On a crisp night in Portsmouth, there’s a certain magic to wandering Market Square with friends, laughter in the air and the irresistible aroma of baking dough trailing from every corner. Portsmouth’s pizza scene is an open secret among locals—a flavorful mix of tradition, creativity, and hidden gems. With every bite, you taste not only the quality but the quirky charm of this coastal city.
I’ve sampled my way through bustling pizzerias and tiny counters tucked away from the crowds, trading stories and recommendations with die-hard fans along the way. If pie-perfection is what you seek, Portsmouth has easy answers and unexpected delights. Ready to find your own favorite slice? Here’s a guide that cuts through the fluff and goes straight for the good stuff.
1. Flatbread Company
Flatbread Company is where wood-fired pizza dreams come to life. The smell of roasting dough and open flames greets you the moment you walk in. Where many pizza shops chase trends, Flatbread keeps it simple: organic, local ingredients and a menu that’s refreshingly honest.
I once ordered the Coevolution—an inspired blend of organic wheat, caramelized onions, mushrooms, and a charred, smoky crust. The earthy flavors made every bite memorable. For something classic, the Jay’s Heart is perfect: fresh tomato sauce, mozzarella, and just enough garlic to make you smile but not scare away your lunch date.
Flatbread Company is a top pick for those who love quality and a relaxed vibe. Their vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options mean everyone can join the table.
2. Bratskellar Pizza Pub
Bratskellar Pizza Pub is a Portsmouth tradition where the atmosphere is as inviting as the menu. Locally owned since 1968, it’s the place where regulars gather for pizza, conversation, and the coldest soda on tap.
I remember sharing a hot slice of their signature veggie pizza with friends on a rainy evening. The crust struck a perfect balance between chewy and crisp, while the homemade sauce delivered a rich, herby punch. Their Greek-style pies have a devoted fan base, and it’s easy to see why—especially the House Special, topped with a lively mix of vegetables and fresh cheese.
Bratskellar wins fans with dependable quality and a laid-back vibe. Order the House Special for a taste of why this spot is still beloved after decades.
3. Portsmouth Pizza Factory
Portsmouth Pizza Factory is the neighborhood standby when you want pizza that hits the spot without any fuss. Tucked away on Islington Street, it’s a favorite for takeout or a casual sit-down meal. Fast, friendly service keeps the locals coming back.
On my last visit, I tried their simple veggie pizza. The crust was golden and chewy, with a generous helping of fresh vegetables and perfectly melted cheese. It felt both comforting and satisfying—the kind of pizza that fits every craving, from solo lunches to group dinners.
Portsmouth Pizza Factory stands out for its reliable quality and straightforward flavors. If you’re after something classic, their cheese and veggie pizzas deliver every time.
4. Dough Craft Pizza
Dough Craft Pizza delivers a true Italian flair to Portsmouth’s pizza scene. You notice the difference right away—the dough is made fresh daily using imported Italian flour, and each sauce features real San Marzano tomatoes. Nothing feels mass-produced here.
During a rainy afternoon, I shared a Margherita pizza with a friend. The crust was both delicate and chewy, topped with just the right amount of fresh mozzarella and basil. Every slice had that subtle char you crave from a carefully tended oven.
If you want to feel like you’re in Naples, the Margherita or Veggie pizzas are both strong bets. With gluten-free and vegan options, Dough Craft Pizza suits any group in search of quality and comfort.
5. Luigi’s West End Pizzeria
Luigi’s West End Pizzeria feels like a slice of New York tucked into Portsmouth. Thin, foldable slices and a crisp, satisfying crust set the tone for a familiar favorite done right. The staff serves up genuine smiles and quick service every time.
I popped in after a late shift and ordered the classic cheese pizza. Each bite had that distinct chewy texture and gooey cheese pull that only a dedicated New York-style shop can deliver. It’s the sort of pizza you want to fold and eat on the go, but the cozy vibe of Luigi’s made me want to linger.
The cheese and veggie pies are especially popular here. When you’re craving big flavors and bigger slices, Luigi’s is a safe bet.
6. Otto
Otto makes an impression with its creative toppings and modern atmosphere. Housed in the historic Frank Jones 1884 House, it’s the spot where friends gather for both a quick slice and a proper sit-down meal. The inviting two-level space means there’s room for everyone, even on busy nights.
I stopped in for lunch and couldn’t pass up their roasted cauliflower and mushroom pizza. The flavor combination was unique and the crust had an addictive crunch that’s tough to forget. Otto takes risks with toppings, and they pay off in delicious ways.
For a real taste of Otto’s inventive style, try anything from their veggie lineup. You won’t find these flavor pairings anywhere else in Portsmouth.
7. Joe’s New York Pizza
Joe’s New York Pizza delivers that unmistakable city swagger right in Portsmouth. The vibe is straightforward, with big slices and little fuss—just what you need when a craving strikes. Whether you dine in or grab a box to go, you’ll spot locals coming back for good reason.
On my first visit, I tried their veggie pie. The crust was thin and foldable, packed with fresh vegetables and gooey cheese. It’s comfort food, plain and simple, and hard to put down until the last bite.
If you want an authentic New York-style experience, grab their classic cheese or veggie slices. Joe’s hits all the right notes for those who appreciate classic pizza done well.
8. Gigi’s Pizza
Gigi’s Pizza feels like a secret treasure hidden just off the main road. Known for its thin crust, each bite offers plenty of crispness alongside authentic Italian flavor. The simple counter service and no-frills dining room keep the focus on what matters—honest, flavorful food.
One weekday lunch, I tried their veggie thin-crust pizza. Fresh toppings and a cracker-thin base let every ingredient shine. For a little variety, their calzones are another crowd-pleaser, stuffed and baked until golden.
The real draw at Gigi’s is the combination of thin, traditional pies and friendly, quick service. If you’re looking for a quick bite between errands or a quiet spot for a casual dinner, Gigi’s delivers.
9. Tradeport Pizza
Tradeport Pizza is the go-to spot for those in Portsmouth’s business district hunting for a satisfying lunch. Quick service and a relaxed setting make it popular for office breaks and casual gatherings alike. What stands out is their daily rotation of fresh pies and classic flavors.
One afternoon, I grabbed a slice of their spinach and tomato pizza. The crust was just the right thickness—soft on the inside, with a light crunch. You can tell they don’t skimp on toppings or quality.
Choose from a range of classic and veggie options. It’s ideal when you need a speedy, delicious lunch without crossing town, and their breakfast offerings set them apart from your typical pizza joint.
10. Portsmouth Gas Light Co. Pizza Pub
Portsmouth Gas Light Co. Pizza Pub offers a lively backdrop for sharing good pizza downtown. Housed in a historic brick building, its charm lies in both atmosphere and thin, generously topped pies. The open kitchen lets you watch your pizza bubble in the oven—a nice touch if you like seeing the action.
I stopped by during a busy weekend and tried their classic veggie pizza. The crust was crisp, the sauce bright, and the mix of peppers and onions gave it just enough bite. The portions are generous, making it a top pick for group dinners.
Go for one of their specialty veggie or margherita pies. The old-world setting and reliable flavors always make for a memorable meal.
Frequently Asked Questions
What style of pizza is most common in Portsmouth, NH?
Most spots in Portsmouth serve **thin-crust, New York-style, and traditional Italian pies**. There’s also a healthy dose of creative, wood-fired options around town.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Portsmouth?
Absolutely. **Many pizzerias in Portsmouth, including Flatbread Company and Dough Craft Pizza, offer vegetarian and vegan pies**. Most also provide gluten-free crusts if needed.
Which Portsmouth pizzerias offer gluten-free pizza?
**Flatbread Company, Dough Craft Pizza, and Bratskellar Pizza Pub** are known for reliable gluten-free options. Always double-check for kitchen practices if you have allergies.
Can I get pizza delivered in Portsmouth?
Yes. **Most pizza places in Portsmouth offer delivery, either directly or through third-party apps**. Takeout and quick slice counters are also widely available.
Where can I get a quick slice of pizza downtown?
**Joe’s New York Pizza and Otto’s slice counter** are go-to picks for a speedy bite without the wait.