If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in New City, NY, you’re not alone. For years, I’ve tried pies from brick ovens tucked beside busy streets and family recipes passed down like hidden treasures. Few things compare to that moment of anticipation when a hot, cheesy slice lands on your plate, the aroma hinting at both tradition and creativity. This town may look quiet, but its pizza scene is anything but sleepy.
Deciding where to grab your next slice shouldn’t feel like a gamble. Some pie joints here lean classic, while others get creative without losing touch with quality. This guide gives you the inside scoop, from smoky crusts to endlessly stretchy mozzarella—each spot is worth your time, and I’ve included only those that make the cut for freshness, quality, and flavor. Whether you’re a devoted regular or new on the scene, you’ll find something on this list that stands out from the crowd.
Where to find the best pizza in New City, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in New City, NY:
- Rocco’s Family Restaurant
- Blu Fig
- Mille Luci New City New York
- Pakulas Pizza
- Napoli’s Pizza
- Ray’s Pizza and Restaurant
- Calabria Restaurant
- Norcina
- Domino’s Pizza
- Picciotto NYC
1. Rocco’s Family Restaurant
Rocco’s Family Restaurant sits right at the heart of Main Street, serving up pizza that feels both classic and new. The moment you walk in, the scent of baking dough and bubbling cheese instantly grabs your attention. I once ducked in on a rainy afternoon, expecting a quick bite. Instead, I lingered, drawn in by their perfect balance of crispy crust and generous toppings.
What sets Rocco’s apart is their dedication to quality. Whether you need a lunch break or a laid-back dinner, the menu has thoughtful options for everyone—including gluten-free and vegetarian choices.
Order the Margherita or Sicilian pie if you want to taste what Rocco’s does best. The sauce tastes fresh and bright, and the cheese melts just right. This spot is a must for pizza in New City, NY.
2. Blu Fig
Blu Fig offers pizza with a fresh twist, blending classic Italian flavor with a modern vibe. The dining room is bright and welcoming, making it just as great for a solo lunch as for a group dinner. I first stumbled in on a whim, only to be surprised by how much care went into each dish—especially the pizza, which came out bubbly and perfectly charred at the edges.
Blu Fig stands out with a menu that includes vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free pizza options. This inclusivity never sacrifices taste; every bite feels thoughtfully crafted and satisfying.
Try the Fig & Ricotta pizza for a mix of savory and sweet, or the classic Margherita for a simple, flawless slice. Each pie reflects Blu Fig’s knack for bold, balanced flavors.
3. Mille Luci New City New York
Mille Luci New City New York is a spot you might miss if you’re not looking closely, but its loyal fans know it’s worth stopping for. Cash only and cozy, the place trades frills for honest-to-goodness pizza. I dropped in one evening craving something basic, and found their pies spoke louder than any decor—just thin crust, fresh sauce, and gooey cheese.
This is where local tradition meets no-nonsense pizza-making. The menu isn’t sprawling, but it doesn’t need to be. Every order comes out hot and hearty.
Order a classic Cheese or veggie pie. The simplicity lets the flavors shine and shows off Mille Luci’s focus on getting the basics perfectly right—for anyone serious about great pizza in New City, NY.
4. Pakulas Pizza
+1 845-709-6609
Pakulas Pizza sits quietly on Little Tor Road but has built a reputation that stretches far beyond its address. Walking in, you catch the hum of locals chatting, all knowing they’ve found a go-to spot. I remember grabbing a pie for a family dinner—the crust had that signature chew and every layer of cheese felt just right.
Pakulas stands out for its homey hospitality and reliable quality. The menu strikes a clever balance between classic comfort and modern taste, accommodating a broad range of pizza lovers.
Try their White Pizza or classic Margherita. Both showcase a dough that’s crisp outside yet tender inside, with toppings that taste fresh and balanced. Each slice tells its own story, and none disappoints.
5. Napoli’s Pizza
Napoli’s Pizza is one of those neighborhood places where you know exactly what you’re getting—straightforward, no-fuss pizza that consistently hits the mark. The first time I stopped in, I was met with friendly faces, a tempting display of pies, and the timeless smell of fresh-baked crust. It felt like stepping into the heart of a local tradition.
What sets Napoli’s apart is their focus on quality ingredients and classic technique. Every order gets a crisp crust, tangy sauce, and plenty of cheese—no shortcuts here.
Order their classic Cheese Pizza or dive into a loaded Vegetable Pie. They both show off Napoli’s knack for balance and flavor, keeping loyal customers coming back for pizza in New City, NY.
6. Ray’s Pizza and Restaurant
Ray’s Pizza and Restaurant is a Main Street staple, known for serving up classic slices that keep locals coming back. Stepping into Ray’s, the vibe is laid-back but energetic, filled with the buzz of regulars who rarely leave unsatisfied. My first visit was on a Saturday afternoon—I ordered a pie to go and was met with a perfect blend of chewy crust and slightly sweet tomato sauce.
Ray’s stands out for its generous portions and friendly staff. Everything about the place feels genuine, from the service to the food itself, making it a true neighborhood spot.
The Grandma Pie and White Pizza are standouts. The Grandma features a rich, herby sauce, while the White Pizza brings together creamy cheese and golden edges. Both represent Ray’s at its best for pizza in New City, NY.
7. Calabria Restaurant
Calabria Restaurant brings a piece of Italy to South Main Street, with a focus on fresh, comforting flavors. The dining room is cozy and welcoming—a spot I found by chance on a bitterly cold night. The promise of stone-baked pizza lived up to the hype, each bite packed with a hint of wood-fired char and quality ingredients.
What makes Calabria stand out is their careful attention to every pie that leaves the oven. The menu covers the classics, but the flavors never feel routine.
Order the Margherita or a Vegetable Pizza. The Margherita highlights their rich tomato sauce and creamy cheese, while the veggie option brings out the flavor in every ingredient. Calabria captures how great pizza in New City, NY should taste.
8. Norcina
Norcina has carved out its own niche on North Main, serving up artisan pizza with a modern twist. The air is warm and lively, and you can’t help noticing the wood-fired oven at work. I stopped by for dinner on a whim and ended up marveling at the perfectly blistered crust and bold flavors in every bite.
Norcina stands out for its inventive menu and commitment to fresh, local ingredients. Pies here aren’t just food—they’re little works of art.
Order the White Pizza or Norcina’s signature Margherita. The White comes topped with a creamy blend of cheeses, while their Margherita transforms simplicity into something special. Norcina proves that pizza in New City, NY can be both traditional and inspired.
9. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on South Main may be a national name, but here it wins points for consistency and speed. I’ve dashed in more than once to grab a quick dinner after a long day. No matter when you order, you get the same hot, cheesy pizza and a crispy crust that’s always reliable.
What makes Domino’s stand out is its range and convenience. If you want a classic pie or something a little different, you don’t have to wait long.
Try the Thin Crust if you like a foldable slice or go for the Handmade Pan Pizza for extra thickness. Their Margherita-style or veggie pizzas are both flavorful and satisfying, showing Domino’s can do more than just fast food in New City, NY.
10. Picciotto NYC
Picciotto NYC isn’t your typical pizza joint—it’s a mobile experience that brings Sicilian street food right to New City. The first time I stopped at their truck, the aroma alone promised something special. Every slice had a rustic, square-cut charm, and the flavors took me straight to Palermo without ever leaving Main Street.
The star at Picciotto NYC is their authentic approach and focus on Sicilian specialties. You’ll find rare treats like sfincione and veggie-filled buns that stand out in a crowd of regular pies.
Order the classic Sicilian square or try the sfincione for a real taste of Sicily. Each pizza layers bold tomato sauce, onions, and thick, pillowy crust—proof that Picciotto NYC offers a one-of-a-kind experience for pizza in New City, NY.
More Things to Try in New City, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most popular pizza style in New City, NY?
Most pizzerias in New City focus on classic New York-style and Sicilian pies, known for their crisp crust and foldable slices. A few spots offer artisan takes, like wood-fired or specialty veggie pies.
Are there gluten-free or vegan pizza options in New City?
Yes. Many local favorites, including Blu Fig and Rocco’s Family Restaurant, offer gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese options, so everyone can enjoy a slice.
Where can I find the best vegetarian pizza in New City?
Blu Fig, Norcina, and Calabria Restaurant are top choices. Each offers inventive veggie combinations and uses fresh ingredients for bright, bold flavors.
Which pizza places in New City offer delivery or takeout?
Almost all. Domino’s, Rocco’s Family Restaurant, Pakulas Pizza, and Napoli’s Pizza offer reliable delivery and takeout. A few food trucks and specialty shops stick to takeout only, but there are plenty of options for convenience.
Can you get authentic Italian-style pizza in New City?
Definitely. Norcina and Calabria both specialize in Italian recipes, with stone-baked and wood-fired crusts. For something different, Picciotto NYC serves up true Sicilian street food pies.