Finding the best pizza in Prescott, AZ is a quest that’s both delicious and surprisingly layered. This isn’t just about gooey cheese or a crispy crust—though those certainly help. It’s about that first bite that makes you pause mid-conversation, rethink your pizza standards, and silently vow to come back soon. Prescott punches above its weight, with pizzerias tucked into historic buildings, main street gems, and even a few chains that hold their own.
After sampling the local favorites (yes, I’ve done the appetizing legwork), I can promise you this: Prescott’s pizza game covers every craving and style. Whether you’re lured by wood-fired Neapolitan pies, classic American slices, or inventive gourmet toppings, you’re in for a treat. Keep reading to discover where the real magic is being made by the slice—you might just find your new favorite spot.
1. Bill’s Pizza
Bill’s Pizza sits right by the courthouse, impossible to miss if you’re strolling through Prescott’s classic downtown. This spot is a local legend—something about the aroma of fresh dough and vibrant tomato sauce drifting out the door draws you in every time.
What makes Bill’s Pizza stand out is its creative blend of topping combinations and a crust that hits the sweet spot between crisp and chewy. I once grabbed a slice of the Elton John (yes, it’s named after the legend) and was an instant convert—a delicious showcase of artichoke, garlic, tomatoes, and a medley of cheeses.
Order the Wise Guy for a peppery punch or the Queen Margherita for a simple yet flavorful classic. Their menu covers vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free needs, making it easy to bring everyone along.
2. Rosa’s Pizzeria
Rosa’s Pizzeria feels like you’ve stumbled upon a family secret, just off Gurley Street. Every visit comes with a side of warmth, thanks to the classic, bustling Italian vibe. The open kitchen lets you see the dough spinning and pizzas sliding into the oven—an experience as satisfying as the first bite.
Rosa’s is famous for its classic New York-style slices, offering the thin, foldable crust that locals swear by. The sauce here is bright and balanced, making each slice memorable. I still think about the moment I tried their Margherita—fresh basil and creamy mozzarella stealing the spotlight.
If you love a bit of adventure, try their white pizza with ricotta and spinach. Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free choices make it a welcoming table for everyone.
3. Limoncello Pizzeria Napoletana
Limoncello Pizzeria Napoletana brings a genuine Neapolitan touch to the heart of Prescott. From the moment you step inside, the aroma of wood-fired dough and the sight of fresh pasta being made by hand hint at something special. The Italian chef’s attention to detail transforms humble ingredients into showstoppers.
What makes Limoncello remarkable is the focus on true authenticity. Each pizza boasts a thin, chewy crust with slightly charred edges—just as you’d find in Naples. My favorite here is their Margherita, with bright tomato, creamy mozzarella, and fragrant basil creating a perfect balance.
Adventurous eaters can try a pizza topped with grilled veggies or a classic quattro formaggi. The menu’s vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options let everyone join the table without compromise.
4. Two Mamas’ Gourmet Pizzeria
Two Mamas’ Gourmet Pizzeria feels like discovering a neighborhood secret that’s too good not to share. Nestled on North Cortez, this spot impresses with hand-tossed pies and an unhurried, welcoming vibe. I once stopped in after a downtown stroll, only planning for a quick slice, but ended up staying for seconds.
Two Mamas’ stands out for its generous toppings and inventive flavor pairings. Their crust strikes a perfect balance—crispy yet soft enough to soak up every bit of sauce. The Veggie Delight is a personal favorite, brimming with colorful, fresh ingredients and a sprinkle of herbs.
For something classic, go for the Margherita or try their unique pesto-topped pie. Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options mean no one is left out.
5. Fresca Cafe
Fresca Cafe combines the charm of an Italian café with the comfort of a local favorite. You’ll notice straight away—the attention to freshness jumps out, from homemade gelato to pizzas that arrive piping hot. The vibe makes you want to linger, sipping coffee and enjoying good company.
Fresca Cafe sets itself apart with imported Italian cheeses and top-quality produce. Their pizzas celebrate simplicity: a thin, crisp crust and well-balanced toppings. My go-to is the classic Margherita, which delivers on flavor without fuss.
If you enjoy lighter pies, try the veggie pizza, finished with seasonal ingredients. There are vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free crusts, so everyone can have a slice of the action.
6. Rosati’s Pizza
Rosati’s Pizza sticks to its roots, offering a taste of Chicago right here in Prescott. The moment you step in, there’s a comforting sense of tradition—recipes passed down, hands dusted with flour, and that unmistakable aroma of home-baked dough.
Rosati’s stands out because it never chases trends. The focus here is on hearty, scratch-made pies with bold flavors. I always lean toward their deep-dish veggie pizza, packed with cheese and a robust tomato sauce, finished with plenty of fresh toppings.
If classic is your style, their thin crust is also worth a try. Portions are generous, so bring friends. Vegetarian options make sharing easy, even in a crowd.
7. Park Plaza Liquor and Deli
Park Plaza Liquor and Deli is no ordinary corner stop—it’s a lively local haunt with a deli, wine shop, and wood-fired pizza all under one roof. The moment you walk in, there’s an energizing mix of stacked bottles and the scent of crisp dough meeting an open flame.
What makes Park Plaza special is its fearless approach to pizza. The wood grill lends a smoky depth that elevates every pie, whether you opt for a classic combo or something more daring. The Mediterranean pizza loaded with artichoke hearts and feta is a personal favorite, always coming out with a perfect char.
With vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, there’s a seat for everyone at the table—perfect for lively group outings.
8. Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘n’ Bake Pizza
Papa Murphy’s takes a unique approach—you pick up a fresh, uncooked pizza and bake it yourself at home. There’s something satisfying about the aroma filling your kitchen, turning an ordinary night into a homemade feast. It’s easy, fresh, and always just the way you like it.
Papa Murphy’s stands out because its pizzas are prepped with fresh ingredients and never frozen dough. The process puts control in your hands: want your crust a bit crisper? Leave it in a few extra minutes.
I’m a fan of their Veggie pizza, loaded with colorful vegetables and a classic red sauce. There are vegetarian and gluten-free options for easy custom orders. Grab one for dinner and let your oven take care of the rest.
9. Peter Piper Pizza
Peter Piper Pizza delivers more than just a meal—it’s a playful experience, especially for families or groups. The lively arcade, filled with games and laughter, pairs well with the scent of fresh, hand-tossed dough drifting from the oven.
Peter Piper stands out for its made-from-scratch crust and commitment to fresh toppings. The classic Build-Your-Own lets you pile on everything you crave, ensuring each bite matches your mood. I remember tackling their veggie-loaded pie while keeping one eye on a heated Skee-Ball match—every slice as satisfying as a game win.
Stick with a signature veggie combination or customize your own for something new. It’s fast, fresh, and family-friendly, always serving up fun with every order.
10. Granite Mountain Pizza Company
Granite Mountain Pizza Company gives off a small-town comfort that’s easy to love. Tucked away on Willow Creek, it’s the kind of place where you’re greeted with a smile and leave plotting your next visit. There’s a laid-back energy here that fits perfectly with a casual meal among friends.
Granite Mountain Pizza Company stands out thanks to their creative pies and generous portions. The crust is always golden and sturdy, ready to hold layers of fresh vegetables and gooey cheese. I still remember biting into their Veggie Supreme, stacked high with peppers, mushrooms, and tomatoes.
If you’re up for something bold, try building your own pizza—the topping combinations never run out. Vegetarian and vegan options guarantee everyone finds something crave-worthy.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the most popular pizza style in Prescott?
Prescott has a mix of styles but you’ll find thin-crust, New York-style, and wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas are especially beloved here.
Are there any vegan or vegetarian pizza options in Prescott?
Absolutely. Most local pizzerias—like Bill’s, Limoncello, and Granite Mountain Pizza Company—offer creative vegan and vegetarian pizzas, and many also have gluten-free crusts.
Which Prescott pizzerias are best for families?
Peter Piper Pizza is famous for family fun with its arcade, while places like Two Mamas’ and Rosa’s create a welcoming, casual setting for group outings.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Prescott?
Yes. Several spots, including Fresca Cafe, Bill’s Pizza, and Rosati’s, offer gluten-free crusts on their menu.
Which pizza places in Prescott offer delivery or takeout?
Most pizzerias on this list provide takeout, and chains like Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Papa John’s offer delivery. Many local spots also have curbside pickup options.
Is there a spot for authentic Italian-style pizza in Prescott?
Yes—Limoncello Pizzeria Napoletana specializes in authentic Neapolitan pies, made just like you’d find in Italy.