The search for the best pizza in Ocala, FL feels a lot like a delicious mission. You’ll hear local debates sharpen over thin crust versus thick, New York style or something piled with veggies, and each proud shop claims its dough rises above the rest. I remember walking into a pizzeria near Silver Springs, the scent of fresh basil and bubbling cheese swirling together, and thinking, “Alright, Ocala, show me what you’ve got.” That first slice scored high—golden, foldable, and just the right hit of oregano.
Ocala’s pizza scene offers genuine surprises and classics worth craving. Whether you want a spot for game night with friends, a cozy booth for family, or you just feel called by that late-night craving, you’ll find more variety here than a plain cheese pie lets on. This guide brings you a crisp, accurate rundown of local favorites. If you’re wondering where your next best slice is waiting, you’re in the right place.
Where to find the best pizza in Ocala, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Ocala, FL:
- Milano Italian Grille
- Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza
- Formaggio Pizza & Italian Restaurant
- Fiore’s Cafe
- Roma Italian Restaurant
- Little Joey’s Pizza & Restaurant
- Sammy’s Pizza & Restaurant
- Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza
- Wiseguys Pizzeria
- J Rocks Pizzeria
1. Milano Italian Grille
Milano Italian Grille has a warm, inviting vibe that instantly feels like a local secret. The aroma of fresh dough hit me as soon as I stepped inside, and each seating area gives you a passport to a slice of Italy. What really sets Milano apart is their devotion to tradition—their pizza dough is made fresh daily, and every ingredient tastes thoughtfully chosen.
If you crave classic, try their Margherita: fresh basil, house-made sauce, and rich mozzarella on crisp, golden crust. The Bianca pizza is a standout too—creamy ricotta, mozzarella, and a drizzle of garlic oil that lingers in the best way. Milano proves you don’t need a passport for unforgettable Italian pizza in Ocala.
2. Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza
Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza delivers a bold twist on classic pizza with its signature stone-fired approach. The sizzle from their ovens creates a crust that’s both light and full of flavor. I still remember the first bite of their Mediterranean pizza—the blend of roasted veggies, feta, and herb oil left a real impression.
Every pizza emerges from the oven with a perfect golden edge and a balance of toppings that doesn’t overwhelm. Their Margherita is a showpiece, but if you like something more robust, the Quattro Formaggi brings a rich, gooey blend of cheeses that stretches with every slice. Piesanos is the place for a lively crowd, fresh ingredients, and pizzas that always arrive hot and satisfying.
3. Formaggio Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Formaggio Pizza & Italian Restaurant is the kind of spot where you walk in and immediately feel at home. There’s a genuine warmth in the air—partly from the ovens, partly from the staff’s energy. My first visit, I was handed a slice of veggie pizza straight from the kitchen, the cheese melting and the crust still crisp.
What sets Formaggio apart is the balance of tradition and creativity. The classic cheese pizza shines, but the Veggie Lovers pie is the real crowd-pleaser here, bursting with fresh peppers, mushrooms, and tangy sauce. If you want something a little different, try their white pizza. Each pizza reflects the family-owned spirit in every bite—simple, generous, and full of flavor.
4. Fiore’s Cafe
+1 352-789-6980
Fiore’s Cafe comes with a comfortable energy that feels both classic and refreshing. On my last visit, I watched a pizza come straight from the oven to table—the crust had that perfect golden tint, and the tomato sauce gave off a slow-cooked aroma you only find in honest kitchens.
Their Margherita features plump tomatoes, silky mozzarella, and a basil finish that brings every bite to life. What stands out about Fiore’s is their flexibility—they cater to gluten-free and vegan diets without anyone missing the point of great pizza. For something heartier, their Vegetarian pizza overloads on fresh veggies but keeps things light and flavorful. If you want a pizza that feels crafted just for you, Fiore’s delivers every time.
5. Roma Italian Restaurant
Roma Italian Restaurant feels like a hidden gem just off the main road. The first thing you notice is the inviting, family-style setting, where laughter and conversation seem to hang in the air. I found myself drawn in by the scent of baking crust and bubbling cheese, which led to an unforgettable table-side Margherita.
Roma’s pizzas are all about simplicity and quality. Their Classic Cheese pizza comes out with a crisp crust, tangy sauce, and just the right cheese pull. If you like bolder flavors, the Veggie pizza is a hit, loaded with peppers, mushrooms, and olives. Roma Italian Restaurant is the place for those who appreciate a straightforward, satisfying pizza experience built on tradition.
6. Little Joey’s Pizza & Restaurant
Little Joey’s Pizza & Restaurant has the charm of a neighborhood gathering spot. The moment you walk in, you’ll notice regulars chatting with staff, and the inviting smell of pizza dough in the air. I once caught a glimpse of their kitchen, where the pizza cooks still use time-honored methods to stretch and toss the dough by hand.
The pizza here is all about comfort and abundance. Their Supreme is topped edge to edge with fresh veggies and gooey cheese, creating a fork-and-knife-worthy slice. If you’re a devotee of classic flavors, try their Cheese or Veggie Pizza—both hit that nostalgic sweet spot. Little Joey’s takes pride in generous portions and a satisfyingly crisp crust, making every visit feel like a return to your favorite neighborhood pizzeria.
7. Sammy’s Pizza & Restaurant
Sammy’s Pizza & Restaurant gives off a genuine, family-run vibe the moment you step through the door. The décor is cozy, the staff are quick with a greeting, and the ovens seem to work overtime cranking out pies for locals in the know. My first bite of their classic pizza left an impression—stretchy cheese and a crust that’s never too thick or too thin.
Their Veggie Supreme is a go-to for a burst of color and flavor, loaded with mushrooms, onions, and bell peppers on a layer of gooey mozzarella. The plain cheese isn’t just for kids; it stands on quality alone, with a sauce that’s bright and zesty. Sammy’s captures the spirit of neighborhood pizza with warmth in every slice.
8. Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza
This Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza location has a lively feel that pairs well with the energy of Canopy Oak Plaza. Watching pizzas slide out of the stone oven is all the entertainment I need—a sight that guarantees a crisp, chewy crust every time. My most memorable experience was sharing a large Margherita with friends, fresh from the oven and loaded with melty cheese.
What sets Piesanos apart is their commitment to top-notch, stone-fired results. The flavors are intense, and each topping stands out without overpowering the others. Their Quattro Formaggi is a creamy, rich favorite, while the Veggie Stone Baked offers a lighter, brighter bite. For anyone who wants pizza with depth and no shortcuts, Piesanos delivers every time.
9. Wiseguys Pizzeria
Wiseguys Pizzeria brings a little playful attitude to the table, and it works. Every visit here promises a lively buzz, whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or hanging with friends for dinner. I once sat near the open kitchen, catching the scent of baking bread and seeing the chefs work their magic on each pie.
Their hand-tossed crust is firm enough to fold, with a great balance of chew and crunch. Go for the Classic Cheese if you want to appreciate the basics done right, or try the Veggie Pizza for a garden-fresh experience with every slice. Wiseguys doesn’t mess around; when it comes to fresh ingredients and attention to detail, this spot earns its reputation one pizza at a time.
10. J Rocks Pizzeria
J Rocks Pizzeria comes across as relaxed, but their pizza game is anything but casual. This is where you go if you want something beyond the predictable. My first visit came with a loaded Veggie pizza—the crust had that oven-kissed flavor, and they didn’t hold back on fresh toppings or melty cheese.
Their New York-style pies shine for their wide, foldable slices and crisp edges. Order the classic Cheese if you want purity, but don’t overlook their Spinach and Ricotta pizza. It’s creamy, garlicky, and unique to J Rocks. Every slice feels handcrafted, with just the right touch of creativity on a traditional base. J Rocks Pizzeria proves that you can have fun and still take your pizza seriously.
More Things to Try in Ocala, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza spots in Ocala, FL?
Some local favorites include Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza, Milano Italian Grille, Wiseguys Pizzeria, and Formaggio Pizza & Italian Restaurant. Each offers unique styles and standout specialties.
Is it easy to find vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Ocala?
Absolutely. Most top pizza places in Ocala, like Piesanos and Fiore’s Cafe, offer plenty of vegetarian pizzas and vegan-friendly alternatives, including gluten-free crusts.
Which Ocala pizzerias serve New York-style pizza?
Check out Wiseguys Pizzeria, J Rocks Pizzeria, and 484 New York Pizza for wide, foldable slices and that signature thin, crisp crust.
Do these pizza restaurants offer takeout and delivery?
Yes, nearly all popular Ocala pizza restaurants offer takeout, and most partner with delivery services or provide it directly. Check each restaurant’s website for details.
Where can I find pizza for a large group or party in Ocala?
Places like Milano Italian Grille, Piesanos, and Five Star Pizza are known for accommodating groups and offering party-sized pies or catering options.