There’s something unmistakable about the aroma of a fresh pie drifting along the streets of Rockville Centre. Looking for the best pizza here is a journey worth savoring—one full of crisp crusts, bubbling cheese, and a dash of local character in every bite. I’ve sampled slices after late-night chats, quick lunch breaks, and even on the hunt for the elusive perfect crust. Each experience sharpened my sense for what sets a memorable pizza apart from the rest.
Rockville Centre holds a deep bench of classic pizzerias and inventive newcomers. It doesn’t matter if you lean toward a thin Neapolitan round or a gooey Sicilian square; the options here are serious. Wondering where to spend your pizza dollars or what spot might surprise you? This guide pulls together the standouts, from loved family joints to hush-hush local favorites—so you can skip the second-guessing and land a slice that sparks joy.
1. Gino’s Pizza
Gino’s Pizza has a way of pulling you in from the sidewalk with the scent of their signature sauce. The first time I stepped in, I noticed how the place buzzed with locals, all eager for their regular order. The staff treats everyone like family, whether you’re picking up a pie or settling in for a meal.
What makes Gino’s Pizza special? The crust is always crisp yet fluffy, striking just the right balance. Their cheese pizza is a lesson in restraint—simple, flavorful, not greasy. If you want a little adventure, try the Margherita or a Sicilian square; both showcase how fresh ingredients and old-school technique can elevate a classic. Gino’s sets the standard for pizza in Rockville Centre.
2. Genovese Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc
With Genovese Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc, every visit feels like joining a big Italian family dinner. My first slice here featured a tangy sauce and plenty of gooey cheese over a blistered crust—simple, but each bite had character. Friends recall celebrations at Genovese, where staff remembered everyone by name and never let a glass go empty.
This place stands out for its careful balance of old-world flavors and welcoming energy. The pizza menu is stacked with options, but if you want a true taste of what Genovese does best, go for the Classic Margherita or a veggie-loaded pie. Both highlight their dough’s light texture and the kitchen’s respect for solid ingredients. At Genovese, pizza is both comfort and craft.
3. Nick’s Pizza
Nick’s Pizza has the kind of reliability that makes it a cornerstone in Rockville Centre. I’ve ducked in for a slice after long workdays, always greeted by the smell of fresh dough and a cheerful crew. The pies at Nick’s are crafted with a light hand, never heavy with oil or overloaded with toppings.
What sets Nick’s Pizza apart is their devotion to texture—a crisp, yet foldable crust that holds up under generous amounts of tangy tomato sauce. I recommend starting with their classic cheese slice; it proves that understated can still be memorable. If you’re sharing, try the white pizza topped with ricotta and mozzarella. Nick’s respects tradition, but always leaves room for a pleasant surprise in every bite.
4. Mother Kelly’s
Mother Kelly’s is all about comfort—with a dining room that feels more like a friend’s living space than a typical pizzeria. When I visited, the warmth came not just from the ovens, but from the regulars sharing stories across tables. This sense of community shines through in every slice served.
Mother Kelly’s excels at pizzas where every topping is given space to shine, never buried or overdone. Their thin crust keeps things light and crisp, perfect for those who want flavor without the heft. Try the classic Margherita—fresh basil and tomatoes let the crust and sauce do the talking. Slices here are simple, but that’s what lets quality stand out. Mother Kelly’s keeps things honest and satisfying.
5. Centre Slice Pizzeria
(516) 442-7733Call
Centre Slice Pizzeria feels like a spot built for locals—quick service, friendly nods, and pizza that holds its own in a crowded field. The first time I grabbed a slice here, I noticed the crust had that unmistakable snap, a detail that can turn a quick snack into something special.
At Centre Slice, the menu leans traditional but comes with a commitment to freshness in every bite. The plain slice is a standout, balancing the right amount of cheese and sauce, always piping hot. If you’re in the mood to try something different, the veggie slice shows off their knack for getting each topping just right. It’s a place where classic New York pizza gets the attention it deserves.
6. Farfalle Pizza Restaurant
(516) 536-3070Call
Farfalle Pizza Restaurant delivers a low-key charm from the minute you walk in. It’s the kind of place that doesn’t shout for attention, yet every pizza shows a quiet respect for tradition. My first bite here was a clear reminder of why classic technique still matters—crispy crust paired with a bold but balanced tomato sauce.
Farfalle excels at making the everyday special. Their plain cheese pizza is where they shine, letting quality mozzarella and a well-seasoned sauce take center stage. Don’t miss the white pizza either; it’s smooth, rich, and lets the dough’s character come through. With easygoing service and consistent flavor, Farfalle stands out as a steady option for anyone craving solid pizza in Rockville Centre.
7. Gianni’s Pizza & Pasta
(516) 763-9600Call
Gianni’s Pizza & Pasta is the sort of place you discover by word of mouth, then keep coming back for more. The dining space is unfussy, but the pizza comes out with real flair. My visits here have always been defined by slices that are generous with cheese and have a subtle snap in every bite.
What makes Gianni’s different is their bold crust, which manages to be tender and crisp at once—a rare feat. Start with a classic cheese or veggie pie; the sauce carries just enough tang to wake up your taste buds. For something heartier, their Sicilian slice is thick, satisfying, and doesn’t skimp on flavor. Whatever you order, expect a pizza with both soul and substance.
8. Quatro Amici Inc
(516) 594-4040Call
Quatro Amici Inc adds a layer of warmth to the usual pizza routine, tucked into the heart of the Rockville Centre Shopping Center. This is a spot where conversations flow as easily as the mozzarella, and every pie looks like it was made with an audience in mind. My visit here proved that even a basic slice could feel special, with a crust that was both airy and sturdy.
Quatro Amici stands out for its attention to detail. The sauce? Bright but mellow. The cheese? Rich and stretchy without being oily. Try their Margherita pizza for the freshest take, or a veggie slice if you’re in the mood for colorful toppings. Every order shows care, and you taste it in every bite.
9. Bonbino’s Pizza & Restaurant
Bonbino’s Pizza & Restaurant blends comfort with a hint of elegance, making it a local favorite for those after more than just a slice. My first pie here was devoured at a family dinner, with every slice vanishing before the next one even hit the table. There’s a reason people keep coming back to this spot.
Bonbino’s stands out for its balanced crust—crispy on the edges, light in the center—and a sauce that layers tang and sweetness. The Margherita pizza highlights their quality ingredients, while their veggie pie is generous with toppings, never soggy. For a true taste of what Bonbino’s does best, order a classic cheese pizza and savor the fresh mozzarella. Consistency and a touch of tradition make Bonbino’s memorable.
10. 3 Brothers Pizzeria Inc
3 Brothers Pizzeria Inc isn’t afraid to do things differently, and that’s clear from the moment you walk in. My first experience here was grabbing a 99-cent slice—the deal is almost as good as the pizza. It’s a spot where college students, families, and late-night snackers brush shoulders and swap stories, all while waiting for their order.
What sets 3 Brothers apart is their menu variety, from vegan pies to classic options, always with a focus on quality. If you’re curious, start with their vegan cheese slice—it’s every bit as satisfying as the original, a rarity in the local pizza game. For a standard pick, their plain cheese pizza boasts a chewy, golden crust and just the right amount of sauce.
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of pizza are popular in Rockville Centre?
You’ll find all the classics—thin-crust New York slices, Sicilian squares, and specialty pies loaded with veggies or fresh mozzarella. Vegetarian options are widely available, and a few places offer vegan-friendly pizzas as well.
Is there pizza delivery available in Rockville Centre?
Yes, nearly every pizzeria in Rockville Centre offers delivery and takeout. Many also partner with third-party apps for fast, easy ordering.
Are there gluten-free pizza options in Rockville Centre?
Several local pizzerias cater to gluten-free needs. Just call ahead to make sure they have crusts available and can accommodate your preferences.
Which pizzerias have the best atmosphere for dining in?
Mother Kelly’s and Bonbino’s are well-known for warm, comfortable dining rooms, ideal for families or casual meetups. Many other spots are popular for a quick bite or a relaxed lunch.
Can I find vegan pizza in Rockville Centre?
Absolutely. Spots like 3 Brothers Pizzeria Inc offer creative vegan pies that don’t compromise on taste or texture.