Craving pizza in Pickerington, Ohio? It’s easy to see why. This town knows its way around a pie, whether you’re after classic comfort or a new spin on tradition. Having spent more than a few evenings in search of that perfectly baked crust and bubbling cheese, I can say Pickerington delivers more than just pizza—it delivers variety, local flair, and occasionally, an unexpected slice that lingers in your memory.
Picking the “best” pizza has sparked more debates among friends here than football or winter weather, and for good reason. Every spot from cozy, family-run taverns to national chains takes pride in their pie. If you’re hungry and picky (the best combo, honestly), this guide lines up the top places for pizza in Pickerington. Whether you’re plotting a late-night run or a laid-back dinner, you’ll find options that are miles ahead of average and full of flavor.
1. Pizza Cottage – Pickerington
Pizza Cottage – Pickerington immediately feels like a place where locals gather for good reason. The staff greets you with genuine smiles, and there’s a comforting buzz in the air, especially around dinnertime. My last visit started with a whiff of their signature sauce—rich, a little sweet, undeniably inviting.
The crust is perfectly crisp, hinting at tradition with every bite, while toppings remain fresh and generous. The deluxe pizza stands out with its loaded layers, but I always find myself coming back for their classic pepperoni. Both pies capture the balance between nostalgia and the sort of quality you only get when someone truly cares.
If you’re looking to explore, their specialty pizzas with fresh vegetables prove that Pizza Cottage caters to every appetite in Pickerington.
2. Jet’s Pizza
Jet’s Pizza brings something different to Pickerington—a style and flavor that makes people crave their signature square slices. You notice it immediately: crisp, golden edges and toppings loaded all the way to the corners. Sitting at Jet’s means the scent of baking cheese and buttery dough is never far away.
The Detroit-style deep dish is what draws most to Jet’s, and it’s easy to understand why after tasting the thick, airy crust. I once stopped in hoping for a quick lunch and ended up pondering their Jet 10, a pie that somehow fits a garden and a butcher shop onto a single slice—hearty, satisfying, never boring.
Go for the deep dish or the 8 Corner Pizza. Both reflect the bold, no-shortcuts approach that defines Jet’s in Pickerington.
3. MOD Pizza
MOD Pizza in Pickerington flips tradition by putting the power in your hands. On a recent visit, I watched families and friends turn pizza-building into a team sport. The MOD Squad keeps things friendly and fast, customizing every pie with that personal touch Pickerington seems to love.
The unlimited toppings rule is the real draw. There’s something satisfying about stacking on roasted veggies or finishing with a swirl of tangy barbecue sauce—no extra charge, no judgment. The thin, chewy crust balances every creation.
If you’re stuck choosing, try the Mad Dog for its classic, crowd-pleasing flavors, or build-your-own for a true MOD adventure. MOD Pizza nails the customizable, quick-service concept without sacrificing quality or creativity.
4. Cardo’s Pizza & Tavern
Cardo’s Pizza & Tavern is the local go-to for a mix of hearty eats and lively atmosphere. Evenings here feel less like dinner out and more like joining a community gathering—complete with big screens, an impressive tap list, and the largest patio in Pickerington. The hum of conversation and live music makes every bite more enjoyable.
The classic Cardo’s Deluxe is always in order: a pizza layered with fresh vegetables and generous cheese, the kind that stretches beautifully when you lift a slice. After a recent game night visit, it’s clear their pies hold up whether you’re there for sports, live tunes, or a family meal.
Patrons swear by the quality of the crust and the way every pizza packs flavor without going overboard—proof that Cardo’s has perfected its craft.
5. Donatos Pizza
+1 614-759-8000
Donatos Pizza brings a unique, unmistakable identity to Pickerington’s pizza landscape. The first time I tried their famous Edge to Edge® approach, I realized Donatos means business—no bare dough borders, just toppings from crust to crust. Every visit gets you that signature thin, crispy base that stays light even when topped to the max.
The pepperoni pizza here is a classic, but their veggie pie is loaded and never skimps on flavor. The attention to freshness is obvious in every slice, and each pizza feels carefully crafted, not just quickly made.
If you want a taste of Pickerington and Ohio pizza history, Donatos’ crisp crust and abundant toppings set a high bar for local flavor and consistency.
6. Pizzeria New York
Pizzeria New York has that unpretentious charm and big-city confidence you want from a neighborhood pizza joint. The aroma hits you first: a mix of bubbling cheese and a slightly smoky crust that promises authenticity. On a rainy evening, I found myself tucked into a booth, watching the staff work with the precise chaos that signals real pizza craft.
The New York-style cheese pizza is a must-try—chewy on the inside, crisp on the outside, with the kind of foldable slice that’s meant for grabbing on the go. For more variety, their veggie pie feels both hearty and fresh, packed with colorful toppings that don’t weigh the crust down.
This spot thrives on simplicity and quality, offering that East Coast experience without leaving Pickerington.
7. Romeo’s Pizza
Romeo’s Pizza makes its mark in Pickerington, thriving on bold flavors and a reputation for signature sweet tomato sauce. The first bite of their classic pizza is always a surprise if you’re used to more traditional sauces—it’s tangy, sweet, and balances the cheese and crust perfectly. That touch alone keeps locals and newcomers curious for more.
Their specialty pizzas are worth a try, with creative toppings and that same sweet sauce base. I sampled the Veggie Supreme and found every bite had a fresh, lively finish that sets Romeo’s apart.
If you’re seeking a twist on your usual slice or want to see what everyone’s buzzing about, Romeo’s is one of Pickerington’s most memorable pizza stops.
8. Grapevine Pizza
Grapevine Pizza is one of those classic neighborhood spots where regulars and first-timers feel at home. There’s a relaxed, no-fuss atmosphere that invites you to settle in—perfect for those evenings when all you want is good company and even better pizza. I’ve lingered over their pies with friends, noticing how the conversation is always interrupted by the sound of another slice being claimed.
Their traditional crust delivers a satisfying crunch while holding a mountain of toppings and golden cheese. The Supreme pizza stands out, loaded with fresh vegetables and generous cheese, each bite staying crisp and flavorful from edge to center.
If you value consistency and crave a classic local slice, Grapevine Pizza feels like a Pickerington staple you’ll return to time and time again.
9. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Pickerington is the go-to for quick, consistent pizza that hits the spot on a busy night. You know what you’re getting—every pie arrives piping hot, with the box’s aroma promising a classic Domino’s experience. More than once, I’ve relied on them for late-night cravings or big game nights, and they always deliver on time.
The Hand Tossed crust finds just the right middle ground between chewy and crisp. Try the Pacific Veggie if you want layers of flavor and a good dose of freshness without overdoing it. Their build-your-own option lets you craft a pizza to suit the whole group.
For comfort food with predictable results and zero hassle, Domino’s makes a dependable case in Pickerington’s pizza scene.
10. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in Pickerington brings a familiar sense of nostalgia. There’s something about sliding into a booth with friends and watching a cheese-laden pie arrive at the table, steam curling off every slice. I remember countless birthday parties and group dinners here, each one attached to the promise of hot, satisfying comfort food.
The Original Stuffed Crust® has a cult following for good reason—each bite delivers a gooey, cheesy finish that’s hard to forget. For a crowd-pleaser, you can’t go wrong with the Veggie Lover’s or classic Hand-Tossed. Every pizza captures that signature Pizza Hut blend of sauce and cheese, balanced and bold.
If you crave tried-and-true flavors, Pizza Hut’s steady presence in Pickerington always lives up to the memory.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Pickerington?
Local favorites include Pizza Cottage, Grapevine Pizza, Cardo’s Pizza & Tavern, and Jet’s Pizza. Each spot has its own style, making it easy to find a slice you’ll love.
Does Pickerington offer vegetarian or vegan pizza options?
Yes, many pizzerias like MOD Pizza, Pizza Cottage, and Donatos Pizza offer vegetarian pizzas and some have vegan-friendly crusts and toppings. Always check menus or ask staff for the latest options.
Are there gluten-free pizza options in Pickerington?
Absolutely. Restaurants like MOD Pizza and Donatos Pizza serve gluten-free crusts so you can enjoy pizza with fewer worries.
Which pizzerias deliver in Pickerington?
Most spots, including Domino’s Pizza, Pizza Hut, Romeo’s Pizza, and Donatos, offer delivery. Many also partner with popular delivery apps for convenience.
Where can I find late-night pizza in Pickerington?
Cardo’s Pizza & Tavern and national chains like Domino’s and Pizza Hut tend to stay open later. Always check current hours before heading out or ordering.