Searching for the best pizza in Peach Lake, NY can feel like hunting for buried treasure—except with fewer maps and much more cheese. If you’ve ever craved just the right crust or debated the art of sauce-to-topping ratio, you’re not alone; I can still remember weaving through Peach Lake’s winding roads, that first hint of garlic in the air telling my stomach it was in for something special. One wrong turn, and I ended up at a place full of laughter and the pleasant clatter of pizza peels, proving that sometimes the best finds are accidental.
This guide is built on curiosity, far too many taste tests, and genuine love for honest pizza. You deserve more than a plain list; you should know where to find stretchy mozzarella, crispy edges, and real-deal flavor—all without wasting a single bite or a dollar. Whether you’re after New York thin, pillowy Sicilian, or something piping hot from a wood oven, you’re about to discover a lineup with the proof in every perfect, savory slice.
Where to find the best pizza in Peach Lake, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Peach Lake, NY:
- Pizza Place & Trattoria II
- La Strada Pizza and Pasta
- Five Brothers Pizza & Pasta
- Domino’s Pizza
- Luigi’s Famiglia Cucina II
- Salem Pizza And Pasta
- Player’s Sports Bar & Restaurant
- Portofinos Pizza & Pasta
- Milano’s Pizzeria E Caffee’
- Bambinos Pizza
1. Pizza Place & Trattoria II
Pizza Place & Trattoria II at 35 Main St in Brewster is the kind of spot where pizza dreams stay simple and delicious. Slide inside and catch the hum of locals grabbing slices, proof that this place is always in steady demand.
The menu covers classics and creative spins, but the Margherita here set the standard for me—fresh basil, soft mozzarella, and a crust with just the right chew. If you like your pizza with a bit of personality, their signature Trattoria Special piles on vegetables and flavor without overpowering the dough.
Prices are refreshingly low for the quality you get. Whether you’re eating in or stopping by to grab a pie for Peach Lake picnics, you’ll leave with a new favorite.
2. La Strada Pizza and Pasta
(845) 279-1922Call
Nestled on North Brewster Road, La Strada Pizza and Pasta is the answer when comfort food calls. The place feels cozy yet alive, with staff who remember faces and seem to know just the right thing to recommend. My first encounter involved a chatty server and a generous slice of their Grandma pie—impossibly light crust, sweet tomato sauce, and a touch of fresh garlic.
La Strada’s thin, foldable New York-style pizza is another local legend, and if you like a classic vibe, the cheese or mushroom pies deliver every time. Slices arrive piping hot, and the balance of cheese to sauce never disappoints.
Prices sit comfortably in “treat yourself” territory without breaking the bank. Grab a seat for an unhurried meal or phone in a takeout order to enjoy by the lake.
3. Five Brothers Pizza & Pasta
(845) 278-4500Call
Five Brothers Pizza & Pasta sits tucked in Brewster Square, and the first bite tells you this is a family operation with old-school roots. On my visit, a buzz of regulars filled the space, trading stories over slices—always a good sign. What really struck me was the dedication to quality. The dough is made fresh daily, and you can taste it in every crunchy, airy bite.
Try their Sicilian slice if you want something hearty. It’s thick, golden, and comes draped in a tangy tomato sauce with just enough cheese. Their Classic Cheese Pizza also nails that simple, satisfying craving.
Expect generous portions. Whether you’re sharing a pie with friends or grabbing a quick lunch, Five Brothers brings the crowd-pleasing flavor that keeps locals coming back.
4. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Main Street may be a national chain, but it’s carved out a local following in Brewster with its quick service and reliably hot pies. On nights when your craving can’t wait and you want something familiar, this place steps up. I remember late study sessions fueled by Domino’s Handmade Pan Pizza—thick, golden, and loaded with sauce and cheese.
If you like experimenting, try their Brooklyn Style, which manages that classic fold without skimping on flavor. For a gooey twist, their Parmesan-Stuffed Crust is always a crowd-pleaser, offering something extra in each bite.
With tons of deals and fast delivery, Domino’s is my pick for those last-minute gatherings by the lake or a solo movie night at home.
5. Luigi’s Famiglia Cucina II
Luigi’s Famiglia Cucina II feels like a true slice of Italy tucked inside Danbury Square. The aroma when you walk in is straight from a family kitchen—layers of dough, roasted garlic, and slow-cooked tomato sauce. During my first visit, warm lighting and even warmer greetings made the meal feel like a special occasion.
Luigi’s stands out for its wood-fired pizzas, with a crust that balances crisp bite and airy softness. The Vegetarian Pizza bursts with garden-fresh toppings and tangy sauce, while their Margherita is elegantly simple and full of flavor.
This is my pick when I want pizza that feels both comforting and made with care. Delivery is fast, but it’s worth sitting in and savoring each slice straight from the oven.
6. Salem Pizza And Pasta
(914) 669-5815Call
Salem Pizza And Pasta on June Road is a low-key gem that nails comfort and quality in equal measure. The first time I stopped in, the friendly staff offered recommendations and handed over a slice that brought me right back to family Sunday dinners.
Their White Pizza deserves a mention, with creamy ricotta, spinach, and buttery mozzarella on a perfectly crisped base. For something more traditional, the Classic Margherita offers fresh basil and a sauce that tastes bright and homemade.
Salem keeps things simple: good ingredients, generous portions, and a menu that lets you linger a bit longer. Whether you grab a quick bite or relax with friends, it’s a spot where the atmosphere encourages you to return.
7. Player’s Sports Bar & Restaurant
(845) 278-7900Call
Player’s Sports Bar & Restaurant on Fields Lane blends the buzz of game night with satisfying, hearty pizza. The first time I walked in was on a rainy evening, and the energy was infectious—big screens, local fans, and the unmistakable aroma of pizza baking in the oven.
While it’s easy to get distracted by the action, the Buffalo Chicken Pizza cut through the noise for me. It’s spicy, cheesy, and always arrives piping hot. They also do a mean Supreme Pizza, loaded with fresh vegetables and a crust that can stand up to any crowd.
Whether you’re in for a quick bite during halftime or meeting friends after work, Player’s delivers crisp slices and a laid-back vibe every time.
8. Portofinos Pizza & Pasta
(845) 363-1024Call
Portofinos Pizza & Pasta sits right on Route 22 and is a staple for anyone craving Italian comfort with a local touch. My first slice here was a simple cheese pizza, but the depth of flavor made it memorable—savory sauce, gooey cheese, and a crust that begged for just one more bite.
The atmosphere is family-friendly and relaxed, making it easy to linger over a meal or grab something quick for a Peach Lake picnic. Don’t miss the Vegetarian Pizza; it’s loaded with crisp veggies and a robust, herbed sauce that’s anything but bland.
For those who like their pizza with a bit of sophistication but zero fuss, Portofinos manages to hit the spot again and again.
9. Milano’s Pizzeria E Caffee’
(203) 792-3989Call
Milano’s Pizzeria E Caffee’ on Mill Plain Road is a quiet retreat for pizza lovers who appreciate tradition. My first visit was met with warm, Italian hospitality and the unmistakable scent of dough baking fresh in the oven. There’s an attention to craft here that gives even a basic slice real character.
Their Neapolitan Pizza is outstanding—thin, chewy, and finished with a touch of char from the oven. For a bit more flair, the Vegetarian Pizza delivers on freshness and balance, letting every ingredient shine.
If you enjoy pizza that feels both classic and lovingly prepared, Milano’s is the sort of place where a single slice leads to another—and probably a good coffee, too.
10. Bambinos Pizza
Bambinos Pizza sits on Mill Plain Road and brings a welcoming, no-fuss vibe to Danbury’s pizza scene. I dropped in after a long afternoon and was met with quick service and the aroma of sauce simmering just behind the counter. What sets Bambinos apart is their knack for crisp, thin crusts and toppings that taste like they were prepped just for you.
The Bambinos Special Pizza is a highlight—overflowing with vegetables, tangy sauce, and a layer of cheese that browns just right at the edges. Their Margarita Pizza is also a safe bet, balancing tomato and cheese for that simple, classic flavor.
Perfect for a family dinner or casual takeaway, Bambinos proves you don’t need frills to deliver a memorable pizza experience near Peach Lake.
More Things to Try in Peach Lake, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places near Peach Lake, NY?
Several standout spots include Pizza Place & Trattoria II, La Strada Pizza and Pasta, Five Brothers Pizza & Pasta, Portofinos Pizza & Pasta, and Bambinos Pizza. Each offers its own style, from classic New York thin crust to Sicilian squares.
Do any local pizzerias offer delivery to Peach Lake?
Yes, many pizzerias around Peach Lake, including Domino’s and Luigi’s Famiglia Cucina II, provide delivery services so you can enjoy pizza at home or by the lake.
Are there vegetarian pizza options in Peach Lake, NY?
Absolutely. Most local spots have vegetarian pizzas on the menu, such as veggie-loaded pies and classic margheritas, making it easy to find a satisfying meat-free slice.
Which pizzerias near Peach Lake are good for families?
La Strada Pizza and Pasta, Portofinos, and Bambinos Pizza are all great choices for a family outing. They feature relaxed spaces, friendly service, and a range of pies that please all ages.
Can I find gluten-free pizza near Peach Lake?
Some pizzerias in the area offer gluten-free options. It’s a good idea to call ahead and ask about available crust choices to suit your dietary needs.
Where can I get a quick takeout pizza near Peach Lake?
Domino’s, Salem Pizza And Pasta, and Five Brothers Pizza & Pasta are popular for fast, reliable takeout. Just call ahead or order online for speedy service.