Finding the best pizza in Melbourne, FL, is like embarking on a flavorful journey through a city that offers more than just beaches and sunshine. Over the years, I’ve sampled slices from countless pizzerias, and each visit reveals a new twist on the classic favorite. Whether it’s a thin-crust marvel or a thick, cheesy slice, Melbourne’s pizza scene promises something for every craving. This guide aims to highlight those spots that truly stand out — places where quality ingredients, skillful craftsmanship, and a passion for pizza combine to create memorable meals.
You might wonder what makes a pizza truly exceptional. Sometimes it’s the crispy crust that perfectly balances gooey cheese. Other times, it’s the innovative toppings or the cozy atmosphere that elevates the experience. Whatever your preference, you’ll find that Melbourne, FL offers options that never disappoint. With honest recommendations and insider insights, this article will help you discover your next favorite pizza joint, ensuring each bite is worth savoring.
Where to find the best pizza in Melbourne, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Melbourne, FL:
- Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Melbourne, FL
- Genna Pizza Company
- N.y. Pizza Spot & Italian Kitchen
- BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse
- Blaze Pizza
- Slices Pizza & Italian Kitchen
- Bella Luna
- FM Pizza Oven
- Michelli’s Pizzeria
- Napoli Pizza n Pasta
1. Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Melbourne, FL
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza in Melbourne, FL, offers a modern twist on traditional Italian flavors. Walking into this trendy pizzeria feels like stepping into a cozy, welcoming home. Helmed by Chef Renato Viola, one of Italy’s premier Master Pizza Chefs, the restaurant prides itself on quality and authenticity. The atmosphere is inviting, making it a perfect spot to enjoy a slice of Italy in Florida’s space coast.
What truly sets Mister O1 apart is its 72-hour dough and use of the finest ingredients, many exported from Italy. The menu features both traditional and innovative thin-crust pizzas, along with fresh salads and antipasti. A must-try is the signature Margherita pizza, boasting a crispy crust topped with fresh mozzarella and basil — a true reflection of the restaurant’s commitment to excellence. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, Mister O1 promises an extraordinary pizza experience.
2. Genna Pizza Company
Genna Pizza Company in Melbourne, FL, is a favorite spot for families and locals seeking authentic pizza with a cozy, casual vibe. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with the aroma of freshly baked pies and a warm atmosphere. It’s the kind of place where everyone feels at home, whether grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a plated dinner.
The menu stands out with a variety of coal-fired, brick oven New York style, Chicago, and Detroit pizzas. Their commitment to using premium ingredients shines through in every bite. I recommend trying the New York-style thin crust topped with fresh toppings — it captures the authentic city pizza experience. With friendly service and versatile options, Genna Pizza Company makes every visit memorable.
3. N.y. Pizza Spot & Italian Kitchen
N.y. Pizza Spot & Italian Kitchen brings a slice of New York to Melbourne, FL with its cozy, family-run charm and bold flavors. The moment I stepped in, I was greeted like a regular — a testament to their warm hospitality. The space is intimate, and the aroma of fresh dough and herbs sets the tone for a satisfying meal.
What makes this spot shine is its dedication to authentic New York-style pizza and hearty Italian classics. Their Brooklyn Special is a standout — loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and extra cheese on a crisp, foldable crust. For something lighter, the Margherita pizza offers a fresh, balanced bite. With generous portions and consistent quality, this women-owned gem is a reliable go-to for pizza lovers in Melbourne.
4. BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse
BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse blends a laid-back vibe with deep-dish ambition. Tucked just off New Haven Avenue, it’s more than a chain spot—it’s where you linger a little longer after dinner. What sets it apart is the careful balance between their Chicago-style deep-dish pizzas and an undeniably Californian flair.
If you’re new, start with the Gourmet Five Meat Deep Dish (minus haram meats if needed). Its crust—thick, golden, and satisfyingly chewy—carries a perfect ratio of sauce, cheese, and toppings. For lighter fare, the Vegetarian Deep Dish is impressively full of flavor.
BJ’s doesn’t lean on gimmicks. It relies on consistency, thoughtful service, and that rare feeling that a casual dinner can still feel like something special.
5. Blaze Pizza
Blaze Pizza in Melbourne, FL is the go-to spot when you want quality pizza fast without compromising flavor. The moment you step in, you become part of the creative process, choosing from over 30 toppings to build your perfect pie. Their blazing hot 180-second bake time consistently delivers a thin, crisp crust with fresh, vibrant toppings.
What makes Blaze Pizza stand out is the balance between customization and speed. I especially appreciate the Build-Your-Own Pizza option, which lets you pick from a variety of artisanal vegetables, cheeses, and sauces, all guaranteed to be fresh and thoughtfully sourced. For a classic touch, their Red Vine pizza with pepperoni and mozzarella captures the essence of traditional flavors with a modern twist.
Blaze’s emphasis on fast-fire’d, handcrafted pizzas makes it ideal for those busy days when you crave quality without the wait.
6. Slices Pizza & Italian Kitchen
At Slices Pizza & Italian Kitchen in Melbourne, FL, the focus is on creating a warm, family-friendly environment rooted in authentic Italian traditions. The moment you walk in, you’re greeted with a welcoming atmosphere that feels like dining at a friend’s home. Their dedication to using fresh, locally sourced ingredients results in a menu bursting with flavor and quality.
Their pizzas are a highlight, crafted from authentic recipes and personalized with seasonal greens and toppings. I recommend the Margherita pizza — simple, fresh, and well-balanced, reflecting their commitment to quality. For a heartier option, their Calzone offers a satisfying fold-over filled with cheeses and meats, showcasing the kitchen’s mastery of Italian comfort food.
Whether for a casual lunch or an evening dinner, Slices Italian Kitchen delivers delicious experiences crafted by passionate staff dedicated to good food and family moments.
7. Bella Luna
Tucked into a quiet corner of Wickham Road, Bella Luna offers a calm, elegant space to enjoy classic Italian pizza without fuss. The setting feels intentionally cozy, inviting guests to unwind over a meal that leans into tradition rather than trend.
What stood out to me was the perfectly crisp yet tender crust—a clear sign of care in the dough. I tried the vegetarian pizza, which came topped with fresh, vibrantly seasoned vegetables that didn’t overpower the subtle sauce.
The menu focuses on quality over complication. Their Margherita pizza is a solid go-to—balanced, not drowned in cheese, and served hot with just enough char to the edges. It’s pizza you linger over.
Bella Luna understands how simplicity, done right, leaves a lasting impression.
8. FM Pizza Oven
Set in the heart of the Eau Gallie Arts District, FM Pizza Oven delivers wood-fired authenticity with character. The vintage Chevy truck-turned-food-truck isn’t just a marketing gimmick—it’s a mobile slice of their rustic charm.
My visit started with the Margherita Pizza, where the dough was the star—light, airy, and blistered just right from their Italian Valorian oven. The Vegetarian Pizza came piled with vibrant produce, retaining freshness without drowning in oil or seasoning.
FM stands out for its commitment to tradition. Every pie feels like a craft project with purpose. Their limited but thoughtful menu means no filler—just focused execution.
If you’re seeking flavor with soul, the Neapolitan-style pizzas here offer a grounded experience that reflects Melbourne’s local flavor in a crisp, smoky slice.
9. Michelli’s Pizzeria
Nestled on Palm Bay Road, Michelli’s Pizzeria offers a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere with a focus on authentic Italian flavors. The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with the warm aroma of freshly baked pizza—the kind that promises comfort and quality.
Their classic Margherita pizza stands out, with a thin, crispy crust topped with fresh basil, mozzarella, and a vibrant tomato sauce. For something heartier, the Meat Lover’s Pizza features premium toppings that reflect Michelli’s commitment to top ingredients.
What makes Michelli’s special is their consistent attention to detail and friendly service. It’s a go-to whenever craving a traditional pizza that hits all the right notes.
10. Napoli Pizza n Pasta
Located in Indian Harbour Beach, Napoli Pizza n Pasta delivers a true taste of Italy with daily made-from-scratch dough and authentic recipes. The warm, inviting atmosphere makes it easy to indulge in a slice of Sicily without leaving Florida.
During my visit, I was captivated by their Grandma Sicilian pizza. Its thick, chewy crust topped with fresh, flavorful ingredients offered a perfect balance of richness and tradition. You can enjoy it by the slice or as a full pie, which is ideal for sharing.
What sets Napoli apart is their dedication to quality and homemade goodness. Every bite reflects their pride in authentic Italian dining, making it a top choice for pizza enthusiasts seeking a genuine experience.
More Things to Try in Melbourne, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best pizza places in Melbourne, FL?
Some of the top-rated spots include Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza, Genna Pizza Company, Napoli Pizza n Pasta, and Slices Pizza & Italian Kitchen. Each offers a unique style, from Neapolitan to New York-inspired pies.
2. Where can I find authentic Italian pizza in Melbourne?
For a true Italian experience, head to Napoli Pizza n Pasta or Ciao Italian Grill. Both focus on traditional recipes and fresh, handmade dough.
3. Are there any halal or haram-free pizza options in Melbourne?
While most pizzerias don’t explicitly label their offerings, you can find vegetarian pizzas or request custom toppings to avoid haram ingredients. Always check with the restaurant directly to confirm.
4. Who serves the best New York-style pizza in Melbourne?
Genna Pizza Company and N.Y. Pizza Spot & Italian Kitchen are known for their crispy, foldable slices that stay true to the New York tradition.
5. Can I get gluten-free pizza in Melbourne?
Yes, several places like Blaze Pizza and BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse offer gluten-free crusts. Be sure to ask about cross-contamination if you have dietary restrictions.
6. What’s the most family-friendly pizza place in town?
Chuck E. Cheese is a go-to for families with kids, while Your Pie offers a customizable pizza experience in a casual setting.
7. Are there any late-night pizza spots in Melbourne?
Chains like Domino’s Pizza and Papa Johns Pizza typically stay open late. For a local option, check out Doghouse Pizza, which often serves into the evening.
8. Where can I find pizza delivery in Melbourne, FL?
Most major chains like Domino’s, Marco’s Pizza, and Little Caesars offer online ordering and delivery. Many local favorites also partner with delivery apps.
9. What’s the average price for a pizza in Melbourne?
Expect to pay around $10–$20 for a medium to large pizza, depending on the restaurant and toppings.
10. Do any pizza places in Melbourne offer vegan options?
Some spots like Blaze Pizza allow you to build your own pie with vegan cheese and veggie toppings. Always confirm with staff to ensure ingredients meet your needs.