Searching for the best pizza in Medina, OH can feel a bit like trying to find your favorite song at a crowded jukebox—there are plenty of options, but only a few truly hit the right notes. Having sampled my share of pies across town, from the old-school classics to the creative newcomers, I can say with confidence that Medina’s pizza scene brings more than just melted cheese and dough to the table. Each spot tells a story, whether it’s the scent of herbs drifting from a brick oven or a crispy crust that crackles at each bite.
If you’ve ever wondered which pizza joint might end your hunt for the perfect slice, you’re in the right place. The following guide highlights what makes each place special, so you can choose based on cravings, curiosity, or sheer appetite. Prepare yourself to discover new favorites and maybe even start a debate or two—after all, picking the best pizza is always a delicious topic.
1. Dominic’s Pizza
Dominic’s Pizza has that kind of neighborhood charm that can make any day brighter. Set on South Jefferson Street, this spot pulls you in with the scent of fresh dough and tomato sauce. The staff greet you like family, and the air always hums with the clatter of friends sharing slices.
Their signature pizza stands out for its perfectly chewy crust and tangy sauce—a balance that a lot of places just can’t master. Classic cheese, pepperoni, and their veggie specialty are all favorites here. If you’re up for something hearty, try their Deluxe. Each topping tastes fresh, nothing skimps on quality, and the mozzarella always melts just right.
Table service makes a sit-down meal easy, but their takeout travels well. For a casual lunch or late-night craving, Dominic’s delivers the familiar, satisfying flavors people love in Medina.
2. Courthouse Pizzaria
Courthouse Pizzaria sits right off Medina’s historic square, a spot where pizza and people-watching go hand in hand. The view of the courthouse adds a dash of character, and the steady stream of locals says a lot about its reputation.
The dough is always freshly made, and every bite delivers a noticeable crunch before giving way to a soft, chewy center. Their menu highlights classics, but the Margherita—bright with basil and ripe tomatoes—really showcases their commitment to simple, quality ingredients.
Courthouse Pizzaria is also a haven for vegetarians, offering several veggie-heavy pies that never feel like an afterthought. For lunch or dinner, the takeout option makes enjoying great pizza effortless—whether you’re picnicking in the square or settling in at home.
3. Master Pizza
Master Pizza feels like a love letter to classic pizza—where each pie comes with a hefty dose of tradition. Tucked along Medina Road, this spot collects regulars who know what a good slice should taste like. There’s something comforting about the aroma as soon as you walk in.
Crust is king here: just thick enough, with a light crispness that doesn’t overpower the star player—those flavorful toppings. The “Classic Deluxe” shines with fresh mushrooms and sweet red peppers, but their Veggie Lovers’ is a strong contender too.
Delivery and takeout are fast and reliable, perfect for a quick dinner that never sacrifices quality. If you’re seeking a Medina staple that delivers every time, Master Pizza knows exactly what you crave.
4. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza offers a familiar, no-fuss approach that has won over locals year after year. Slide in for lunch or dinner and you’ll see families gathered around hot, cheesy pies—there’s a reason people keep coming back to North Court Street.
Every pizza here is handcrafted, with a focus on dough that’s soft yet holds its shape, and toppings that never shy away from flavor. Marco’s Pepperoni Magnifico is a favorite—pepperoni crisps along the edge, leaving just enough spice in its wake.
If you’re after something lighter, the classic Veggie pizza rivals the best with sweet red onions and green peppers. Marco’s hits the balance between comfort and quality, making it a Medina must-try.
5. Antonio’s Pizza
Antonio’s Pizza feels like the kind of place where memories are made over a box full of warm slices. Set on Pearl Road, it’s a go-to for anyone craving both tradition and consistency. Once you try a slice, the balance of flavors makes sense—here, pizza feels personal.
The cheese blend stands out, stretchy without being greasy, and every slice holds its form without skimping on toppings. The “Vegetarian Pizza” is a hit with a colorful mix of mushrooms, peppers, and olives, all layered generously for full flavor in every bite.
Takeout at Antonio’s is a breeze and delivery is always prompt, so you get your pizza hot and fresh. This spot has become a staple in Medina’s pizza scene for a reason: they simply get it right.
6. Gionino’s Pizzeria
Gionino’s Pizzeria has made itself a Medina mainstay by focusing on community as much as quality. It’s the kind of spot where regulars are known by name, and the steady parade of people picking up pizzas says it all. They promise to be the local favorite, and honestly—they deliver.
Their crust has a subtle crunch, and the sauce brings just enough zing to every slice. The “Gionino’s Best” is exactly what it claims—loaded with green peppers, mushrooms, and plenty of melted cheese. You can taste the extra mile in every bite.
Pick-up and delivery are smooth and fast, so getting a reliable, hot pizza for lunch or dinner never feels like a gamble. Gionino’s is proof that local pride goes a long way in every box.
7. Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars Pizza on North Court Street is where value meets speed, and that’s a combination tough to beat. This spot always seems to have a steady stream of customers in and out, drawn by the promise of hot, fresh pizza with no wait.
The crust here has a familiar, buttery crunch, and the cheese pulls off in satisfying ribbons. Their “Hot-N-Ready” classic pizza does exactly what it promises—no frills, just consistently good slices, always ready to grab and go.
If you’re feeling extra hungry, the Cheesy Bread is a crowd-pleaser and pairs perfectly with any of their pizzas. Little Caesars is where you go for reliability, simplicity, and a no-nonsense pizza fix in Medina.
8. Romeo’s Pizza
Romeo’s Pizza stakes its claim as a Medina favorite for good reason—its reputation echoes all over town. The moment you try their pizza, you’ll understand why so many say it’s the best. The dining room buzzes, and the scent of baking dough is impossible to resist.
What sets Romeo’s apart is their signature sweet sauce—it lifts every bite and offers something genuinely different from the standard. The “Butcher Shop” pizza is a crowd favorite, piled with generous toppings and full of bold flavor.
For those seeking something lighter, the Veggie pizza pops with color and crunch. Stop by, and you might just end up joining the chorus of loyal fans who return time and again.
9. Jo Jo’s Sports Bar and Grill
Jo Jo’s Sports Bar and Grill pairs lively energy with generous portions, making it an unexpected gem for pizza fans in Medina. The inviting space on South Jefferson Street is perfect for groups hoping to catch a game and share a meal without pretension.
The pizza menu surprises with creative combinations and a crust that stays crisp under all that cheese and sauce. The signature Jo Jo’s Supreme is a winner—full of fresh veggies and tangy sauce, layered just right for that perfect bite every time.
Whether you dine in or order for delivery, the service never misses a beat. For an upbeat night out or a cozy dinner at home, Jo Jo’s hits the mark with flavor and fun.
10. Romeo’s OT Sports Bar
Romeo’s OT Sports Bar is the spot where Medina locals gather for big games, cold drinks, and surprisingly standout pizza. The vibe is relaxed—TV screens glow from every angle, and there’s a steady low buzz of friendly banter. When you want comfort food done right, this place rises to the occasion.
Pizzas here carry the signature Romeo’s touch: a slightly sweet sauce and toppings that are always piled high. Their “Overtime Special” brings vibrant bell peppers, onions, and an extra layer of cheese that never disappoints after a long day.
Pizza and sports are a natural duo, and Romeo’s OT nails the balance. Bring friends for a game-day gathering or order out for a low-key dinner—the flavor and energy shine either way.
Frequently Asked Questions
What pizza places in Medina offer delivery?
Most local favorites like Dominic’s Pizza, Master Pizza, Antonio’s Pizza, Gionino’s Pizzeria, and Little Caesars deliver. Many also offer easy online ordering for added convenience.
Are there any vegetarian-friendly pizza options in Medina?
Definitely. Spots such as Courthouse Pizzaria, Antonio’s Pizza, and Jo Jo’s Sports Bar and Grill offer a range of veggie pizzas packed with fresh toppings.
Who makes the best pizza in Medina, OH?
This is a hot debate. Locals often praise Romeo’s Pizza for its sweet sauce, Dominic’s for its classic style, and Gionino’s for consistency. Your favorite may depend on your personal taste in crust and toppings.
Where can I find gluten-free pizza in Medina?
Some larger chains like Marco’s Pizza occasionally offer gluten-free crusts, but it’s best to call ahead to confirm. Smaller, local spots may have options, too—just ask when ordering.
What’s the best pizza for a family meal in Medina?
Master Pizza’s larger pies and Little Caesars’ value deals are both crowd-pleasers for bigger groups or family meals.