Finding the best pizza in Raleigh, NC can feel like a treasure hunt, but there are few cities where the quest is quite this rewarding. If you’ve ever wandered along Hillsborough Street with the smell of fresh dough wafting through the air, you know Raleigh doesn’t mess around when it comes to pizza. Whether you’re after a classic slice, a gooey deep-dish, or something with a twist, every corner here seems to offer its own pizza personality—each one vying for the top spot.
I remember my first Raleigh pizza: the crust was crisp, the sauce tangy, and I ended up devouring more slices than intended. Since then, I’ve explored the city’s most talked-about pizza joints, comparing notes with locals and friends, getting lost in conversations about wood-fired ovens and perfect cheese pulls. The result is a local’s guide, written for people who want their pizza experience to be spot-on every time. Read on and discover which Raleigh pizzeria could become your new favorite.
Where to find the best pizza in Raleigh, NC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Raleigh, NC:
- Mellow Mushroom Raleigh
- Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar
- Trophy Brewing and Pizza
- Manhattan Pizza
- Milton’s Pizza and Pasta – Raleigh
- Vic’s Italian Restaurant
- Kings Bowl-North Hills
- Oakwood Pizza Box
- Lilly’s Pizza
- Slice of NY Pizza
1. Mellow Mushroom Raleigh
Mellow Mushroom Raleigh feels like a vibrant pizza wonderland. Walk in and you’ll notice the quirky art, buzzing atmosphere, and that wonderful aroma of fresh dough baking on stone. It’s the sort of place you start out with a casual dinner and end up lingering for hours.
The crust is where Mellow Mushroom shines. Their spring water dough makes every pizza feel light yet satisfying. If you want a proper introduction, order the Mighty Meaty or the Kosmic Karma—each offers a punch of flavor and quality melted cheese. They’ve nailed the balance between creative toppings and classic tastes.
Vegetarian and gluten-free options keep everyone in the group happy. When it comes to reliability and flavor, Mellow Mushroom Raleigh sits at the top of the game.
2. Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar
+1 919-246-0640
Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar brings a laid-back, social vibe to Brier Creek. Walking in, you’re met with the warm aroma of the wood-fired oven, always the heart of the action. The lively chatter and open kitchen make it feel like you’re in a friend’s home rather than a restaurant.
What sets Brixx apart is their knack for turning simple ingredients into bold flavors. Their wood-fired pizzas come out with perfectly blistered crusts. My go-to is the Wild Mushroom pizza—earthy, cheesy, and undeniably satisfying.
Their menu has plenty for everyone, from vegan to gluten-free options. Brixx’s commitment to scratch-made meals and creative toppings proves they’re more than just another pizza spot.
3. Trophy Brewing and Pizza
Trophy Brewing and Pizza is the sort of place where you’ll spot friends gathering after work or families celebrating a win. The energy is contagious, with the ovens going and a buzz of conversation filling the air. Their hand-made pizzas steal the show, but the creative drinks and relaxed vibe make the experience even better.
The Detroit-style pizza, offered Monday and Tuesday evenings, is a game-changer—think thick, caramelized crust that’s soft inside with a satisfying crunch on the edge. It’s what drew me in on my first visit, and I keep coming back for slices piled high with fresh toppings.
Trophy’s menu keeps vegetarians and gluten-free diners happy too. For a real taste of Raleigh’s pizza scene, their classic Margherita or the inventive “Local Celebrity” are hard to beat.
4. Manhattan Pizza
Manhattan Pizza brings a taste of New York right to Raleigh with its classic, no-frills charm. Stepping inside, you’re greeted by the smell of bubbling cheese and a steady hush of conversation—a true neighborhood pizzeria vibe.
The thin, foldable crust is exactly what you’d expect from a New York slice. Every pie comes out piping hot, with just the right balance of sauce and cheese. My favorite? The plain cheese pizza, simple but unforgettable, where you appreciate every component on its own.
Vegetarian options abound, so everyone’s covered. If you’re after a slice that tastes like it came straight out of Manhattan’s streets, this spot nails it.
5. Milton’s Pizza and Pasta – Raleigh
Milton’s Pizza and Pasta – Raleigh is the sort of place where regulars are greeted by name and newcomers quickly become fans. It’s bright, spacious, and always feels welcoming, whether you’re with family, friends, or a hungry work crew.
The pizza menu is packed with classics and specialty options. Their “Milton’s Special” is a feast—loaded with veggies and gooey cheese, all on a sturdy, golden crust. If you’re feeling adventurous, try their thin crust for a lighter touch that still delivers tons of flavor.
What really caught my eye was the giant salad bar and generous lunch buffet. For comfort food done right in Raleigh, Milton’s is always at the top of my list.
6. Vic’s Italian Restaurant
Vic’s Italian Restaurant sits in the heart of downtown and serves up genuine Italian charm with every meal. The stone walls and rustic décor give it a cozy feel, while the steady flow of smiling diners says plenty about the food.
Vic’s is all about tradition and quality. Their margherita pizza highlights this perfectly—simple, with a bubbly crust and fresh basil. On my last visit, the slice was so perfectly baked that I couldn’t resist a second.
Vegetarian choices and classic Italian sides make it easy to please a crowd. If you’re looking for pizza that’s both comforting and refined, Vic’s is always a smart choice.
7. Kings Bowl-North Hills
+1 919-600-5700
See Menu
Kings Bowl-North Hills isn’t just about bowling and games—there’s pizza worth talking about, too. With its retro-inspired vibe and energetic crowd, it feels like a throwback night out with modern comforts. It’s the kind of spot where you can eat, laugh, and compete, all under one roof.
Their pizzas are big on flavor, with crisp crusts and generous toppings. The Veggie Supreme is always a hit at my table—fresh peppers, mushrooms, and a tangy tomato sauce that stands out from the crowd.
There are good gluten-free and vegetarian options, so no one has to skip the pizza run. Kings Bowl gives you more than just a meal; it delivers a genuinely fun dining experience.
8. Oakwood Pizza Box
Oakwood Pizza Box is the Raleigh spot for pizza purists. The place is small and always buzzing, with locals picking up pies and regulars chatting by the counter. It feels like a slice of classic New York right in the heart of Raleigh.
The star here is their classic cheese pizza. The crust is thin but sturdy, with the perfect snap and just enough chew. The sauce is balanced, and the cheese melts into a gooey, golden layer that’s hard to resist. I still remember the first bite—simple but memorable.
Their veggie options are solid, too, showing you don’t need a dozen toppings for great flavor. Oakwood Pizza Box proves that less is often more when it comes to good pizza.
9. Lilly’s Pizza
+1 919-833-0226
Lilly’s Pizza is every bit the neighborhood hangout, with funky art on the walls and a low-key, comfortable vibe. It’s the type of place you find yourself returning to, whether you’re craving lunch after a busy morning or need a late-night bite with friends.
Their crust is thick and full of flavor, but the real magic is in the toppings. Each pizza is loaded with fresh veggies and thoughtfully paired cheeses. The Buddhapesto is my top pick, with its punchy pesto, ripe tomatoes, and classic mozzarella—perfectly showing off Lilly’s unique flair.
Vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free choices are plentiful here. Lilly’s Pizza proves that creativity and quality can go hand in hand, making it a must for any pizza lover.
10. Slice of NY Pizza
Slice of NY Pizza serves classic New York-style pies that are as authentic as you’ll find south of Manhattan. The setting is casual, perfect for grabbing a quick bite or lingering over a big, foldable slice with friends.
The real draw here is their oversized slices. Each one is thin, perfectly crisp at the edge, and never skimping on cheese. My favorite order is their plain cheese or veggie—delicious and comforting, just like in the city it’s named for.
It’s easy to see why locals keep coming back; Slice of NY gets the details right every time. When you want classic pizza without any fuss, this spot is a go-to in Raleigh.
More Things to Try in Raleigh, NC
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in Raleigh?
You’ll find almost every kind: New York-style, Detroit-style, wood-fired, thin crust, deep dish, and gluten-free choices are all on the menu throughout the city.
Do Raleigh pizza places offer vegan or vegetarian options?
Absolutely. Many spots, like Lilly’s Pizza and Brixx, are known for their creative vegetarian and vegan pies. Just ask for the available options or check their menus online.
Are there gluten-free pizza options in Raleigh?
Yes. Places like Mellow Mushroom, Brixx, and Milton’s offer gluten-free crust, so you don’t have to miss out on great pizza in Raleigh.
Can I get pizza delivered in Raleigh?
Most pizzerias offer delivery, either directly or through services like DoorDash and Uber Eats. Always double-check with your favorite spot for delivery details.
What’s the best pizza place for families?
Milton’s Pizza and Pasta and Mellow Mushroom are both family favorites, thanks to big menus, roomy dining areas, and plenty of choices for kids and adults alike.