Craving pizza in Roslyn Heights leads you on a journey that’s anything but ordinary. This patchwork of local haunts and national chains manages to serve slices for every palate—thin, classic, chewy, or crispy. Each spot boasts its own secret sauce, signature crust, or a local following that swears by their favorite. If you know where to look, there’s a pie here with your name on it.
My search for the best pizza started with a single, bubbling slice shared on a cold weekend. What followed was a genuine appreciation for flavors that range from the honest to the inventive. With every box opened, it became clearer: hidden gems and cult favorites line up together in Roslyn Heights, ready for you to discover. If you’re on a hunt for a slice that’s just right, keep reading—the best is closer than you think.
Where to find the best pizza in Roslyn Heights, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Roslyn Heights, NY:
- Attilio’s Pizza
- Skinny Pizza
- Sotto Luna
- Carlos Pizza
- Abeetza Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- Village Pizza
- Gino’s Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Papa John’s Pizza
1. Attilio’s Pizza
Stepping into Attilio’s Pizza, you feel like you’ve entered a neighborhood staple. The scent of rising dough and simmering tomato sauce greets you before you even see the counter. Attilio’s stands out for its unwavering dedication to classic New York pizza—thin, crisp, and always satisfying.
My go-to is the classic cheese slice. Its balance of tangy sauce, gooey cheese, and that perfect snap of crust always hits the spot. For something heartier, try their Sicilian. The square slice arrives golden at the edges and layered with robust flavor.
Everything about Attilio’s says comfort—friendly faces, familiar tastes, and quality you can count on. If you like your pizza honest and memorable, this should be your first stop.
2. Skinny Pizza
Skinny Pizza redefines indulgence with a lighter touch. The first time I visited, I was skeptical—could healthier pizza actually deliver on flavor? With a crisp, cracker-thin crust and inventive toppings, Skinny Pizza proves you can have it all.
What sets them apart is attention to fresh, quality ingredients, minus the heavy feeling. The Skinny Margherita is a highlight. Bright sauce, basil, and creamy mozzarella combine in a way that feels both classic and refreshingly modern. If you like a bit of heat, their Veggie Spicy Pie adds just the right kick.
Places like Skinny Pizza remind you that pizza can fit any mood. You’ll leave satisfied and maybe even a little proud of your choices.
3. Sotto Luna
Sotto Luna crafts Italian classics in a warm setting where tradition meets a modern twist. Fresh ingredients are the star here, evident from that first, inviting basket of bread to the final bite of pizza. My visits have always felt like a slow afternoon in a family trattoria, where the staff knows your name and the aroma of tomatoes and herbs fills the air.
Their Margherita pizza is my favorite—it balances that pillowy yet crisp dough with just the right amount of bright sauce and mozzarella. If you’re craving something different, the vegetarian options come loaded with garden-fresh toppings and vibrant flavor.
Sotto Luna stands out for its genuine hospitality and an authentic menu that makes you want to linger longer. If you love your pizza with a side of old-world atmosphere, you’re in the right place.
4. Carlos Pizza
See Menu
Carlos Pizza keeps things classic, and that’s part of its charm. Its location feels like a well-kept local secret, where regulars share stories over slices. Carlos shines for its tried-and-true approach to New York-style pizza—no frills, all flavor.
The thin crust cheese pizza is the ultimate order here. The crust gives just enough crunch, with a subtle char that speaks to a hot oven and a confident hand. If you’re after a little extra, their white pizza hits that creamy, garlicky note without overpowering the basics.
What I appreciate most at Carlos is the laid-back vibe paired with consistently good food. Stop by for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner; either way, you’ll feel like you’ve found a neighborhood favorite.
5. Abeetza Pizza
(516) 484-3123Call
Abeetza Pizza feels like a lively hub, always bustling with energy and chatter. My first visit was sparked by the buzz from locals who swear by their pies—and they were right. Abeetza’s biggest draw is its inventive menu and oversized slices that never skimp on flavor.
Their signature Grandma slice is pure comfort: a thin, square base topped with fresh tomato, generous cheese, and fragrant basil. If you’re in the mood for something bolder, the Upside Down slice flips tradition with sauce on top, creating a tangy bite that’s both playful and satisfying.
Abeetza caters to cravings for both classic and creative, making every visit a little different. Swing by when you want pizza that feels familiar but never boring.
6. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Roslyn Heights always comes through for a no-fuss, late-night craving or a quick dinner after a long week. Its strength is consistency—every order arrives hot, with a crust that’s crisp on the edge and just doughy enough in the middle.
The menu has range, but my usual pick is the Hand Tossed Veggie, piled high with colorful toppings and that signature garlic seasoning on the crust. If you like a little drama, the Parmesan Stuffed Crust delivers a cheesy surprise in every bite.
What I enjoy about Domino’s is the simple convenience. Delivery is fast, deals make it easy on your wallet, and you always know that first slice will taste just right, every time.
7. Village Pizza
Village Pizza has that cozy, old-school pizzeria energy that makes you linger a little longer. It’s the kind of place where you know the slice will taste just as good this week as it did last year—reliable, crisp, and always fresh. My first visit felt like joining a neighborhood tradition in progress.
Their cheese pizza hits classic notes with a sturdy yet light crust, tangy sauce, and a melty layer of cheese. For something more, try the veggie slice—it’s loaded with fresh toppings that add color and crunch to every bite.
Village Pizza makes an impression with friendly service and generous portions. If you’re after that dependable, straightforward slice you grew up with, this spot will not disappoint.
8. Gino’s Pizza
Gino’s Pizza has the vibe of a busy Italian café, always alive with laughter and the clatter of plates. What sets Gino’s apart is its reputation for balancing tradition with fresh twists, making each visit feel a little special. My first bite here brought back memories of family gatherings and homemade meals.
Their Margherita slice offers a golden, blistered crust and bold sauce, accented by bright basil—classic, simple, and memorable. If you want to taste Gino’s creativity, try their white pizza, which blends cheeses to creamy perfection on a crackly crust.
Service here is quick but personable, and the quality never falters. Whether you’re in the mood to sit and linger or just need great pizza to go, Gino’s delivers every time.
9. Pizza Hut
There’s a certain nostalgia that comes with a visit to Pizza Hut in Westbury. Pizza Hut stands out for its familiar menu and unmistakable pan pizza—thick, golden crust that manages to be both crunchy and soft. Sharing a pizza here takes me back to simple gatherings and carefree nights.
The Original Stuffed Crust remains a personal favorite, with gooey cheese hidden inside a pillowy edge. If you’re a fan of flavor-packed combinations, the Veggie Lover’s or the classic Cheese Pizza delivers consistency in every bite.
Service is quick and no-nonsense, which fits when you want something familiar without a wait. For late night cravings or family meals, Pizza Hut delivers the comfort and predictability you need.
10. Papa John’s Pizza
Papa John’s Pizza in Carle Place is the go-to when you’re craving something cheesy and straightforward. It’s the signature dough—pillowy, slightly sweet, and freshly made—that keeps me coming back. Every pie packs a familiar, comforting taste that takes the guesswork out of ordering.
The Garden Fresh pizza is a standout, layered with colorful veggies on a zesty sauce. For a classic experience, the Cheese or Spinach Alfredo pizzas offer a rich, satisfying bite without feeling heavy.
Papa John’s is reliable for quick delivery or a low-key meal with friends. The flavors are familiar, and you always get that little container of garlicky dipping sauce, which somehow makes each slice better.
More Things to Try in Roslyn Heights, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Roslyn Heights, NY?
Some top picks include Attilio’s Pizza, Skinny Pizza, Abeetza Pizza, and local favorites like Village Pizza and Carlos Pizza. Each offers its own take on crust, sauce, and toppings, so there’s something for everyone.
Do any pizza places in Roslyn Heights offer gluten-free or vegetarian options?
Yes, several do. Skinny Pizza and Sotto Luna both have gluten-free crusts and plenty of vegetarian choices, while most local shops can customize pies to fit special diets.
Which spot is best for a quick slice?
Village Pizza and Carlos Pizza are great for a fast, classic slice. If you want quick delivery, Domino’s and Papa John’s move fast every time.
Are there any late-night pizza options in Roslyn Heights?
National chains like Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Papa John’s deliver late. Many local spots may close earlier, so check their hours before heading out.
Can I order pizza online or for delivery in Roslyn Heights?
Absolutely. Most pizza shops now offer online ordering for takeout or delivery. Just visit the pizzeria’s website or use popular delivery apps for easy ordering.