
9. Lily’s Pizza
Lily’s Pizza in San Angelo is the kind of spot where flavor speaks louder than flash. Nestled on Vanderventer Ave, this cozy eatery leans hard into authentic Italian recipes with a Texas-sized helping of hospitality. The brick oven does the talking, producing hand-tossed pizzas that deliver crunch, char, and crave-worthy depth.
What makes Lily’s stand out is the balance between bold simplicity and quality ingredients. There’s nothing overcomplicated here—just pizzas made right. The Margherita is a masterclass in restraint, while the vegetarian calzone manages to be both hearty and refined.
If you’re planning a visit, start with the Brick Oven Veggie Pizza. Its roasted vegetables and crisp crust capture Lily’s signature style: satisfying, fresh, and unmistakably Italian—with no shortcuts.
10. Little Caesars
Little Caesars at 1505 S Bell St is known for offering quick, budget-friendly pizza that doesn’t compromise on flavor. I stopped by during a busy weekday, and their signature Hot-N-Ready pies made it easy to grab a satisfying meal without waiting. The efficient service and inviting scent made it clear why it’s a local favorite.
What makes Little Caesars stand out is its value and consistency. The Classic Pepperoni Pizza delivers a crispy crust, gooey cheese, and savory pepperoni every time. For a quick snack, their Deep! Deep! Dish is surprisingly hearty, with thick toppings and a thick crust that hits the spot.
Whether you’re in a rush or just looking for a straightforward, tasty pizza, Little Caesars provides reliable options in San Angelo—an easy choice anyone can enjoy.
More Things to Try in San Angelo, TX
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the best pizza in San Angelo, TX?
Check out Cork and Pig Tavern for wood-fired options, Joe’s Italian Restaurant for hearty Italian classics, and Trophy’s Pizza for local, no-frills charm. Each brings something different to the table.
Which pizza places in San Angelo are budget-friendly?
Little Caesars, Domino’s, and Cicis Pizza offer wallet-friendly prices with consistent taste. Hot Stuff Pizza is another solid pick if you’re near a convenience store location.
Are there any dine-in pizza restaurants in San Angelo?
Yes. Cork and Pig Tavern, Old Central Firehouse Pizzeria & Taproom, and Joe’s Italian Restaurant offer full-service dining with welcoming atmospheres.
Who serves the most unique pizza in town?
Old Central Firehouse Pizzeria & Taproom gets creative with its rotating menu of specialty pies and beer pairings. It’s a good choice if you want something beyond the basics.
Which pizza spot is best for takeout or delivery in San Angelo?
For speed and convenience, Domino’s, Little Caesars, and DoubleDave’s Pizzaworks handle takeout and delivery orders well. Orders are easy to place online or by phone.
Do any pizza restaurants in San Angelo offer halal or vegetarian options?
Some spots like Joe’s Italian Restaurant and DoubleDave’s offer vegetarian-friendly pizzas. To avoid haram items, always double-check the menu or call ahead to confirm ingredients used.
Is there a family-friendly pizza spot in San Angelo?
Cicis Pizza and DoubleDave’s Pizzaworks both offer casual settings, buffet-style options, and plenty of space for kids and groups.
Are there any local pizza joints, not national chains?
Yes. Trophy’s Pizza, Old Central Firehouse, and Joe’s Italian Restaurant are locally owned favorites. These places give you a taste of San Angelo’s own pizza style.
Where can I get late-night pizza in San Angelo?
Domino’s Pizza and Hot Stuff Pizza often operate later than most and are good bets for a late-night craving. Check specific hours, as they can vary by location.
Which places offer deep-dish or pan-style pizza?
Little Caesars has their Deep! Deep! Dish, while DoubleDave’s offers thick, filling crusts that come close to the deep-dish feel.