Choosing the best pizza in Portage, IN can feel a bit like navigating a delicious maze. Each corner offers its own aroma, from classic deep-dish to paper-thin crusts bubbling with cheese. Whether you lean toward tangy tomato or crave a mountain of veggies, this city has no shortage of options that beg for your taste test. The local pizza scene isn’t just about a quick bite; it’s about finding that special spot where each slice leaves you planning your next visit before you’ve even finished the first.
As someone who’s sampled more pies than I’d care to admit, I’ve come to appreciate the subtle ways each parlor sets itself apart. Some charm with inventive toppings, while others win you over with a crust so perfect it could stand alone. If you’re curious where your next pizza night should be, let’s start with a lineup of spots that have earned their place on Portage’s pizza map.
1. CiCi’s Pizza
(219) 764-8045Call
CiCi’s Pizza at 6028 Central Ave is where pizza cravings and indecision finally meet their match. The endless buffet here means you can try everything: pillowy pan pizzas, gooey stuffed crust, classic cheese and those cinnamon rolls that somehow steal the show. The place buzzes with families, friends, and anyone who can’t settle for just one slice.
I’ve lost track of the number of times I’ve reached for just one more piece of the zesty pepperoni—CiCi’s somehow gets the crust to that just right spot between chewy and crisp. If you really want to taste Portage on a plate, go for their signature BBQ pizza or the spinach Alfredo.
Bottom line: variety, affordability, and always an excuse for seconds.
2. Verona Pizza IV
(219) 764-6464Call
Verona Pizza IV, tucked along US Highway 6, brings an unmistakable local charm to the Portage pizza landscape. This spot feels like a neighborhood secret—the kind you discover once and never forget. Every order, from the perfectly blistered crusts to the robust sauce, comes with a sense of genuine care.
What’s impressive is how they nail both traditional and creative pies. I still think about their deluxe pizza, piled high with crisp vegetables and savory beef, the kind that turns a regular dinner into an event. Their classic cheese slice also deserves its own shout-out: silky mozzarella and balanced sauce over a crust that gets the golden treatment every time.
If you like feeling right at home while sampling solid slices, Verona makes it easy.
3. Pizza Hut – Closed
Pizza Hut on US Highway 6 may have closed its Portage doors, but its memory lingers for anyone who grew up on their Original Stuffed Crust or the instant comfort of a piping hot Meat Lovers pie after a long week. All those classic red-roof vibes, breadsticks, and carryout boxes have left a mark that’s hard to forget.
I remember meeting friends here for a quick slice and friendly debates about which crust reigned supreme. The supreme pizza always delivered, loaded with a medley of veggies and tender beef. For fans of more than just pizza, the creamy pasta and signature wings were always reliable favorites.
If you ever enjoyed a family dinner here, you know what made this location stand out: familiar comfort paired with iconic pies.
4. Bam Pizza Company
Bam Pizza Company brings a bold approach to pizza in Portage. Walking into their spot at the Portage Mall, I was floored by the buzz—and by the aroma of dough that’s genuinely made fresh daily. The “Big Bam” pizza is legendary for size alone, arriving as a 30-inch circle of crisp crust and bubbling cheese that demands a crowd.
What sets Bam apart is the creativity, from New York-style thin to stuffed pies and Chicago-style deep dish with the sauce on top. Every option oozes quality, but the deep dish loaded with vegetables stands out for its perfect balance and flavor. Their hand-tossed dough is the kind of chewy-soft you remember long after the meal.
If you’re after original pies or feeding a group, Bam makes every visit feel like an event. Their devotion to craft—and size—makes this a true Portage favorite.
5. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza at 1895 Crisman Rd makes ordering pizza both simple and satisfying. Efficient service and consistent quality keep locals coming back, whether you’re grabbing a quick carryout or waiting for a piping hot delivery at home. The customizable menu gives everyone room to make their perfect pie.
I’ve leaned on Domino’s more times than I can count, especially when hunger hits late and options are limited. Their Handmade Pan pizza gets high marks for its buttery crust and fluffy center—a real comfort slice. If you want a twist, the Parmesan Stuffed Crust brings gooey richness that elevates classic toppings.
For variety, opt for a veggie-loaded pie or try their popular sides—their seasoned bread twists are always tempting. Domino’s keeps things reliable and tasty, every time.
6. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Hunt Brothers Pizza, tucked inside Zip Foods on Samuelson Rd, is a hidden gem for anyone who loves a generous pizza. The promise of “All Toppings No Extra Charge” turns decision-making into an adventure and lets you pile on those vegetables or extra cheese without hesitation. They serve up both original and thin crust, so everyone finds something to like.
Stopping here after a long day has become a small tradition for me. Their classic cheese pizza wins with a creamy mozzarella melt and a nicely browned crust. You can build your own masterpiece or stick with time-tested favorites.
For classic flavor and value, Hunt Brothers makes every order feel like a good decision. Try customizing—you’ll leave satisfied every time.
7. Santini’s Pepper Pot Pizza
(219) 762-2113Call
Santini’s Pepper Pot Pizza on Willowcreek Rd does pizza with a classic, no-frills touch that keeps folks loyal for years. It’s the sort of spot where you can actually taste the care in every crust and find a staff that remembers your favorite order. What sets Santini’s apart is their flavorful, slightly spicy sauce that brings every slice to life without overpowering the cheese.
The combo pizza is worth a try, loaded with a hearty mix of vegetables and savory beef. I’ve popped in for a quick dinner more than once, always leaving satisfied with a slice that tastes like home. The cheese pizza has that perfect golden top and just enough chew in the dough to keep you reaching for another piece.
If you want honest, satisfying pizza, this place never disappoints.
8. Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars Pizza on Central Ave is where you go when time is tight but you still crave a hot, satisfying meal. The “Hot-N-Ready” pizzas give instant gratification—fresh pies waiting on the rack so you’re in and out in minutes. It’s the kind of convenience that’s rescued many of my busy evenings.
Little Caesars stands out because it keeps things simple and reliable. The classic cheese or pepperoni pizza has a chewy, buttery crust and that signature zesty sauce. The Italian Cheese Bread is a favorite side, thick with melty cheese and a golden finish that pairs well with any pizza order.
If you want solid flavor and unbeatable speed, Little Caesars is always up to the job.
9. J & J Pizza Shack
J & J Pizza Shack on Central Ave has a cozy, old-school feel that keeps Portage regulars coming back year after year. Big portions and a family-friendly vibe make this more than just a pizza stop—it’s a go-to for group meals and celebrations. I remember walking in on a chilly evening and being greeted by the warm aroma of fresh dough and bubbling cheese.
Their House Special pizza is a crowd-pleaser, heaped with a generous mix of veggies and savory beef. The crust is thick and golden, with just the right amount of chew. If you’re feeling adventurous, try their stuffed crust options—they pack every bite with flavor.
For classic comfort food and a laid-back atmosphere, J & J is a reliable choice.
10. Aurelio’s Pizza
Aurelio’s Pizza on US Highway 6 knows how to coax big flavor from simple ingredients. The signature thin-crust pies have a shatteringly crisp finish and are loaded edge-to-edge so every bite counts. Aurelio’s stands out in Portage thanks to a long family tradition and pizzas that straddle classic and creative with confidence.
I’ve always enjoyed their super taco pizza, which brings together layers of beans, cheese, and zippy vegetables on their legendary thin base. For something simpler, the cheese and fresh tomato pie delivers a delicate balance of sauce and gooey mozzarella.
If you love crackly crusts and a generous helping of toppings, Aurelio’s delivers a slice of history with modern flavor in every order.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Portage, IN?
Some favorites include Giordano’s, Bam Pizza Company, Aurelio’s, J & J Pizza Shack, and Little Caesars. Each spot brings something unique, whether it’s signature crusts, big portions, or creative toppings.
Where can I find vegetarian pizza options in Portage?
Most places offer veggie pizzas, but Domino’s, Aurelio’s, Bam Pizza Company, and Hunt Brothers Pizza all have solid builds with fresh vegetables and great cheese blends.
Which Portage pizza restaurants are best for families?
CiCi’s Pizza, J & J Pizza Shack, and Bam Pizza Company stand out for their casual atmospheres, crowd-pleasing menus, and ability to handle hungry groups.
Are there any late-night pizza spots in Portage?
Domino’s Pizza and Little Caesars are known for extended hours, so they’re solid bets when a craving hits after dinner.
Which pizzerias offer pizza delivery in Portage, IN?
Domino’s, Little Caesars, Bam Pizza Company, Papa Johns, and Aurelio’s all deliver fresh, hot pizza straight to your door.
Can I order gluten-free pizza in Portage?
Several major chains like Domino’s and Papa Johns offer gluten-free crust. It’s best to call ahead at local shops for their latest options.