When it comes to finding the best pizza in Outer Banks, NC, the search can feel as tricky as navigating the winding coastal roads. Having visited the area multiple times, I’ve sampled countless slices—each offering a unique flavor profile influenced by fresh local ingredients and distinct culinary styles. From thin, crisp crusts to hearty, cheese-laden pies, the Outer Banks pizza scene combines classic charm with inventive twists, making it a rewarding journey for any pizza lover.
In this guide, I’ve carefully selected ten standout pizzerias that uphold quality, flavor, and halal-friendly options to ensure everyone can indulge without compromise. Whether you’re craving a traditional margherita or a creatively topped specialty, this list blends local favorites with hidden gems. Let’s dive into the best places where a perfect slice awaits you on the Outer Banks shorelines.
1. Slice Pizzeria
Slice Pizzeria, nestled in Kill Devil Hills, offers a straightforward yet memorable pizza experience. On my visit, the first bite revealed a perfect balance of a chewy, hand-tossed crust with fresh, vibrant toppings—a true reflection of their commitment to high-quality ingredients.
This take-out and delivery spot stands out by focusing solely on the essentials, making every pizza crafted with care and community in mind. Their menu features vegetarian and vegan options, catering well to diverse tastes without sacrificing flavor.
If you try one pie here, the classic margherita is a must. The simplicity highlights the freshness of their ingredients and the skill in their dough preparation, echoing the coastal region’s laid-back yet flavorful style. Slice Pizzeria is where authenticity meets convenience on the Outer Banks.
2. American Pie Pizza & Homemade Ice Cream
American Pie Pizza & Homemade Ice Cream is a beloved spot in Kill Devil Hills, offering more than just pizza—it’s a full beachside experience. On a recent visit, I appreciated the lively atmosphere coupled with the enticing aroma of freshly baked pizzas and homemade ice cream, a perfect match for a casual Outer Banks outing.
This place shines with its hand-tossed pizzas that promise a crispy crust and balanced toppings, crafted with care for both locals and visitors. Its family-friendly vibe and convenient location on Beach Road make it a top choice for lunch or dinner.
The standout here is the combination of a classic pepperoni pizza paired with their signature homemade ice cream for dessert. This duo captures the warm, welcoming spirit of the Outer Banks while showcasing quality and variety that keeps people coming back.
3. Angelo’s Pizza
Angelo’s Pizza in Buxton on Hatteras Island delivers a comforting, no-frills take on pizza that feels like a warm neighborhood secret. During my visit, the cozy atmosphere and friendly service instantly made me feel at home, setting the stage for a satisfying meal.
What sets Angelo’s apart is its dedication to simplicity and flavor, with a menu that caters well to vegetarians and those seeking a reliable pizza fix. Each pie is baked with care, boasting a golden crust and well-seasoned toppings that resonate with the local palate.
Their classic cheese pizza is a highlight, showcasing quality ingredients and a clean, balanced taste. Angelo’s Pizza captures the laid-back charm of Hatteras Island while ensuring every slice meets the expectations for halal-friendly choices and authentic Outer Banks flavor.
4. Gidget’s Pizza & Pasta
Gidget’s Pizza & Pasta in Avon celebrates nearly three decades of serving fresh, flavorful dishes that draw locals and visitors alike. On my visit, the warm ambiance and attentive table service enhanced the experience, making it more than just a meal—more like a cherished tradition.
What makes Gidget’s stand out is its commitment to using fresh ingredients and offering a diverse menu that extends beyond pizza to include pasta, salads, and subs—all crafted with care.
Their classic pepperoni pizza is a standout, combining a thin crust with high-quality toppings that reflect the easygoing yet refined Outer Banks style. For those seeking a relaxed dinner with genuine taste, Gidget’s provides an excellent option with halal-conscious care and exceptional quality.
5. Jason’s Restaurant
Jason’s Restaurant in Ocracoke offers a welcoming atmosphere that feels like a home away from home. During my visit, the variety on the menu instantly impressed me, ranging from fresh seafood to hearty American classics, all served with attentive customer care.
This spot stands out for its wide-ranging options and ability to cater to various dietary needs, including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free choices. Its pizza offerings pair perfectly with the relaxed coastal vibe of the Outer Banks.
Their veggie pizza is a highlight, loaded with fresh, colorful vegetables on a thin crust that complements their versatile menu. Jason’s skillfully balances quality and comfort, making it a great choice for those seeking halal-friendly options with authentic Outer Banks flavors.
6. Southern Shores Pizza
Southern Shores Pizza offers a memorable dining experience right in the heart of Southern Shores. When I stopped by, the inviting aroma and friendly staff immediately set the tone for a satisfying meal. The focus on fresh ingredients and careful preparation was evident in every bite.
This pizzeria stands out for its dedication to quality and a vegetarian-friendly menu, making it accessible to a broad range of tastes. Their use of digital payments adds a modern convenience without sacrificing the warmth of the local experience.
Their signature veggie pizza, loaded with garden-fresh toppings on a perfectly crisp crust, captures the coastal spirit of the Outer Banks. Southern Shores Pizza combines comfort with quality, delivering a halal-friendly dining option that reflects the laid-back charm and flavors of the region.
7. Dare Devil’s Pizzeria
Dare Devil’s Pizzeria in Kill Devil Hills has been a local favorite since 1987, blending tradition with a lively dining atmosphere. During my visit, the warm service and vibrant setting with a big-screen TV created a welcoming place to enjoy pizza with friends or family.
This pizzeria stands out with its diverse menu offering vegetarian and vegan options, alongside classics like stromboli and subs. Their careful attention to ingredient quality ensures each dish delivers authentic Outer Banks flavor.
I recommend the margherita pizza, where fresh basil and mozzarella highlight their commitment to simple, flavorful combinations. Dare Devil’s offers a satisfying, halal-friendly dining experience that honors both taste and tradition on the Outer Banks.
8. Gingerbread House Bakery & Pizza
Gingerbread House Bakery & Pizza in Frisco offers a unique blend of fresh bakery delights and savory pizzas that embody the charm of Hatteras Island. On my visit, the cozy setting and inviting aroma of baked goods made the experience feel both comforting and special.
This spot shines through its dedication to quality ingredients and flavorful pizzas, with a menu that thoughtfully includes vegetarian-friendly options. The bakery’s expertise in dough creates a crust that is both tender and perfectly crisp.
Their signature pizza, topped with fresh vegetables and herbs, captures the essence of Outer Banks simplicity and taste. Gingerbread House Bakery & Pizza provides a halal-conscious choice that balances artisanal skill with homey satisfaction.
9. Village Pizza of Nags Head
Village Pizza of Nags Head is a welcoming, family-owned gem that brings fresh, handcrafted flavors to the Outer Banks. When I stopped in, the friendly atmosphere and inviting menu made it clear this spot takes pride in every dish they serve.
Known for their house-made, hand-tossed pizza, Village Pizza also offers standout starters like their world-famous garlic knots—perfect for sharing. Their commitment to freshness shines through in every bite, with vegetarian and vegan options available.
Their veggie pizza is a must-try, with vibrant toppings and a perfect crust that reflects both quality and care. Village Pizza of Nags Head offers a halal-friendly dining experience that warmly welcomes both locals and visitors alike.
10. Nags Head Pizza Company
Nags Head Pizza Company offers a unique waterfront dining experience that perfectly complements its exceptional pizza menu. I enjoyed sitting on their deck, taking in the coastal views while savoring a slice that was fresh, flavorful, and crafted with care.
This restaurant stands out with its variety, offering everything from classic cheese and pepperoni to gourmet options like barbecue chicken and Mediterranean pies. They also provide gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan options, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
The Mediterranean pizza is a personal favorite, showcasing fresh ingredients and bold flavors representative of the Outer Banks’ culinary creativity. Nags Head Pizza Company blends quality and atmosphere seamlessly, making it a halal-friendly choice for visitors seeking both taste and scenery.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: What are the best places to find halal-friendly pizza in Outer Banks, NC?
A1: Several pizzerias in Outer Banks offer halal-friendly options, including Slice Pizzeria, Jason’s Restaurant, and Dare Devil’s Pizzeria. These spots use fresh ingredients and often provide vegetarian or vegan choices that align with halal dietary preferences.
Q2: Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Outer Banks?
A2: Yes, many Outer Banks pizzerias such as Southern Shores Pizza, American Pie Pizza & Homemade Ice Cream, and Village Pizza of Nags Head offer vegetarian and vegan pizzas that use plant-based toppings and cheese alternatives.
Q3: Can I order pizza for delivery or takeout in Outer Banks?
A3: Absolutely. Most pizzerias like Slice Pizzeria, Dare Devil’s Pizzeria, and Gingerbread House Bakery & Pizza provide takeout and delivery services, making it easy to enjoy quality pizza wherever you are in the Outer Banks.
Q4: What pizza styles are popular in Outer Banks, NC?
A4: Outer Banks features a variety of pizza styles, from classic hand-tossed and thin crust to more gourmet pies with toppings like pesto, Mediterranean vegetables, or barbecue chicken. The focus is on fresh, locally inspired ingredients.
Q5: Are there gluten-free pizza options available?
A5: Yes, places like Nags Head Pizza Company offer gluten-free crust options, ensuring that guests with gluten sensitivities or preferences can still enjoy delicious pizza on the Outer Banks.
Q6: What are some must-try pizzas unique to the Outer Banks?
A6: The Mediterranean and barbecue chicken pizzas are popular unique choices, reflecting the coastal region’s love for bold, fresh flavors combined with traditional recipes in spots like Nags Head Pizza Company and Dare Devil’s Pizzeria.