Nothing sharpens your appetite like a stroll through downtown Punxsutawney, where the aroma of bubbling cheese and crispy crust drifts through the air. I still remember my first visit—crunching through autumn leaves, I followed the scent straight to a corner pizzeria, hungry and curious. That single slice set a high bar, and since then, I’ve sampled nearly every local spot, each with its own spin on a classic.
Finding the best pizza in Punxsutawney isn’t about luck—it’s about knowing where to look. Whether you crave gooey mozzarella, crave a chewy Neapolitan base, or love robust tomato sauce with a side of small-town charm, this guide will lead you straight to the pizzas that locals love. Ready to find your next favorite pie? Let’s see what Punxsutawney is baking up.
1. Punxsy Pizza
Punxsy Pizza feels like the local legend everyone whispers about after their first bite. Tucked on North Findley Street, it’s the sort of spot where a simple cheese slice gets you hooked. The pies come out with a golden crust and the right dose of gooey cheese—simple, but done right.
What sets Punxsy Pizza apart is its no-nonsense approach to fresh ingredients and classic methods. Each pizza brims with flavor, and the staff always makes you feel like family. I’m partial to their veggie pizza, loaded with crisp peppers and mushrooms—just enough crunch in every bite.
If you want the true experience, try their Deluxe Pizza. It’s a local favorite, stacked generously with fresh toppings, and captures everything people love about pizza in Punxsutawney.
2. Laska Pizza
Laska Pizza is one of those places where the first bite tells you you’ve found something special. Nestled on North Main Street, it’s known for its handcrafted dough and that unmistakable scent of real, bubbling cheese. My first visit ended with a few slices missing before I even reached home—yes, it’s that hard to resist.
The real charm of Laska Pizza is in the crust. Each pie comes out light and airy, with a subtle crunch that’s satisfyingly different from other spots in town. Laska’s team is quick, and the takeout stays warm and fresh until the last bite.
Try their Veggie Pizza or a classic cheese pie, both highlighting their signature, well-balanced sauce and fresh toppings. It’s a Punxsutawney staple for good reason.
3. Pizza Town
Pizza Town sits on West Mahoning Street and has perfected the art of reliable, tasty pies. My first run-in with their pizza happened after a long day, and their signature sauce honestly revived me. The place strikes a balance between friendly local charm and hearty Italian flavor.
What makes Pizza Town stand out is its memorable sauce—rich, tangy, and never overwhelming. Their crust is soft in the center but crisp at the edges, perfect for those who appreciate traditional Italian style with an American kick.
If you’re stopping by, order the Sicilian pizza or their cheese and veggie combo. Both serve as a showcase for their fluffy dough and fresh, flavorful toppings.
4. Fox’s Pizza Den
Fox’s Pizza Den, found in the Ground Hog Plaza, feels instantly familiar—like the kind of spot you relied on for team parties or quick family dinners. My go-to order here always brings back memories of sharing slices with friends, everyone reaching for the last piece.
The standout at Fox’s is their consistently generous toppings. Each slice carries plenty of cheese and sauce, layered over a crust that’s neither too thin nor too thick—just right for satisfying a serious pizza craving.
Their Veggie Pizza or the classic cheese Stromboli are easy winners, each reflecting Fox’s knack for balance and freshness. If you love a no-surprise, hearty pie, Fox’s Pizza Den hits the mark every time.
5. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on Route 119 offers a familiar comfort, whether you crave a quick carryout or plan to linger over a meal. I’ve ducked in after a late night more than once, happy to find my favorite pizza ready before I even get settled at a booth.
The real draw here is consistency. You know what you’re getting every time—a chewy, buttery crust and layers of creamy cheese. The staff turns out pies with efficiency and always manages a smile at the counter.
Order the Original Stuffed Crust® or a classic Veggie Lover’s, both with that golden finish and heaps of fresh toppings. When craving reliable pizza, Pizza Hut doesn’t let down in Punxsutawney.
6. New Anchor Inn
The New Anchor Inn blends history with hospitality, having served Punxsutawney since 1925. I’ve stopped by for dinners where the walls echo with stories and the dining room always buzzes with local laughter. It’s the kind of spot where family meals turn into traditions.
What sets the New Anchor Inn apart is its commitment to comfort food made from scratch. Their pizza doesn’t follow trends—it follows family recipes passed down for generations. Each pie comes with a soft, pillowy crust and a balance of toppings that never overwhelms.
If you haven’t yet, try their classic cheese or veggie pizza. The flavors capture the spirit of old-school pizza in Punxsutawney—hearty, genuine, and best enjoyed with friends and family.
7. Gimmicks Restaurant
Gimmicks Restaurant sits quietly on Ridge Avenue, known equally for its comfort food and friendly faces. My first visit started with a quick lunch—before I knew it, pizza had landed on my table looking far better than I’d expected from a spot that does it all. The surprise? It tasted even better.
What makes Gimmicks stand out is its commitment to homemade flavors. Their pizza comes hot and fresh, always with a crust just thick enough to hold generous toppings without being heavy. The atmosphere encourages conversation, making it a favorite for families and groups.
Order the Veggie Pizza or the cheese pie, both great showcases of their devotion to fresh, local ingredients. It’s a reliable pick for anyone looking for more than just a typical pizza night.
8. Luigi’s
Luigi’s on East Mahoning Street has the feel of a family-run treasure—one that draws regulars year after year. The first time I walked in, the aroma was so inviting it made the dinner choice easier than ever. Each pizza feels as if it’s made to order, with close attention to every detail.
Luigi’s stands out for its perfectly balanced sauce and chewy, satisfying crust. The staff always seem to know just when you need a refill or a box for leftovers, and there’s something comforting about their old-school service style.
Their Margherita pizza and classic cheese pizza never disappoint. Both highlight Luigi’s dedication to authentic flavor, using fresh tomato, basil, and a just-right layer of cheese. It’s a taste of tradition right in Punxsutawney.
9. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Indiana Street is where speed meets reliability—even on the busiest game nights or those evenings when cooking is out of the question. I’ve ordered from here in a pinch and never had to wait long. The smell of warm crust and tangy sauce always arrives right on schedule.
What makes Domino’s shine is how customizable everything feels. You can select from a range of crusts and fresh veggie toppings, all layered up just the way you want. Orders are always accurate and the staff moves fast from oven to delivery.
For a crowd-pleaser, go for their Handmade Pan Pizza or Veggie Pizza, both loaded with cheese and just enough crunch. It’s fast, flexible, and reliably good every time.
10. Sarah L Defelice Pizza House
Sarah L Defelice Pizza House is a name locals remember—part legend, part go-to spot for comfort food. My own first bite was pure nostalgia. Every pizza feels hand-crafted, right down to the classic sauce that’s tangy without overpowering the rest of the flavors.
What really sets Sarah L Defelice Pizza House apart is the dough. Each pizza rises with a light, airy texture that’s pillowy inside and crisp at the edges. It’s a flavor and feel you don’t forget.
The cheese pizza here is as classic as it gets, while veggie options keep the regulars coming back, each topped with fresh, well-prepared ingredients. It’s the kind of place that defines pizza in Punxsutawney.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizza place in Punxsutawney, PA?
Preferences differ, but Punxsy Pizza, Laska Pizza, and Pizza Town are long-time local favorites known for their fresh ingredients and friendly service.
Are there vegetarian pizza options in Punxsutawney?
Absolutely. Most pizzerias—including Punxsy Pizza, Laska Pizza, and Domino’s—offer veggie pizzas and the option to customize your own pie.
Which pizza spots offer delivery in Punxsutawney?
Delivery is available from popular places like Fox’s Pizza Den, Domino’s Pizza, Papa John’s, and Pizza Hut. Online and phone orders are both common.
Can I get gluten-free pizza in Punxsutawney?
Chain restaurants such as Domino’s and Pizza Hut typically offer gluten-free crust options. Always call ahead to double-check availability and preparation details.
Where can I find locally-owned pizza shops?
You’ll find local charm at Sarah L Defelice Pizza House, Gimmicks Restaurant, and New Anchor Inn, each with its own unique approach to classic pies.