There is something quietly thrilling about searching for the best pizza in Phillipsburg, NJ. This town has developed a pizza scene full of passionate dough-slingers, each with their own approach to the crust, sauce, and that perfectly melted cheese. You’ll find a mix of old favorites tucked into corners, unassuming storefronts that locals swear by, and family recipes that somehow feel familiar yet completely new. Over many weekends (and after too many slices to count), I discovered not only the standout pies, but also the humble confidence behind every perfect slice.
If you’re tired of the same old chain pizza options and crave something more interesting, you’re in the right place. I’ve sampled everything from classic plain pies to creative white pizzas, always searching for that perfect balance you only get from a true neighborhood pizzeria. This guide covers the spots where every bite tells a story, where you notice the little details, from hand-tossed crusts to house-made sauces. If pizza holds a place of honor in your life, you’ll want to keep reading.
1. Nicolosi’s Pizza
Nicolosi’s Pizza has long been a favorite for locals needing comfort food that never disappoints. Tucked along Route 22, this spot draws you in with the aroma of fresh dough and bubbling cheese. It’s the kind of pizzeria where the regulars know each other’s names, and newcomers always feel welcome.
The crust is thin but sturdy, never floppy. Their plain pie is a lesson in balance: tangy sauce, golden cheese, and just enough crisp at the edge. I keep coming back for their vegetarian pizza loaded with fresh vegetables—each slice tastes bright and never soggy.
Delivery and takeout are quick and reliable, but letting a hot slice cool just enough to eat inside Nicolosi’s is an experience worth having. When in doubt, ask for their classic cheese pizza. It’s a Phillipsburg staple.
2. La Bella Via
Walking into La Bella Via, you notice right away that this is not your average pizza joint. The vibe feels stylish yet relaxed, perfect for lingering over conversation and a good meal. Vegan and vegetarian options make it easy to order with friends, no matter their tastes.
The pizza menu is both creative and classic. I still remember my first bite of their margherita pizza—light, aromatic basil, just-sweet-enough tomato sauce, and a crust that manages to be chewy and crisp all at once. They take pride in their ingredients, and it shows.
If you’re feeling adventurous, their veggie pizza with roasted red peppers and spinach is a must. For the full La Bella Via experience, dine-in and let the staff suggest a pie for you.
3. Frank’s Trattoria
Frank’s Trattoria, found in Pohatcong Shopping Center, takes its cues from classic Italian pizzerias. The atmosphere is easygoing, the kind of place where the server actually chats about which pie is going to be best that day. This spot stands out for pies that taste as good on a Tuesday lunch as on a Saturday night.
I often go for their classic veggie pizza. The crust is thin, golden, and made for folding, while the sauce carries just enough zing. Every slice has a reassuringly homemade feel—fresh, satisfying, never greasy.
If you can’t decide, the plain cheese is always reliable. Or, ask for a white pizza brushed with garlic oil and spinach, a local favorite for good reason.
4. Rocco’s Pizza
In Phillipsburg, Rocco’s Pizza is the kind of place people mention when talking about the “good stuff.” This family-run spot feels welcoming, always busy but never frantic. There’s a local pride in every slice they serve.
The menu covers old-school favorites, but it’s the pizza that keeps regulars loyal. The crust has that classic chewy bite—never doughy—with a thin layer of tangy sauce and cheese that melts into bubbly perfection. I always choose their veggie special for a fresh, colorful mix of toppings that never weighs down the pie.
Rocco’s is ideal for a casual lunch or an easy dinner with friends. Order a plain pizza or try their signature white pizza with spinach and mushrooms. Every bite seems to sum up what pizza should taste like.
5. Bella Mia Pizzeria
Bella Mia Pizzeria has the kind of menu that makes you want to try a little bit of everything. Their pizzas arrive fresh from the oven, with a golden crust and just the right blend of seasonings. The staff moves quickly, getting orders out hot whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout after a long day.
The plain pizza is a crowd-pleaser—unfussy and always spot on. I’ve often gone for their veggie pizza, which stands out for its mix of crisp bell peppers and earthy mushrooms. The balance of sauce and cheese means no soggy slices here.
This is an easy choice if you love a classic New Jersey-style pizza. Reliable, tasty, and fast—Bella Mia delivers on every promise.
6. Garas Pizza
Garas Pizza is tucked away on Strykers Road, but it’s far from a hidden gem among locals. The place is casual and unpretentious, perfect for a quick lunch or an easygoing dinner. The pies come out piping hot, and there’s a comforting scent of fresh-baked dough as soon as you walk in.
The menu keeps it simple and classic. I always gravitate toward their veggie pizza, topped with sweet peppers, onions, and a light blend of cheese. The crust is a notch above the usual—flavorful, sturdy, and never overdone.
If you’re not sure what to order, stick with their plain pie. It’s a great showcase for Garas’ house sauce and careful baking. It’s one of those places that makes you want another slice before you’ve even finished the first.
7. Cisneros Pizzeria
Cisneros Pizzeria surprises with its blend of Italian and Mexican influences, making each visit a little different from your average pizza night. The atmosphere is unfussy, but there’s a lot of care in every pie they bake. This is a spot where creativity meets tradition without overcomplicating things.
Their vegetable pizza stands out for bright, fresh toppings and a crust that holds its own, slice after slice. There’s a gentle kick in the sauce, enough to keep you curious about the next bite. I often recommend their plain cheese pizza as a simple test—it always delivers on flavor and texture.
If you like a twist, ask about seasonal specials. Cisneros Pizzeria isn’t afraid to add something new while keeping the classics solid.
8. Italy’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
Italy’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria feels like stepping into a local institution. The cozy dining room and inviting staff set the stage for a meal that’s equal parts comfort and tradition. It’s a spot where family gatherings seem to come naturally.
The pizza here leans toward a classic, New Jersey-style with thin, crisp crust and a sauce that has a hint of sweetness. I never skip their margherita or veggie pizza, both loaded with fresh, colorful toppings that taste like they were chopped that morning.
If you’re not sure what to get, try their plain cheese or white pizza with plenty of garlic and spinach. Italy’s takes simple ingredients and gives them the royal treatment.
9. Marianna’s Restaurant and Banquet Center
Marianna’s Restaurant and Banquet Center knows how to make every meal feel memorable, whether you’re stopping in for lunch or celebrating something special. The welcoming staff, warm lighting, and relaxed setting put you at ease right away. It’s the rare spot in Phillipsburg where you can enjoy both a casual slice and a full Italian dinner.
Their pizza showcases a thin, well-baked crust topped with bright, robust tomato sauce. Don’t miss their classic tomato pie; it’s a nod to tradition that still feels fresh. I’ve found the veggie pie loaded with roasted peppers and spinach is another standout option.
If you want a little nostalgia, ask for their plain pie and let the simple flavors speak for themselves. Marianna’s always feels like home, and the pizza matches that vibe.
10. Francesco’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
Francesco’s Pizzeria & Restaurant brings a taste of Southern Italy to Phillipsburg, grounding each meal in tradition while keeping flavors fresh. The space feels laid-back and cheerful, ideal for a family treat or a night out with friends.
The pizza here is a standout, with a crust that hits the sweet spot—crispy underneath but tender on top. I’m partial to their veggie pizza, where zucchini, peppers, and mushrooms stack up alongside bubbling cheese. Each bite shows off their attention to quality ingredients.
The plain cheese pizza is a reliable favorite if you’re new. Or ask for their margherita, which lets the sauce and house-made mozzarella shine. Francesco’s delivers consistently no matter what you order, always with a personal touch.
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in Phillipsburg, NJ?
Phillipsburg covers the classics: thin crust, Sicilian, white pizza, and specialty veggie pies. Most local spots focus on New Jersey-style thin crust, but you’ll also spot inventive toppings and old-school tomato pies.
Are there vegetarian and vegan pizza options?
Yes. Many pizzerias, including La Bella Via and Nicolosi’s, offer vegetarian and some vegan pizzas. Most staff are happy to suggest plant-based toppings or modify a pie to your preference.
Which pizza place is best for takeout or delivery?
For reliable delivery and takeout, Nicolosi’s Pizza, Bella Mia, and Garas Pizza regularly get high marks for prompt service and consistent quality.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Phillipsburg?
While not every pizzeria offers gluten-free options, you’ll find some, like La Bella Via, willing to accommodate requests. It’s best to call ahead to confirm availability.
What’s the must-try pizza topping combo locally?
Classic cheese pizza is always a hit, but veggie pies with peppers, onions, and spinach stand out. Many locals also swear by margherita or white pizzas for their simple, bold flavors.