There’s something quietly magical about pizza in Nacogdoches, TX. The city holds a charm that translates directly into its food—and the pizza scene here is more than a mix of chains and local kitchens. It’s a patchwork of family traditions, bold flavors, and reliable favorites that suit everything from midnight cravings to laid-back dinners with friends. I’ve spent late nights chasing the warm scent of freshly baked crust, and midday lunches sampling slices where the sauce tells a story. Whether you’re into thin crusts, wood-fired ovens, or loaded specialties, Nacogdoches serves up pizza worth slowing down for.
This guide isn’t just a list. It’s curated from hours of taste testing, chats with staff, and exploring menus that offer more than just pepperoni and cheese. Each spot on this list earned its place, not through flashy promotions, but through consistent quality and community love. From old-school places that keep it simple to newer spots redefining what pizza can be, you’ll find something here that suits your tastes—and might even surprise you. Let’s get into the dough, so to speak.
Where to find the best pizza in Nacogdoches, TX
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Nacogdoches, TX:
- Napoli’s Pizza & Restaurant
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Little Caesars
- Pizza Hut
- Cicis Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Salma’s Pizza And Indian Restaurant
- Newk’s Eatery
- Little Caesars Pizza
- CiCi’s Pizza
1. Napoli’s Pizza & Restaurant
Napoli’s Pizza & Restaurant blends cozy atmosphere with old-world charm. When I first stepped inside, I was greeted with aromas that reminded me of a wood-fired kitchen tucked away in a quiet Italian neighborhood. It’s one of those places where the tables are filled with families and the servers know the regulars by name.
Napoli’s stands out for its thoughtful balance of quality and comfort. Their pizzas are crafted with care—crispy crusts, rich sauce, and generous toppings without overpowering the whole. Vegetarian and vegan options are woven seamlessly into the menu, showing their attention to inclusive tastes.
The Margherita is a must-try. Simple, fresh, and delicately layered with mozzarella and basil, it’s Napoli’s understated strength. For something heartier, the Veggie Lovers offers depth in flavor without sacrificing freshness. Their dough and sauce alone earn respect.
If you’re looking for authentic flavor in a laid-back setting, Napoli’s is a solid contender. It’s the kind of spot that reminds you why some places stay favorites year after year.
2. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza in Nacogdoches, TX, exemplifies a commitment to using better ingredients for better pizza. During a quiet evening visit, I was impressed by the aroma of its signature sauce and the fresh toppings that made each slice feel thoughtfully crafted. It’s a place where quality shines through each bite.
What sets Papa Johns apart is their focus on simplicity paired with premium ingredients. Their original dough, combined with flavorful sauces and generous toppings, results in a consistently satisfying slice. It’s a go-to for those craving reliable pizza that’s made with care.
If you’re unsure what to order, the Classic Pepperoni or the Pepperoni-Spicy Italian are tried-and-true choices that showcase the brand’s quality. For a complete meal, pairing with garlic knots or wings enhances the experience, making it perfect for any occasion.
3. Little Caesars
Little Caesars in Nacogdoches, TX, is known for its quick service and affordable, hot pizza. I visited on a busy evening and was surprised at how fast my order was ready—perfect for a casual, no-fuss dinner. The warm scent of melting cheese and freshly baked crust made it hard to resist.
What makes Little Caesars stand out is their focus on convenience and value. Their iconic “Hot-N-Ready” pizzas provide a fresh, satisfying option without the wait, ideal for those on a tight schedule.
If you’re ordering, the Deep!Deep Dish Pepperoni or the classic Cheese Pizza are dependable choices that reflect the brand’s straightforward style. Pair it with their garlic or butter sauce for a simple, flavorful meal that hits the spot every time.
4. Pizza Hut
During a family gathering in Nacogdoches, I ordered from Pizza Hut, and it proved to be the perfect choice for shared comfort food. The familiar aroma of baked crust and tasty toppings brought everyone to the table with anticipation. It’s a spot that combines convenience with a touch of nostalgia.
Pizza Hut stands out with its signature stuffed crust and classic flavors. Their Meat Lovers® special offers a hearty, satisfying bite, while the original stuffed crust adds an extra layer of indulgence that’s hard to beat. It’s consistent quality that keeps bringing people back.
If you’re undecided, the Hut Favorite Pepperoni or Veggie Lover’s pizzas are reliable picks. Pair them with their signature wings or cheesy bread for a well-rounded, satisfying meal that reflects Pizza Hut’s reputation for hearty, flavorful pizza.
5. Cicis Pizza
Cicis Pizza in Nacogdoches offers a budget-friendly, all-you-can-eat experience that’s hard to match. Whether you’re there for a casual lunch or winding down over dinner, the buffet lineup delivers variety without compromise.
On a weekday visit, I found the thin-crust pepperoni surprisingly flavorful—crispy edges with a well-seasoned sauce. The mac & cheese pizza, a fan favorite, is unconventional but satisfying, especially when paired with a plate of salad from their bar.
What sets Cicis apart is its emphasis on customization and value. You’re not confined to a menu; you explore. Kids love the dessert pizza, while regulars lean toward classics like the zesty supreme or the meat-eater’s combo—each consistent and well-balanced.
For pizza lovers seeking variety in Nacogdoches, Cicis is a reliable and lively stop.
6. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut at 3102 N University Dr offers a dependable spot for familiar flavors. When I stopped by for dinner, the atmosphere was calm, and the staff didn’t rush you through a quick order—something rare in chain dining.
Their Original Stuffed Crust® remains a winner. It’s indulgent in all the right ways, with that signature cheese pull wrapped in a crispy base. For something hearty, the Meat Lovers® packs in enough savory punch to satisfy a late-night craving without tipping into excess.
What sets this location apart is the consistency. Every pie lands with balanced toppings, no awkward slices. If you’re planning takeout, curbside service is surprisingly quick and smooth.
In Nacogdoches, Pizza Hut earns its place as a go-to for comfort and straightforward taste.
7. Salma’s Pizza And Indian Restaurant
Inside Walmart Supercenter, Salma’s Pizza And Indian Restaurant presents a refreshing blend of American comfort and Indian spice. My visit was a surprise—a place that offers more than just standard pizza, with aromas of curry and freshly baked crust filling the air. It’s a spot that invites curiosity and comfort.
What makes Salma’s stand out is its unique fusion of flavors. Their creamy Chicken Biryani and flavorful Samosas are authentic, while their pizzas feature inventive toppings that reflect a fusion twist—crisp, well-balanced, and satisfying. The Butter Chicken pizza, in particular, is a must-try for its rich, velvety sauce combined with a classic crust.
If you’re in Nacogdoches, exploring this place means experiencing a creative menu that honors tradition while embracing innovation. For a taste of both worlds, their Jeera Basmati Rice pairs well with any dish, offering a complete and flavorful meal.
8. Newk’s Eatery
During a recent lunch visit to Newk’s Eatery in Nacogdoches, I was greeted with a warm, inviting atmosphere that instantly made me feel at home. The open kitchen design added a sense of transparency and comfort, as I watched chefs craft each dish with care. The menu offers a delightful mix of classics and innovative creations.
What makes Newk’s stand out is its focus on quality ingredients and diverse options. Their crispy, made-to-order pizza features fresh toppings and a perfectly baked crust, reflecting a commitment to excellence. The salads are vibrant and packed with flavor, perfect for those seeking lighter fare.
If you’re trying to decide, the Margherita Pizza highlights simple, fresh ingredients, while the Veggie & Pesto Pizza offers a creative twist. Pair it with a hearty soup for a satisfying meal that showcases Newk’s dedication to flavor and freshness.
9. Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars Pizza on North Street in Nacogdoches delivers exactly what it promises: fast, affordable, and consistently satisfying pizza. On a recent visit, I grabbed a Hot-N-Ready Pepperoni and was out the door in under five minutes. The crust had that signature crunch, and the cheese—a blend of 100% Mozzarella and Muenster—was perfectly melted.
What sets this spot apart is its Pizza Portal® pickup, which makes grabbing a meal feel almost futuristic. No waiting, no fuss—just in and out with a hot box of comfort food.
If you’re unsure what to try, go for the ExtraMostBestest® Cheese or Pepperoni Pizza. It’s a mouthful in name and flavor, offering more cheese and toppings than their regular pies without breaking the bank.
10. CiCi’s Pizza
My visit to Cicis Pizza in Nacogdoches was an enjoyable experience of endless variety. The all-you-can-eat buffet allows you to sample multiple flavors—perfect for those who want diversity without the hassle of multiple orders. The lively atmosphere and friendly staff made the meal even more inviting.
What makes Cicis unique is its focus on variety and value. The pizza options are plentiful, from classic cheese and pepperoni to specialty pies. Their fresh salads and desserts complement the pizzas well, creating a complete, satisfying meal.
If you’re undecided, the Buffet Plate with different pizza slices or the Build-Your-Own Pizza station lets you customize your experience. It’s a fun way to indulge in a wide range of flavors under one roof.
More Things to Try in Nacogdoches, TX
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the best pizza place in Nacogdoches, TX?
A: The best pizza spot depends on your taste, but popular choices include Napoli’s for authentic Italian-style pizza and Pizza Hut for classic favorites with consistent quality.
Q: Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Nacogdoches?
A: Yes. Many local places like Napoli’s and Cicis offer vegetarian options, and some restaurants, such as Salma’s Pizza and Indian Restaurant, provide vegan-friendly dishes too.
Q: Do local pizza places offer delivery or takeout?
A: Most establishments, including Domino’s, Papa Johns, and Little Caesars, provide both delivery and takeout services for added convenience.
Q: Are there gluten-free pizza options available in Nacogdoches?
A: Yes, some restaurants like Newk’s Eatery and Cicis offer gluten-free crusts, catering to dietary preferences while maintaining great flavor.
Q: Which pizza restaurants in Nacogdoches are family-friendly?
A: Places like Cicis and Little Caesars are perfect for families, offering buffet-style options or quick, affordable slices suitable for all ages.