Discovering the best pizza in Ocean Pines, MD isn’t just about picking the place with the most toppings or the largest slice. It’s the hunt for that ideal, golden crust and the kind of sauce that makes you pause after each bite. I once drove through Ocean Pines on a rainy afternoon, clutching a list of pizza joints that locals claim would change my mind about what good pizza really means. My journey ended with a pie that had the perfect blend of chew and crunch, proving this town takes its pizza seriously.
The secret to Ocean Pines’ pizza scene? Diversity and dedication. Between family-run shops that swear by dough recipes handed down for generations and playful newcomers daring with bold flavors, you’re bound to find more than just a meal here. This guide isn’t filled with hype. Instead, it’s packed with real talk, clear detail and a dash of wit—because finding your next favorite pizza should be as fun as that first glorious bite.
1. Johnny’s Pizza Dough Factory
Johnny’s Pizza Dough Factory sits tucked away on Manklin Meadows Lane, but don’t let the low-key spot fool you. In Ocean Pines, it’s the place people mention when pizza comes up. On my last visit, I remember the waft of baking crust pulling me in before I’d opened the door. The staff greets you with genuine warmth and the open kitchen gives you a front-row seat to what comes next.
What makes Johnny’s stand out is their hand-tossed dough—a recipe that gets all the details right, from chewy edges to crisp base. The classic cheese pizza is a must-try for its balance and simplicity, but the Margherita feels crafted for the purist. If you want something hearty, their veggie combo delivers bold flavors with every slice.
2. Paul & Vinny’s Pizza
(410) 208-6600Call
Paul & Vinny’s Pizza sits right on Cathell Road, quietly earning its loyal following among Ocean Pines locals. The first time I tried their pizza, I found myself craving another slice before finishing the first. There’s a welcoming, old-school charm here that feels rare.
The heart of Paul & Vinny’s is in their crust—thin, with just the right chew, supporting a house-made sauce that’s light and bright. The pepperoni pizza shows off that balance with crisp edges and melty cheese. For something out of the ordinary, order their white pizza. The blend of garlic, olive oil and ricotta makes each bite silky and bold, reflecting the handiwork and care poured into every pie.
3. Trattoria Lombardi’s Rstrnt
Trattoria Lombardi’s Restaurant has a reputation in Ocean City that’s hard to miss. Locals tip you off to it before you even ask about great pizza. My first visit was a family affair, with the team bustling around big tables and the aroma of baking dough filling the air. There’s a friendly energy here that keeps the dining room full.
Lombardi’s stands out for its authentic pies—think thin, slightly blistered crusts and a bright, tangy sauce. Their classic Margherita is a staple for good reason, but it’s the specialty White Pizza that left an impression on me. It’s creamy, garlicky and simple, made for people who appreciate tradition and real flavor. If you want something seasonal, their Summer Pizza brings fresh ingredients and a lighter touch.
4. Pizza Tugos
Pizza Tugos delivers fast, crowd-pleasing pies with a friendly, laid-back vibe on Coastal Highway. The first time I stopped in, it was for a late-night craving shared with friends—quick service and instantly satisfying pizza kept us coming back. There’s a casual energy here that draws a mix of locals and visitors, especially when big game nights roll around.
What sets Pizza Tugos apart is their signature crust: chewy, with a touch of crunch and sturdy enough for serious toppings. The Deluxe Pizza is the one to order. Layers of cheese and an array of veggies create a balanced bite in every slice. Their plain cheese is also a test of skill—fresh, hot, and never skimping on quality.
5. Grotto Pizza
Grotto Pizza has made a name for itself along Coastal Highway, drawing beachgoers and families looking for a reliable bite. I remember sitting by the window watching the summer traffic, enjoying how Grotto kept the mood light without rushing anyone out the door. The casual, laid-back setting makes it easy to settle in with friends or kids in tow.
Grotto’s signature swirl of sauce over the cheese is more than just a gimmick—it locks in flavor and keeps the pie tasting fresh from first to last slice. Try their Classic Cheese Pizza to see what all the fuss is about, or branch out with the Veggie Deluxe for something loaded. The crust hits that sweet spot between soft and crisp, every single time.
6. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Ocean Gateway is the go-to for pizza lovers looking for quick service and a familiar menu. On a late-night study session, I once placed an order here and was surprised by how consistently good the pies arrived, every slice just as fresh as the first. It’s this blend of speed and reliability that keeps people coming back.
Domino’s excels in variety, from their thin, foldable New York Style to the thick, satisfying Handmade Pan. For a solid choice, try their classic Pepperoni or the Parmesan Stuffed Crust, which adds a layer of richness to each bite. No matter what you order, the toppings always come plentiful, and the pies are built for sharing or tackling solo.
7. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on Nicholas Lane brings a sense of nostalgia to the Ocean Pines area. One rainy evening, a friend and I decided nothing else would do, and stepped into the warm, golden light of this familiar chain. The staff recognized our craving for comfort and served up exactly what we hoped for—classic, straightforward pizza done right.
What makes Pizza Hut stand out is their signature Pan Pizza, thick and fluffy with that iconic buttery crust. If you’re in the mood for something different, the Veggie Lover’s Pizza packs in garden-fresh toppings on a generous base. Every pie gets the same careful treatment: hot, reliable, and shareable, making it an easy pick when you want a reliable classic done well.
8. Mama Della’s
(410) 208-3529Call
Mama Della’s on Cathell Road has built a quiet reputation for wholesome, no-nonsense pizza. My first visit happened by chance while looking for a new spot to try, and I ended up savoring every bite at a cozy corner table. There’s an inviting warmth here—somewhere between family kitchen and local hangout.
What puts Mama Della’s on the map is their focus on fresh dough and quality cheese. Their traditional cheese pizza captures everything good about the basics: bubbling mozzarella, smooth tomato sauce, and a crust with just enough bite. For something a little elevated, the White Pizza brings rich ricotta and herbs front and center. It’s ideal for anyone who prefers their pizza classic, honest, and made with care.
9. Fox’s Pizza Den
Fox’s Pizza Den, tucked away on Samuel Bowen Blvd, is the kind of spot you stumble into and end up a regular. My first time was on a game night, where lively chatter and sizzling pies filled the room. The staff are quick with a smile, making it easy to feel at home whether you’re with friends or family.
The appeal of Fox’s comes down to their variety and hearty, satisfying style. Their Big Daddy Pizza delivers serious size and bold flavor, ideal for sharing (or not). If you want something classic, their cheese pizza holds its own—oozy cheese, a light sauce, and a golden crust. Fox’s blends cozy, diner-like service with pizza that keeps you looking for an excuse to come back.
10. Serpones Pizzeria
Serpones Pizzeria on Manklin Creek Road delivers the sort of neighborhood charm that makes you linger at your table. My introduction to Serpones came on a quiet evening, where the atmosphere was relaxed and every pie came out piping hot. The staff’s attention to detail made it clear they care about the food and the people eating it.
What sets Serpones apart is their balance—thin crust, flavorful sauce, and a generous topping spread that never overwhelms. The Margherita Pizza is a highlight, featuring fresh basil and a perfectly blistered edge. Their Veggie Pizza also stands out, loaded with crisp vegetables that taste fresh from the market. Here, it’s about straightforward, well-made pizza that hits the sweet spot every time.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Ocean Pines, MD?
Some of the most talked-about spots include Johnny’s Pizza Dough Factory, Paul & Vinny’s Pizza, and Trattoria Lombardi’s Rstrnt. They all offer a range of classics and unique specialties.
Can I find vegetarian pizza options in Ocean Pines?
Absolutely. Almost every pizzeria in town serves great vegetarian pies. Try the Veggie Deluxe at Grotto Pizza or a classic Margherita from several local favorites.
Which pizza spot offers the best delivery in Ocean Pines?
Most locals swear by Domino’s Pizza and Papa Johns for fast and reliable delivery, but several independent places also deliver hot, fresh pizza right to your door.
Are there any local pizzerias with gluten-free options?
Yes, many spots now offer gluten-free crusts. It’s always best to call ahead to confirm, but chains like Domino’s and some independent pizzerias will accommodate.
Where can I get a classic New York-style slice in Ocean Pines?
If you’re craving that thin, foldable crust, check out Paul & Vinny’s Pizza or Johnny’s Pizza Dough Factory. Both places are known for their take on the classic style.