Finding the best pizza in Plum, PA is a delicious quest, especially in a town where everyone seems to have a strong opinion. Plum isn’t short on options, and each pizza spot offers its own spin—whether you’re after thin crust, gooey cheese, or that perfect, chewy bite. I know the thrill of biting into a hot slice that’s just right, and I’ve trudged through every dive and glowing parlor in search of favorites. Few things compare to discovering a place that gets the dough spot-on and uses fresh, reliable toppings every single time.
Consider this list your shortcut through the local debate. From pizza joints hidden away on quiet corners to spots that draw a crowd on Friday nights, Plum delivers more than just nostalgia. Each stop has its own crowd-pleaser, and if you think pizza is just pizza, you may want to give these places a try. By the end of this guide, you’ll know where to find a slice that’ll have you coming back for seconds, whether you’re a classic pepperoni fan or hunting for something out of the ordinary.
1. Grand Slam Pizza
Tucked away on Abers Creek Road, Grand Slam Pizza feels like a secret everyone in Plum knows. Walking in, the smell of fresh dough and bubbling cheese sets all expectations high—and they hit the mark every time. Their crust lands perfectly between crispy and chewy, which means every bite manages to hold all that flavor without falling apart.
What sets this place apart? It’s their attention to detail. The sauce? Bright, zesty, and never too sweet. The cheese? Generous without being overwhelming. If you’re undecided, order their classic round pie or try the Sicilian square slices—both showcase what Grand Slam does best. For something bold, locals swear by the white pizza, topped with garlic and a blend of cheeses.
2. Fox’s Pizza Den
Fox’s Pizza Den on Golden Mile Highway is that spot you end up returning to again and again, almost by instinct. There’s an easy comfort here—maybe it’s the charm of the place, or maybe it’s just how reliable the pizza always feels. Every visit reminds me why it stands out, thanks to dough that’s tasted fresh every time and a sauce that packs just the right tang.
It’s the Big Daddy Pizza that grabs attention—giant, cheesy, and loaded with favorite toppings. This pie is a must when you’re sharing with friends or feeding a hungry family. If you’re after something classic, the pepperoni here always lands just right, with its crisped-up edges and a satisfying snap.
Fox’s makes pizza the centerpiece, but they don’t forget the details, like speedy takeout and a friendly staff. It’s the kind of place that turns you into a regular after just one slice.
3. Pizza Marsala
Pizza Marsala brings a bit of Old World flair to takeout and delivery, right on Monroeville Boulevard. The moment you pop open a box, the aroma of freshly baked dough speaks for itself. Their pizzas strike a smart balance—thin but sturdy, with toppings laid out like a chef’s signature.
What makes them special is how they go beyond the standard. The gourmet and traditional pies are tailored for every kind of craving. The Margherita, bright with basil and generous cheese, has made me a repeat visitor more than once. Don’t skip their garlic dipping sauce either; it’s a low-key game changer with every bite.
If you like to pair your pie with extras, try their breadsticks or a slice of creamy cheesecake for the full experience. It’s quick, consistent, and always a pleasant surprise.
4. Meglio’s Pizza
Meglio’s Pizza at Garden City Plaza marries neighborhood warmth with spot-on consistency. My first visit set the bar high, thanks to dough that had a light bite and toppings you could actually taste, not just see. There’s a sense they care about the little things—from the first hello down to how the cheese stretches in every pull.
The Veggie Pizza stands out for its colorful mix and crisp base, but their plain cheese is a quiet powerhouse. If you like a good balance, the Meglio’s Special is loaded but never soggy. Every slice feels thoughtfully crafted, from the snap of the crust to the lively tomato sauce.
Meglio’s shines brightest when you’re craving something reliable yet memorable, no matter how simple your order.
5. Gateway Grill
Gateway Grill on Northern Pike offers more than just a place to watch the game—it’s where the pizza never disappoints. My experiences here almost always start with the aroma of fresh pizza drifting from the kitchen and end with a table of empty plates. The atmosphere feels both relaxed and lively, especially on a Friday night.
What sets Gateway Grill apart is how their thick, golden crust stands up to hearty toppings. The Deluxe Pizza is a personal favorite, with every bite layered and balanced. If you’re searching for that perfect stretch of cheese or a sauce that tastes homemade, this is the spot.
For those who lean toward the classic, their plain cheese and veggie options bring solid comfort every time. It’s reliable, friendly, and always leaves you looking forward to your next visit.
6. Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings offers a twist that’s hard to forget: pizzas kissed by a real coal-fired oven, giving every slice a deep, smoky edge. My first bite here set the bar for how bold pizza should taste in Monroeville. The crust comes out with just the right char, while the sauce and cheese hold their own—never lost in the mix.
The standout is their Hot Honey Pizza, where the sweetness and little kick create something memorable. If you’re up for more, their classic Margherita lets the high-quality ingredients shine, and the veggie pies are fresh and flavorful.
Even outside their pizzas, the vibe is laid back but focused—whether you’re grabbing takeout or settling in for a full dinner. It’s where tradition meets a little adventure, which is rare to find in the pizza scene around Plum.
7. Veltre’s Pizza
Veltre’s Pizza in Oakmont is a spot that’s earned loyal fans across the Plum area for a simple reason: every bite delivers. Walk in and you’ll notice the buzz, with regulars swapping pizza stories and staff working the ovens with practiced ease. The aroma hints at why this place keeps drawing a crowd.
What really sets Veltre’s apart is their perfectly chewy, flavorful dough and just the right amount of sauce. I keep coming back for the plain cheese pizza—it’s classic and hearty, with a golden top that’s never greasy. For a real treat, try their white pizza; the balance of ricotta, garlic, and tangy cheese is memorable.
Trust Veltre’s for a reliable and satisfying slice, especially when you’re after something familiar, made with real care.
8. Vocelli Pizza
Vocelli Pizza on Mosside Blvd is a place where consistency and quality go hand in hand. My first pie from Vocelli was a revelation—crispy on the outside, soft where it counts, and always fresh out of the oven. They keep things simple, but every detail is polished, from their homemade dough to the rich tomato sauce they’re known for.
The menu offers plenty, but the Vocelli Deluxe Pizza captures everything they stand for: loaded with fresh veggies and meats, with no single topping overpowering the rest. I also can’t skip their margherita—bright, fragrant, and just cheesy enough to keep you reaching for another slice.
Vocelli’s is never too heavy, making it ideal for sharing or for a late-night craving. It’s a steady go-to when you want pizza that delivers on flavor every single time.
9. Universal Pizza
Universal Pizza on Main Street makes the kind of pizza that’s perfect for a relaxed night in or a big family gathering. The atmosphere is straightforward, but you can tell they take their time with each pie. Every order I’ve placed leaves the box almost too hot to carry—a small detail, but a sign the pizza is always fresh from the oven.
What earns my repeat visits is their classic cheese pizza; the crust has a nice snap and the cheese-to-sauce ratio is always spot on. Everything tastes clean, never weighed down or greasy, which says a lot about the ingredients used. Their veggie options are also worth mentioning, piled high and crisp after a bake in the hot oven.
Universal rounds it out with a friendly, neighborhood feel and quick service, making them an easy pick for pizza night.
10. Della Sala’s Pizza
Della Sala’s Pizza on Verona Road is a true neighborhood spot, with a no-fuss setup that’s all about the food. What strikes me every time I visit is the steady crowd—locals who seem to know that this is where to find real, honest pizza. The approach here is classic, and it’s all about tradition done right.
What makes Della Sala’s special is the dough: soft in the middle with a gentle chew and crispy edges. Their classic cheese pizza deserves the spotlight, featuring a subtle tomato sauce and just the right amount of oozy cheese, nothing more and nothing less. Every bite delivers comfort and nostalgia, exactly what pizza should be.
Della Sala’s keeps it simple and lets quality do the talking—perfect for when you crave a tried-and-true slice.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Plum, PA?
Some of the most well-loved spots include Grand Slam Pizza, Fox’s Pizza Den, Meglio’s Pizza, and Universal Pizza. Each has loyal fans for good reason, offering unique flavors and fresh ingredients.
Are there pizza places in Plum, PA that offer delivery?
Yes, many local favorites like Grand Slam Pizza, Vocelli Pizza, and Pizza Marsala offer delivery to the Plum area. Ordering online or by phone is usually quick and easy.
Can I find vegetarian pizza options in Plum, PA?
Absolutely. Most pizza shops, including Veltre’s, Meglio’s, and Universal Pizza, feature veggie pies stacked with fresh vegetables. Just ask your server or check the menu for options.
Which pizza shop in Plum, PA has the best crust?
Crust preferences are personal, but Grand Slam Pizza and Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings get high marks for their signature crusts—crispy on the outside, perfectly chewy on the inside.
Is it possible to order pizza for large groups or parties in Plum, PA?
Yes, many places like Fox’s Pizza Den and Gateway Grill offer large pies and catering specials. Just call ahead to make arrangements, especially for bigger gatherings.