Pizza lovers know the search for the perfect slice is equal parts adventure and dedication—especially in New Hyde Park, where every corner seems to promise a new favorite spot. If you’ve ever stood on Jericho Turnpike, torn between the scent of bubbling cheese from one shop and the scent of fresh basil at the next, you get it. I’ve spent more than one evening caught in pizza debates with friends, arguing over crust thickness and the best sauce-to-cheese ratio in town. There’s something about New Hyde Park’s pizza scene that makes these lively debates worth having.
The real charm of pizza here? Each pizzeria brings something unique to the table. A thin-and-crispy classic, Neapolitan brick oven wonder, or cheese-stretch masterpiece—whatever your craving, you’ll find plenty to savor. Armed with a napkin in one hand and an open mind in the other, I set out to make sense of the options. If you’re ready to find the best slice without sifting through dozens of menus, you’re in the right place. Let’s get started.
Where to find the best pizza in New Hyde Park, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in New Hyde Park, NY:
- Umberto’s
- Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria Restaurant
- Eddie’s Pizza
- Iavarone Italian Kitchen + Pizzeria
- Previti Pizza and Papazzio Dining – West
- Gino’s Trattoria & Pizzeria of New Hyde Park
- Gigi’s Pizzeria
- Alessio Pizzeria and Restaurant
- Angoletto Cafe
- Piccolo Gourmet
1. Umberto’s
It’s hard to think about New Hyde Park pizza without picturing a slice of Umberto’s famous Grandma Pie—a local legend for good reason. The first bite delivers a crisp edge and a layer of fresh tomato sauce that’s almost impossible to forget. If you ever find yourself in their lively dining room, you’ll notice families passing slices and sharing stories, a scene that feels straight out of an old movie.
Umberto’s stands out with its fusion of tradition and innovation. The crust balances chewy and crunchy, while the toppings stick to quality over quantity. Don’t sleep on their Specialty Pizza section, either; a table full of creative pies means everyone can find their favorite. If you’re serious about pizza, start with their classic and work your way through.
2. Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria Restaurant
There’s a quiet confidence to Mama Theresa’s that draws regulars back time after time. I remember ducking in late one evening, only to be greeted by the aroma of fresh basil and charred dough wafting from the oven. The staff makes you feel like you’re an old friend, even if you’re just stopping by for your first slice.
Where Mama Theresa’s really shines is in its consistent approach to classic pies. Their Margherita Pizza is always reliable—simple, with the perfect balance of tomato and cheese. For a little adventure, their white pizza delivers a creamy, garlicky punch that’s hard to resist. Whatever you order, expect it hot, quick, and made with real care.
3. Eddie’s Pizza
If you grew up in the area, Eddie’s Pizza probably became part of your routine before you even realized it. The vibe’s casual, with pizzas sliding in and out of the oven like clockwork. My first Eddie’s pie was a personal thin-crust masterpiece, and I was hooked after the first crispy bite.
What sets Eddie’s apart is its dedication to the cracker-thin crust—a canvas for a range of inventive toppings. Don’t miss their Bar Pie, which is a local classic for those who like pizza that’s light, crunchy, and easy to share. The simple cheese pie here lets the tomato and cheese shine, showing off the kitchen’s confidence in its ingredients.
4. Iavarone Italian Kitchen + Pizzeria
Iavarone Italian Kitchen + Pizzeria feels like a taste of Italy right in New Hyde Park. Walking in, you get a sense of warmth—think cozy booths and the unmistakable smell of dough rising in a real kitchen. My first visit, I found myself watching the chefs spin dough behind the counter, always a promising sign.
Their Neapolitan-style pizza is a highlight, especially the Margherita: fresh mozzarella paired with a bright tomato sauce. Everything about the pie, from its chewy crust to the just-charred edges, speaks to real skill. If you’re hungry for something a little different, their vegetarian pies pack a garden’s worth of flavor. For me, it’s the freshness that sets Iavarone apart from the pack.
5. Previti Pizza and Papazzio Dining – West
Previti Pizza and Papazzio Dining – West delivers a slice of Manhattan flair right here in New Hyde Park. The space carries a welcoming energy, with an open layout that hints at the blend of fine dining and classic pizza joint. The first time I tried their pizza, I sat at the window and watched people marvel at the oversized slices arriving at every table.
What sets Previti apart is their approach to gourmet pies. Their Spinach Artichoke Pizza is the kind of dish that steals the show—rich, creamy, but balanced by a delicate crust. For those who like to mix it up, their lunch buffet lets you sample a range of inventive options. It’s a memorable spot for anyone serious about flavors.
6. Gino’s Trattoria & Pizzeria of New Hyde Park
Step into Gino’s Trattoria & Pizzeria and you’ll feel like you’ve stumbled on a cozy family secret—one that’s been simmering for decades. I first came in after a long train ride, and instantly appreciated the warm welcome and the easy hum of conversation filling the room.
What puts Gino’s on the map is its commitment to classic Northern Italian flavors. The Traditional Cheese Pizza offers a thin, golden crust and sauce that tastes like it’s been simmering all morning. For those looking to branch out, the Vegetarian Pie arrives loaded with colorful vegetables, all perfectly fresh. With every bite, you taste the attention to detail and the genuine passion that shapes every pie.
7. Gigi’s Pizzeria
There’s something instantly inviting about Gigi’s Pizzeria—the kind of spot where laughter and the scent of fresh dough fill the air. During my first visit, I found myself lingering over a second slice, unconcerned with time. The space is uncomplicated, focusing instead on doing the basics beautifully.
Gigi’s wins you over with its flavorful, perfectly charred crust. Their classic cheese pizza is the kind you remember long after you’ve left, with a sauce that’s just the right side of tangy and cheese that pulls away in satisfyingly long strings. For those seeking something lighter, try their vegetable pie—bursting with seasonal, crisp toppings that never overwhelm. This pizzeria is all about simple pleasures, done right.
8. Alessio Pizzeria and Restaurant
+1 516-326-2953
Alessio Pizzeria and Restaurant is where straightforward pizza cravings meet a laid-back, welcoming vibe. The first time I popped in, I caught a glimpse of the pizza makers tossing dough with an ease that can only come from years in the business. It’s the kind of neighborhood joint that quietly keeps regulars coming back.
The pizza here is always fresh and full of classic flavor. A slice of their regular cheese pizza says everything you need to know—thin crust, just enough sauce, and a satisfying layer of golden cheese. For something extra, their Sicilian pie stands out, known for its pillowy, airy base and generous portions. Alessio delivers consistency along with that “just right” New York slice every time.
9. Angoletto Cafe
Angoletto Cafe feels like a best-kept secret for anyone craving homemade flavors and a homey atmosphere. On my last visit, a friendly buzz filled the air as locals dropped by for both quick slices and long, relaxed dinners. There’s an attention to detail here that never feels fussy, only inviting.
Their personal Margherita pizza is pure comfort—chewy crust with just the right touch of char, topped with real mozzarella and fresh basil. For variety, their vegetarian pies are colorful and thoughtfully loaded, making each bite taste like summer. Whether you’re in for a single slice or a sit-down meal, Angoletto’s warm hospitality and classic flavors make it a neighborhood staple.
10. Piccolo Gourmet
Piccolo Gourmet is what happens when a classic deli meets a neighborhood pizzeria. I wandered in one afternoon for a slice and found myself tempted by a menu that’s as full of personality as the staff. The setting is always buzzing—families picking up dinner, friends splitting a pizza, and regulars chatting with the cooks behind the counter.
Their Grandma pizza is the headliner: square-cut, crisp-edged, and topped with a generous helping of fresh tomato and basil. When I’m in the mood for something light yet satisfying, their vegetable slice does the trick. Piccolo stands out for keeping things fresh, making every pie and sandwich feel like a local tradition in the making.
More Things to Try in New Hyde Park, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated pizza places in New Hyde Park, NY?
Some of the local favorites include Umberto’s, Mama Theresa’s, Eddie’s Pizza, Iavarone Italian Kitchen + Pizzeria, and Gino’s Trattoria & Pizzeria. Each spot has its own style, so trying a few is part of the fun.
Is there vegetarian or vegan pizza available in New Hyde Park?
Yes, many pizzerias like Angoletto Cafe and Umberto’s offer vegetarian and even some vegan pizza options. You can also find a variety of veggie toppings almost everywhere.
Who serves the best thin-crust pizza in town?
Eddie’s Pizza is famous for its ultra-thin bar pies—a signature local favorite. Other places like Gigi’s also serve thin and crispy pies worth tasting.
Are there gluten-free pizza options?
Several places, including Umberto’s and Iavarone Italian Kitchen + Pizzeria, offer gluten-free pizza crusts. Call ahead to confirm since availability may change.
Do local pizzerias offer delivery or takeout?
Almost all the top pizza spots in New Hyde Park, like Mama Theresa’s, Alessio, and Angoletto Cafe, provide delivery and takeout options, making it easy to enjoy pizza at home.
Which pizza places are best for families or larger groups?
Umberto’s and Gino’s Trattoria both have spacious dining rooms and a family-friendly vibe—great for group dinners or celebrations where pizza is the star.