If you’ve ever wandered through downtown New Bern with the scent of wood-fired crust trailing behind you, you know this town takes its pizza seriously. I still remember ducking into a cozy spot off Metcalf Street on a rainy afternoon, expecting something passable—and walking out with a new favorite slice. That first bite was a revelation: crisp edges, balanced sauce, and cheese that didn’t overwhelm. Since then, I’ve made it a mission to explore every pizza joint in town, from family-run gems to familiar chains. New Bern’s pizza scene is surprisingly diverse, and if you know where to look, you’ll find pies that rival big-city favorites.
This guide is built for those who want more than just a quick bite. Whether you’re craving a classic margherita, a deep-dish indulgence, or something with a local twist, you’ll find the right spot without wasting time. I’ve sifted through reviews, menus, and personal experiences to highlight the best pizza places in New Bern, NC—each with its own flavor, story, and loyal following. So if you’re ready to discover where the crust is golden and the toppings are thoughtfully chosen, keep reading. Your next favorite pizza might be just a few blocks away.
Where to find the best pizza in New Bern, NC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in New Bern, NC:
- Savage’s Wood Burning Pizzeria
- Sara’s Big Apple
- Beartown Bistro & Pizza Company
- Famous Subs & Pizza
- Big Apple Pizza
- La Casetta
- Panichellis Pizzeria
- Thirty Seventh Street Pizzaria
- Gina’s Pizza
- Mario’s Pizza
1. Savage’s Wood Burning Pizzeria
(252) 672-0103Call
There’s something unmistakably satisfying about the crackle of a wood-fired crust, and Savage’s Wood Burning Pizzeria delivers that experience with quiet confidence. Tucked into downtown New Bern, this unpretentious spot has become a local favorite for its authentic New York-style pies cooked in a genuine brick oven fueled by oak and hickory. The aroma alone is enough to draw you in, but it’s the flavor that keeps you coming back.
What sets Savage’s apart is its balance of tradition and creativity. The Greek Vegetarian pizza is a standout—loaded with caramelized onions, roasted red peppers, Kalamata olives, and feta, it’s a flavorful option that doesn’t rely on meat to impress. If you’re in the mood for something heartier, try The Big Savage, a smoky, savory blend of grilled chicken, bacon, and barbecue sauce that hits all the right notes.
On my last visit, I grabbed a slice of the Margherita and a side of garlic knots. The crust was crisp but not dry, the sauce tangy without being overpowering, and the fresh basil added just the right touch. It’s the kind of place where even a quick lunch feels like a small indulgence. Service is fast, the vibe is relaxed, and the food is consistently solid.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Savage’s is worth a stop. It’s not flashy, but it doesn’t need to be. The pizza speaks for itself.
2. Sara’s Big Apple
(252) 636-2555Call
At Sara’s Big Apple, the menu reads like a love letter to comfort food, but it’s the pizza that anchors everything. Tucked away on Broad Creek Road, this spot blends the charm of a neighborhood joint with the ambition of a full-scale Italian kitchen. The crust is soft with just enough chew, the sauce leans slightly sweet, and the cheese is always generous. It’s the kind of place where you can walk in hungry and leave with leftovers—and no regrets.
What makes Sara’s stand out is its range. You can grab a classic cheese slice or go bold with their White Pizza topped with spinach and ricotta. On my last visit, I tried the Pepperoni Wheel—crispy, cheesy, and just indulgent enough to feel like a treat. It’s not just pizza here, but the pizza is what keeps people talking.
The vibe is casual, the service is quick, and the portions are generous. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, Sara’s Big Apple delivers consistency and flavor. It’s a reliable go-to when you want something satisfying without the fuss.
If you’re exploring pizza in New Bern, this one deserves a spot on your list. It’s not trying to be trendy—it’s just good.
3. Beartown Bistro & Pizza Company
Beartown Bistro & Pizza Company offers a refreshing twist on classic pizza, set in the friendly James City neighborhood. During my visit, I was impressed by how the aroma of freshly baked pies fills the air, promising a satisfying meal. The restaurant combines a relaxed atmosphere with a menu that balances pizza perfection and hearty American fare.
What makes Beartown stand out is its commitment to quality ingredients and creative toppings. I recommend trying the Seafood Pizza, layered with shrimp and scallops, which showcases their expertise and dedication. The Margherita slice is a crisp, flavorful favorite for simplicity and freshness.
Perfect for casual dining or takeout, Beartown Bistro & Pizza Company impresses with consistent flavor and a welcoming vibe. It’s a must-visit for those seeking genuine, well-crafted pizza in New Bern.
4. Famous Subs & Pizza
Famous Subs & Pizza on Neuse Boulevard is more than a pizza joint—it’s a local institution with a full-service kitchen and an in-house bakery. The scent of fresh dough and artisan bread hits you before you even step inside. It’s the kind of place where regulars are greeted by name and newcomers feel instantly welcome.
What sets Famous apart is its blend of Mediterranean flair and classic Italian-American comfort. The pizza crust is crisp yet chewy, with just the right char. I tried the Greek Pizza, topped with kalamata olives, feta, and fresh tomatoes—it was a standout for its balance of tang and richness.
If you’re craving something hearty, the Meat Lovers Pizza delivers without overwhelming. It’s a great spot for a casual meal that doesn’t cut corners on quality.
5. Big Apple Pizza
Tucked inside the New Bern Mall, Big Apple Pizza delivers big flavor without the big-city fuss. It’s the kind of place where the slices are generous, the crust is golden, and the sauce tastes like someone’s Nonna still stirs it by hand.
I stopped in for a quick bite and ended up staying longer than planned. The Special Pizza, loaded with nine toppings, was a standout—balanced, not overloaded, and baked just right. Their Greek Pizza, with fresh spinach, garlic, and feta, brings a lighter, flavorful twist.
What sets them apart? Consistency and value. You get quality ingredients, friendly service, and prices that don’t make you blink. For a casual, satisfying pizza fix in New Bern, this spot hits the mark.
6. La Casetta
Hidden in the Town Park Plaza, La Casetta offers a refined taste of Italy in New Bern. From the moment you step inside, the aroma of freshly made pasta and simmering sauces transports you straight to a trattoria in Rome. The kitchen’s star is Chef Francesco, whose dedication to authentic, homemade dishes shines through every plate.
On my visit, I was drawn to their Homemade Sugar-Free Pasta, perfectly al dente and paired with a robust marinara. Their Margherita Pizza displays a light, crisp crust topped with fresh basil and mozzarella, embodying simplicity and quality.
What makes La Casetta stand out is its focus on genuine ingredients, paired with an elegant ambiance. It’s a special place for anyone craving true Italian flavors in a cozy setting.
7. Panichellis Pizzeria
Tucked beside the Trent River, Panichelli’s Pizzeria delivers classic Italian comfort with a made-from-scratch promise. The dough is hand-prepared daily, and it shows. Every slice feels like it was made with intention.
What stood out to me was the Pepperoni and Mushroom Pie, where the crust was crisp, the toppings fresh, and the flavor balanced. It wasn’t trying to be trendy—it was just good pizza, done right.
Homemade mozzarella sticks pair well with any order, and their hand-cut salads offer a refreshing contrast to the hearty mains. The vibe is casual, but the food? Anything but careless.
If you’re after pizza in New Bern that leans into fresh ingredients and Italian simplicity, this pizzeria gets it right.
8. Thirty Seventh Street Pizzaria
Thirty Seventh Street Pizzaria is a charming Italian restaurant located at 2402 Neuse Blvd, New Bern, NC. Known for its cozy ambiance and authentic flavors, it’s a local favorite for both casual dining and special occasions. With wheelchair accessibility, free parking, and a welcoming atmosphere, it’s a spot where everyone feels at home.
What sets Thirty Seventh Street Pizzaria apart is its dedication to fresh, high-quality ingredients and its emphasis on delicious, handcrafted pizzas. Their menu showcases a delightful fusion of Italian, Continental, and European cuisines, offering something for everyone. The price range is below average, making it an affordable indulgence for families and friends.
If you visit, don’t miss their signature Margherita Pizza, a simple yet flavorful masterpiece that highlights their fresh dough and tomato sauce. The Vegetarian Pizza and the Mediterranean Special are also worth trying for their rich, satisfying toppings. Each bite reflects the pizzeria’s passion for excellence.
Whether you’re craving a hearty slice or a lighter Italian dish, Thirty Seventh Street Pizzaria is a must-visit in New Bern, NC. Their warm service and mouthwatering menu make every visit memorable.
9. Gina’s Pizza
Located on Highway 70 in James City, Gina’s Pizza offers a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere with a focus on authentic Italian flavors. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible and provides free parking, making it an easy choice for a quick, satisfying meal. The friendly staff and inviting environment make every visit feel like coming home.
What makes Gina’s stand out is its consistent quality and variety. Their Meat Lovers Pizza packs plenty of savory toppings, while the Vegetarian Pizza showcases fresh, colorful ingredients. Each pie is made with care, reflecting their commitment to authentic, flavorful pizza.
My personal favorite is the Margherita Pizza, with its simple yet perfectly balanced combination of tomato, mozzarella, and basil. It’s a testament to Gina’s dedication to quality ingredients and authentic Italian preparation.
For a dependable, delicious pizza experience in New Bern, Gina’s is a choice you can count on.
10. Mario’s Pizza
(252) 633-0836Call
Mario’s Pizza on S Glenburnie Road delivers what many in New Bern crave—authentic New York-style pizza with crisp edges and bold flavor. An extension of its original Havelock location, this family-run spot blends comfort and consistency in every bite.
What sets Mario’s apart is its perfectly balanced crust-to-cheese ratio and no-frills charm. It’s the kind of place where your favorite booth feels like yours, and the staff already knows your order.
The stromboli and classic pepperoni pie steal the show, but don’t overlook their veggie pizza, loaded and never soggy. Each slice tastes like it was crafted with intention.
If you’re after pizza that feels familiar but still excites, Mario’s gets it right—no fuss, just flavorful, straightforward Italian cooking.
More Things to Try in New Bern, NC
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is the best pizza place in New Bern, NC?
It depends on your taste, but Savage’s Wood Burning Pizzeria is often praised for its artisan crust and wood-fired flavor. For classic New York-style slices, Sara’s Big Apple and Mario’s Pizza are local favorites.
2. Are there any halal or vegetarian pizza options in New Bern?
Yes, several spots like Beartown Bistro & Pizza Company and Gina’s Pizza offer vegetarian-friendly pizzas. While halal options are limited, it’s best to call ahead and ask about custom orders without pork or alcohol-based ingredients.
3. Who serves the most authentic Italian pizza in New Bern?
La Casetta and Paula’s Italian Restaurant & Pizza are known for their traditional Italian recipes, including thin crusts, fresh tomato sauce, and house-made dough.
4. Where can I find gluten-free pizza in New Bern?
Domino’s Pizza, Papa Johns, and Pizza Hut offer gluten-free crusts. For a more local touch, check with Thirty Seventh Street Pizzaria or Panichellis Pizzeria—they sometimes offer gluten-free options upon request.
5. What’s the most affordable pizza in New Bern?
Chains like Little Caesars, CiCi’s Pizza, and Hunt Brothers Pizza are known for budget-friendly deals. For value and flavor, Famous Subs & Pizza also delivers solid portions at a fair price.
6. Are there any late-night pizza spots in New Bern?
Yes, Domino’s Pizza and Papa Johns typically stay open later than most local spots. Always check their hours online, as they may vary by day.
7. Which pizza places offer delivery in New Bern?
Most major chains like Domino’s, Pizza Hut, Papa Johns, and Little Caesars offer delivery through their apps or third-party services. Some local favorites like Mario’s Pizza and Big Apple Pizza also deliver.
8. Where can I find pizza with the best crust in New Bern?
Savage’s Wood Burning Pizzeria is known for its crispy, charred crust, while Sara’s Big Apple delivers a chewy, foldable base that fans of New York-style pizza love.
9. Is there a pizza buffet in New Bern?
Yes, CiCi’s Pizza offers a pizza buffet with a wide variety of flavors, including vegetarian options and dessert pizzas.
10. What’s the most popular pizza topping in New Bern?
Pepperoni still reigns supreme, but veggie combos and extra cheese are close contenders. Most places allow full customization to suit your preferences.