Trying to hunt down the best pizza in Odenton, MD is almost a sport of its own. This isn’t the type of town where pizza means just greasy slices and soggy crust. Here, every spot comes with its own loyal fans, secret recipes, and a wide range of options for crust, cheese, and toppings—without any ingredients that clash with halal preferences.
My quest through the local pizza joints started on a rainy evening, the kind that all but demands you find comfort in a box of something hot and cheesy. I’ve bitten into everything from thin crust to deep dish, eager to find slices that impress not just on first glance, but after every bite. Reading this guide means you’ll skip the duds and go straight to the memorable pies—even if your favorite bragging rights are still up for grabs.
1. Mamma Roma Incorporated
Mamma Roma Incorporated isn’t just a pizza stop; it’s a slice of Italy right here in Odenton. The warm, bustling dining room feels inviting the moment you walk in, and the aroma of fresh-baked dough fills the air. This is a place that cares about tradition and hospitality in equal measure.
On my last visit, I was swept away by their crispy, thin-crust Margherita. The tomato sauce tastes like it was simmered all day, and the cheese melts with that perfect stretch. Even after trying countless pizza spots, this one always keeps calling me back.
For those who want variety, the vegetarian and vegan options are solid. Still, if you’re craving classic, go for the classic cheese or their artful veggie pizza—each bite sums up why locals keep Mamma Roma at the top of their must-visit list.
2. Angelina’s Pizza & Pasta
Angelina’s Pizza & Pasta delivers that rare combination of cozy atmosphere and standout flavors. Tucked into a bustling plaza, this family-run spot is easy to miss—until you taste what’s coming out of their ovens. Every pizza is cooked with obvious care, channeling a big dose of Italian comfort into each slice.
I sat down one afternoon with friends and, on a whim, ordered the Veggie Special. Each ingredient tasted fresh and was balanced just right, and the crust had that great crackle when you bite in. The vibe makes you want to linger with good company and good food.
For newcomers, the classic cheese or the White Pizza stands out. Both capture why pizza lovers make Angelina’s a regular part of their dinner rotation.
3. Three Brothers Pizza-Catering
Three Brothers Pizza-Catering is the kind of spot where community ties run as deep as the sauce on every pie. With nearly two decades serving Odenton, there’s a reason folks keep coming back. You get a true taste of family at every table, whether you’re there for a single slice or ordering for a crowd.
I once stopped in after a long day and the first bite of their classic cheese pizza reminded me why I skip the chains. The New York-style crust is thin, foldable, and has just the right amount of chew. Every ingredient, from the sauce to the cheese, hits that nostalgic note.
If it’s your first visit, their veggie pizza is a safe bet—fresh toppings and a flavor-packed base show off the kitchen’s attention to detail. The welcoming vibe and quality keep Three Brothers firmly on the local pizza map.
4. Angelico La Pizzeria
Angelico La Pizzeria brings a modern twist to the Odenton pizza scene, blending classic recipes with a fresh, upbeat setting. The staff brings a bit of energy to every visit, making the whole experience as inviting as the food itself. You get the feeling that this place knows how to keep things simple and delicious.
Stopping by for lunch, I tried their classic Margherita pie. The sauce tasted lively, the cheese was smooth, and the crust was crisp along the edges. There’s real balance—nothing overpowers, everything works together.
It’s tough to beat their Veggie Pizza, stacked with generous layers of vegetables on that signature crust. For anyone searching for flavor and freshness, Angelico’s style keeps you coming back for more.
5. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza in Odenton is more than a familiar chain—it feels like a neighborhood staple. Sometimes you need consistency, and this location nails it every time with quick service and hot, fresh pizzas. Their promise of “Better Ingredients. Better Pizza.” isn’t just a slogan here; you can taste the difference in the dough and sauce.
After a late study session, I ordered their Original Cheese Pizza. The crust was soft but had a light crispness on the bottom, and the cheese stretch was worthy of a slow-motion cheese pull. No frills, just good, reliable pie.
If you’re undecided, the Garden Fresh pizza is an easy favorite—plenty of fresh-cut veggies and bold flavors, showcasing exactly what makes Papa Johns a classic choice for pizza lovers in Odenton.
6. Little Caesars
Little Caesars keeps pizza simple and fast, and that’s why it draws a steady crowd in Odenton. There’s something reassuring about walking in and grabbing a hot, fresh pizza without waiting. This spot caters to busy schedules and those sudden pizza cravings with no fuss.
I’ve popped in after work and left with a warm classic cheese or veggie pizza more times than I can count. The crust is chewy and satisfying, layered with just enough zesty sauce and stretchy cheese. You know exactly what you’re getting—dependable pizza that’s actually ready when you are.
If you’re after value and speed, the veggie pizza is a favorite, packed with fresh peppers, onions, and mushrooms on that signature base. Picking up a box here is all about convenience without sacrificing flavor or quality.
7. Pizza Boli’s
Pizza Boli’s sits right in the heart of Odenton, and it’s nearly impossible to miss with its bold presence on Annapolis Road. What makes this spot a go-to is the focus on both flavor and Halal-friendly options, making it easy to share a meal without worrying about the menu.
After a late meeting near Fort Meade, I stopped by and grabbed a veggie pizza that hit the mark—pile on the onions, peppers, and mushrooms over a golden crust and you get something crave-worthy. The pizzas come out hot and loaded with toppings, keeping every bite interesting.
Order their Mediterranean or Veggie pizza for a taste that feels both familiar and unique. Pizza Boli’s delivers big flavor, plenty of options, and stays top-of-mind for Odenton locals.
8. Romeo’s Pizza & Subs
Romeo’s Pizza & Subs brings a homespun charm to the pizza scene in Odenton, serving up pies that feel crafted, not churned out. There’s a friendly, family-run air to the place—you walk in and immediately sense you’re in for something special. Their crust is fluffy but never too thick, giving each pizza a welcoming balance between softness and crunch.
My go-to is their plain cheese or veggie pizza. The tomato sauce tastes bright and fresh, the cheese is layered with just enough stretch, and the veggies pile high without making the crust soggy. No corners are cut here, whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout.
Try their Supreme Veggie pizza if you want a loaded option. Romeo’s nails the basics, and every hearty bite is proof that small-scale attention can equal big flavor.
9. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut at Odenton Road feels like a rite of passage for anyone who grew up nearby. It’s the place where group orders and movie nights got their start, and the signature red roof still brings a dose of nostalgia every visit. What Pizza Hut does best is comfort food on a crust that’s consistent, chewy, and always piping hot.
I still crave their Original Stuffed Crust Cheese Pizza when I want that extra stretch and satisfaction. The cheese is generous, the crust is golden, and the sauce has just the right tang. It’s a classic you come back to, especially if you like the soft, fluffy base.
The Veggie Lover’s pizza is a safe order here—loaded with crisp peppers, onions, mushrooms, and tomatoes. Pizza Hut specializes in reliable, crowd-pleasing pies that go well with just about any gathering.
10. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Odenton is all about flexibility, speed, and getting it just the way you like. Whether you’re after a quick solo meal or feeding a group, the staff makes sure every order is fresh and hot. The online ordering system has saved me on more than one late night, and their deals keep the final bill friendly.
What sets this spot apart is the range, from thin New York style to their surprisingly satisfying Handmade Pan. I go back again and again for the Parmesan Stuffed Crust Cheese Pizza—the crust is golden, filled with warm, savory cheese you can’t help but savor.
For something lighter, try the Pacific Veggie pizza. Domino’s has mastered the art of customization, making it a smart pick for pizza fans with specific cravings.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Odenton, MD?
Odenton offers a mix of local favorites and well-known chains. Standouts include Mamma Roma Incorporated, Angelina’s Pizza & Pasta, Three Brothers Pizza-Catering, Pizza Boli’s, and more. Each spot brings something unique, whether it’s a family recipe, unique crust, or specialty pies.
Are there halal or vegetarian pizza options in Odenton?
Yes, several places provide halal and vegetarian options. Pizza Boli’s highlights its halal offerings and most spots, like Mamma Roma and Angelina’s, have veggie pizzas that suit a plant-based diet.
Who offers delivery or takeout for pizza in Odenton?
Most pizza restaurants in Odenton offer delivery and takeout. Major chains like Domino’s, Papa John’s, Pizza Hut, and Little Caesars have streamlined online ordering. Local shops, such as Romeo’s Pizza & Subs and Three Brothers Pizza-Catering, are reliable for quick, hot takeout.
Which Odenton pizza spot is best for large groups or parties?
If you’re feeding a crowd, Three Brothers Pizza-Catering is a solid choice. They specialize in catering and can handle big orders, while places like Mamma Roma and Pizza Boli’s have shareable pies that work well for gatherings.