Finding top-notch pizza in Penn Hills, PA is a mission I take as seriously as the perfect cheese pull. After a stretch of Friday nights dedicated to the science of trying different pies, I’ve discovered a community fiercely proud of its pizza—crispy crusts, bubbling mozzarella, and a mosaic of local favorites you can’t resist. Whether it was grabbing a late-night slice after a Penguins game or bringing home a box for a casual family dinner, each spot brought something different to the table.
If you’ve ever debated thin vs. thick crust or spent too long staring at a menu, you’re in the right place. This guide is built from both taste tests and real conversations with locals who know their way around a pizza. Get ready to meet the standouts, from old-school classics to modern takes—and a few surprises tucked away in Penn Hills’ neighborhoods.
1. Frankstown Wood-Fired Pizza
Frankstown Wood-Fired Pizza is the spot where classic pizza meets smoky, wood-fired character. Tucked on Frankstown Road, this place is beloved for its crisp, blistered crusts and a menu that caters to a range of tastes. My visit stood out for the aroma alone. The scent of baking dough pulls you in before you even open the door.
What sets it apart? They take care with ingredients. Each pie feels crafted, not rushed. The margherita is a reliable hit—simple, fresh, and packed with flavor. If you skip their veggie pizza, you’re missing out. Piled high with market vegetables, it tastes bright and satisfying.
Try the wood-fired margherita to appreciate their signature touch on a classic.
2. Pasqualino’s Pizza and Pasta
Pasqualino’s Pizza and Pasta feels like a slice of Italy right in Penn Hills. This local gem thrives on tradition with its classic red sauce and family-friendly buzz. I remember waiting for a piping hot pizza while basking in the aroma of garlic and melting cheese—that anticipation made the first bite even better.
What puts Pasqualino’s on the map is the balance of their crust: thin enough for a crisp bite, yet sturdy to hold generous toppings. They never skimp on quality. The veggie pizza is loaded with color and full of flavor, while the white pizza with fresh tomatoes and spinach is a must for anyone who likes a lighter pie.
Order their signature white pizza to see how fresh ingredients and real skill make all the difference.
3. Universal Pizza
Universal Pizza is the place I think of when I crave a big, no-nonsense slice. It’s a Main Street mainstay that sticks to what it does well: hearty pies and quick, friendly service. My last visit was a grab-and-go lunch, and the slice I snagged was just right—cheesy, classic, and satisfying with each bite.
There’s a certain straightforward charm here. Universal doesn’t complicate things, and that’s a good thing. The traditional cheese pizza is always a safe bet, but their veggie option stands out for how fresh everything tastes. No limp peppers or soggy mushrooms—just crisp, well-cooked toppings that hold up to the hungry crowd.
Don’t skip their traditional cheese pizza if you’re a fan of the classics done well.
4. Carol of Casey’s
Carol of Casey’s has that small-town pizzeria feeling that draws you in, even on a weekday evening. It’s tucked away yet always buzzing, and my last takeout order from here turned a regular night into something a bit more special. The crust came out golden, and the sauce tasted unmistakably homemade.
There’s no rush at Carol of Casey’s—they’re about careful preparation and generous portions. What stands out is their sauce: tangy, not too sweet, and just the right amount of spice. It sets the tone for every bite, especially when paired with a cheesy topping.
The cheese pizza is a staple, but if you want something bold, try a veggie-loaded pie to experience their fresh ingredients and signature flavor.
5. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Frankstown Road nails the art of reliable comfort food. Sometimes nothing beats knowing exactly what to expect when you place an order after a long day. I’ve lost count of the nights I turned to Domino’s for a quick, hot delivery that never misses the mark on consistency.
Domino’s stands out for its endless customization and speedy service. Crust options range from thin and crispy to a pillowy pan, and their robust menu gives you choices for every type of pizza fan. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic cheese pie or want to load up on vegetables, the decision is always in your court.
The Handmade Pan Pizza is a standout for its golden edges and soft center, while the classic veggie pizza offers lots of fresh, flavorful toppings and a satisfying crunch.
6. Fox’s Pizza Den
Fox’s Pizza Den is a classic choice for anyone craving pizza with a side of nostalgia. Its spot in the Penn Hills Municipal Shopping Center makes it convenient, and the vibe always feels welcoming. I think back to sharing a large Fox’s pizza with friends, each slice loaded and piping hot, making those get-togethers memorable.
The hallmark here is portion size. You’ll find generous cuts and thick, satisfying cheese pulls. The crust is just crispy enough to stand up to their hearty toppings, never soggy or bland. Fox’s builds every pie with consistency, so you know what you’re getting every single time.
The Veggie Pizza is a winner if you like a loaded, flavorful pie. For pure cheese lovers, their classic cheese pizza never disappoints.
7. Wing Street
(412) 795-7900Call
Wing Street might be better known for wings, but their pizza deserves just as much attention. I ended up here during a group dinner, half-expecting the pizza to play second fiddle. Instead, the crust was perfectly baked and the balance of sauce and cheese surprised me in the best way.
This spot stands out for those who want both classic and adventurous flavors. Their pizzas are built for sharing, with a soft, chewy base that holds up under plenty of toppings without falling apart. Plus, it’s a great stop when you can’t decide between pizza or something else—everyone leaves satisfied.
The cheese pizza makes a strong case for simple pleasures, and the veggie pizza gives you a colorful, flavorful kick.
8. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in Penn Hills brings a sense of familiarity you can count on, whether you’re stopping in for carryout or waiting for a delivery to land at your door. I’ve found this location particularly reliable—quick service, hot pizza, and that signature aroma that signals pure comfort food is on the way.
The “Hut” stands out for its thick, chewy crusts and over-the-top cheese factor. There’s something about a hot slice of their pan pizza that always brings me back. The Original Stuffed Crust® has been a personal staple on family pizza nights, with its extra layer of gooey cheese in every bite.
The veggie pizza shines with its generous topping spread, and the Original Stuffed Crust® is a guilty pleasure for anyone who loves cheese just as much as the pizza itself.
9. Pizza Marsala
Pizza Marsala brings old-school charm with every pie they pull from the oven. Every time I’ve picked up from their red and white counter, the aroma of fresh dough and herbs hints at something special inside. Here, the crusts come thin and just crispy enough, letting the toppings shine through.
What sets Marsala apart is their attention to detail. The thin crust has an artisan feel, and each pizza bursts with bold, balanced flavors. If you enjoy a lighter bite that skips the heaviness but keeps all the taste, this is your go-to.
The gourmet veggie pizza is a standout. Its fresh toppings are thoughtfully arranged and perfectly roasted, making each slice bright and satisfying.
10. Meglio’s Pizza
Meglio’s Pizza is the hidden gem I stumbled upon when craving a change from the usual. This mom-and-pop shop in Garden City Plaza delivers warm service and a menu full of local favorites. I remember being greeted like a regular on my very first visit—always a good sign in a pizza place.
What’s different here? Their dough is made fresh daily, giving their pizzas a chewy, flavorful base. The sauce is lively without overpowering, making every bite balanced. Meglio’s also prides itself on consistency; each pie tastes just as good as the last.
Go for the classic cheese or veggie pizza. Their light hand with cheese means you actually taste the fresh sauce and toppings, letting each ingredient stand out on its own.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places for pizza in Penn Hills, PA?
Local favorites include Frankstown Wood-Fired Pizza, Pasqualino’s Pizza and Pasta, Universal Pizza, and Carol of Casey’s. You’ll also find reliable options from chains like Pizza Hut and Domino’s.
Where can I find vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Penn Hills?
Frankstown Wood-Fired Pizza and Pasqualino’s Pizza and Pasta offer vegetarian-friendly pies. Many places will customize your pizza to suit plant-based diets too.
Who delivers pizza in Penn Hills?
Most pizzerias in the area, including Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Pizza Marsala, offer delivery. Local shops like Meglio’s Pizza and Universal Pizza provide delivery and takeout options as well.
Is thin crust or thick crust more popular in Penn Hills?
You’ll find both styles widely available. Wood-fired and artisan shops tend to specialize in thinner, crispier crusts, while chains offer thick, pan-style versions.
Are there pizza places open late in Penn Hills?
Many chain locations like Domino’s and Pizza Hut stay open late. Local pizzerias may have earlier closing hours, so check their websites or call ahead.