Pizza in Ouray, Colorado, is an experience that has quietly built a loyal following. The crispy crust, bubbling cheese, and savory aromas are more than just food—they’re comfort after a mountain hike or a reward at the end of a snowy day. Finding the best slice amid the breathtaking San Juan scenery isn’t just about taste; it’s about discovering where local stories and flavors meet.
I still remember ducking into a busy spot downtown after a long afternoon exploring Box Canyon. The laughter at nearby tables, flour-dusted hands working the oven, and that first warm bite convinced me that Ouray takes its pizza seriously. If you’re searching for the top picks—whether locals’ favorites or hidden gems—a few stand out. Stay with me to map out a route to the most delicious pizza Ouray (and its neighbors) have to offer.
1. Colorado Boy Southwest Pub
Colorado Boy Southwest Pub feels like the beating heart of Ouray’s downtown. The blend of lively locals, the aroma of baking dough, and the hum of conversation make this spot hard to miss. Stepping inside, I was struck by the mix of Southwestern flair and classic pizzeria comfort.
What sets Colorado Boy apart is their devotion to artisan pizza paired with their house-brewed beer. The crust arrives perfectly blistered from their stone oven, ready for a generous layering of bold toppings. Their green chile pizza, a local favorite, confidently brings the Southwest to your plate in every bite.
If you’re unsure what to try, start with a custom pie or the “Southwest” specialty. The fresh ingredients and balance of spice show the kitchen’s respect for both tradition and flavor. Add a pint of their own brew, and you’ll see why this place is a cornerstone for pizza lovers in Ouray.
2. Goldbelt Bar & Grill
Goldbelt Bar & Grill brings a laid-back energy to Main Street. The friendly buzz draws families, hikers, and locals alike. On my last visit, I grabbed a sidewalk table and watched the light shift over the mountains while pizza sizzled in the kitchen.
The Goldbelt stands out for its inclusive menu, offering both traditional and gluten-free pizza options. Crusts here come lightly crisped and ready for a creative mix of fresh toppings. Their “Ouray Special” pizza, loaded with vegetables and gooey cheese, showcases the kitchen’s approach—generous, colorful, and consistently well-made.
If you like sharing, order a large pie for the table. The active, friendly staff and mountain-town vibe make every meal feel easy. It’s the kind of spot where you end up staying for one more slice.
3. Brown Dog Pizza
Brown Dog Pizza may be tucked away in Telluride, but its reputation echoes across the region. I stopped in after a snowy drive and was greeted by the warm, bustling atmosphere. From first glance, this isn’t your standard pizza joint. The trophies on display hint at their national pizza-making accolades.
What really sets Brown Dog apart is their Detroit-style pizza, an airy, thick-crust marvel with caramelized edges. Every bite balances crunch and pillowy softness. Their “3-1-3” pie, named after Detroit’s area code, is a standout, with sauce draped over layers of cheese and toppings in perfect, square slices.
If you want a taste of something different, their Sicilian and American classics shine. The focus on quality dough and original combinations rewards adventurous eaters. Every visit offers something memorable on a slice.
4. Baked in Telluride
Baked in Telluride, or BIT as it’s locally known, feels like a welcoming anchor just off Telluride’s main drag. My first visit was on a festival weekend; the lines moved quickly and the atmosphere buzzed with energy. The aroma drifting from their ovens draws anyone in need of a pick-me-up.
Baked in Telluride is famous for its blend of bakery classics and no-fuss pizza. Slices are wide, crusts have just the right chew, and toppings taste fresh from the market. Their veggie pizza stands out—loaded with colorful produce and melty cheese, it’s hearty, fast, and always satisfying.
If you want something reliable and unfussy, order a slice and take it on a stroll. BIT’s strength is consistency and honest, well-made food, perfect for a quick bite before another adventure.
5. Crazy Elk
Crazy Elk sits at the heart of Mountain Village, giving off serious classic pizzeria vibes. On my last visit, skiers in boots and kids in snow jackets crowded the entry, everyone eager for a hot meal. The place hums with laughter and spills over with a warm, easy spirit.
What makes Crazy Elk memorable is its fearless embrace of classic, crowd-pleasing pizza. Crusts arrive thin and golden, ready to fold in half New York–style. Their “Mountain Pie” is a favorite—a savory mix of peppers, olives, mushrooms, and plenty of cheese in every bite.
For those with hearty appetites, the generous pies easily satisfy. Crazy Elk’s pizzas are thoughtfully crafted, using quality ingredients and a keen sense for what comfort food should be. It’s a reliable spot for post-ski relaxation or a simple family dinner.
6. Papa John’s Pizza
Papa John’s Pizza in Ridgway is known for delivering a familiar and reliable slice just a short drive from Ouray. When I needed a dependable option late at night, their online ordering saved the day. The team manages to keep the process simple—always hot, always ready.
What distinguishes Papa John’s is its signature crust and well-known approach to classic pizza. Each pie comes with that soft dough, tangy sauce, and all the comfort of something you’ve enjoyed before. Their vegetarian or classic cheese pizzas offer consistency and quality for families and groups alike.
If you want to stick with something tried-and-true, go for the “Garden Fresh” pizza. It delivers on flavor, with crisp vegetables and that signature finish that makes Papa John’s so familiar.
7. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Hunt Brothers Pizza in Ridgway is a no-nonsense stop for a quick and satisfying pizza fix. My last experience was during a road trip, where a hot Hunt Brothers pie fit perfectly into an afternoon break. It’s the spot you turn to when you want convenience without fuss.
Hunt Brothers stands out for its build-your-own approach and quick turnaround. Pies come out fresh, with all the customizable toppings you might want, making it easy to please everyone in your group. The crust manages to be both soft and sturdy, a reliable base for any combination.
Try their “Loaded Pizza”—it comes piled with a mix of veggies and cheese, each bite hearty and flavorful. Hunt Brothers makes casual, accessible pizza an easy choice after a long day on the road or trails.
8. Colorado Boy Brewing Co
(970) 626-5333Call
Colorado Boy Brewing Co in Ridgway brings together small-town hospitality and serious pizza credentials. On a recent evening, the inviting glow from inside hinted at a crowd unwinding over fresh pies and local brews. There’s an energy here—part communal gathering, part rustic pizzeria.
Their pizza menu is concise, focused on hand-tossed dough and robust flavors. Each pie features a crisp crust and punchy sauce, blended with a thoughtful selection of cheeses and toppings. The margherita pizza here stands out for its fresh basil and balanced simplicity, while specialty pies get creative without losing their roots.
Pair your pizza with a pint of their in-house beer. Colorado Boy Brewing Co manages to make each meal feel like a celebration of craft—simple, bold, and satisfying.
9. High Pie Pizzeria & Taproom
High Pie Pizzeria & Taproom is a lively spot right on Telluride’s main avenue. It’s where you’ll find sports on TV, laughter at every table, and the aroma of pizza wafting through the air. My first visit included a spirited discussion with locals about which pie reigns supreme—nobody could agree, which says a lot about the menu’s appeal.
This pizzeria impresses with a vast selection of creative pizzas and the largest tap beer list in town. From classic cheese to pies topped with garden-fresh veggies, there’s something for every craving. Their “Avalanche” pizza is a local favorite, loaded with crisp vegetables and finished with a bold, savory sauce.
If you’re with a group, order a few different pies and sample around. High Pie balances creativity with dependable quality, making it a staple for both regulars and newcomers.
10. Bagels N Stuff Inc
Bagels N Stuff Inc might sound like it’s all about breakfast, but their pizza deserves just as much attention. I stumbled in one afternoon craving something savory and left with a fresh, satisfying slice that kept me thinking about it long after. This spot has the welcoming feel of an old-school deli mixed with a mountain-town bakery.
Their pizza stands out for its honest, homemade quality and golden, chewy crust. Each slice tastes like it was made with care, not just tossed together. The veggie pizza, built on vibrant produce and gooey cheese, is a highlight for anyone craving something wholesome and filling.
If you’re after comfort and simplicity, grab a slice and settle in. Bagels N Stuff Inc shows that sometimes the best pizza is found where you least expect it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where can I find the best pizza in Ouray, CO?
You’ll find top options like Colorado Boy Southwest Pub and Goldbelt Bar & Grill right in town. Each has its own approach—one is known for artisan pies and the other for creative toppings.
Q: Are there any vegetarian pizza options in Ouray?
Yes, most pizzerias in and around Ouray offer vegetarian choices. Standouts include the veggie pies at both Baked in Telluride and Goldbelt Bar & Grill.
Q: Do any pizza places near Ouray offer gluten-free crusts?
Goldbelt Bar & Grill is known for its gluten-free pizza crust option. It’s a reliable choice for those with special dietary needs.
Q: Are there family-friendly pizza restaurants in Ouray?
Most pizza spots in Ouray welcome families. Crazy Elk and Goldbelt Bar & Grill both have relaxed, lively atmospheres perfect for groups with kids.
Q: Can I get pizza delivery in Ouray?
Delivery is limited in Ouray itself, but Papa John’s in nearby Ridgway offers takeout and may deliver depending on your location.
Q: Which place is best if I want pizza and craft beer?
Colorado Boy Southwest Pub and Colorado Boy Brewing Co both serve fresh pizza with a lineup of local beers, making either spot a great pick for pizza and a pint.