If you crave pizza in Pigeon Forge, you’re in for a good time. This city does not mess around when it comes to satisfying a pizza craving. Whether you want classic New York slices, a smoky wood-fired pie, or something with a regional twist, there’s a kitchen here tossing the dough just how you like it. The more I explored the pizza scene here, the more I realized every place brings a unique style to the table. One night, after a long day wandering the Parkway, I found myself debating if I had room left for another slice—turns out, I did. And it was worth every bite.
Finding the best pizza in Pigeon Forge takes more than luck; it means knowing which pizzerias are worth your time. This guide is your shortcut. Each spot on this list has earned its place with fresh ingredients, crave-worthy crusts, and flavors that stick with you long after the last slice. Hungry yet? Good. The best pizza in Pigeon Forge is waiting, and the crust is hot.
Where to find the best pizza in Pigeon Forge, TN
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Pigeon Forge, TN:
- J. Del’s Pizza
- Jersey Hustle
- Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Waldens Creek
- Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge
- Big Daddy’s Pizzeria
- Mellow Mushroom
- Pizza at The Cove
- Pizzario – The Brazilian Way
- Smoky Mountain Brewery & Restaurant
- Marco’s Pizza
1. J. Del’s Pizza
J. Del’s Pizza stands out as a cozy, family-run spot you can count on for authentic Italian flavors. On my last visit, I was struck by the aroma from their ovens—it’s the kind of scent that teases you from the parking lot. Each pizza here is made with all-natural ingredients, and you can taste the difference in every bite.
If you want a true Pigeon Forge experience, order a classic Margherita or their rich veggie pizza. Both options let the freshness shine, and the crust always comes out with a perfect, gentle crunch.
J. Del’s also caters to vegetarian and vegan eaters, which isn’t always easy to find in this town. Round out your pizza with their friendly late-night service, perfect for a tasty end to your day.
2. Jersey Hustle
Jersey Hustle feels just like a neighborhood pizzeria should: lively, unpretentious, and full of character. I remember stopping in for a quick lunch and ending up staying longer for the stories and the smell of sauce bubbling. This family-run spot knows how to deliver a New Jersey-style pie with real personality.
If you’re up for a classic, their thin-crust cheese pizza is a must. The crust has a crisp bite but never overpowers the toppings. The veggie deluxe is another strong bet, packed with fresh ingredients that highlight their commitment to quality.
Gluten-free and vegetarian options make this place stand out, especially if your group has varying tastes. It’s an easy pick for both late-night cravings and relaxed family meals.
3. Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Waldens Creek
Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Waldens Creek brings old-school pizza flair to a relaxed corner of Pigeon Forge. On my last visit, I was welcomed by the satisfying sound of dough tossing and friendly local chatter. This spot has a knack for crisp, flavorful crusts and toppings that don’t hold back on freshness.
Their signature cheese pizza is a strong choice if you want something classic. For something heartier, go for a veggie-loaded pie—their fresh toppings always hit the mark. If you’re feeling adventurous, their calzones are as good as their pizza, stuffed generously and baked golden.
They cover everyone’s taste with gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan options. It’s the kind of place where the whole table gets what they want without compromise.
4. Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge
Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge is where pizza meets creativity, both in flavor and atmosphere. The moment I walked in, the quirky décor gave me a hint that their menu would be far from basic—and it delivered. Their stone-baked pizzas are famous for a chewy, hand-tossed crust that keeps regulars coming back.
If you like something with personality, the Kosmic Karma—a pizza dressed up with feta, spinach, tomatoes, and pesto—shows off their knack for bold, fresh flavors. Their Mighty Meaty pizza is another favorite if you want something hearty and classic.
Vegans and gluten-free diners get real choices here, making it easy for everyone to dig in. Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge is all about good vibes and memorable slices.
5. Big Daddy’s Pizzeria
At Big Daddy’s Pizzeria, you’re greeted by the scent of fresh dough and wood smoke, a sign you’re in for something better than average. Every visit, I’m drawn in by the hearty atmosphere and the open kitchen where you can watch pies crafted by hand. Their pizzas go straight from a wood-fired oven to your table, with a crust that’s both chewy and crisp.
The Smoky Mountain Cheese pizza is a standout—simple, cheesy, and the perfect way to appreciate their quality dough and sauce. If you want more adventure, the Big Kahuna, loaded with vegetables, is always a good call.
Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options show their commitment to every guest. It’s hard to leave Big Daddy’s without already looking forward to your next visit.
6. Mellow Mushroom
Mellow Mushroom on Island Drive always feels like stepping into an art gallery where the smell of fresh pizza is part of the exhibit. What caught my attention first was the lively, colorful decor—it’s impossible not to relax and look forward to what’s next on the menu. This spot specializes in hand-tossed, stone-baked pizzas made with a spring water crust, giving each slice a distinct flavor and texture.
The House Special pizza, warm and loaded with a blend of veggies and cheeses, wins high marks for freshness. Looking for something lighter? Their Veg Out pizza shows off Mellow Mushroom’s flair for creative yet balanced toppings without being heavy.
Plenty of vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free choices make it easy for all to enjoy. Mellow Mushroom stands out with its dedication to both quality and a memorable dining experience.
7. Pizza at The Cove
Pizza at The Cove is a laid-back, locals-approved spot where I’ve found the pace to be as welcoming as the staff. It’s a place you come to unwind, grab a slice, and enjoy genuine hospitality. Their pizzas have a perfectly chewy crust and a simple, comforting flavor profile that always hits the mark.
If you want a real local favorite, try their perfectly balanced veggie pizza or a classic cheese. Each slice shows off their commitment to quality ingredients and careful baking.
Vegetarian options are thoughtfully included, making everyone feel at home. Whether you dine in or take out, Pizza at The Cove delivers satisfying pizza that feels made just for you.
8. Pizzario – The Brazilian Way
Pizzario – The Brazilian Way turns every pizza night into a lively, unforgettable event. Stepping in for the first time, I was welcomed by the vibrant energy and a Rodizio-style service—think an endless parade of fresh, creative pizzas at your table. Each sourdough pizza is crafted with care, using fresh, high-quality ingredients and a touch of Brazilian flair.
If you love sampling different flavors, this spot is for you. With more than 15 unique pizza varieties cycling through, you’ll find both classic and adventurous options. The cheese and veggie pizzas are favorites, perfect for those who want bold yet balanced tastes.
Vegan and vegetarian options are plentiful, so no one misses out. Pizzario stands out for both its fun atmosphere and its embrace of Brazil’s zest for good food.
9. Smoky Mountain Brewery & Restaurant
Smoky Mountain Brewery & Restaurant is a favorite for travelers who want lively energy with their pizza. Tucked into the Shops at Walden’s Landing, it’s hard to resist the buzz of conversation and the hum of live entertainment. On my last visit, I was drawn in by the inviting aroma of their pizzas fresh out of the oven. This spot is all about bold flavors, generous portions, and a warm, bustling vibe.
Their signature Brewmaster Pizza brings together fresh vegetables and a rustic, hand-tossed crust—perfect for sharing. For a classic choice, their Margherita pizza lets you savor the chew of quality dough and ripe tomatoes in every bite.
Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options are easy to find here. There’s something for every appetite, all served with a side of Smoky Mountain hospitality.
10. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza hits the spot when you need comforting, reliable pizza during your Pigeon Forge trip. I stopped in for a quick bite and was greeted by the friendly staff and the smell of just-baked crust. Their pies are hearty, topped with classic flavors, and served fast without sacrificing quality.
If you’re undecided, the Garden Pizza is a standout. It’s loaded with crisp veggies and a flavorful, golden crust. For something rich and satisfying, the White Cheezy pizza proves that simple ingredients, done right, make all the difference.
Vegetarian and vegan eaters will appreciate that their menu covers everyone. Marco’s is perfect for a casual meal or takeout that never disappoints.
More Things to Try in Pigeon Forge, TN
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizza place in Pigeon Forge, TN?
There’s no single winner, but local favorites include J. Del’s Pizza, Big Daddy’s Pizzeria, and Mellow Mushroom. Each offers unique styles and signature flavors.
Do any Pigeon Forge pizzerias offer gluten-free or vegan options?
Yes, many spots like Mellow Mushroom, Big Daddy’s Pizzeria, and Jersey Hustle offer gluten-free and vegan pizzas.
Are there any pizza restaurants in Pigeon Forge with delivery?
Absolutely. Chains such as Marco’s Pizza, Domino’s, and Papa John’s provide delivery, as do some local favorites. Look for “Delivery” when you call or visit their sites.
What’s unique about pizza in Pigeon Forge?
Pigeon Forge pizzerias deliver a mix of classic pies, creative specialties, and Southern hospitality. Many use wood-fired ovens or fresh, local ingredients for their distinct flavors.
Do restaurants in Pigeon Forge have options for large groups?
Most do. Several, like Smoky Mountain Brewery & Restaurant and Mellow Mushroom, have roomy dining areas and shareable menu options fit for families or groups.