Looking for the best pizza in Russellville, KY feels a bit like searching for hidden treasure. The town may not shout its love of pizza from the rooftops, but those in the know understand that the spots here deliver far more than a quick fix. Over the years, I’ve wandered through Russellville’s neighborhoods on a quest for that perfect slice—the kind that surprises you with every bite and makes you forget about the world for a moment.
Whether your taste leans traditional or you’re after something unique, Russellville has a spot for you. Each pizzeria comes with its own story, a little local charm, and a recipe or two that keep friends arguing over favorites. I’ve tasted my way through them all, so you’re in good hands. Read on, and let’s unravel which places truly rise above the rest.
1. Sylfoni’s Pizza
(270) 946-9922Call
Tucked into Bethel Shopping Center, Sylfoni’s Pizza feels like a gem only locals know. When you walk in, the aroma sets the stage—cheese bubbling, sauce simmering, crusts finishing in the oven. The casual space means you can relax and focus on what matters: the pizza.
What sets Sylfoni’s apart is its crave-worthy crust. It’s crisp enough to hold up, yet soft at the edge, hinting at homemade roots. I still think back to the day I tried their “Classic Supreme”—layers of pepperoni, peppers, and onions, all in balance without feeling overloaded.
The cheese blend here melts just right, and the sauce hits that sweet-and-savory spot. If you want a taste of Russellville tradition in every slice, this spot won’t let you down.
2. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Walking into Hunt Brothers Pizza inside Stop N Shop 1 always reminds me of late-night cravings that demanded quick satisfaction. Their counter is never complicated. It’s all about building your perfect pizza without fuss.
The real standout here: all toppings come at no extra charge. That’s a dream for anyone who likes to customize. Pile on peppers, olives, or onions—your pizza, your choice, no nickel-and-diming.
If you ask me, the original crust has that classic, chewy bite. Try the Veggie Lovers option with extra cheese, or build your own for a combination that hits the spot. This place proves you don’t need frills for a satisfying, flavor-packed dinner.
3. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on North Main Street is a familiar stop, whether you’re grabbing a bite after errands or settling in for movie night at home. The smell as you walk in brings back a lot of memories—cheesy, toasty, and always a little bit nostalgic.
What really makes Pizza Hut stand out is consistency. The crust is always warm and just the right thickness. Their Original Stuffed Crust and the Meat Lovers® pizza are easy crowd-pleasers. I always find myself reaching for one more slice, even if I claim I’m full.
If you want something classic, go for the Pan Pizza. The carryout and delivery options are a lifesaver when you just want comfort food—fast and reliably tasty.
4. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza on West 9th Street always catches my attention with its promise of “better ingredients.” You notice it right away—one bite and the sauce tastes brighter, the dough a little fresher than your average chain.
What makes this spot shine is the perfect balance in their Classic Cheese or Garden Fresh pizzas. The crust stays soft and chewy, but every slice holds up under those generous toppings. I’ve often grabbed a pizza for a quick lunch, and the flavor never disappoints.
If you want my advice, try the Classic Garden Fresh pizza for a veggie-packed punch or order the thin crust for a lighter meal. Each pizza reflects Papa Johns’ commitment to good flavors, done with consistency.
5. Domino’s Pizza
What I like most about Domino’s Pizza at Shelton Lane is how fast they manage to deliver every time. The menu is loaded, but the pizza always arrives hot, cheese still bubbling, and just how you asked for it.
If you like options, Domino’s has you covered. The New York Style pizza is perfect if you want thin, foldable slices—great for anyone who likes to eat on the go. The Handmade Pan, meanwhile, gives you a thicker, golden crust. I’ve found the Veggie pizza here delivers a nice balance, never soggy or bland.
Try their Parmesan Stuffed Crust for something indulgent. The value deals make ordering more than one pizza pretty tempting, especially if you can’t settle on just one style. It’s hard to go wrong here.
6. Filling Station
(270) 717-1170Call
The Filling Station on Bowling Green Road is a spot you probably wouldn’t expect to be on a pizza list, but the locals know better. There’s a laid-back charm here—no rush, just good food and friendly conversation while you wait.
It’s the kind of place where the crust comes out with a golden edge, and every topping feels thoughtfully placed. I remember stopping in for a quick bite and being surprised at how satisfying the veggie pizza was—loaded with fresh, colorful ingredients.
You can’t go wrong with their classic cheese pizza. The balance between the sauce and the melted cheese hits just right, making it an easy favorite when you crave a no-nonsense, quality pie in Russellville.
7. Little Caesars
(270) 847-4162Call
Little Caesars on Sam Walton Drive is the place for anyone who values speed and simplicity. More than once, I’ve popped in on a busy night and walked out with a hot pizza in minutes—no waiting, no hassle.
The crust here is always sturdy with a nice chew, and the balance of sauce and cheese nails that straight-out-of-the-oven taste. Little Caesars’ Hot-N-Ready cheese or veggie pizzas work when you need pizza in a pinch, and they never cut corners on freshness.
If you want variety, grab a thin crust for an extra-crispy bite or try their stuffed crust if you’re feeling a little more indulgent. Sometimes, a classic pie done well is all it takes to turn any meal around.
8. Papa Murphy’s Take N Bake Pizza
Papa Murphy’s Take N Bake Pizza on Walton Road is a twist on the usual pizza run. You step in, pick your pizza, and leave with it ready to bake fresh at home. There’s something satisfying about pulling a pizza from your own oven and letting the aroma fill your kitchen.
The Cowboy pizza is my go-to—it’s piled high with mushrooms, olives, and gooey cheese, with the crust baking up golden every time. If you like to tweak flavors, you can even adjust the toppings before you bake.
Papa Murphy’s feels right for those who want piping-hot pizza on their own schedule. It’s convenient, fun, and always delivers on taste.
9. Casey’s General Store
Casey’s General Store on West 9th Street isn’t just a stop for fuel—it’s an unexpected haven for pizza fans in Russellville. There’s something almost legendary about grabbing a hot, made-from-scratch pizza from a spot better known for coffee and snacks.
What makes Casey’s pizza special is the bakery-style dough and rich, flavorful sauce. The cheese blend stays gooey until the last bite, and every pizza feels freshly made, not just assembled. I’ve picked up their veggie pizza on road trips, and it always hits the mark when I need real food, fast.
If you want a classic with a twist, try the breakfast pizza. It’s hearty and full of flavor, and it shows the creativity behind Casey’s menu.
10. Ariella
Ariella on South Main Street brings an Italian flair to Russellville’s pizza scene. When you step in, it feels like a cozy family-run trattoria, where the kitchen hums and every table is greeted with warmth.
Their pizza stands out for its artisanal crust—perfectly crisp at the edge and light in the center. I’m a fan of the Margherita pizza; the fresh basil and tomato deliver real flavor, while the cheese stretches just the right amount.
For something more robust, try one of their specialty veggie pizzas. Each bite speaks to the kitchen’s attention to detail. Ariella shows that pizza can be elegant and comforting, all in one sitting.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Russellville, KY?
You’ll find a range of favorites, from local spots like Sylfoni’s Pizza and Ariella to popular chains such as Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Papa Johns. Each brings its own style—try a few to find your personal favorite.
Who offers the fastest pizza delivery in Russellville?
Domino’s and Pizza Hut are known for their speedy delivery. For take-and-bake, Papa Murphy’s lets you skip delivery and bake at home when you’re ready.
Where can I find vegetarian pizza options?
Just about every pizzeria in Russellville offers veggie pizzas. Ariella, Casey’s General Store, and Papa Johns have reliable vegetarian options packed with fresh vegetables and balanced flavors.
Are there any unique or local pizza experiences in the area?
Sylfoni’s Pizza and Ariella offer that local charm you don’t get from the big chains. For something different, the breakfast pizza at Casey’s General Store turns your morning into a treat.
Can I customize my pizza in Russellville?
Absolutely. Most spots, especially Hunt Brothers Pizza, Domino’s, and Papa Murphy’s, encourage you to build your own pizza with a range of toppings, sauces, and crust options. You can keep it classic or get creative.