If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Salem, VA, you’ve landed in the right spot. Having spent countless evenings exploring the local pizzerias—from cozy family-run spots to well-known chains—I can confidently say Salem offers a flavorful slice for every palate. Whether you crave a thin crust topped with fresh basil or a sturdy pie loaded with halal-friendly meats and veggies, this town caters to every mood and appetite.
Navigating the pizza scene here isn’t just about finding a quick meal; it’s about uncovering places where quality ingredients meet authentic recipes. I’ve tasted pies with perfectly crisp crusts, rich sauces, and melted cheese that doesn’t overpower but complements. Stick around as we dive into Salem’s top pizza joints, each offering a unique twist that might just make it your new favorite. This guide promises clear and accurate details to help you make the perfect choice—no guesswork involved.
1. Mamma Maria’s
Mamma Maria’s, located on West Main Street, brings a genuine taste of Italy to Salem. The moment you walk in, the aroma of fresh herbs and baking dough signals a promise of quality. Their commitment to authentic recipes and top-notch ingredients shines through every dish, making it a standout spot for pizza lovers.
What caught my attention most was their deluxe pizza pies, crafted with a perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and fresh toppings. For those seeking halal-friendly options, the menu’s versatility, including vegetarian and vegan choices, ensures a satisfying experience for everyone. Their gluten-free crust is a thoughtful touch for diners with specific dietary needs.
Try the classic Margherita pizza—its simplicity highlights the freshness of their tomatoes, basil, and mozzarella, showcasing Mamma Maria’s dedication to quality. This isn’t just pizza; it’s a nod to Italian tradition, elevated to fit Salem’s diverse tastes perfectly.
2. Papa’s Pizza
Papa’s Pizza on Electric Road is a local favorite known for its comforting, no-frills approach to Italian and American favorites. During my visit, the inviting atmosphere and friendly service made it feel like a neighborhood gem where everyone is welcome. Their focus is on simplicity done right, which is evident in every bite.
What sets Papa’s Pizza apart is its consistent quality and hearty portions. The crust strikes a nice balance between chewy and crisp, perfect for supporting generous toppings. If you’re in Salem and want a reliable halal-friendly pizza, their classic pepperoni or veggie options are satisfying choices that showcase their commitment to fresh ingredients.
For a full experience, try the combination pizza, loaded with fresh vegetables and just the right amount of cheese—simple, flavorful, and exactly what you’d expect from a solid local pizzeria.
3. Lydia’s Italian Kitchen
Lydia’s Italian Kitchen on Riverview Drive impresses with a warm, family-friendly vibe and a beautifully renovated space. During my visit, the wood-fired brick oven created an inviting aroma that set high expectations—ones they clearly met. Their commitment to handmade dishes and fresh ingredients is evident throughout the menu.
What makes Lydia’s truly stand out is their wood-fired brick oven pizza, delivering a crispy crust with a smoky finish that captures authentic Italian flavors. Their extensive gluten-free options also make it easy for everyone, including halal diners seeking safe choices, to enjoy a meal here.
I recommend trying their Margherita pizza—simple yet flavorful, it highlights their approach to quality. Pair it with a fresh salad for a balanced, satisfying meal that perfectly reflects Lydia’s dedication to excellent food and happy guests.
4. Mamma’s Pizza
Mamma’s Pizza on South Electric Road is a cozy, family-owned spot that feels like a home away from home. I was drawn in by the inviting buffet, offering a variety of classic Italian dishes that promise something for every taste. It’s an ideal place for a casual meal or a gathering with friends and family.
What makes Mamma’s stand out is its balance of authentic flavors and affordability. Their pizza selection consistently delivers fresh toppings on a sturdy, flavorful crust. For anyone seeking halal-friendly options, their clear dedication to quality ensures every pie is made with fresh, trusted ingredients.
One standout is their daily dinner specials, which often highlight unique pizza creations and pasta dishes. Don’t miss the gelato for a sweet finish that complements the meal perfectly.
5. Frank’s Pizza
Frank’s Pizza, situated on East Main Street, offers a welcoming spot for pizza enthusiasts in Salem. From my visit, the warm ambiance and attentive service made for a memorable dining experience. Their menu features a variety of options that cater to both traditional and adventurous palates.
What sets Frank’s apart is its commitment to fresh, quality ingredients and flavorful combinations. Their vegetarian-friendly pizzas provide great choices for halal diners and those with dietary preferences. The crust strikes a pleasing balance—crispy yet tender—providing a solid base for the generous toppings.
The signature Supreme Pizza is a highlight, packed with fresh vegetables and savory spices, reflecting Frank’s style of bold flavors without overwhelming the senses. It’s an excellent pick for anyone seeking reliable, delicious pizza in Salem.
6. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on West 4th Street is a convenient choice for those looking to satisfy pizza cravings quickly in Salem. From my experience, their efficient service and consistent quality make them a reliable option, whether for takeout or delivery. The menu offers classic and innovative choices to suit a variety of tastes.
What distinguishes Domino’s is their wide selection, including thin New York Style and Handmade Pan pizzas. Their Parmesan Stuffed Crust pizza is a must-try, blending cheesy goodness with a crispy crust. For halal diners, it’s reassuring that Domino’s maintains high standards for ingredient quality and preparation.
Beyond pizza, their sides like mac and cheese and salads offer a nice balance to the meal. With frequent deals, Domino’s provides both value and taste, perfect for a casual night in.
7. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza on West 4th Street delivers a dependable pizza experience in Salem. I appreciate their clear focus on using better ingredients, which translates into pizzas with fresh dough, flavorful sauce, and quality toppings. This commitment is noticeable the first time you bite into their crispy, golden crust.
What makes Papa Johns stand out is their consistent attention to ingredient quality and flavor balance. Their menu offers a variety of options suitable for halal diets, ensuring inclusivity without compromising taste. The Classic Pepperoni Pizza is a standout, with perfectly seasoned pepperoni and a rich, tangy sauce.
Pair your pizza with their breadsticks or wings for a full meal. Whether ordering carryout or delivery, Papa Johns provides solid quality and flavor worth returning for whenever you want great pizza in Salem.
8. Milano’s Pizza And Italian Grill
+1 540-389-1111
Milano’s Pizza And Italian Grill on East 7th Street is a go-to for those craving generous portions and authentic Italian flavors in Salem. I was impressed by the sheer size of their pizzas, which make for a great shared meal. The blend of Tuscan, Sicilian, and Central-Italian influences adds depth to their menu.
What truly sets Milano’s apart is their claim to fame as the home of the largest pizza in Salem. This isn’t just a novelty—the quality remains high despite the size. Their toppings are fresh and thoughtfully combined, catering well to halal diners with vegetarian and classic options.
I recommend trying their classic Sicilian-style pizza, which combines a thick, airy crust with rich tomato sauce and a blend of cheeses. It’s a hearty, flavorful choice that captures Milano’s Italian roots perfectly.
9. Tivoli Pizza
Tivoli Pizza, located on Lynchburg Turnpike, offers a vibrant atmosphere perfect for family meals or casual outings. When I first visited, I was struck by the genuine warmth in the service paired with a menu that focuses on authentic Italian flavors. It quickly became clear why they’re considered among the best Italian restaurants in Salem.
Tivoli Pizza stands out for its commitment to quality and tradition. Their pizzas feature a perfectly balanced crust and fresh, flavorful toppings, ideal for halal diners looking for genuine Italian options. The classic Italian Margherita pizza is a highlight, showcasing simplicity at its best with fresh mozzarella, basil, and rich tomato sauce.
For a complete experience, pair your pizza with one of their house salads or sides. Tivoli’s dedication to taste and authenticity shines through in every dish, making it a must-try in Salem.
10. Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars Pizza on West Main Street is known for delivering quick, affordable pizza without compromising on taste. During my visit, I appreciated the streamlined service and consistent quality—a reliable option when time is tight but hunger calls. Their straightforward menu keeps things simple yet satisfying.
What makes Little Caesars a go-to is their commitment to value, paired with recognizable flavors. Their Hot-N-Ready classic pepperoni pizza stands out for its zesty sauce and crispy crust, ideal for halal diners seeking a trustworthy option. The balance between sauce, cheese, and toppings feels just right without being heavy.
For a no-fuss meal, this spot fits the bill perfectly. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or a whole pie, Little Caesars delivers recognizable, quality pizza at a fair price in Salem.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Where can I find halal pizza options in Salem, VA?
A1: Many Salem pizzerias offer vegetarian, vegan, or customized pizzas that can comply with halal requirements. Places like Mamma Maria’s, Lydia’s Italian Kitchen, and Papa’s Pizza provide fresh toppings and clearly indicate dietary options, making them solid halal-friendly choices.
Q2: Which Salem pizzerias offer gluten-free pizza?
A2: Lydia’s Italian Kitchen, Mamma Maria’s, and other local spots offer gluten-free crusts. These options ensure those with sensitivities can enjoy delicious pizza without sacrificing flavor.
Q3: Are there family-friendly pizza restaurants in Salem?
A3: Absolutely. Mamma’s Pizza and Lydia’s Italian Kitchen are well-known for their welcoming atmospheres and family-style dining, perfect for kids and groups.
Q4: Which Salem pizza places offer delivery or takeout?
A4: Domino’s, Papa Johns, Frank’s Pizza, and many others provide convenient delivery and takeout services, perfect for enjoying pizza at home.
Q5: What are the must-try pizza styles in Salem?
A5: From wood-fired brick oven pizzas at Lydia’s to thick Sicilian slices at Milano’s, Salem offers a range of styles. Try the Margherita for simplicity or a Supreme pie for a hearty meal.