Plainville doesn’t just serve pizza—it serves personality by the slice. After munching my way around town, I learned that each spot offers its own twist on the classic pie, and the difference often comes down to a family recipe or a fleeting moment of genius behind the counter. Whether you crave a charred, chewy crust or the kind that folds without a fuss, you’ll find genuine flavor in every corner of this Connecticut town.
Hunting for the best pizza in Plainville becomes less of a chore and more of an adventure. I’ve watched locals passionately debate the best sauce, and once shared a booth with a driver who detoured twenty minutes just for his favorite slice. If you want to know where dough is kneaded with care, and toppings are more than just a topping, stick around. The search for Plainville’s top pizza starts here—one delicious stop at a time.
1. Sax Restaurant & Pizza
There’s something comforting about passing through the doors at Sax Restaurant & Pizza. Maybe it’s the hum of familiar conversation or the aroma of cheese melting into golden crust. I once stopped in on a rainy afternoon, and the staff’s warm greeting matched the heat from the ovens—a detail I haven’t forgotten.
Sax’s pizza dough hits a spot between chewy and crisp. Their plain cheese pizza lets the sauce shine, but I’m drawn to the sausage and peppers option. Each bite balances savory toppings with a sturdy, old-school base.
If you’re after something classic, go for their pepperoni pie. The slices are generous, with just the right pull of mozzarella. Whether you dine in or grab a box to go, Sax’s serves up reliable comfort in a town that knows its pizza.
2. Papa Pizza
At Papa Pizza, the scent of fresh dough hits you as soon as you walk in. I’ve watched the team stretch it by hand before layering on their zesty sauce—a process that sets the bar for freshness. When a craving hits late, their drive-thru window has saved my evening more than once.
What sets Papa Pizza apart is their commitment to crafting everything in-house, every day. The crust always has that soft, airy lift, and the veggies taste like they were chopped just moments earlier.
If you’re looking for a must-try, go for the veggie pizza or the classic margherita. Both showcase the bright tomato sauce and gooey cheese blend. The result? Slices that keep you reaching back for more, no matter what time you roll through.
3. First & Last Tavern
First & Last Tavern brings a slice of Old World tradition right to Cooke Street. On a sunny Saturday, I found a table outside and watched pies fly from the stone oven to expectant hands. The energy is as warm as the oven—friendly without being fussy.
What makes this spot sing is their authentic Italian approach. The dough is thin with just the right amount of char, and the toppings are thoughtfully selected. Even classic options here seem to carry a little extra care—from herbs to cheese.
If you want to taste what sets them apart, try their white clam pizza or the classic margherita. Both capture that coastal Italian spirit and showcase the delicate crunch and flavor that makes this tavern feel timeless.
4. Stavros Pizza and Restaurant
When I first stepped into Stavros Pizza and Restaurant, I was greeted by a lively blend of Greek and Italian aromas. The menu offers variety, but the focus is clear—their passion for pizza shines in every bite. Something about the sound of bubbling cheese from the oven feels instantly welcoming.
Stavros stands out with its creative blend of Greek and Italian influence. The crust is golden yet light, with a hint of olive oil that makes each slice distinct. It’s a spot where the old favorites get a fresh twist.
If you’re not sure what to order, go for the Greek-style pizza topped with feta and tomatoes. It’s bright, tangy, and decidedly memorable—a compelling reason to keep Stavros on your regular rotation.
5. Elvis Pizza
Elvis Pizza keeps things simple: good pies, friendly faces, and fast service. One late night, desperate for a quick bite, I found the kitchen still bustling and the pizzas flying out with ease. No frills, just honest-to-goodness flavor.
What sets Elvis apart is their classic approach—they don’t fuss with trendy toppings, instead perfecting the staples. The crust comes out light and crispy, never soggy, and you’ll notice a gentle tang in the sauce.
My go-to here is the classic cheese or pepperoni pizza. Both show off their signature balance and make for an easy favorite when you want comfort food done right. Simple, satisfying, and worth every bite.
6. Village Pizza Restaurant
Walking into Village Pizza Restaurant feels like coming home, even on your first visit. I once ducked in for a late lunch and found regulars chatting with staff, giving the place real neighborhood charm. It’s laid back and genuinely welcoming.
Village stands out for its generous portions and classic, hand-tossed crust. The pies are hearty, with plenty of sauce and cheese that stretches with every slice. You can taste the effort in each layer, right down to the seasoned tomato sauce.
If you’re in the mood for something substantial, the veggie supreme pizza is loaded with fresh toppings and never feels skimpy. If you lean classic, grab a plain cheese or pepper pizza—comfort you can count on, every single time.
7. West Main Pizza
+1 860-747-2724
West Main Pizza has all the makings of a neighborhood staple—steady service, relaxed atmosphere, and pies that always deliver. I stopped in once after a marathon morning, and the staff managed friendly conversation while keeping the pizza line moving fast.
Their crust is a highlight—thin and crisp, just sturdy enough to support generous toppings. The kitchen doesn’t skimp on cheese or sauce, and every bite feels balanced and satisfying.
If you’re scanning the menu, don’t miss the house special pizza. It’s loaded with fresh veggies and just the right amount of cheese. For a comforting classic, their plain cheese pie never disappoints—solid proof that West Main knows what pizza should taste like.
8. Husky Pizza
Husky Pizza brings college-town energy to downtown Plainville. I remember picking up a late-night order—piping hot, packed with toppings, and generous enough to share. The shop always seems busy, but the service is refreshingly quick.
What sets Husky apart is their bold flavors and impressive serving sizes. Their crust is a little thicker, sturdy enough to hold stacks of pepper, onion, or fresh tomato. A slice here is more of a meal than a snack.
If you want to try their best, go for the vegetable deluxe or the plain cheese pizza. Both show off Husky’s rich sauce and pillowy dough. Whether you’re feeding a crowd or flying solo, Husky’s has you covered for a hearty, memorable feast.
9. Roma Pizza
There’s a real sense of tradition at Roma Pizza. The first time I tried their pizza, the crust was still warm from the oven, with a light crunch that lingers in memory. It’s the kind of spot where you want to linger over your meal, letting the atmosphere soak in.
Roma stands out with its classic sauce and a crust that doesn’t try too hard yet gets everything right. The staff treats you like family—prompt, personable, and always willing to honor special requests.
Don’t miss the margherita pizza. Fresh tomato and basil bring out the best in their dough, making for a pie that proves simple is often superior. Roma is all about comfort, one perfect slice at a time.
10. PizzaPie
+1 860-747-0777
The menu at PizzaPie is refreshingly no-nonsense—pure pizza, no distractions. When I checked it out on a whim, the staff was quick, and my pie was hot and bubbling straight from the oven. It’s a spot for people who want their pizza experience all about the basics.
What makes PizzaPie stand out is their focus on freshness and straightforward flavors. Each pizza comes with the right ratio of sauce and cheese, creating a satisfying bite without the extras getting in the way.
If you’re after a true taste of their style, the plain cheese pizza says it all. Crisp crust, melty cheese, and a bright red sauce—PizzaPie nails the fundamentals, and that’s what keeps folks coming back.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Plainville, CT?
Sax Restaurant & Pizza, Papa Pizza, and First & Last Tavern top the list for locals seeking classic, satisfying pies.
Are there vegetarian pizza options in Plainville?
Yes, several spots like Husky Pizza and Village Pizza Restaurant offer vegetarian-friendly pies loaded with fresh veggies and classic cheeses.
Can I get gluten-free pizza in Plainville?
First & Last Tavern offers gluten-free options. It’s a good idea to call ahead to check availability at other locations.
Which pizza place offers the best takeout in Plainville?
Papa Pizza and West Main Pizza are go-tos for quick, reliable takeout—perfect for those busy nights or impromptu gatherings.
What style of pizza is most common in Plainville?
You’ll mostly find classic New England-style pizza—hand-tossed crust with a thin, crisp bite and generous cheese and sauce.