If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Myrtle Beach, you’re not alone. This coastal town draws plenty of sun-seekers, but the locals know there’s more to Myrtle than the shoreline. The scent of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese drifts from dozens of kitchens here, each pie with its own loyal following. Pizza isn’t just a meal in Myrtle Beach; it’s practically a sport, and everyone thinks they know the champion.
I’ve spent more hours than I can admit weaving through beach traffic for a good slice. I know the places where crust is king, sauce is sacred, and locals judge you if you use a fork. Let me steer you through the pizzerias that rise above the rest—from family-owned spots to legends imported straight from New York. If you’re ready for an honest, no-fluff guide, your Myrtle Beach pizza adventure starts here.
Where to find the best pizza in Myrtle Beach, SC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Myrtle Beach, SC:
- AJ’s Pizza
- Little Italy
- Hot Tomato
- Vicini’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
- Mellow Mushroom
- Capriccio
- Ultimate California Pizza
- Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria
- Toffino’s Italian Bakery Deli Pizza
- Michael’s Pizza, Pasta and Grill
1. AJ’s Pizza
AJ’s Pizza keeps things simple, quick, and delicious. This spot is tucked along N Kings Highway but it never feels like just another slice joint. There’s a loyal crowd—locals and visitors alike—because AJ’s puts freshness first.
What stands out is the clear dedication to quality. The crust has that tender, chewy bite and the sauce tastes like someone’s nonna made it this morning. AJ’s is one of those rare places where even a classic cheese pizza feels special. The Margherita and Veggie Lovers pies are favorites, both packed with flavor and layers of fresh toppings.
If you’re looking for something besides the usual, grab the gluten-free or vegan options—AJ’s welcomes every kind of craving. Delivery’s fast and the staff make you feel like a regular from the first order.
2. Little Italy
Little Italy brings a slice of Old World charm right to Myrtle Beach. The atmosphere feels more like a tucked-away trattoria in Rome than a beachside restaurant. You can almost hear the chef’s accent in every perfectly balanced bite.
What sets Little Italy apart is their attention to detail. Their dough is airy and light, and the toppings—pearled mozzarella, sun-bright tomatoes, and roasted veggies—are fresh each day. I’ve lost count of how many people I’ve recommended to order the Veggie Delight or the classic Margherita. Both pies highlight the way Little Italy blends tradition with coastal freshness.
If you like variety, the menu includes vegan and gluten-free pizzas, too. Pair your meal with a glass of wine, and you’ll see why locals keep this spot on their radar.
3. Hot Tomato
Hot Tomato delivers that classic New York brick oven flavor right by the sea. Walk in and you’ll notice two things: the scent of slow-rising dough and a kitchen crew with serious pizza energy. The vibe is casual, but the food means business.
The crust sets Hot Tomato apart. It’s slightly charred from the brick oven, with just the right amount of chew—a sign they take their craft seriously. Try the Margherita or the Veggie Supreme; both are layered with fresh, flavorful toppings and baked to golden perfection. Each bite delivers the ideal balance of sauce, cheese, and crunch.
Hot Tomato also keeps things interesting with chef specials and gluten-free options. The happy hour deals and inviting atmosphere make this a spot you’ll want to revisit, whether you’re craving pizza for lunch or rounding off a day at the beach.
4. Vicini’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
Vicini’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria has earned a loyal following for good reason. Tucked in a modest strip plaza, this place proves that real Italian cooking doesn’t need flash—just authentic recipes and plenty of heart. The kitchen’s dedication to quality shines through in every pizza that leaves the oven.
The Margherita pizza is a standout, with a crust that’s crispy at the edges and soft in the center. The sauce is bright and simple, and the mozzarella is always fresh. If you’re after something with deeper flavor, the Veggie pizza holds its own with lush, roasted toppings piled high.
Vicini’s offers gluten-free and vegan options, so everyone can join in on the experience. Service is warm and attentive, making it easy to see why diners keep coming back for another slice.
5. Mellow Mushroom
Mellow Mushroom is more than just a pizza place—it’s a local institution with an unmistakable vibe. The art-covered walls and energetic music set the mood for a casual meal, but it’s really the creative pizzas that steal the show. Every visit here feels like walking into a neighborhood hangout where quality matters.
The crust is the star, made with spring water for a soft, chewy base that holds up to bold toppings. My go-to? The Kosmic Karma or Veg Out pizza. Both pile on fresh vegetables and creamy cheese in a way that never feels heavy, just satisfying.
Mellow Mushroom offers gluten-free and vegan options, and the staff knows their way around dietary requests. If you’re hunting for creative combinations and a laid-back setting, this spot stands apart from the crowd.
6. Capriccio
Capriccio brings true Southern Italian flair to Myrtle Beach, blending traditional recipes with a cozy, welcoming spirit. There’s a sincerity to every bite—each sauce, dough, and topping made with care and real skill in the kitchen. Even the aroma as you walk in is promising.
What gives Capriccio its devoted following is their hand-tossed New York style pizza. The sauce is house-made and bright, while the crust lands that perfect balance of crisp and chewy. The classic Veggie is a must, stacked high with fresh produce, or try their Sicilian for a different spin on tradition.
The menu stays friendly for all, offering vegan and gluten-free options. If you crave authentic pizza with a dash of Italian hospitality, Capriccio is the place to seek out.
7. Ultimate California Pizza
Ultimate California Pizza puts a fresh, West Coast spin on the Myrtle Beach pizza scene. It’s the kind of place where creativity trumps tradition and customization is the norm. Whether you like your pizza classic or offbeat, there’s something here for every palate.
The Big Sur and Berkeley pizzas stand out. Both are loaded with bold flavors and generous toppings—a nod to California’s adventurous approach to pizza-making. The crust options range from classic Italian to gluten-free and vegan, so everyone gets a seat at the table.
This spot also wins points for its upbeat, friendly vibe and fast service. If you enjoy trying new combinations or just want an easygoing meal with friends, Ultimate California Pizza delivers every time.
8. Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria
Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria captures the spirit of classic Italian comfort but knows how to make it fit right into the Myrtle Beach vibe. The dining room feels like a neighborhood kitchen, and the staff treat you like you’ve just come home for dinner. Locals rave about this spot, and it’s easy to see why once you try a slice.
The Cheese Pizza is legendary here. It arrives hot, with a crisp yet chewy crust and just the right amount of gooey mozzarella. If you’re in the mood for something loaded, go for the Veggie pie—there’s plenty of fresh produce, and you can taste the quality in every bite.
Ducatis is friendly to different diets, offering vegan and vegetarian options. The consistent quality and warm service mean you can count on a satisfying meal every time.
9. Toffino’s Italian Bakery Deli Pizza
Toffino’s Italian Bakery Deli Pizza is a true Myrtle Beach gem. Their roots in old-world baking are obvious from the moment you walk in—bread, pastries, and pizza all share the spotlight here. The staff have a knack for making guests feel right at home while serving up irresistible aromas.
Their classic cheese and veggie pizzas are local standouts. The crust is thin, lightly crisped, and topped with a generous spread of homemade sauce. Each ingredient feels carefully chosen, and it shows in the taste.
Toffino’s is also a great pick for anyone with dietary needs, thanks to vegan and gluten-free options. If you want pizza with an authentic Italian bakery spin, this place is not to be missed.
10. Michael’s Pizza, Pasta and Grill
Michael’s Pizza, Pasta and Grill channels that laid-back, classic pizzeria feel that regulars love. After more than three decades, this spot has become a local standard—dependable, cozy, and always buzzing with happy diners. The menu is a blend of New York pizzaiolo tradition and familiar Italian comfort.
The NY-style cheese and veggie pizzas are always on point. The crust is thin yet sturdy, with just enough chew to stand up to a bubbling layer of cheese. I’m a fan of their Veggie Supreme, stacked with fresh mushrooms, peppers, and onions. There’s clear attention to the balance of flavors in every bite.
Michael’s offers gluten-free options and a casual patio for those breezy beach nights. Friendly, fast service means you can count on a satisfying experience each visit.
More Things to Try in Myrtle Beach, SC
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Myrtle Beach?
Some of the most recommended spots include AJ’s Pizza, Little Italy, Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria, Vicini’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria, and Ultimate California Pizza. These places are known for their unique flavors, great service, and local favorites.
Do pizzerias in Myrtle Beach offer vegan or gluten-free options?
Yes, many pizza shops such as Mellow Mushroom, Capriccio, and Toffino’s Italian Bakery Deli Pizza provide both vegan and gluten-free choices. It’s a good idea to check the menu or call ahead if you have specific dietary requirements.
Can I find New York–style pizza in Myrtle Beach?
Absolutely. Spots like Michael’s Pizza, Pasta and Grill, Hot Tomato, and Dough Boys NY Style Pizzeria specialize in authentic, foldable New York–style pies.
Which places offer pizza delivery in Myrtle Beach?
Most local and chain pizzerias, including AJ’s Pizza, Michael’s Pizza, and Domino’s, offer delivery. You can also use popular delivery apps for even more variety.
Is there a place for late-night pizza in Myrtle Beach?
Yes, several pizza shops stay open late. Ultimate California Pizza, Mellow Mushroom, and Hungry Howie’s Pizza are known for serving late-night guests, especially during peak season.