Finding a great pizza spot in Rogers, AR, can feel like searching for a hidden treasure. Over the years, I’ve explored many local pizzerias, and each visit has revealed new flavors, crust styles, and creative toppings. One thing remains consistent — the city’s passionate approach to pizza. Whether it’s a thin crust that’s crispy and light or a deep-dish that’s hearty and satisfying, Rogers has something to satisfy every craving.
What sets the best pizzerias apart is their dedication to quality and unique style. From family-owned eateries perfecting their recipes to modern spots using fresh, local ingredients, the scene is vibrant and diverse. If you’re looking for the top places to enjoy a slice, rest assured you’ll find options that combine flavor, authenticity, and a welcoming atmosphere. Dive into this guide, and discover the best pizza Rogers, AR has to offer.
Where to find the best pizza in Rogers, AR
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Rogers, AR:
- The Rail
- Old Chicago
- Artisan Wood Fired Kitchen
- Flashback Pizza And Milkshakes
- Gusano’s Pizzeria
- Cicis Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Papa Johns
- Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe
- Pizza Hut
1. The Rail
Located at 218 S 1st St, The Rail offers a welcoming atmosphere that blends casual comfort with a touch of southern charm. My recent visit revealed a menu that emphasizes quality ingredients and creative flavors, making it a standout among Rogers pizzerias. Whether you’re dining in or opting for takeout, the friendly service and relaxed vibe enhance the experience.
What truly sets The Rail apart is its dedication to accommodating various dietary preferences, including vegetarian and gluten-free options. I highly recommend trying their wood-fired pizza, which delivers a perfect balance of crispy crust and smoky richness. Their classic Margherita showcases fresh ingredients and simple elegance, while the specialty pies reflect the restaurant’s commitment to flavorful, high-quality pizza in Rogers, AR.
2. Old Chicago
Located at 1900 W Pleasant Grove Rd, Old Chicago combines a lively atmosphere with a menu that celebrates pizza’s rich history. During my visit, I appreciated the vibrant environment and the array of flavors inspired by Chicago’s famous deep-dish style. The staff’s friendly service made me feel right at home, whether dining in or taking out.
What makes Old Chicago stand out is its commitment to hearty, flavorful pizza options that cater to various preferences. I recommend trying their Chicago-style deep-dish pizza for a satisfying slice of local tradition. The Margherita pizza reflects simplicity and quality, while their diverse toppings showcase a dedication to fresh ingredients and bold flavors that define their style of pizza in Rogers, AR.
3. Artisan Wood Fired Kitchen
Located at 2203 S Promenade Blvd, Artisan Wood Fired Kitchen offers a uniquely rustic dining experience with a focus on quality ingredients. My visit showcased their skillful use of a wood-fired oven, which gives each pizza a distinctive smoky flavor and perfect crust. The cozy yet sophisticated ambiance makes it an ideal spot for both casual dinners and special occasions.
What makes Artisan Wood Fired Kitchen stand out is their dedication to customizable options, including vegetarian and vegan choices. I recommend their Margherita pizza, which highlights fresh basil, tomato, and mozzarella — all perfectly charred from the wood fire. Their focus on craftsmanship and exceptional flavor makes it a notable destination for pizza lovers in Rogers, AR.
4. Flashback Pizza And Milkshakes
+1 479-372-6013
Situated at 105 S 3rd St, Flashback Pizza And Milkshakes creates a nostalgic vibe, blending classic flavors with a fun twist. During my visit, I enjoyed their variety of fresh, flavorful pizzas served with generous toppings. The lively atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a relaxed meal with friends or family.
What makes Flashback Pizza stand out is its focus on delivering quality pizza with a retro charm. I recommend trying their specialty pizza—a well-balanced combination of crispy crust, gooey cheese, and fresh ingredients. The complement of rich milkshakes makes it a fun, satisfying experience that captures the essence of comfort food in Rogers, AR.
5. Gusano’s Pizzeria
Located at 2603 W Pleasant Grove Rd, Gusano’s Pizzeria stands out as a family-oriented spot with a lively atmosphere. My visit revealed a place that combines great pizza with amenities like a game room and a full-service bar, making it ideal for both casual dinners and celebrations. The SKYBOX reservation option adds a unique touch for larger groups.
What sets Gusano’s apart is its commitment to quality and a welcoming environment. I suggest trying their signature pizza—a perfect balance of crispy crust, flavorful toppings, and melted cheese, reflecting their dedication to authentic, satisfying pizza. With vegetarian options and modern digital payment methods, it’s a top choice for pizza in Rogers, AR.
6. Cicis Pizza
Situated at 3604 W Walnut St, Cicis Pizza offers a lively, family-friendly atmosphere with an emphasis on variety. During my visit, I appreciated their endless buffet of pizza, pasta, salads, and desserts, making it easy to satisfy everyone’s tastes. The all-you-can-eat concept encourages trying different flavors without worry.
What makes Cicis stand out is its focus on providing unlimited options at an affordable price. I recommend trying their customizable pizza or the pasta dishes, which complement the flavorful crusts and fresh ingredients. Whether for lunch or dinner, Cicis is a convenient choice for enjoying a quick, satisfying meal in Rogers, AR.
7. Pizza Hut
Located at 814 W Cypress St, Pizza Hut has long been a familiar name for classic, reliable pizza. During my visit, I enjoyed their signature pan crust, which offers a satisfyingly crispy edge and tender interior. The straightforward ambiance makes it a good choice for casual dining in Rogers.
What makes Pizza Hut notable is its consistency and wide menu selection. I recommend ordering their Hut Favorite Pizza—a well-rounded, flavorful option that showcases their commitment to quality ingredients. For those craving a familiar, hearty slice, Pizza Hut remains a dependable choice for lunch or dinner in Rogers, AR.
8. Papa Johns
Located on Walnut Street, Papa Johns is known for its delivery-friendly approach and quality ingredients. During my experience, I appreciated their signature Original Italian crust, which is both crispy and soft, providing a satisfying base for fresh toppings. Their streamlined menu makes ordering straightforward and reliable.
What sets Papa Johns apart is their focus on freshly baked pizzas with a commitment to quality. I recommend trying the Build Your Own Pizza to customize with your favorite toppings or the Philly Cheese Steak Pizza for a savory, hearty option. For pizza lovers in Rogers, AR, Papa Johns offers consistency and flavor in every slice.
9. Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe
Located in the Pinnacle Hills Promenade, Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe offers a fresh twist on classic comfort food. During my visit, I was impressed by their innovative approach to pizza, using high-quality ingredients and unique flavor combinations. The welcoming environment makes it a great choice for lunch or dinner with friends and family.
What distinguishes Pickleman’s is their commitment to locally owned quality and convenience. I recommend trying their famous toasted pizzas, which feature crispy, toasted bread and flavorful toppings—perfect for those seeking something both satisfying and different. The variety of options, along with their quick online ordering, makes Pickleman’s a standout in Rogers, AR.
10. Pizza Hut
Located at 1717 W. Walnut St. #a, Pizza Hut offers a familiar and consistent pizza experience in Rogers. During my visit, I enjoyed their iconic Original Stuffed Crust pizza, which is crispy on the outside and gooey inside—a true hallmark of their style. The relaxed atmosphere makes it ideal for family dinners or quick bites.
What sets Pizza Hut apart is its dedication to classic flavors combined with innovative options like their Meat Lovers pizza. Their signature wings and pasta also complement the menu perfectly. With options for delivery or carryout, it’s a dependable choice that consistently delivers satisfying, quality pizza in Rogers, AR.
More Things to Try in Rogers, AR
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are the best pizza places in Rogers, AR?
A: Popular options include The Rail for wood-fired pies, Old Chicago for deep-dish style, and Gusano’s Pizzeria for family-friendly Italian favorites. Each offers unique flavors and a welcoming atmosphere.
Q: Are there vegetarian-friendly pizza options in Rogers?
A: Yes, many restaurants like Artisan Wood Fired Kitchen and Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe offer delicious vegetarian pizza choices made with fresh, quality ingredients.
Q: Do Rogers pizza places offer gluten-free options?
A: Some establishments, such as The Rail, provide gluten-free crusts to accommodate dietary preferences. Always call ahead to confirm availability.
Q: Can I get pizza delivered in Rogers, AR?
A: Yes, most top pizzerias like Pizza Hut, Papa Johns, and Domino’s offer delivery or curbside pickup, making it easy to enjoy pizza at home.
Q: What is the average cost of a pizza in Rogers?
A: Prices vary, but most pizzerias offer slices or personal pans starting around $8. Larger pizzas typically range from $12 to $20, depending on toppings and size.