Searching for the best pizza in Red Oaks Mill, NY can feel a bit like chasing a New York autumn: full of charm, but everyone has an opinion about the perfect slice. My own quest began after I moved upstate from the city. I quickly realized that pizza loyalty in this area runs deep. One evening, caught between hunger and curiosity after a long walk past the Mill, I ducked into a neighborhood spot. The blend of sauce and cheese was so good, I could have sworn the chef had read my mind.
Since then, I’ve sampled every crust, cheese pull, and sauce style on offer in Red Oaks Mill. Some places serve perfect classics, while others put a twist on the familiar margherita. With each bite, I become more convinced that this town is quietly serious about its pizza. If you’re wondering where to find the right slice for you, you’re in good company. Consider this your shortcut to the local favorites and unexpected gems that keep pizza night interesting and delicious.
Where to find the best pizza in Red Oaks Mill, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Red Oaks Mill, NY:
- Marco’s Pizza
- Little Caesars Pizza
- Giacomo’s Pizza Cafe
- D D’s Pizza
- Ciccio’s Pizza & Restaurant
- Tony’s Pizza Pit
- Sinapi’s Pizza, Pasta & More
- Joe’s Pizza
- Good Fellas Pizzeria & Restaurant
- Pino’s Pizzeria & Family Restaurant
1. Marco’s Pizza
(845) 204-9880Call
Marco’s Pizza turns an ordinary evening into something special. Inside, the atmosphere feels both cozy and casual, just right for families or a pizza date. The service is steady, never rushed, but always attentive.
What sets Marco’s apart is the way they treat pizza as an art form. The crust is crisp but never dry, and their sauce carries a hint of sweetness that lingers. One night, a simple pepperoni pie arrived at my table, bubbling and aromatic—each slice had that balanced, golden cheese melt.
If you’re unsure what to try, go for the Margherita or the Specialty Gourmet pies. Both capture what Marco’s does best: fresh ingredients and genuine attention to detail, one satisfying bite at a time.
2. Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars Pizza leans into the idea of quick, hot, and tasty. One evening, I rushed in just before closing, expecting a wait. Instead, I stepped up to the Pizza Portal, grabbed a Hot-N-Ready pepperoni, and was out in under two minutes. Convenience is clearly their superpower.
Little Caesars stands out for its unbeatable value and consistently crispy crust. The pizzas are always warm and never greasy, with a stretchy cheese pull that surprises you at this price point. The sauce tastes fresh, not too sweet or salty.
For a classic experience, order the Hot-N-Ready Cheese or the ExtraMostBestest Pepperoni. They hit the mark for a craving or a quick, cost-friendly dinner that doesn’t skimp on quality.
3. Giacomo’s Pizza Cafe
Giacomo’s Pizza Cafe has the welcoming feel of a neighborhood favorite. When I stopped in, the scent of fresh dough and roasted garlic convinced me I was in the right place. The staff works with quiet efficiency, and you’ll often see regulars greeting them by name.
What sets Giacomo’s apart is their crust—thin, golden, and always just crisp enough. Every topping tastes fresh, and the cheese blend melts with a hint of savory depth. You can tell a real pizza lover is designing the menu here.
Try the White pizza or the Margherita for something classic, or get adventurous with the Sicilian-style if you like a heartier slice. Each one offers a different mood, but all show off Giacomo’s commitment to quality and flavor.
4. D D’s Pizza
(845) 452-1754Call
D D’s Pizza is the kind of place where you feel like a neighborhood insider the moment you step through the door. One rainy afternoon, I ducked in, hoping to dodge the weather and found a local secret—each pie is cooked with the kind of care that makes you want to linger.
D D’s stands out for its balance of flavor and portion size. The slices are substantial, loaded with cheese, but never overwhelming. The sauce has a mellow, robust character, allowing the freshness to speak for itself.
If you want a classic experience, the plain cheese or veggie pizza is a favorite. These hold up from the first hot slice to the last bite, showing off D D’s commitment to comfort and taste.
5. Ciccio’s Pizza & Restaurant
(845) 473-3100Call
Ciccio’s Pizza & Restaurant delivers on the promise of comfort food, with an inviting vibe and wallet-friendly prices. My visit started with friendly greetings and ended with a smile after tasting their signature pie. It’s the kind of spot where families gather after games and friends catch up over a shared pie.
Ciccio’s stands out for its straightforward, no-fuss approach to pizza. The crust is reliably crisp, and the sauce leans toward savory with just enough zing to make it memorable. Slices come out piping hot and ready to fold, just the way a pizza slice should behave.
The plain cheese and Sicilian-style pies are favorites. Both highlight Ciccio’s approach: uncomplicated, fresh, and pleasantly filling—proof that you don’t have to be fancy to be really good.
6. Tony’s Pizza Pit
(845) 471-4110Call
Tony’s Pizza Pit is that rare spot where the traditions of a classic pizzeria meet a welcoming, everyday energy. My first time trying their pizza was after a long walk through town—one slice in and I was hooked by the light, slightly chewy crust.
Tony’s stands out for consistency and flavor, always delivering a slice that feels made just for you. The sauce has a fresh, tomato-forward taste, and the cheese blend melts perfectly without overwhelming the pie.
The plain cheese and veggie slices are essentials, with crisp edges and solid foldability. For a treat, try their white pizza—it shows off Tony’s careful approach and easygoing confidence in every bite.
7. Sinapi’s Pizza, Pasta & More
Sinapi’s Pizza, Pasta & More feels warm and relaxed from the moment you walk in. On my last visit, the scent of baking dough and oregano made the wait seem shorter than it was. This family-run spot hasn’t lost its personal touch, and you can taste that in every bite.
Sinapi’s stands out with its mix of traditional style and genuine hospitality. Their crust is airy without being too thick, and every pizza gets just the right amount of cheese and sauce, balanced and flavorful.
Try their Grandma or Margherita pizza to experience the quality that regulars rave about. Both highlight what Sinapi’s does best: straightforward comfort and great ingredients in every slice.
8. Joe’s Pizza
(845) 849-3999Call
Joe’s Pizza is the definition of a no-frills, reliably good neighborhood spot. I stumbled in one rainy day and found the kind of comfort that only a big slice and friendly counter staff can deliver. The dining area is simple, but the pies speak for themselves.
What sets Joe’s apart is the balance of crunch and chew in their crust. Every bite starts crisp and gives way to a warm, soft inside. The sauce has a subtle tang, and the cheese is always generous but never greasy.
If you’re stopping by, order the classic cheese slice or the veggie pizza. Both capture Joe’s approachable style—straightforward, satisfying, and made for sharing.
9. Good Fellas Pizzeria & Restaurant
(845) 463-2020Call
Good Fellas Pizzeria & Restaurant delivers on its promise of hearty, flavorful pies with a friendly atmosphere. My first visit caught me off guard—one minute, I was eyeing the case, the next, I was chatting with staff about toppings like an old friend. It’s the sort of place where newcomers feel instantly comfortable.
What puts Good Fellas on the map is their hand-tossed dough and bold, vibrant sauce. The pizzas strike the right balance of crispness and chew, topped with cheese that browns just enough for that perfect bite.
For a proper introduction, order a plain cheese or a veggie-loaded pie. Both showcase Good Fellas’ focus on simple ingredients and timeless technique that bring regulars back again and again.
10. Pino’s Pizzeria & Family Restaurant
Pino’s Pizzeria & Family Restaurant brings a touch of old-school charm to the local food scene. Walking in, you’re greeted with the sights and sounds of a classic neighborhood pizzeria—kids coloring at tables, families sharing pies, and staff who remember your name if you’ve been twice.
Pino’s stands out for its slightly chewy, golden crust and fresh toppings that taste like they just left the market. While every pizza is solid, you can count on the sauce to deliver a gentle kick of flavor in every slice.
If you’re sharing with a crowd, order the veggie or Margherita pizza. Both show off Pino’s knack for balancing bold flavors with great texture, keeping you coming back for more.
More Things to Try in Red Oaks Mill, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Red Oaks Mill, NY?
Some local hotspots include Marco’s Pizza, Giacomo’s Pizza Cafe, Pino’s Pizzeria & Family Restaurant, and Good Fellas Pizzeria & Restaurant. These spots are loved for their consistent quality and friendly atmosphere.
Do any pizzerias in Red Oaks Mill offer delivery or takeout?
Yes, most well-known places like Little Caesars, Domino’s, and Pino’s offer delivery and takeout. Many local pizzerias also provide online ordering for even more convenience.
Which pizza style is most common in Red Oaks Mill?
New York-style thin crust dominates, but you’ll also find Sicilian and specialty pies for those seeking a twist or heartier option.
Are there vegetarian pizza options available?
Absolutely. Nearly every shop offers a range of vegetarian choices, from classic Margherita to loaded veggie pies featuring fresh, local produce.
What should I try if it’s my first time in the area?
Start with a cheese slice or Margherita pizza at any of the top spots. If you’re feeling adventurous, ask for each shop’s specialty pie—you’ll often discover a unique house favorite.