Pizza in Orlando has an attitude all its own. Walk through any Orlando neighborhood, and you’re bound to stumble across pies that could spark a heated debate—crisp Neapolitan wheels, oozy Chicago deep-dish, foldable New York slices, and local favorites with a twist. Having spent more lunches than I care to admit testing cheese pulls and critiquing charred crusts, I can confirm that Orlando’s pizza scene is anything but ordinary.
If you find yourself craving the perfect slice, you’re in the right place. Each pizzeria on this list has been sampled, savored, and scrutinized for what it does best. From family-run gems to big-name classics, this guide will lead you to the pies that locals line up for and visitors wish they could take home. Get ready—your next favorite pizza joint is probably on this list.
Where to find the best pizza in Orlando, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Orlando, FL:
- Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza – Dr. Phillips
- Solorzano’s Pizzeria & Poolside Bistro
- NYPD Pizza
- NYPD Pizza Lake Cay
- Blaze Pizza
- Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings
- Sal’s Market Deli
- Red Oven Pizza Bakery
- Flippers Pizzeria O-Town West
- UNO Pizzeria & Grill
1. Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza – Dr. Phillips
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza – Dr. Phillips serves up paper-thin crusts with the kind of char usually reserved for Naples’ best. The first time I bit into their Star Luca pizza, the balance of spicy salami, gooey cheese, and honey drizzle changed my mind about what Orlando pizza could be.
What sets Mister O1 apart is its obsession with quality—every ingredient is carefully sourced, and the flavors shine because of it. The menu boasts plenty of vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, so everyone gets to join the party.
Don’t miss the Star pizzas, famous for their unique shape and generous fillings. Each slice is proof that artistry and flavor go hand-in-hand at this popular Orlando spot.
2. Solorzano’s Pizzeria & Poolside Bistro
If you’re searching for a classic slice, Solorzano’s Pizzeria & Poolside Bistro might convince you that New Jersey’s best packed up and moved south. I stopped in expecting typical beachside fare but found a crust with serious crunch and perfectly tangy sauce.
This spot stands out for its #RealJerseyPizza mantra—each pie arrives hot and sturdy, ready for serious folding. Even late at night, the flavor never feels tired. Plus, with vegetarian and vegan options, picky eaters never need to compromise.
The Margherita slice is a must-try—fresh basil and creamy mozzarella show off their commitment to quality. Solorzano’s offers a real taste of the Northeast in the heart of Orlando, and it’s one you won’t want to miss.
3. NYPD Pizza
NYPD Pizza brings a true slice of New York to Orlando. On my first visit, the bustling atmosphere and that familiar aroma of baking dough set the stage. Their crust is thin but holds up, perfect for folding just like in Manhattan.
This place has made a name for itself with authentic pies and a sprawling menu. Every bite delivers the snap and chew you’d expect from a classic New York slice. There’s no need to board a plane for the taste of the five boroughs.
Order the Traditional Cheese Pizza or the White Pie—both showcase how NYPD keeps it straightforward but never boring. Family-friendly, convenient, and always satisfying, NYPD Pizza is a standout on Orlando’s competitive pizza map.
4. NYPD Pizza Lake Cay
NYPD Pizza Lake Cay is the spot where serious pizza cravings meet genuine New York flavor. My last visit yielded that telltale crackle from a well-built crust—hand-tossed, with a sauce that practically demands a second slice.
The main draw here is their focus on fresh ingredients and authentic technique. This location feels like a New York pizzeria, right down to the warm hum of locals and tourists swapping stories over pies.
The Brooklyn Family Pie is a standout. Each cheesy bite tastes like something straight out of a city borough, solid proof of why this place has won “Best Pizza” awards again and again. If you’re nearby, don’t skip their late-night service—it’s a satisfying end to any Orlando adventure.
5. Blaze Pizza
Blaze Pizza is perfect for when you want your pizza just so—and fast. My last trip here was a lesson in patience, only because watching your custom pie zip through the oven creates real anticipation. In three minutes, it’s hot, crisp, and ready to eat.
The magic comes from over 30 toppings, letting you create anything from a classic Margherita to a bold veggie-packed masterpiece. Vegan, gluten-free, and vegetarian folks will find plenty of fan-favorite options.
Try their Build Your Own Pizza, where the combinations are as wild or classic as you’d like. Fast, fresh, and cooked to order, Blaze delivers on both flavor and speed—ideal for anyone needing a quality bite between Orlando adventures.
6. Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings brings a smoky edge to the Orlando pizza scene. I remember my first visit—cracking into their signature crust revealed a gentle char and deep flavor that only comes from a coal oven.
This spot excels with bold, unmistakable flavors and a focus on fresh, premium ingredients. You can taste the difference, especially in their classic cheese pie, where the sauce and cheese shine against that toasted base.
Order the Hot Honey Pizza or a classic Margherita, both favorites that capture Anthony’s commitment to old-school technique with just the right amount of modern flair. If you’re feeling adventurous, the coal oven-roasted wings make for a solid side.
7. Sal’s Market Deli
Sal’s Market Deli in the heart of Loews Portofino Bay Hotel is like a quick trip to a charming Italian marketplace, minus the airfare. My first time grabbing a slice after a theme park marathon, I was won over by their fresh-baked offerings and friendly staff.
Sal’s stands out with a simple focus on quality, freshness, and classic flavors. The pizzas are thin-crusted and bubbling from the oven, making for an ideal break between park visits or a relaxing dinner after a long day.
The Margherita pizza is a standout, topped with plenty of basil and just the right amount of cheese and sauce. Gluten-free and vegan options round out a menu that keeps every traveler satisfied.
8. Red Oven Pizza Bakery
Red Oven Pizza Bakery brings Old World Italy to Universal Orlando. Watching the bakers slide pies into a roaring stone-lined oven is worth the visit alone. My last stop here had me torn between the lure of buffalo mozzarella and the aroma of fresh basil.
This spot shines because of its artisan approach and top-tier ingredients. Each pizza emerges with a perfectly crackled, blistered crust that keeps both locals and visitors coming back for more.
The Bianca pizza is a house favorite—simple, creamy, and flavorful. If you like classic tastes prepared with care, Red Oven should be on your Orlando pizza tour. Vegetarian and vegan options make it a crowd-pleaser for all.
9. Flippers Pizzeria O-Town West
Flippers Pizzeria O-Town West offers the kind of pizza that’s perfect for sharing with friends and family after a day in Orlando’s theme parks. My go-to is grabbing a piping-hot pie to fuel up before a night out, savoring that chewy-crisp, fire-baked crust.
The reason Flippers stands out is its dedication to fresh dough and premium ingredients. With gluten-free and vegan-friendly options, it’s easy for everyone to find a favorite. The staff is always welcoming and quick, even when the place is busy.
Try the Veggie Pie or the classic Margherita for a taste of what makes their pizza a repeat hit. Every slice is bubbly, cheesy, and made with obvious attention to detail.
10. UNO Pizzeria & Grill
UNO Pizzeria & Grill delivers a deep-dish tradition that’s hard to find outside Chicago. On my first visit, I dug into a classic deep-dish and needed a fork—the layers of golden crust, gooey cheese, and chunky tomato sauce were worth every hefty bite.
UNO isn’t just about one style. Here, you’ll find Chicago deep dish, crispy thin crust, and their new Detroit-style pizza, all baked fresh daily. The variety lets you mix it up, and there are vegan and gluten-free options that don’t compromise on flavor.
Order the Numero Uno Deep Dish or Detroit-style Veggie Pizza to sample the house specialties. UNO’s hearty, bold approach makes it a go-to for Orlando pizza fans craving something substantial and satisfying.
More Things to Try in Orlando, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
What style of pizza can I find in Orlando?
You’ll find nearly every style here: hand-tossed New York slices, Chicago deep-dish, Neapolitan, Detroit-style, and creative local specialties. There’s something for every preference.
Are there good options for vegetarians and vegans in Orlando pizzerias?
Absolutely. Most top pizza spots offer robust menus with vegetarian and vegan pies, plus gluten-free crusts and dairy-free cheese.
Can I get gluten-free pizza in Orlando?
Yes, many places—including family-run shops and big chains—serve tasty gluten-free pies that don’t skimp on flavor or texture.
Which area in Orlando has the best pizza?
Great pizza is scattered all over: Dr. Phillips, International Drive, and Lake Buena Vista each boast several favorites. Exploring different neighborhoods pays off.
Is there late-night pizza in Orlando?
Yes. Several pizzerias stay open late, perfect for satisfying those post-theme-park cravings or spontaneous pizza runs.