Finding great pizza in Russellton, PA isn’t a scavenger hunt; it’s a rewarding stroll down a lane of neighborhood gems and hidden sauce secrets. This isn’t about chasing Instagram trends or trusting oversized billboards. The best slices in Russellton come from ovens tended by folks you’ll find tossing dough behind the counter, still chatting with the regulars. The aroma alone is half the charm, curling through the air and drawing you in after a long week or a rainy night.
When I first rolled through Russellton, I stopped for a quick bite at a spot that looked as unassuming as any roadside pizza joint. A local steered me inside with a knowing nod. That one slice was enough—a crisp, chewy crust, the right hit of tomato, cheese that stretched like it meant business. From that moment, I started keeping track of where the pies sang out loud and clear. If you want reliable slices, family recipes, and maybe even a little something you haven’t tried before, this list will lead you straight to the good stuff. Each spot has a story, and your new favorite could be just around the corner.
1. Stello’s Pizzeria
Stello’s Pizzeria sits at the heart of Russellton—unpretentious, always warm, and clearly run by people who know their dough. On a recent visit, the staff carried on animated conversations with nearly everyone who walked in, myself included, which gave the place a lived-in, familiar charm.
What sets Stello’s apart is their crust, rolled out just-thick-enough to hold a serious load of toppings without ever turning soggy. There’s a real art to their sauce—a hint of sweetness, balanced with the right tang to complement each bite.
If you want to understand why locals swear by Stello’s, try their classic cheese or their veggie pizza. Both reflect the pizzeria’s commitment to quality, showing off fresh ingredients and that unbeatable, golden-baked finish.
2. Fox’s Pizza Den
Fox’s Pizza Den feels like the kind of place where old friends gather and newcomers quickly become regulars. On my last visit, a friendly debate broke out at the next table about whose favorite pizza is the best, and I couldn’t help but smile. The staff here remember your order almost as quickly as your name.
Fox’s stands out with its generous toppings and a crust that finds the sweet spot between soft and crisp. They offer a broad menu, but pizza is the undisputed star. You can count on fast service, whether it’s a takeout night or you need a quick bite with family.
Try the traditional deluxe pizza—a no-nonsense blend of cheese, peppers, and plenty of pepperoni. It’s unmistakably Fox’s: satisfying, flavorful, and made to order every time.
3. Matts Sub Shack and Pizza
(724) 265-3322Call
Matt’s Sub Shack and Pizza is the kind of small-town place where lunchtime is both casual and comforting. My stop at Matt’s turned into a genuine break from the day—the warm greeting at the counter and the aroma of fresh dough set a familiar, relaxed tone.
The focus here is on flavor. Their pizza stands out for its generous layer of cheese and a crust that’s both crispy and light. There’s a straightforward, no-frills style to the pies that makes every slice feel honest and filling.
The classic cheese pizza at Matt’s is a cornerstone: simple, packed with real cheese, and just the right amount of sauce. For something a little more indulgent, the veggie pizza showcases Matt’s knack for balancing toppings and flavor.
4. Zrebny’s Pizza Shop
(724) 265-4400Call
Zrebny’s Pizza Shop is a true local spot—unpretentious, with friendly banter drifting from behind the counter. The first time I ordered here was on a neighbor’s recommendation, and it didn’t disappoint. There’s a comfort in their straightforward approach and the inviting scent of fresh-baked pies in the air.
What makes Zrebny’s special is their crust: firm at the edges, just soft enough in the center. You’ll notice every bite is loaded with a balanced mix of sauce and cheese, a clear sign these folks value tradition and quality.
If you want to taste what sets Zrebny’s apart, start with their classic cheese pizza—a lesson in satisfying simplicity. Their veggie pizza is also worth a try, with crisp toppings that highlight their careful prep and oven time.
5. P & M Pizza
(724) 339-9177Call
P & M Pizza proves that you don’t need a flashy storefront to draw a loyal crowd—just good food and a friendly touch. My first time picking up an order here, I was greeted by name on my second visit, and that’s something you remember.
The appeal at P & M is in the details: consistently flavorful sauce, cheese with just the right stretch, and a crust that stays crisp even after a ride home. There’s no fuss or pretense, just straightforward, honest pies at a wallet-friendly price.
If you’re not sure what to try, go for their signature cheese pizza or the veggie pizza. Both are reliable choices that showcase why P & M has become a low-key staple among locals in the Russellton area.
6. Fazio’s Pizza & Italian Foods
(724) 337-8521Call
Fazio’s Pizza & Italian Foods brings a bit of old-world flavor to the Russellton area. The first time I dropped by, I left with both a hot pizza and a bag of ingredients to try making my own at home. It’s a place where tradition and food culture mix seamlessly.
Fazio’s stands out for its deep roots—they’ve been perfecting their recipes since 1968, and it shows in every slice. Their dough is always just right, and the sauce has a distinct richness from imported Italian ingredients.
If you’re craving something standout, the classic cheese or veggie pizzas deserve your attention. Each bite is a tribute to their long history, giving you a taste of real Italian care in every crust, sauce, and layer of cheese.
7. Sisters Corner Shoppe
(724) 265-1350Call
Sisters Corner Shoppe feels like the beating heart of its neighborhood—every visit just feels a little more personal. My first pie from here came on the recommendation of someone who insisted, “You’ll taste the care in every bite.” They weren’t wrong. The smile from behind the counter set the tone for a true local experience.
What catches your attention here is the crust: chewy, golden, and clearly made with patience. The cheese is melted perfectly, never greasy, and the sauce carries just enough seasoning to pull you in for another slice.
If you’re considering what to order, start with their cheese pizza—simple, yet full of flavor. For a twist, their veggie pizza does justice to its fresh toppings, all brought together on that signature crust.
8. Donatos Pizzeria
Donatos Pizzeria blends classic comfort with a modern, friendly vibe that’s easy to enjoy, whether you’re dining in or taking your pie to go. The first time I tried Donatos, the sheer uniformity of the toppings made me pause—it’s a detail that shows they take pride in every pizza served.
Donatos stands out thanks to its signature thin crust, which somehow stays crisp under layers of expertly applied sauce and cheese. The crust is the right kind of crunch, never dry, and gives each bite a satisfying finish.
For a taste of what makes Donatos different, try their classic cheese pizza or the veggie option. Both showcase generous toppings and that signature square-cut style, delivering flavorful bites from edge to center.
9. Don’s Pizza
(412) 767-1717Call
Don’s Pizza keeps things straightforward—good food, quick service, and a vibe that feels like part of the neighborhood. The first time I dropped by, the team behind the counter swapped pizza tips like old friends, making the space genuinely inviting.
This is the place where pizza means comfort. Their dough is soft in the middle, with just the right crunch at the edge, and every slice is loaded with flavor. Don’s doesn’t try to reinvent the wheel; they just serve it well every time.
If you want to keep things classic, go for the cheese pizza—each bite is balanced and rich. For something extra, the veggie pizza piles on fresh toppings that keep things interesting without losing that traditional Don’s touch.
10. Villa Ballanca
Villa Ballanca has the classic atmosphere you want when you’re in the mood for a genuine Italian meal. The first time I walked in, the smell of fresh-baked pizza and herbs was enough to let me know this wasn’t fast food—it was slow-cooked comfort.
What makes Villa Ballanca unique is its commitment to generous portions and bold flavors. The crust is perfectly risen with just the right amount of chew. The sauce is rich, tangy, and layered under cheese that melts beautifully every time.
To get the full experience, try their cheese pizza or the veggie pizza. Both showcase the same attention to quality ingredients and time-honored recipes Villa Ballanca has built its reputation on in the Russellton area.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top pizza places in Russellton, PA?
Russellton has several standout spots for pizza including Stello’s Pizzeria, Fox’s Pizza Den, and Matts Sub Shack and Pizza. Each spot offers its own style and atmosphere, so there’s something for every taste.
Are there any pizza places in Russellton with vegetarian options?
Yes, many of Russellton’s pizzerias serve quality veggie pizzas. Stello’s, Zrebny’s Pizza Shop, and Villa Ballanca are known for their fresh and flavorful vegetarian choices.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Russellton?
Options can vary, but some restaurants in the surrounding area, like Donatos Pizzeria, occasionally offer gluten-free crusts. It’s best to call ahead to confirm availability before visiting.
Do Russellton pizzerias offer delivery or takeout?
Most local pizza places, including Fox’s Pizza Den and Donatos Pizzeria, offer both takeout and delivery. Check their websites or give them a call to see current options and hours.
Which pizza spot is best for families or groups?
Many pizzerias in Russellton are family-friendly, but Fox’s Pizza Den and Stello’s Pizzeria stand out for their welcoming service, space, and flexible menu for groups.
Can I customize my pizza at Russellton pizzerias?
Absolutely. Most places let you build your own pizza with your choice of toppings, whether you want to keep it classic or try something new and different.