Finding the best pizza in Paducah, KY, is like going on a treasure hunt, where each slice reveals a new flavor and experience. This charming town, nestled in the heart of Kentucky, boasts a vibrant pizza scene that caters to every taste—whether you crave a classic pepperoni or something a bit more adventurous. As someone who has savored each pie firsthand, I can tell you that Paducah’s pizza spots aren’t just places to grab a bite; they are local legends, each with its own story to tell.
From cozy pizzerias with a family feel to trendy spots featuring craft beer pairings, the choices can be overwhelming. But fear not; I’ve sifted through the dough and sauce to bring you a curated selection of the top places to satisfy that pizza craving. So, if you’re ready to dive into the world of melted cheese and perfectly baked crust, stick around. You’ll discover hidden gems and beloved favorites that are sure to make your taste buds dance with delight.
Where to find the best pizza in Paducah, KY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Paducah, KY:
- Pizza By The Pound
- Pizza Inn
- Mellow Mushroom Paducah
- Paducah Beer Werks
- Pizza Warehouse
- Michaels New York Style Pizza
- Max’s Brick Oven
- Italian Village Pizza
- Rocket Fired Pizza
- Marco’s Pizza
1. Pizza By The Pound
Pizza By The Pound is a beloved family-owned gem nestled in Paducah. Since its launch in 1990, this spot has offered a delightful mix of traditional and specialty pizzas. With a full bar and spacious party room, it’s ideal for gatherings or a relaxed night out.
What sets it apart is the unwavering commitment to quality. Each pizza is crafted using high-quality ingredients, giving every bite a burst of flavor. During my last visit, I savored their House Special pizza, topped with fresh veggies and savory meats, perfectly balanced with a rich sauce.
For something unique, don’t miss the calzones—they’re loaded and baked to perfection, showcasing the restaurant’s dedication to deliciousness. Pizza By The Pound is a must-try for anyone seeking genuine pizza delight in Paducah.
2. Pizza Inn
Pizza Inn has carved out a cozy niche in Paducah, offering a welcoming atmosphere for pizza lovers. With a focus on quality ingredients, this pizzeria stands out for its delicious crusts and generous toppings. It’s the perfect spot for anything from a casual lunch to a family dinner.
During my last visit, the aroma of fresh pizza drew me in. I decided to try their Buffalo Chicken Pizza, and it did not disappoint. The spicy chicken paired with creamy ranch dressing created a flavor explosion that left me wanting more.
For those who enjoy a mix of flavors, the dessert pizzas are a must-try. Whether you go for the classic cinnamon or the rich chocolate version, they perfectly cap off a satisfying meal at Pizza Inn.
3. Mellow Mushroom Paducah
Mellow Mushroom Paducah is a haven for pizza lovers, renowned for its stone-baked, hand-tossed pies. The vibrant, art-filled atmosphere makes dining here a unique experience. Combining creative decor with excellent customer service, Mellow Mushroom truly embodies its motto of being a culture and a state of mind.
On my visit, I opted for the Mellowteranian Pizza, featuring fresh veggies and flavorful feta, all atop their signature spring water crust. The balance of flavors was remarkable, showcasing their commitment to high-quality ingredients.
For a deliciously different experience, don’t miss the bruschetta as an appetizer; the fresh ingredients beautifully complement the pizzas. Mellow Mushroom Paducah elevates the pizza experience beyond the ordinary—perfect for anyone seeking a fun dining adventure.
4. Paducah Beer Werks
Paducah Beer Werks is a unique destination that pairs craft beer with an inviting yet lively atmosphere. Housed in the historic Greyhound Bus Station, this local brewery not only serves award-winning beers but also offers a menu that captures the essence of casual dining.
During my visit, I enjoyed their Peach Wheat Ale while nibbling on their delicious BBQ Chicken Pizza. The combination of their freshly brewed beer and flavorful pizza created a perfect balance, showcasing their dedication to quality ingredients.
With rotating guest taps featuring other Kentucky breweries, it’s an experience that keeps evolving. Paducah Beer Werks stands out as a go-to spot for a relaxed night of great food and local entertainment—a true taste of what Paducah has to offer.
5. Pizza Warehouse
Pizza Warehouse is an inviting spot that combines hearty pizza with a casual dining experience. Located on Jordan Drive, it’s a go-to place for residents craving delicious, no-fuss meals. The relaxed atmosphere and friendly staff make it feel like a home away from home.
During my last visit, I decided to try the Meat Lover’s pizza, and it was a satisfying choice. Each slice was generously topped with various meats cooked to perfection, creating a flavor-packed delight.
What really sets Pizza Warehouse apart is their commitment to keeping things simple yet delicious. Whether you’re stopping in for lunch or dinner, their menu ensures there’s something for everyone. Don’t miss out on their cheesy breadsticks as a perfect accompaniment.
6. Michaels New York Style Pizza
Michaels New York Style Pizza transports you straight to the streets of New York with its authentic pies and casual charm. Tucked on Kentucky Avenue, this spot is perfect for those seeking big, foldable slices reminiscent of classic New York pizza.
On my recent visit, I tried the Margherita pizza, and it exceeded expectations. The fresh basil and quality mozzarella made each bite a celebration of flavor, while the perfectly crisp crust held it all together.
What makes Michaels stand out is the commitment to traditional methods combined with a warm neighborhood vibe. If you’re in the mood for something hearty, the pepperoni slice is a crowd-pleaser that never disappoints, reflecting their dedication to quality in every bite.
7. Max’s Brick Oven
Max’s Brick Oven is a culinary delight located in the heart of Paducah, known for its cozy atmosphere and delicious, wood-fired pizzas. The inviting space makes it a perfect spot for a casual dinner or a late-night bite with friends.
When I visited, I couldn’t resist the BBQ Chicken pizza, which was an absolute standout. The smoky BBQ sauce paired perfectly with tender chicken and fresh vegetables, all nestled on a beautifully charred crust.
Max’s commitment to quality shines through in every dish. For a hearty addition, consider their stuffed breadsticks as a delicious appetizer. With options for both vegetarian and gluten-free guests, Max’s is a welcoming place for anyone craving a slice of exceptional pizza.
8. Italian Village Pizza
Italian Village Pizza is a charming eatery that brings a taste of Italy right to downtown Paducah. Known for its welcoming atmosphere, it’s a fantastic spot for both lunch and dinner, whether you’re dining in or taking out.
On my last visit, I ordered the Garlic Chicken pizza, and it was a delightful surprise. The roasted garlic paired beautifully with tender chicken and a medley of fresh vegetables, all on a crispy crust that made each bite memorable.
What makes Italian Village stand out is its commitment to traditional flavors and friendly service. Don’t skip the meatball sub if you’re feeling adventurous; it’s another tasty option that showcases their dedication to hearty, satisfying meals.
9. Rocket Fired Pizza
Rocket Fired Pizza is a unique culinary experience in Paducah that expertly combines speed with quality. Located on Kentucky Avenue, this spot is perfect for those looking to enjoy delicious pizza throughout the day, with options for breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
During my visit, I opted for the Buffalo Chicken pizza, which came out perfectly crispy and packed with flavor. The tangy sauce combined with the chicken and fresh toppings created an irresistible combination.
What sets Rocket Fired apart is their fast-casual vibe that doesn’t compromise on quality. If you want a slice of something different, the Veggie Delight is a fantastic choice, showcasing their commitment to fresh ingredients and vibrant flavors. It’s a fun place to gather and indulge in quality pizza anytime.
10. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza on Lone Oak Road is a neighborhood staple that delivers consistent, quality pizza every time. Known for its fresh ingredients and friendly service, Marco’s creates a welcoming atmosphere for both dining in and takeout.
During my last meal there, I tried the delicious All Meat pizza, topped generously with pepperoni, sausage, and ham. Each bite was hearty and flavorful, showcasing their commitment to high-quality toppings.
What makes Marco’s stand out is their focus on flavor and craftsmanship. Don’t miss the Cheesy Breadsticks as an appetizer; they’re a perfect complement to any pizza and a fan favorite. Marco’s Pizza is an excellent choice for anyone craving a comforting slice in Paducah.
More Things to Try in Paducah, KY
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best pizza places in Paducah, KY?
Some top choices include Pizza By The Pound, Mellow Mushroom, and Marco’s Pizza. Each offers a unique style and menu that locals love.
2. Do any pizza places in Paducah offer gluten-free options?
Yes, many pizzerias like Mellow Mushroom and Max’s Brick Oven provide gluten-free crusts, ensuring everyone can enjoy a slice.
3. What is the most popular pizza topping in Paducah?
While preferences can vary, pepperoni is a classic favorite across most pizzerias in Paducah. It’s consistently popular among locals.
4. Are there vegetarian pizza options available in Paducah?
Absolutely. Many pizza places, including Pizza Inn and Italian Village, offer a range of delicious vegetarian toppings and specialty pizzas.
5. Can I order pizza for delivery in Paducah?
Yes, many pizza spots in Paducah, such as Domino’s and Marco’s, offer delivery services, making it easy to enjoy pizza at home.