Richmond’s pizza scene offers more than just average slices. Over the years, exploring its diverse pizzerias has revealed local gems that craft each pie with genuine passion and attention to detail. From classic Italian recipes to innovative toppings, the city’s pizzerias cater to all tastes. My personal favorites include spots where the dough is perfectly chewy and the cheese melts just right — those bites create memorable experiences.
What sets Richmond apart is its commitment to quality ingredients and authentic flavors. Whether you’re craving a thin-crust Neapolitan or a hearty New York-style slice, the city’s hidden treasures deliver. This guide aims to navigate the best pizza options the city has to offer, ensuring every pizza lover finds their perfect fit. Dive in to discover Richmond’s top pizzerias, each promising a true taste of local craftsmanship.
Where to find the best pizza in Richmond, VA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Richmond, VA:
- Mellow Mushroom Richmond – Carytown
- Bottoms Up
- Carini’s Italian Restaurant & Pizza
- Triple Crossing Beer – Fulton
- Pupatella Pizza
- Capriccios Italian Restaurant
- Mary Angela’s Pizzeria
- Vinny’s Italian Grill and Pizza
- 8 1/2
- Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders
1. Mellow Mushroom Richmond – Carytown
Nestled in the heart of Carytown, Mellow Mushroom Richmond offers a creative twist on classic pizza. I once enjoyed their standout Artichoke & Spinach Pizza, where a thin, chewy crust supported fresh toppings and perfectly melted cheese. It’s a place that makes pizza feel both familiar and exciting.
What makes Mellow Mushroom shine is its vibrant, art-inspired atmosphere and commitment to quality ingredients. Their stone-baked pies are crafted with a signature flair, reflecting both tradition and innovation. For a true taste of Richmond’s pizza scene, try their Margherita or Veggie Delight, which showcase fresh, flavorful toppings that highlight the chef’s creativity. Whether dining in or ordering delivery, it’s a memorable pizza experience.
2. Bottoms Up
Located along the James River, Bottoms Up has been a Richmond staple for over two decades. I once tried their custom pizza topped with fresh vegetables and smoked meats, and the flavor combination was exceptional. Their long-made, flavorful crust is a signature that sets them apart.
What makes Bottoms Up unique is its extensive, customizable pizza menu with toppings like shrimp, goat cheese, and even oysters. Their dedication to using fresh ingredients ensures every slice is satisfying. For a truly Richmond experience, the BBQ Chicken Pizza or Veggie Special showcase bold flavors and the restaurant’s commitment to quality. Whether dining in or ordering late at night, Bottoms Up delivers a memorable pizza experience.
3. Carini’s Italian Restaurant & Pizza
Located in Richmond’s East End, Carini’s Italian Restaurant & Pizza is a reflection of family success and authentic Sicilian-Italian cuisine. I recall trying their signature pizza topped with fresh, quality ingredients, which perfectly captured the essence of traditional Italian flavors. The warm, welcoming atmosphere makes every visit feel like dining at a friend’s home.
What sets Carini’s apart is its dedication to family recipes and fresh ingredients. Their wood-fired pizza offers a crispy crust paired with flavorful toppings like seasoned meats and vibrant vegetables. For a true taste of Italy, I recommend the Pizza Siciliana or their homemade Eggplant Parmesan. These dishes embody the restaurant’s rich culinary heritage and commitment to quality. It’s a place where tradition and taste go hand in hand.
4. Triple Crossing Beer – Fulton
Triple Crossing Beer – Fulton blends Richmond’s craft beer culture with artisan Neapolitan-style pizza. Tucked away in Fulton, its relaxed patio vibe and friendly table service make it ideal for casual lunch or laid-back dinner. During my visit, the scent of wood-fired dough and the hum of conversation set the tone for a meal that didn’t feel rushed.
What truly stood out was their pizza, baked in a Marra Forni oven. The crust had that classic airy chew, with just enough char to hint at tradition. Their vegetarian pizza options use fresh local produce and layer bold, balanced flavors. The combination of good beer and high-quality pizza makes this spot hard to beat.
Don’t skip their classic Margherita Pizza—simple, but handled with care. It’s a testament to how less can be more when the ingredients speak for themselves.
5. Pupatella Pizza
Pupatella Pizza offers an intimate slice of Naples in the heart of Richmond. Tucked inside a cozy spot on Morris Street, their wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas bring a depth of flavor few can match locally. The dough? Airy with a slight char. The sauce? Bright, balanced, unmistakably Italian.
What makes Pupatella shine isn’t just technique—it’s a commitment to simplicity done right. The Margherita, with its melted bufala mozzarella and basil, is a reliable first step into their menu. Looking for a kick? Try the Diavola—peppery, layered, and utterly addictive.
I swung by on a cool weekday evening and watched the oven glow while sipping a ginger ale. The warmth of the staff and that crust alone convinced me it’s worth revisiting.
6. Capriccios Italian Restaurant
Capriccios Italian Restaurant brings an authentic taste of Italy and New York-style pizza to Richmond. During my visit, I enjoyed their thin-crust margherita pizza, which was crisp on the edges but soft inside—a perfect balance of textures. The atmosphere is casual yet inviting, ideal for a quick lunch or family dinner.
What makes Capriccios stand out is its dedication to genuine flavors and quality ingredients. Their pizza, with its expertly prepared dough and flavorful toppings, reflects a commitment to excellence. I recommend the Four Cheese Pizza or the Sicilian Pepperoni—both showcase their skill in crafting satisfying, high-quality pies.
If you’re craving a classic Italian-American experience, Capriccios delivers with consistency and tradition in every bite.
7. Mary Angela’s Pizzeria
Mary Angela’s Pizzeria in Carytown is a cozy spot that feels like a neighborhood staple. On my last visit, I grabbed a slice of their New York-style cheese pizza and a veggie stromboli. The crust had that perfect chew, and the sauce was bright without overpowering.
What sets this place apart is its consistency. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, the food arrives fresh and well-prepared. The staff keeps things friendly and efficient, even during busy hours.
Try the Mary Angela’s Special—a loaded pie with pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. It’s a great showcase of their balanced flavors and generous toppings. For something lighter, the White Pizza with ricotta and garlic is a solid pick.
It’s casual, reliable, and one of Richmond’s go-to spots for pizza done right.
8. Vinny’s Italian Grill and Pizza
Vinny’s Italian Grill and Pizza in Short Pump offers a warm, family-oriented atmosphere that instantly makes you feel at home. During my visit, I was greeted by Giacomo and Victoria, whose friendly service matched the comforting aromas wafting from the kitchen. Their >35 years of experience shines through in every dish, especially their pizza.
What makes Vinny’s stand out is its blend of family recipe tradition with a welcoming vibe. Their wood-fired pizzas have a perfectly crisp crust and fresh toppings that highlight quality. I recommend the Margherita or Veggie Pizza—simple but executed with care and passion.
For a taste of genuine Italian comfort, Vinny’s feels like visiting family, leaving you full, satisfied, and eager to return.
9. 8 1/2
8 1/2 is tucked into the Fan District like a secret worth sharing. The place is small, but the flavors are anything but. I stopped in for takeout and left with a red pizza that had a crisp crust, a balanced sauce, and roasted green peppers that added just the right bite. It’s the kind of pizza that doesn’t need to shout—it just delivers.
What makes 8 1/2 stand out is its simplicity. No frills, just honest food. The dough is pliable yet crisp, and the sauce leans savory with a subtle kick. Their vegan pizza, topped with broccolini and a whisper of spice, is a quiet triumph.
If you’re looking for pizza in Richmond that’s unfussy but full of character, this is your spot. Order the Red Pizza with roasted peppers—it’s a local favorite for good reason.
10. Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders
Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders feels like the kind of place that knows its strengths and sticks to them. I dropped in for lunch and was greeted with warm service and the scent of fresh-baked bread. The vibe is casual, but the food is anything but forgettable.
What sets Bellacino’s apart is its commitment to quality. Their pizzas are oven-baked from scratch daily, and the crust has that perfect balance of chew and crisp. The sauce leans savory, and the cheese is generous without overwhelming.
Order the Bellacino’s Pride Pizza—a loaded classic with pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers, and black olives. It’s a solid representation of their style: hearty, flavorful, and satisfying. For something lighter, the Veggie Pizza delivers freshness without compromise.
If you’re after pizza in Richmond that’s consistent and comforting, Bellacino’s is worth the stop.
More Things to Try in Richmond, VA
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizza place in Richmond, VA?
Richmond offers a range of top-tier pizzerias. Mellow Mushroom in Carytown is known for its stone-baked crust and creative toppings. Bottoms Up Pizza stands out with deep-dish offerings. Pupatella excels with authentic Neapolitan-style pies. The “best” depends on personal preference—style, crust, and location.
Where can I find halal-friendly or pork-free pizza options?
While not all restaurants publicly list halal certification, some places like Christian’s Pizza and Tazza Kitchen offer vegetarian options or allow custom pizzas without pork. Always ask staff to confirm ingredients and preparation methods.
Are there pizza places in Richmond that offer gluten-free crust?
Yes. Mellow Mushroom and California Pizza Kitchen both have gluten-free alternatives. Keep in mind that cross-contamination may occur in kitchens, so confirm with staff if you have dietary restrictions.
Which Richmond pizza restaurants are best for families?
Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders is a reliable choice for casual family meals. Mary Angela’s Pizzeria and Joe’s Subs, Pizza & Salads also offer laid-back atmospheres and sizable menu options that suit all ages.
Are there any late-night pizza spots in Richmond?
8 1/2 and Jo Jo’s Pizza are local favorites for late-night cravings. Their menus stay available into the evening, especially on weekends.
Do Richmond pizza places offer vegan options?
Some spots like Pupatella and Zorch Pizza serve pizzas with vegan dough and vegetable toppings. Ask about dairy-free cheese or opt for classic marinara-based pies with fresh vegetables.
Is Pizza Hut on W Broad St worth visiting?
If you’re after familiarity and standardized options, Pizza Hut 9486 W Broad St delivers reliable fast-food-style pizza. It may not offer the local flair or scratch-made freshness of independent shops, but it meets expectations for a quick bite.
What are the most unique pizza offerings in Richmond?
Triple Crossing BeerBrambly Park
Do any pizza places in Richmond serve beer or wine?
Yes. Triple Crossing BeerBrambly Park both integrate pizza with curated beverage menus. ChiantiCapriccios also pair their Italian fare with wine lists that complement their pizzas.