If you’ve ever tried to pick the absolute best pizza spot in Rapid City, you already know it’s no small task. This city isn’t content with plain cheese and predictable pepperoni. From bubbling, hand-tossed crusts to adventurous toppings that steer clear of the ordinary, Rapid City’s pizza scene can delight even the most stubborn slice hunter. I once thought I had seen it all until I wandered off a downtown street and wound up with a pizza so good I forgot to check my phone for at least twenty minutes. That’s a rarity.
Consider this your personal roadmap to finding that pizza. Not just any pizza—the one that makes you pause mid-bite, look up, and wonder what else you’ve been missing. Whether you want a quick pie on your lunch break or a leisurely dinner with friends, this guide covers both legendary local gems and reliable national hot spots. No guessing, no lackluster slices—just Rapid City’s finest pies lined up for your consideration.
1. Independent Ale House
Independent Ale House feels like a true local hideout at 625 Saint Joseph Street, blending cool with comfort. The long list of craft taps draws in beer fans, but I return for their pizza. When you hear crust crackle as it hits your table, you know you’re in the right place.
What sets them apart? Inventive toppings. There’s a Thai Pie that balances sweet heat and the trusted Margherita with a fresh, herby punch. They’re serious about vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options too, which puts everyone at ease.
Order the signature pies—something offbeat, like their weekly special, or the crowd-pleasing Spinach-Artichoke. You’ll leave remembering why pizza is its own kind of celebration here.
2. Blaze Pizza
Blaze Pizza at 1325 Eglin Street is for anyone who hates waiting for great food. My first visit, I watched dough transform into a bubbling, crisp pizza in what felt like the length of a song on the radio. Their open kitchen lets you build your own creation—think artisan ingredients, endless choice, and staff who move quicker than you’d imagine possible.
The oven does its magic in three minutes, leaving each pie with just the right crunch. If you like to take control, the DIY approach is fun. But even I was tempted by their signature pizzas like the Green Stripe, stacked with zingy arugula and creamy pesto drizzle.
Go for something off-script or trust the menu—it’s quality and fast, no compromise necessary. The gluten-free and vegan options mean everyone gets in on the action.
3. Pauly’s Pizzeria & Sub Co.
Pauly’s Pizzeria & Sub Co., tucked near Saint Patrick Street, feels like the kind of neighborhood spot you wish you lived closer to. It’s one of those places where regulars trade stories with staff, and everyone seems to walk out smiling. I wandered in on a chilly evening and found the place welcoming, right down to the warming aroma from their ovens.
What sets Pauly’s apart is its traditional approach to pizza paired with a huge selection. They roll their dough fresh, piling on toppings with a heavy hand. Vegetarian, vegan, or gluten-free? They’ve got it covered, so no one goes without.
Order their classic Veggie Deluxe or a custom-built pie. The crust arrives crisp, and the balance of sauce and cheese hits that satisfying, nostalgic note. This is Rapid City’s pizza comfort food at its best.
4. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza on Cheyenne Boulevard delivers exactly what you want when the craving is real—big, bold pies in generous portions. It’s the sort of spot locals trust, whether they’re eating in or grabbing a slice on the go. On my last visit, I watched as a dinner crowd joked with the staff like old friends.
The appeal rests in their hearty, doughy crusts and a menu that leans classic but never dull. The freshness comes through, and their range of vegetarian and vegan options means nobody settles for less.
Try the White Cheezy; it’s a crowd-pleaser layered with three cheeses, garlic sauce, and fresh veggies. If you’re in a group, don’t skip a custom Half-and-Half—it’s Marco’s way of letting everyone win.
5. Piesano’s Pacchia
Piesano’s Pacchia sits quietly on Canyon Lake Drive, but its reputation for authentic pizza is anything but subtle. My first time there, the open kitchen and the scent of baking dough set the stage for something memorable. Families fill the tables, and every server seems to have a favorite pie to recommend.
Their secret? Italian-inspired recipes crafted with care. Each pizza boasts a thin, golden crust and thoughtfully layered toppings. Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free guests will find plenty of choices, which makes gathering friends here easy.
The Margherita pizza and Garden Special are must-tries, shining with bright flavors and a just-the-right-amount-of-char on the crust. For a cozy, unfussy meal that feels like tradition, this spot delivers every time.
6. Pizza Ranch
Pizza Ranch on Luna Avenue is where you go when variety is the priority and hungry crowds are in tow. My memory of the buffet is endless choices and families fueling up after a day at the shops. The party rooms buzz with laughter, and everyone seems to leave a little more content than when they arrived.
What stands out here is the Legendary Buffet. The salad bar starts things off fresh, but anyone who knows Pizza Ranch heads straight for the hot, ready pizzas gliding onto the counter.
Try the Garden Veggie or a classic cheese. If you time it right, catch a slice of their famous dessert pizza, finished with a scoop of ice cream—simple, homey, and completely satisfying.
7. Pizza Ranch
Pizza Ranch on Stumer Road packs more than just pizza—it’s a destination where kids dash from the buffet to the arcade and back again. My last visit involved keeping up with a table of cousins who debated toppings while plotting their next arcade conquest. This is a spot built for groups and moments that need a little extra fun.
It’s the huge buffet and party-friendly atmosphere that make this location shine. With six party rooms, everyone gets space, and the salad bar and vegetarian options keep things balanced.
Opt for the signature veggie pizzas and save room for dessert pizza. Whether you’re watching kids rack up tickets or catching up with friends, Pizza Ranch delivers smiles along with the slices.
8. MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub
MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub, right on Eglin Street, feels like you’ve stepped into a lodge after a day in the mountains. The décor, all wood accents and rustic touches, sets a cozy stage for what’s to come. On my visit, the aroma of fresh-baked crust coaxed me into lingering a little longer than planned.
The kitchen specializes in inventive pizzas with a Rocky Mountain spin. Their crust is the perfect balance of crisp and chewy, while toppings range from classic to creatively regional. Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free diners find plenty to choose from here.
Order the Flathead or the Thai Pie if you want a true taste of their adventurous spirit. It’s the kind of pizza that feels crafted for the bold and the comfort-seeker alike.
9. Blaze Pizza
The Blaze Pizza on Mountain View Road is the kind of place where you breeze in and leave happy, pizza in hand. The build-your-own format and open kitchen give it a fun, interactive vibe. The first time I visited, I tested out wild topping combinations just because I could.
Blaze stands out for its speedy service and fresh, customizable approach. The crust bakes up thin and crisp in minutes, and there’s a sense of energy as staff assemble each creation—no two pies are alike.
Try the Art Lover or go custom; with more than 30 topping choices, you’re in creative control. This spot is where Rapid City’s pizza crowd comes to play, shape, and savor their own perfect pie.
10. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza on Haines Avenue is a go-to for anyone craving a familiar classic, done right. On busy nights, it’s the box most likely to show up at Rapid City gatherings, and I’ve found their reliably consistent pizzas can turn an ordinary dinner into something a little cozier.
This spot leans hard into its motto: better ingredients, better pizza. The crust is pillowy, the sauce tangy, and you can count on everything tasting fresh. Perfect for delivery, or grabbing a quick carryout for a movie night.
Order the Garden Fresh if you’re feeling virtuous, or the classic Cheese for simple comfort. There’s something enjoyable about a pizza joint that never tries to be anything other than exactly what it is.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated pizza places in Rapid City, SD?
Some favorites include Independent Ale House, Pauly’s Pizzeria & Sub Co., Blaze Pizza, MacKenzie River Pizza, and Piesano’s Pacchia. Chains like Papa Johns and Pizza Ranch are also popular for quick, consistent options.
Are there gluten-free or vegan pizza options in Rapid City?
Yes. Many spots such as Blaze Pizza, Independent Ale House, and MacKenzie River Pizza offer gluten-free and vegan options so everyone can enjoy a slice.
Which pizza places in Rapid City are best for families or groups?
Pizza Ranch, especially with its buffet and party rooms, plus MacKenzie River Pizza (spacious and casual) are great picks for families and large gatherings.
Can I get pizza delivered in Rapid City?
Absolutely. Papa Johns, Marco’s, Domino’s, and Pizza Hut all deliver, and many local pizzerias offer their own delivery or work with delivery apps.
What’s the most unique pizza you can try in Rapid City?
Try the Thai Pie at Independent Ale House or the Flathead at MacKenzie River Pizza for creative spins you won’t find at just any pizza shop.