There’s something oddly thrilling about chasing down the best slice in town—especially in North Babylon, where pizza cravings run deep. I once slipped into a cozy pizzeria here on a rainy afternoon, only to discover a slice so good it made me rethink what I thought I knew about crust. Each spot in North Babylon brings something unique to the table and, after sampling my way across the area, it’s clear this town doesn’t settle for bland or boring.
Whether you’re hunting for that charred, chewy Neapolitan crust or a classic New York fold, North Babylon delivers. The sheer variety means there’s always a new pie to try or a topping you haven’t tasted yet. I’ve sifted through local favorites and hidden gems so you can skip the guesswork. Let’s break down the best pies, the secret recipes, and where to find your new favorite slice.
Where to find the best pizza in North Babylon, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in North Babylon, NY:
- Pizzaiola
- Nonna Bella’s Pizza Cafe
- Dalisa Pizza
- Pizza crust inc
- Mangia Pizza & Restaurant
- Little Caesars
- Jem Pizza Corp
- Nonna Bella Pizza Cafe
- Sbarro
- Giordano’s
1. Pizzaiola
Pizzaiola on Deer Park Ave is more than just another pizza spot—it’s an experience that hits the sweet spot between classic and inventive. On my last visit, I found myself lured by the aroma of their wood-fired pies, all while the staff treated guests like old friends.
What sets Pizzaiola apart is their attention to dietary needs. You’ll find gluten-free crusts, vegan cheese, and a menu that feels welcoming to everyone. For pizza lovers, the Margherita is a must. The sauce is vibrant, the dough perfectly chewy.
Say yes to the Vegetarian Special if you want fresh roasted veggies atop a crackling crust; it’s a local favorite for good reason. Pizzaiola nails the balance between hearty comfort and fresh flavor—always worth another slice.
2. Nonna Bella’s Pizza Cafe
Nonna Bella’s Pizza Cafe wraps you in a cozy, inviting atmosphere from the moment you walk in. My first slice here had me convinced that family tradition hasn’t lost its touch—everything tastes straight from a home kitchen with recipes passed down over generations.
Their hand-tossed crust and sauce are the real draw. There’s a bright tang, a hint of sweetness, and a depth you only get when someone cares about every step. The Grandma Pie is the showstopper: a thin, crisp base topped with garlicky tomato sauce and fresh basil, making each bite unbeatable.
I’d also recommend their Sicilian slice, which perfectly balances lightness with a hearty, golden crust. Nonna Bella’s keeps tradition alive and reminds you that pizza can be personal.
3. Dalisa Pizza
Dalisa Pizza brings a friendly, no-fuss approach to classic pies right on Deer Park Ave. The vibe is casual, with staff who remember your order and still ask how your day’s going. I once tried to beat their quick delivery time—decidedly lost, but ended up with a piping hot pizza better than any rush job I could make at home.
Dalisa crafts a strong, reliable New York slice. The cheese bubbles just right, the crust holds its own, and the sauce leans savory but never overwhelms. Their White Pizza, topped with ricotta and fresh herbs, is always a solid bet for something creamy and rich.
If you prefer a little crunch, order their thin crust options. Dalisa knows how to keep pizza simple and satisfying, the way it ought to be.
4. Pizza crust inc
+1 631-661-6239
Pizza Crust Inc feels like a local secret hiding in plain sight. The storefront might be understated, but what comes out of their ovens is anything but ordinary. My first encounter was during a lunch break, and I ended up returning for dinner just to sample another slice.
The star here is the crust—crisp at the edge, tender at the center, and never greasy. There’s a real sense of balance in their pies, like they’ve nailed the golden ratio of dough to toppings. Their classic cheese pizza says everything you need to know about their philosophy: simple, clean, and made with care.
If you’re looking to branch out, their veggie pie is stacked with fresh produce and doesn’t skimp on flavor. Pizza Crust Inc has a knack for letting good dough shine.
5. Mangia Pizza & Restaurant
(631) 661-6188Call
Mangia Pizza & Restaurant feels like one of those rare spots where regulars and newcomers blend in. The first time I walked in, the warm greeting and scent of rising dough made it hard to resist a second visit.
Mangia’s menu is broad, but their pizzas anchor the experience. The crust has a satisfying crunch, while the sauce leans tangy and just a bit sweet. Their Sicilian slice is a neighborhood favorite—a thick, airy base with a caramelized edge that never feels heavy.
Their veggie pizza is a standout, piled high with fresh ingredients that actually taste seasonal. If you want something reliably classic but not lacking in depth, Mangia is your stop for hearty, flavorful pizza done right.
6. Little Caesars
(631) 522-1722Call
Little Caesars in North Babylon is the spot for anyone craving quick, no-nonsense pizza. I’ve made more than a few impromptu stops for their signature Hot-N-Ready pies when the clock says dinner but my fridge says otherwise.
Speed and consistency are where Little Caesars shines. The classic cheese pizza is crisp and gooey right out of the box—never a long wait, never a surprise. The Crazy Bread is another crowd-pleaser, ideal for sharing or, honestly, not sharing at all.
If you’re after affordable comfort and a reliable slice, Little Caesars delivers every time. It’s the kind of place that feels familiar, making it easy to enjoy fresh pizza with zero fuss.
7. Jem Pizza Corp
(631) 242-4274Call
Jem Pizza Corp might not win any points for flashy decor, but it more than makes up for it with flavor and familiarity. My visits have always felt surprisingly personal; you’re more than just another order here.
Jem’s pies are all about sturdy slices and a sauce that’s quietly complex. Their regular cheese pizza is never greasy, with a golden crust that holds up even after a leisurely drive home. There’s care in the way toppings are placed—spread evenly, never piled on as an afterthought.
For something a bit different, the veggie slice is crisp on the bottom and loaded with fresh peppers and mushrooms. Jem Pizza Corp proves you don’t have to be trendy to deliver memorable pizza in North Babylon.
8. Nonna Bella Pizza Cafe
Nonna Bella Pizza Cafe has a loyal local following, and it’s easy to see why. My first visit, the cozy, family-focused atmosphere struck me right away—I felt right at home before my order even hit the table.
The pizza here delivers that hand-tossed charm coupled with bold, homemade flavors. Each slice is just the right thickness, with a crust that’s crisp and airy by turns. Their Margherita pie stands out: sweet tomato, creamy mozzarella, and fragrant basil in perfect harmony.
If you’re after something with a little more substance, the Sicilian slice is a local legend—light, fluffy, and beautifully golden on the bottom. Nonna Bella wins you over with thoughtful details and consistent quality in every pie.
9. Sbarro
Sbarro is a name that most recognize, but in North Babylon, it means dependable pizza whenever you’re on the go. I’ve often found myself here during busy afternoons when I crave something warm and filling, but don’t have much time to linger.
Sbarro is known for its classic, oversized New York slices and generous toppings. The cheese slice is always gooey and delivers a comforting dough-to-sauce ratio that’s just right. Their tomato and spinach pizza brings something fresher to the table, with bright flavors and a pillowy crust.
If you’re after a fast, satisfying lunch or dinner, Sbarro won’t let you down. It’s pizza without pretense, for those moments when you want something familiar and quick.
10. Giordano’s
(631) 665-6350Call
Giordano’s in Bay Shore gives off genuine neighborhood pizzeria vibes, right down to the friendly staff who remember your favorites. My first bite here was all about balance—the crust had real structure, while the cheese and sauce pulled together seamlessly.
Giordano’s stands out for its stuffed pies and classic New York slices. Their specialty veggie pizza is loaded with roasted peppers, onions, and mushrooms, offering delight in every forkful and fold.
If you’re in the mood for something heartier, try the deep-dish. The thick, almost buttery crust and layers of cheese deliver a proper meal, not just a snack. Giordano’s is the go-to if you like your pizza filling and packed with flavor.
More Things to Try in North Babylon, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in North Babylon?
You’ll spot just about every style—classic New York thin crust, Sicilian squares, deep-dish, and even gluten-free or vegan options at select spots.
Are there any places with vegan or gluten-free pizza?
Yes. Pizzaiola is a standout for both, offering vegan cheese and gluten-free crusts alongside their regular menu.
Which pizzeria in North Babylon is best for quick takeout?
Little Caesars and Sbarro are favorites for their fast service and ready-to-go pizzas, so you’re never waiting long for a hot slice.
Where should I go for a traditional Italian pizzeria experience?
Nonna Bella’s Pizza Cafe and Dalisa Pizza serve up classic recipes and a cozy, family-run vibe that’s hard to find elsewhere.
Is delivery available from most North Babylon pizzerias?
Almost every spot—Dalisa Pizza, Nonna Bella’s, and more—offers delivery. It’s as easy as a quick call or online order.