Olney hides some of Maryland’s best pizza in plain sight. Whether you’re a thin-crust loyalist or searching for the kind of doughy, cheesy slice that leaves a lasting impression, finding the top spot can feel like a quest through a wonderland of tomato sauce and bubbling mozzarella. Every local has their “secret” favorite, and after more taste tests than I’ll admit, I’ve gathered intel you’ll want before picking your next pizza night.
There’s a slice for everyone in Olney. Picture this: one night it’s a smoky, just-charred crust from a family-run shop; the next, it’s a super gooey pie that lands hot in your hands before the box is even closed. From the classic institutions to the hole-in-the-wall gems, I’m laying out where to find your next excellent pizza—minus the hype and the marketing fluff. Get ready for a tour of Olney’s top ovens, and maybe settle a debate or two along the way.
1. Mamma Lucia of Olney
Mamma Lucia of Olney proves that not all neighborhood pizza joints are created equal. Each time I step inside, the aroma of fresh basil and sizzling cheese feels like a warm invitation. The dining room buzzes with families sharing laughter over generous pies and classic Italian fare.
The pizza here is the real headliner. Their Margherita—simple yet rich with ripe tomatoes and creamy mozzarella—reminds me why basics, done right, never go out of style. Give their white pizza a try, too; the blend of ricotta and mozzarella makes it a standout for anyone craving a little comfort.
Service is attentive whether you’re dining in or grabbing a pie to go, so you never leave hungry. For a casual lunch or a lively dinner, Mamma Lucia hits the mark.
2. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza in Olney is where you go when you crave consistency and a quick fix done right. The familiar green box arrives steaming, and it’s hard not to dive in before setting it on the table. The scent of their signature pizza sauce always brings me back to late-night study sessions and low-key weekends.
What makes this spot pop is their fresh, pillowy dough and bold tomato sauce, which set the stage for any topping combination. Their classic Cheese Pizza is reliable, but I keep going back for the Garden Fresh Pizza. Loaded with vegetables and baked to a gentle golden finish, it shows off Papa Johns’ knack for fresh flavors.
Friendly staff, fast service, and a lineup of crowd-pleasing specialty pies keep Papa Johns firmly in the Olney pizza conversation. Perfect for a group or a solo treat.
3. Umberto’s Restaurant
Umberto’s Restaurant pairs cozy charm with genuine Italian craftsmanship, making it a favorite for laid-back dining in Olney. Each visit feels a bit like stumbling onto a family gathering, with welcoming staff and the scent of freshly baked dough setting the scene.
Their pizzas are all about balance—thin crusts with just the right crunch, topped with a careful blend of cheese and house-made tomato sauce. I’m partial to their classic Veggie Pizza. Every bite tastes like peak season produce and real kitchen care.
Service is relaxed but attentive, never rushing you through a meal. Whether you dine in or take out, Umberto’s delivers honest flavors and a taste of neighborhood tradition.
4. Ledo Pizza
Ledo Pizza has built a legacy in Olney with its unmistakable square pies and flaky, golden crusts. There’s something nostalgic about opening a box and seeing that unique shape—perfect for sharing, or at least pretending to share. Families gather here, and the place has a comfortable, lived-in vibe.
Their Veggie Pizza is a highlight, dotted with ripe tomatoes, peppers, and mushrooms on top of a crisp crust. The sweet, slightly tangy sauce sets Ledo apart from the usual suspects. The slices are generous, so come hungry.
Catering and group orders are another Ledo strong suit, making them the go-to choice for everything from game nights to office lunches. When only a square will do, Ledo doesn’t disappoint.
5. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Olney nails the art of fast, no-nonsense pizza that actually delivers on taste. Whether I’m in need of a quick weeknight dinner or feeding a crowd at the last minute, their app’s ease and prompt delivery are a lifesaver. There’s never much waiting; hot pizza seems to appear right on cue.
The standout here is customization. From thin New York Style to soft, doughy Handmade Pan, you can build your ideal pizza. I’m a fan of their Spinach & Feta Pizza—it’s savory, creamy, and always comes perfectly cooked.
Deals are easy to spot, so you can get a satisfying meal without breaking the budget. Domino’s blends fast service with dependable flavor in every order.
6. Armands Chicago Pizzeria In Olney
Armands Chicago Pizzeria in Olney is a haven for anyone who loves their pizza deep, hearty, and unapologetically cheesy. Every time I dig into a slice here, I’m reminded of why Chicago-style pies inspire such devotion. The crust is thick yet light, with a generous helping of cheese bubbling over a tart, rich tomato sauce.
Their Spinach specialty pizza is a must for those wanting flavor and comfort, baked until every bite tastes like a celebration of simple, good ingredients. It’s hefty enough to eat with a fork, but best enjoyed piping hot right out of the pan.
Prices are wallet-friendly, and the atmosphere feels relaxed, perfect for everything from casual family nights to solo cravings. Armands does Chicago in Olney—and does it well.
7. Stained Glass Pub Too
(301) 774-3778Call
Stained Glass Pub Too brings a neighborhood pub vibe and some of the most addictive thin-crust pizza in Olney. Walking in, the lively hum and the sight of classic pies sliding from the oven are always inviting. There’s a sense that every table has its own story and favorite topping combination.
Their signature House Pizza offers a balance of fresh vegetables and bubbling cheese on a golden, crisp crust, making it an instant favorite for both locals and first-timers. If you enjoy a thin crust with an edge of crunch, you’re in the right spot.
Service is warm, and the atmosphere invites you to linger, whether with friends or a solo pizza outing. For no-fuss, flavorful pizza, Stained Glass Pub Too hits all the right notes.
8. Ricciuti’s Restaurant
Ricciuti’s Restaurant turns the art of brick oven pizza into a local ritual in Olney. The scent of charring crust and fresh herbs always hits you before you reach your table, promising a meal that lingers in memory as much as on the palate. There’s something about their cozy, modern setting that makes each dinner feel special yet welcoming.
Their classic Margherita is where Ricciuti’s really shows off—sweet tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil on a crackling, smoky crust. The freshness of each ingredient speaks for itself, reflecting their philosophy of simple food done well.
Every pizza comes with a bit of flair, but none lose sight of classic Italian roots. For a pizza night with just a touch of upscale comfort, Ricciuti’s fits the bill beautifully.
9. Jerry’s Subs and Pizza
(301) 774-3436Call
Jerry’s Subs and Pizza has mastered the art of fast, satisfying pizza for Olney locals on the go. I’ve stopped in for a quick bite more times than I can count, and the reliable quality keeps me coming back. Nothing fancy—just solid, classic slices built for those who want flavor without the fuss.
Their Veggie Pizza stands out with a crisp base and a colorful mix of fresh toppings, perfect for a lunch break or a casual dinner. Every slice packs plenty of cheese and a bright tomato sauce, balancing comfort with just the right amount of heft.
Staff are always ready with a smile, making Jerry’s an easy choice when you’re hungry and want something familiar. It’s simple, honest pizza that does the trick every time.
10. Angelos Fresh Pasta and Deli
Angelos Fresh Pasta and Deli is where Italian comfort food feels like a heartfelt invite to the family table. The moment you enter, shelves lined with Italian groceries and aromas from the kitchen promise something memorable. I’ve lost count of the times I’ve driven out for their oven-fresh pizza and wound up coming home with extra pasta for the week.
Their Veggie Pizza stands out, topped with ripe tomatoes, peppers, and mushrooms, all on a chewy, flavorful crust. What makes it special is the balance between the fresh, tender vegetables and their just-sweet-enough tomato sauce.
Staff are always friendly and offer great suggestions, turning even a quick takeout order into a chat. For pizza that delivers handmade honesty, Angelos makes it easy to feel like a regular.
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of pizza are most popular in Olney, MD?
Olney is known for its wide range, from classic cheese and veggie pies to thin-crust and deep-dish Chicago styles. Many places also offer brick oven and square-cut pizzas for something a bit different.
Are there options for vegetarian or vegan pizza in Olney?
Absolutely. Most pizzerias feature veggie-heavy pizzas, and several spots like Mamma Lucia and Angelos offer customizable options for specific dietary preferences. Vegan cheese is less common, so calling ahead can help.
Where can I find pizza delivery or takeout in Olney?
Most of the major local favorites, such as Domino’s, Papa Johns, and Ledo Pizza, offer reliable delivery and easy takeout. Many local restaurants provide curbside pickup, too.
Which spot has the best pizza for families or groups?
Ledo Pizza and Stained Glass Pub Too are both crowd-pleasers with friendly service and plenty of space for groups. Their menus are broad enough to satisfy a variety of tastes.
What’s unique about pizza in Olney, MD?
There’s a balance of national chains and independent pizzerias, so you can easily find both dependable classics and pies with a homemade touch. The diverse range of styles means no two pizza nights need to be the same.