If you ever find yourself in Mesa, hungry and searching for the kind of pizza that lingers in your memory, you’re not alone. Years ago, I tasted a slice here that made me rethink everything I knew about dough and cheese. Since then, I’ve trekked across the city in hunt of slices that promised flavor, texture, and that unbeatable fresh-from-the-oven aroma.
Mesa hides more than a few surprises when it comes to great pizza. Hidden gems, family traditions, and even a spot where music meets mozzarella fill this list. Whether you’re a fan of thin crust, crave thick and chewy New York style, or just want the best slice after a long week, you’ll find a place here with your name on it. Pull up a chair. Let’s talk pizza worth your time.
1. Vito’s Pizza & Italian Ristorante
Vito’s Pizza & Italian Ristorante sits quietly on Lindsay Road, but their pizza is anything but shy. I still remember my first visit—Chicago-style thin crust, bubbling cheese, and a red sauce that made me pause after the first bite.
Consistency is the real hook here. Every pie feels homemade, not hurried. The sausage and veggie pizzas are local favorites, but the classic Margherita steals the show with its simplicity and balance.
The kitchen caters to all tastes, offering vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. It’s easy to share a meal, no matter your preferences. If you crave dependable pizza with genuine Midwest character, Vito’s is the place to start your Mesa pizza journey.
2. Organ Stop Pizza
Organ Stop Pizza is more than a pizzeria—it’s an experience you won’t find anywhere else in Mesa. The scent of sizzling cheese fills the massive dining hall while a Wurlitzer Theatre Pipe Organ entertains the crowd. My first visit felt like stumbling upon a secret: music and pizza in perfect harmony.
The real highlight is the lively, family-friendly atmosphere. Ordering a classic cheese or veggie pie here means you’re getting a crust that’s golden, just chewy enough, and best enjoyed with live music ringing in your ears. The vegetarian options and gluten-free crust let everyone at the table join in.
Try the house specialty: a loaded pizza with fresh vegetables. It’s simple, hearty, and pairs perfectly with the one-of-a-kind organ show.
3. Red White And Brew
Red White And Brew’s energy is hard to resist. My last visit started as a dinner and turned into an evening spent on their patio, where every table felt like part of a neighborhood block party. The charm comes from their scratch-made menu and staff who remember your name.
Pizza here leans toward classic American interpretations. The signature Veggie Pizza bursts with roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella. Crust-lovers will notice a satisfying chew, the result of careful baking rather than shortcuts.
Their kitchen doesn’t sideline special diets, offering gluten-free and vegan options alongside the regular pies. For a real taste of the house style, try any pie paired with a glass from their curated wine list—everything’s crafted to be shared and savored.
4. Nello’s Pizza
Nello’s Pizza sits tucked inside an unassuming strip mall, but the flavors are far from ordinary. I remember ducking in one afternoon to escape the Arizona heat, only to find deep-dish perfection and a staff that treated every guest like family.
The signature here is their Pan Pizza. Each bite is soft in the middle, crisp at the edges, and loaded with savory sauce. If you prefer lighter fare, the thin crust holds its own with a gentle crunch and generous toppings.
Vegetarian fans will appreciate creative options layered with fresh veggies. Don’t skip Nello’s Special—a hearty blend of vegetables and cheese that captures the spirit of this cozy local favorite in every slice.
5. Oregano’s
Oregano’s delivers a big dose of personality with every pie. Walking in, I was hit with vintage décor, jazz on the speakers, and a crowd that comes for more than just dinner. It’s the sort of place where you forget time and focus on good food and conversation.
The standout here is their Chicago-style pan pizza, known for its buttery crust and bold tomato sauce. Each slice feels substantial, almost meal-like, making it a favorite for group outings and family dinners.
Vegetarian choices are abundant. I always order the Big Cheese: a mountain of melted mozzarella over tangy red sauce, finished with a delicate sprinkle of herbs. It’s Oregano’s comfort, served hot and cheesy every single time.
6. Sourdough Pizza Italian Restaurant
Sourdough Pizza Italian Restaurant offers something you don’t often see: crust with true personality. The first time I tried their sourdough base, the tangy bite and chewy texture set it apart from every other pizza in town.
Their dough is the star here, hand-crafted and allowed to rise in-house, which gives each pie a satisfying flavor and airy crumb. From the first slice to the last, you taste the difference.
For a real sense of the menu, order the Veggie Pizza. The crisp vegetables on that distinctive crust make for a balanced, unforgettable meal. They also offer gluten-free options, so everyone has a seat at the table at Sourdough Pizza.
7. Venezia’s New York Style Pizzeria
Venezia’s New York Style Pizzeria is where I go when I’m in the mood for a classic, oversized slice. Walking in, the aroma alone transports you to a New York sidewalk, and soon enough, you’re folding your pizza and savoring every cheesy bite.
Their claim to fame is the enormous thin crust pie. It’s delightfully crisp at the edges but soft enough to fold—the true New York way. Even after countless visits, I still marvel at the perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio and that signature, slightly chewy dough.
Order the White Pizza or classic Veggie for a real taste of what Venezia’s does best. These pizzas celebrate fresh ingredients, generous toppings, and a commitment to old-school pizzeria values.
8. MOD Pizza
MOD Pizza embraces the idea that pizza is a canvas. During my first trip, my indecisiveness became a strength: I piled on roasted veggies, extra cheese, and a swirl of spicy sauce. No judgment, only variety.
Customization is the heart of MOD Pizza. You can build your own personal pie with choices from over 40 fresh toppings, including plenty of vegetarian and vegan-friendly options. Each pizza comes out hot and bubbly, with a crust that stays crisp under all those toppings.
The Mad Dog (minus haram items) and a veggie-loaded special show off what MOD does best: bold flavor and flexibility. Gluten-friendly and cauliflower crusts are also available, so everyone leaves satisfied.
9. Mellow Mushroom Mesa
Mellow Mushroom Mesa feels more like a funky art gallery than a pizza spot, but the pizzas quickly steal the show. My first visit, I got lost in the murals and then found my way out with a piping-hot pie on their famous spring water crust.
Each pizza is hand-tossed and stone-baked, creating a crust with the perfect mix of texture and flavor. The eclectic environment feels welcoming, whether you’re in for a family dinner or just craving a unique slice.
The Kosmic Karma or Veg Out pies are standouts—each features loads of fresh vegetables, bold sauces, and optional vegan cheese. Gluten-free and vegan options mean everyone can mellow out and enjoy every bite.
10. Oregano’s
Oregano’s at Superstition Springs continues the chain’s tradition of bold flavors and vintage flair. My most recent stop here involved friends, lots of laughs, and a Chicago-style pizza that fed us all with ease. The team’s warmth made even a busy evening feel laid-back.
Their deep-dish pizza is the star, thick with cheese and layered with tangy sauce that clings to every bite. The crust is perfectly buttery—a proper base for their generous toppings.
Vegetarian and vegan pies are quick to appear from the oven, including the fan-favorite Big Cheese. Order it gooey, hot, and loaded with herbs—a classic comfort in true Oregano’s fashion.
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in Mesa, AZ?
Mesa has a variety—a true mix of New York thin crust, Chicago-style deep dish, classic hand-tossed pies, and creative specialty pizzas. There’s something for every preference.
Are there pizza places in Mesa with vegetarian or vegan options?
Absolutely. Many pizzerias in Mesa offer vegetarian and vegan pizzas, along with gluten-free crusts. Spots like MOD Pizza, Oregano’s, and Mellow Mushroom make it easy to customize your pie.
Where can I get gluten-free pizza in Mesa?
Places like Sourdough Pizza, MOD Pizza, Mellow Mushroom, and many others offer gluten-free crusts. It’s best to ask each restaurant to see their options and baking process.
Is pizza delivery available throughout Mesa?
Most pizza spots offer delivery, from classic joints to newer build-your-own spots. Delivery is usually available directly or through local apps and third-party services.
Which pizzerias are great for families or large groups?
Organ Stop Pizza, Red White And Brew, and Venezia’s New York Style Pizzeria are favorites for groups, thanks to big tables, lively settings, and everyone-friendly menus.