If there’s one thing I’ve learned from wandering the streets of Rye, it’s this: pizza here is serious business. People can politely disagree about Yankees versus Mets, but ask someone about the best slice in town and you’ll get a passionate answer—sometimes with directions, family lore, and a warning about the “wrong cheese.” Rye’s pizza scene is a delightful patchwork of old-school parlors, modern kitchens, and well-guarded recipes that have fed the city for decades. Each place, whether it’s tucked away in a strip mall or lighting up the avenue at dusk, brings something unique to the table.
My quest to sample each contender began out of pure curiosity and a stubborn streak. I’ve navigated the labyrinth of local favorites, done my research (i.e., lots of eating), and compared sauce, crust, and ambiance. The results surprised me—and might surprise you, too. If you have a favorite spot, you might find it here. If you’re searching for a new go-to, this list is crafted to help you discover Rye’s top pizza, one savory slice at a time.
Where to find the best pizza in Rye, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Rye, NY:
- Sunrise Pizzeria
- Piazza Pizzeria
- Aldente Pizzeria
- Valtori Pizza Kitchen
- Tina’s Pizza & Cafe
- Sofias Pizza Restaurant
- Planet Pizza
- Aurora
- Mario’s Pizza & Restaurant
- Roddy’s Pizza
1. Sunrise Pizzeria
Sunrise Pizzeria manages to blend Rye’s small-town comfort with pizzaiolo-level skill. The spot is always buzzing, but the staff keeps things moving with a quiet confidence that only comes from years of perfecting the craft.
The first time I stepped in, the aroma of hot, bubbling cheese and slow-simmered tomato sauce stopped me cold. Their classic New York-style pizza is a solid pick—thin, foldable, with a crisp bite and just enough char on the bottom. There’s no fuss, just honest flavor. Try their Margherita for the sweet basil and creamy mozzarella, or spice things up with the veggie-loaded Primavera.
What sets Sunrise apart is their generosity with toppings and how even a simple slice feels thoughtful. If you’re in a rush, their quick takeout keeps things easy—a serious perk for any pizza lover in Rye.
2. Piazza Pizzeria
Piazza Pizzeria catches your attention with its inviting storefront and keeps you coming back with honest, satisfying pies. The atmosphere feels easy—more of a neighborhood anchor than just another pizza shop. Piazza’s approach is classic but elevated, with dough that’s slightly chewy and sauce that leans just right on the tangy side.
My go-to move is to sit by the window, flipping through their menu, then always ending up with the signature Piazza Special. Loaded with crisp vegetables and just enough gooey cheese, it’s a balance that tastes thoughtfully constructed.
The white pizza here deserves mention, with its creamy ricotta, garlic, and a gentle touch of spinach. If you want pizza that comforts without any pretense, Piazza delivers the goods every single time.
3. Aldente Pizzeria
Tucked just off Rye’s main stretch, Aldente Pizzeria is the sort of spot where locals know the staff by name and out-of-towners get treated like regulars. There’s a welcoming vibe, and a nostalgic aroma that takes you somewhere between a family kitchen and your favorite old-school pizzeria.
What sets Aldente apart is their unwavering commitment to dough—the crust here gets special attention, coming out crisp at the edges but tender and just a bit chewy in the center. A bite feels honest, the sauce tangy, and the cheese perfectly stretchy.
I always find myself returning to their classic Margherita, which lets the bright tomato and velvet mozzarella shine. For a little adventure, try the Quattro Formaggi. Aldente nails the simple things, and that’s what keeps the regulars loyal.
4. Valtori Pizza Kitchen
Valtori Pizza Kitchen hums with energy, its open layout welcoming families, friends, and solo diners alike. There’s something about watching the staff work behind the counter—every toss of dough feels like a small performance.
Valtori’s biggest draw is its crave-worthy pizzas, each with a crust that manages crispiness and chew in proper balance. I remember one lunchtime visit where the steady rhythm of the kitchen was matched only by the steady flow of customers picking up hot pies.
The standout? Their classic cheese pizza, which arrives golden, generous, and piping hot. If you’re after variety, the veggie slice piles on peppers, mushrooms, and olives without overwhelming the sauce. Valtori’s pizzas are built for sharing, but you might want the whole thing to yourself.
5. Tina’s Pizza & Cafe
(914) 481-8481Call
Tina’s Pizza & Cafe is that cozy neighborhood spot where everyone seems to linger a bit longer. The interior is bright and friendly, and there’s an inviting aroma the moment you step through the door. Whether you’re sitting in or grabbing a slice to go, Tina’s manages to make each customer feel like their order matters.
The pizzas here have a light, airy crust that doesn’t overpower the rest. If you’re looking for a standout, try their mozzarella and tomato slice, balanced with just the right amount of basil. Their plain cheese slice is another crowd favorite, built around a sweet tomato sauce and rich, stretchy cheese.
There’s a certain understated charm to Tina’s. You get classic flavor, generous portions, and a sense of comfort that keeps you coming back whenever you need a slice that feels like home.
6. Sofias Pizza Restaurant
(914) 835-2862Call
Sofias Pizza Restaurant brings a classic, unfussy touch to Rye’s pizza scene. There’s a lived-in feeling to the place, and it always seems to have a steady stream of regulars. You get the sense that everyone here has their go-to order—and after a visit, you probably will too.
The warmth starts behind the counter and extends right to your table. Their Sicilian slice—pillowy, golden, and generously topped—is what first grabbed my attention. With a sauce that tastes fresh and plenty of gooey cheese, it’s a piece of comfort done right.
Sofias excels at simple, classic pies made with care. For anyone chasing that old-school pizzeria vibe, this spot is easy to recommend.
7. Planet Pizza
Planet Pizza keeps things lively in Rye with quick service and an impressive roster of pies. The space has a steady, cheerful buzz, making it perfect for grabbing lunch with friends or feeding a hungry group.
What stuck with me was the first bite of their classic cheese slice—the crust is substantial without being dense, and the sauce strikes a nice balance between sweet and savory. They’re not afraid to get creative, either. The veggie slice loads on peppers and onions, while the spinach and mushroom pie packs plenty of flavor and a satisfying bite.
Planet Pizza never skimps on toppings or quality, which is why it keeps regulars returning. It’s a reliable go-to when you want variety and absolutely crave-worthy pizza.
8. Aurora
Aurora is a slice of Italy in Rye, capturing that elusive blend of casual elegance and cozy warmth. The first thing you notice is the aroma of wood-fired pizzas floating through the air. Sitting by the window on a quiet Sunday, I found myself savoring both the view and the food—a rare treat in the bustle of everyday life.
The pizzas here stand out for their texture. The crust is thin, blistered, and smoky from the oven, while the sauce bursts with brightness. The Margherita is a must-try, balancing mozzarella and basil with classic Italian simplicity. For something richer, opt for the earthy mushroom pie, which comes with just the right touch of truffle oil.
Aurora promises a dining experience that’s memorable, especially for anyone searching for pizza that leans elevated but never pretentious.
9. Mario’s Pizza & Restaurant
Mario’s Pizza & Restaurant draws in locals with the promise of genuine Italian flavors and a friendly welcome. On my last visit, the buzz of conversation and the scent of fresh dough set the scene for a satisfying meal.
What makes Mario’s memorable is consistency. Their sauce hits a balanced note between tangy and savory, and the crust always arrives perfectly golden. The classic cheese pizza is reliable and comforting, but I’m partial to their mushroom pie, which is generous with earthy toppings and melty cheese.
If you want pizza that’s unpretentious but clearly crafted with care, Mario’s delivers. Their takeout service is quick too, which makes it a practical go-to for busy weeknights.
10. Roddy’s Pizza
(914) 937-5120Call
Roddy’s Pizza has a loyal following for a reason. It’s the kind of classic pizzeria where regulars chat at the counter and the pizza never disappoints. My visit was met with the hum of conversation and the sight of big, golden pies moving quickly from oven to table.
There’s extra attention to the crust here—thin, sturdy, and crisp enough to hold plenty of toppings without drooping. Their classic cheese pizza is always a solid choice, but if you’re looking for something with a little zing, the veggie slice brings color and crunch in every bite.
Roddy’s excels at delivering comfort in a simple, unfussy way. It’s a spot you keep on your list for dependable, tasty pizza any day of the week.
More Things to Try in Rye, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Rye, NY?
Rye has lots of choices, but some favorites include Sunrise Pizzeria, Piazza Pizzeria, Aldente Pizzeria, Valtori Pizza Kitchen, and Roddy’s Pizza. Each offers something unique—from classic, foldable slices to creative toppings and specialty pies.
Are there vegetarian pizza options in Rye?
Yes, many pizzerias in Rye offer vegetarian-friendly pizzas. Try the veggie slices at Valtori Pizza Kitchen or the fresh Margherita at Aldente Pizzeria for flavorful meat-free options.
Do Rye pizzerias offer takeout or delivery?
Most pizza places in Rye provide both takeout and delivery. Sunrise Pizzeria, Mario’s Pizza, and Planet Pizza are known for their fast, reliable service.
Where can I find wood-fired pizza in Rye?
Aurora is well-loved for its wood-fired pizzas, featuring thin, lightly charred crusts and high-quality toppings that bring a touch of Italy right to Rye.
Which pizzerias are good for families?
Tina’s Pizza & Cafe and Sofias Pizza Restaurant both have warm, welcoming atmospheres with plenty of seating—perfect for family meals or group gatherings.